Tuesday, August 27, 2024

Never Seen It, #161 of 200: Spirited Away

Watching 200 movies I've never seen before, which is just too many movies, but I can't help myself, and I keep watching and watching until finally I turn into a pig.


Spirited Away
2001
Hayao Miyazaki

The other day, I found myself casually reading about the "seven basic plots," which allegedly describe general categories for every type of story that exists. There's one called "Voyage and Return" that is very clearly Spirited Away's plot. "The protagonist goes to a strange land and, after overcoming the threats it poses or learning important lessons unique to that location, returns with experience." Yup, that's it. Chihiro starts the movie worried that there is something missing within her, and, after the voyage, returns to her world more confident in herself and her own abilities.

I was thinking about this because, I dunno, I guess I'm grasping at straws here. I fear that Spirited Away is going to be one of those movies that I like while everyone else loves it. International sensation, Oscar winner, in the Top 100 in that Sight and Sound poll I'm always referencing, more than a few friends recommending it out of the blue, etc., etc. It didn't hit me in the gut like my favorite movies do, and that bothers me. I am probably going to spend a few extra blogging words and paragraphs on attempting to figure out why. And I started with the Seven Plots thing.

I wonder if the "Voyage" that is essential to this type of story is the thing that gives me pause. I'm thinking back to all the "Voyage and Return" films that I've seen in my life, and think about what issues I have with them. I think if I had to generalize it, I'd say that the idea of someone going to a new world and spending a lot of the movie being shocked over and over that the "rules" in this new world are not like the rules they knew in the old world is something that annoys me. Or maybe not "annoys," maybe more like: it's exhausting.

Let's hear some examples. The film that I compared Spirited Away to in my mind—probably because we just last week spent our Family Movie Night watching it—was Labyrinth. There are similarities in structure and tone. Not only does the little girl find herself forced into a magical (and dangerous) world, but the visuals that we the audience see on the screen are wacky and weird and frightening and larger than life. It makes for an intriguing viewing, almost like sensory overload. And that can be fun! But if you strip all that away, it basically amounts to a young protagonist continually whining about how the rules aren't fair here because they don't resemble the rules back home.

And the sticking point for me is that, because the rules are "new," they don't have to make sense to the audience either. I think that's the true frustrating part. I get that there are things happening because they are meant to induce awe in how visually striking they are, but that doesn't excuse the fact that I have no idea why they are happening. There are so many moments in Spirited Away that will stick with me, simply because they are new and strange for me. The charcoal ashes carrying a shoe, the slow trolley ride through shallow water, the river spirit unclogged of the dirty bicycle that was ailing him, the spider guy placing a blanket on a sleeping child. But at a certain point, it starts to feel like beauty for beauty's sake. I require a little more substance. Maybe this is my flaw.

There are other movies in my life that maybe I'm more willing to excuse this idea of "no explanation," so let's briefly examine them, and see if I can tell the difference. Snowpiercer is a recent one. I wouldn't describe this as "Voyage and Return" though, which is maybe the difference. More of a "The Quest" plot mixed with a "Rags to Riches" plot. But there was a lot in that film that went unexplained. I specifically wrote about the gutted fish in my portion of the NSI write-up for that one, and noted the joy in the idea that the fish wasn't explained. What's the difference here? I think the difference is that the protagonist did not view this incident as strange. It wasn't a "new world" for him. This was his world. He already knew the rules. The joy was that the audience was the only one left in the dark. In Spirited Away (among other "Voyage and Return" films), we are to empathize with the protagonist, who is just as confused as we are. And that, in my opinion, makes for a less compelling movie experience.

I'd argue that the CLASSIC 1993 film Super Mario Bros. has a "Voyage and Return" plot. Mario and Luigi, the titular brothers, are Brooklyn plumbers, and struggling to find purpose in life. Then they find themselves in the '90s futuristic steampunk Mushroom Kingdom, where they discover that they are not just plumbers, but HEROES. They return to Brooklyn changed men. They have purpose now. While I believe that this is probably the best film of all time, a true undeniable CLASSIC, I will cop to the idea of it having a similar problem as Spirited Away, in that the protagonists spend a good chunk of the film resisting the idea that this new world is different than they old world that they're comfortable with. What's the difference here? It probably comes down to the fact that Chihiro is very whiny (in a normal ten-year-old-girl way, but still), and Bob Hoskins plays Mario as hilariously irascible, which goes down a lot better. Plus, John Leguizamo as Luigi almost immediately starts playing along to the new rules, charming like a puppy dog looking to please, and that makes a big difference. It undercuts the problem I have with "Voyage and Return" stories. Resistance to the voyage is annoying to me. Luigi doesn't resist.

