Prompt: "A song that has the word 'song' in the title"
Selected by Joe
"Survival Song"
AJJ
People Who Can Eat People Are the Luckiest People in the World, 2007
When I get burnt out on here, occasionally—which I am, probably, right now, maybe we all are, I don't know, I just gotta break through that wall and get to the other side—I like to talk about process and purpose. It helps for some reason. I take a step back and talk about the words that I am writing, instead of just letting them come out. So here I am, with my bizarre sense of self-care. I am writing about a truth. I am writing about myself, and what I perceive to be true. I like to think that each Song Challenge write-up acts as a confession. Here is a small portion of me, revealed. Here I am, for you, a friend, via the internet. Please look at me.
But it's no different than the carefully staged picture on Instagram, at the end of the day. I am showing you who I am but doing so purposefully, crafting an image that I say is true but that might not necessarily be true. You can choose to believe me when I say what I indicate is true. You can also read what I write and, knowing who I am, choose to believe that it is false, or contrived, or bent in some way, either accidentally or to deceive the audience. Sometimes I don't even know what is true. I put something on the digital page and it seems right but there is always a chance that I lack the self-awareness to know that what I wrote was actually lacking in truth. And then, of course, even if I pull the curtain back to reveal the artifice that I have constructed, indicate that I am fully self-aware that I am writing a blog post and that I do not know if the words I am writing are providing the desired effect and yet I am writing them anyway, even then, I don't know if it's enough for you, the audience. Maybe it never will be. Maybe the only truth is that there is no truth. Maybe when I end a paragraph with "I don't know," it's the only true thing I've ever said. I don't know.
Me and Willow and Martha all stood in the rain on Saturday morning, in the outdoor mall parking lot, no umbrella, waiting for a school giveaway to commence. Martha is in her second year of preschool and it is the fourth year in a row that we are sending a child to preschool on the city's dime. Willow is starting first grade, and will be leaving her public elementary school that she attended for grade K and entering a Catholic elementary school. We have already paid the tuition for the year. It is barely affordable but a choice that we have made as a family and at the end of the day, yes, yes, affordable. I paid it upfront to save $50 in fees that would have accrued if we paid in monthly installments. I don't know if that was financially savvy or stupid. The statement of fact here is that we paid more money than we would have if we sent her to public school for this upcoming year.
Writing that paragraph was rife with questions and doubts about what to say and what not to say and what is true and what is an illusion. I have issues with presenting as "rich." I think it has something to do with a self-hating compulsion based on my obvious privilege. I think it also has something to do with a pathological need for humility (which, ya know, the irony is something we've already steam-pressed here on the blog—no, I don't think writing on the blog about myself constitutes a lack of humility, for reasons I don't have the energy to go over again here). I think maybe there was also something about my upbringing and the upbringing of my peers, something about how we were taught to honor our ancestors by appreciating their sacrifices and how that bleeds into people like me pretending that we are also making sacrifices, which is easier emotionally than just admitting that there's a fucking privilege there, man. It's complicated.
But I don't like making it seems like I am rich, because, well, I'm not, but also I have negative feelings about the idea of being rich, and while I don't ever hold that against my friends who were or are richer than me, there's a disconnect in which I imagine that other people will indeed hold it against me, if they misperceive me as someone who is rich enough to be deserving of scorn. And so I take great pains to say shit like "well yeah I just paid thousands of dollars into a school that we're hoping doesn't fuck our kid up but we can just barely afford it." It's true but it also might seem like it's me protesting too much, right? You could easily choose to see the word "barely" as a defense mechanism, a weak one that can't compete against the bullshittery of the subsequent phrase "it's true." I can't tell you what to think. I can't tell you how to perceive me. I write the words about myself but your interpretation of those words is out of my control.
It does feel like we are just barely surviving, financially, though, is the thing. The end of the summer has been rough and has taken great painful swipes at the savings. The twin punches of the tuition and the installation of a sump pump in the basement have bent us without breaking us, but you can see the pressure in that bend, enough to get nervous that a couple more pounds of pressure and you'd hear a snap as potential energy turns into kinetic energy.
Which is fine! As I've already said, emotionally speaking, I'm in the pocket right now. Wealth brings discomfort. Guilt over unnecessarily buying a Wawa hoagie for lunch feels more appropriate. A savings account still in the black enough to afford paying the water bill, but not flush enough that I would feel comfortable buying a new pair of pants before the seams split from overuse, and then plus the perverse pride in wearing pants until they split instead of spending money that could go toward a bill for my kid's education. Guilt, discomfort, stress, these are all emotions that I was taught in my upbringing should be associated with finances, and when I feel them, I feel at right with the earth, in an incredible fucked-up but absolutely true way.
And so making it seem, accidentally, through telling a truth, a truth that could lead to misperception, that I am somehow well-off or wealthy in any fucking sense, brings me an anxiety that gives me the howling fucking fantods. I'd rather seppuku myself in front of a stranger than have that stranger think that I'm rich. I'm just presenting my truth, as fucked up as it may or may not be. This is my truth, the truth in how I feel, described in a blog post about a folk-punk song about surviving.
I think it's fucked up that they make those who cannot afford backpacks for their children (or at least feel that they cannot afford backpacks for their children) wait in the rain for close to an hour so that they can get free backpacks. In a just society, everyone would receive enough of an income that everyone can easily afford backpacks for their kids to use at school, and in a less than just but still mostly just society, every kid would receive a free backpack on the first day of school. But we live in this society, where only those who are aware of the backpack giveaway and have the time and energy to bring their kids to a line in a parking lot for an hour and wait for a while regardless of the weather are the families who deserve a free backpack. I've never seen the squid game show because fuck Netflix but I can easily picture the dystopian plot where people compete to survive or whatever, and I can tell you that we aren't really that far off.
We finally made it into the corral and got the backpacks (my children not yet schooled in the ways of being financially challenge and unable to be completely happy with their free backpacks because they didn't have pink backpacks or purple backpacks, not yet able to grasp the concept that some people don't have to wait in a goddamn line for a goddamn hour to beg for a free backpack and can go to the store and choose whatever color backpack they want). And then we waited in another line for other free stuff, none of it necessary for education but, I dunno, we were already there, and so why not get the free coloring books and the free Rita's Water Ice and the free magnet calendar too.
But that line was moving even slower, and we were stuck in front of a PSD employee under a tarp, in between us a poster in which children were invited to scribble in marker "what makes you special," which my children declined for who knows why, probably not because someone had already written "I am Sonic" but maybe. But we're still standing there, and the lady makes strained small talk with a six-year-old and a four-year-old, here at this public school event where all children are invited to get free stuff that their parents cannot afford, and so of course one of the primary questions is "so where are you going to school?"
And Willow, who doesn't know any of this, knows none of her father's anxieties or guilt or depraved humility regarding the subject of money and capitalism and class struggle and privilege, says, innocently, without any malice at all, that she is going into first grade at a Name of Catholic Grade School. I see the worker's face crumple. I see the disdain. I know exactly why, and I don't know how to respond beyond standing there and saying thank you for being nice to my children and shuffling the kids along to the next tarp in the rain. I don't know if it's true or false, my interpretation of the worker's reaction, but I perceive the thought of "why are you here if you can afford a tuition, what are you, rich?!"
We keep it moving and she gets asked twice more where she is going and each time says the name of her new elementary school with an entry fee greater than zero and each time I can see the wince of the worker as they process what she said and get slapped across the face with the question of why (and, being in education and knowing how to deal with both innocent children and scoundrel parents, blessedly do not articulate that question out loud). I know it and I don't know how to protest it because if I protest it then it looks like I'm trying to hide something. A protest would mean that I am rich and a liar. And so I stay silent. I even try telling Willow to maybe try saying the name of her old school, the public school, but she says no immediately, not understanding why—and she's right, you know, absolutely right that she shouldn't have to lie to protect her father from having his ego damaged by the perceived and possibly false slights of public servants that he will never see again.
I couldn't do that anymore, though, and so I asked them if they wanted to jump in the moonbounce because I knew they'd want to jump in there and the uniformed young woman standing in the rain to lift the flap on the moonbounce did not look like she wanted to be there at all let alone ask parents what schools their kids were going to before they bounced. And then it started raining even harder and we ran to the van and drove home.
But the true interaction here wasn't between me and my children and a well-meaning PSD employee. The true interaction, the one we are here for, is the interaction between author and reader. I am writing what I perceive to be the truth: I fear that I was presented in a false light at the school giveaway and I didn't like it. But here you are reading it. You are reading what I'm writing, and I can easily see how you might read about the situation as I present it and yet still respond with "well, you can afford a Catholic school education," and choose to believe that I am still presenting a false version of my self on a blog. I can lampshade the fact that this is purposefully not a vanity project and yet maybe saying that it isn't vanity is not enough to prevent it from presenting as vanity. I don't know how to prove my truth.
And you are kind. You are a friend. You might feel compelled to publicly defend. "I know exactly who you are, and I accept you for that," you write in a comment. And yet who is to say that this too isn't a false construct. Who is to say that the comment is designed to pacify publicly but in the deep dark recesses of your soul you cannot shake the feeling that this fucking guy who is writing this fucking shit on a blog about his life is in fact not worthy of love or affection or even attention. At a certain point, you have to believe; friendship means believing someone's truth when they attempt to give it to you. But still, you never really do know, do you. You just never truly know what is true.
This is my truth. This is how I choose to present to you my truth. This is my pledge that I believe that what you write is your truth. This is my humility, the knowing that I cannot know the truth and yet I will choose to believe it anyway. This is a blog post. I am who I present to you here. I am telling the truth. This is me. I swear. I swear. This is my truth. This is how I survive. I need to know the truth. I write it out. I present my truth. This is me. I write it even though there is no way to ever prove it. There is no way to prevent someone else from choosing to believe what they want to believe. But I'm going to write my truth. Here it is. In a blog post. On a blog. Here. Right now. The truth.
2 comments:
Look at Mr. Moneybags over here.
Only the Original Nate Dogg would handwave away 2500 words of emotional hemming and hawing with some pithy fucking sarcastic comment. Under the Anonymous name, no less! Let's hear some more forgettable Bandcamp indie rock from 2022, you coward!!!!!!
Post a Comment