In search of an answer, I visited the master—Roger Ebert. (For a "Quest" plot, usually the mentor disappears or dies before the hero can find what he's looking for.) He, naturally, had a lot of good things to say about Spirited Away. There was a time when I resisted reading too much about a film after watching that film, out of fear of homogenizing my opinion of the film. I'm at the point where I don't fear that anymore. I think there's plenty of room for sharing ideas without considering that "changing what you think" just because someone else's disagrees. I also find value in the general Ebertian idea that the magic of any good film happens in the space after the credits roll. There's nothing wrong with me reading about a film to make sense of my own emotions.

There was an anecdote in Ebert's Spirited Away review involving the time that he met director Hayao Miyazaki. Miyazaki clapped his hands together a few times in succession, and then explained to Ebert that he tries to make movies like the spaces of silence in between those claps. I love this. At first glance, there is a lot less meaning to the silence than there is to the noise. But in examining the silence anyway, we the audience might find something unique and worthy that we wouldn't have found otherwise. It's not so much "what does the silence mean?", but rather "what does our interpretation of the silence say about ourselves?" I wonder what it means to me that I had a bit of a struggle interpreting the often nonsensical beauty of Spirited Away.

I think about my friend Steph, the Writer. I recently reconnected with her after a good many years apart (the Voyage, the Return). We sat on barstools in one of the last true smoking bars left in this suburban county and I confessed that I had found her Substack and had read everything, because I like reading my friends' stuff so much that I constructed a whole amateur blog around the concept. She's a writer by vocation, though, is the thing. Like, professionally. And she's real fucking good at it. Which means that she's equipped to write in ways that the office drones and public servants and coat salesmen of Puke on Your Birthday might not ever be (though we do try, though, oh, do we try).

I told her about Family Movie Night and she quickly recommended Spirited Away, not knowing yet that I have a blog where I spend too much of my time blabbering on about movies I've never seen and that Spirited Away was coincidentally the very next film on my alphabetical list. My first crass thought was that I should get the Writer to write something about it for this blog, but after further consideration, I did not want my second line of communication in seven years to be a text that read "hey would u like to write on my blog" because that seemed pathetic in ways that I'm not willing to examine about myself right now. (Though if she ends up reading this and wants to add some thoughts, I'll meet her in the comments or on the emails.)

So we will have to be content to consider hypothetically here what the recommendation means. (Or rather, the silence in between the recommendations.) I choose to view it as thus: to be the Writer is to see the beauty for what it is and for what it means to you. Spirited Away is a film uniquely designed for such a person. Such a person can pluck answers out of beauty that does not seem to the pedestrian individual to contain any answers at all. To the enlightened, Spirited Away is beautiful, and the beauty is the answer. Doesn't matter if No-Face's purpose is questionable or if Yubaba's motivations are inconsistent or that there's no logical reason that Haku is a dragon. Doesn't fucking matter. There is beauty to be found here, if you know how to look for it.

I feel like I often view my life as having the plot of "The Quest," or occasionally even "Overcoming the Monster." That I am spending my time on earth looking for something, and will be who I truly am only when I find it, or defeat the villain, or something along those lines. Think about this film project—it is designed like a Quest, and I feel that when I watch film #200, I will have achieved something. I will have become a better person when I reach the finish line.

But now I wonder whether it might be helpful to view my life and my various pursuits through a different lens. What if the plot of my life is actually "Voyage and Return"? Spirited Away is not a villain to defeat or a treasure at the end of the path, but instead something to visit, but then eventually return from, having changed in some way. I may not be a better version of myself, and I may not "get it," but I have changed. I have returned and have found meaning in experiencing something new, a new world with new rules. The Voyage has changed me. I don't know if my faults are gone, nor do I know if the change will stick, but here, now, I feel it.

Spirited Away is a beauty worth examining. It's just that the value is in the examination of the movie, not necessarily the movie itself.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5 (for now)

NEXT TIME:
Once upon a time, my grandma told me that her favorite movie of all time was Splendor in the Grass. So, assuming that grandma survives for the next week and doesn't meet the Puke on Your Birthday curse, consider this a little preview of next week's write-up's narrative hook: "what the hell was grandma thinking?!?!" I mean, I haven't seen the movie, but I have seen the conservative conspiracy theories on her Facebook wall, so my expectations are low. (In other words: is she a Yubaba or a Zeniba?!)

No comments: