Saturday, August 17, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 118: Joe

Prompt: "A song about a banana... yes, we're doing this prompt again! Fuck all the haters! If I want to hear songs about bananas I'm gonna make my friends and family pick songs about bananas, goddamn it!!!"

Selected by Joe


"Apple"
Charli XCX
brat, 2024

Repetition in blogging is boring as hell, so I'm not gonna repeat how pop music often lands flat with me. There are enough exceptions out there that I wouldn't consider this a "rule," but it is sort of a guiding principle. I don't fuck with a whole lot of pop music. Just a personal preference, not a judgment of any kind. There are usually one or two genuine pop albums per year that manage to break through all the noise and get to me on an emotional level, though. It's not that they aren't popular and it's not that they don't sound like your typical pop album. It's more that the album is just so fucking good that it manages to justify its popularity and overcome the typical trappings of sounding like a pop album. To me, anyway. It's all subjective. Whatever.

brat is that album this year. Really great stuff from Charli XCX, an artist that I've enjoyed moderately in the past but who just fucking knocks it out of the park here in 2024. "Brat Summer" is a thing that I'm aware of as much as someone like me could be (i.e. would be terminally online if he didn't make conscious efforts to not be so terminally online). Kamala Harris is having a Brat Summer? Something like that. I'm down for saying anything positive about the Presidential candidate if it means I don't have to hear weird conservative shit about her, even if the positive stuff is corny meme splatter. My overall point here, though, is that this is a popular album, enough that there's no need to convince anyone here that they should listen to it. You probably already have. This is what makes Charli XCX the perfect anti-Swift—she doesn't really need anyone to convince anyone else to listen to her music, on this blog or otherwise, and she doesn't need her fans to make her seem like the try-hard dork and borderline insufferable that Taylor Swift so clearly is. She instead just makes great fucking music. (The song about Taylor Swift on brat has a decent chance of being my straight-up favorite song of 2024, so I'll save my words about that one for the December Top 25 Songs blurbs.)

But I guess I didn't realize how popular brat was—or how truly deep Brat Summer goes—until I heard a nine-year-old sing "Apple" during karaoke at Keenan's Irish Pub in North Wildwood last week.

It was kids' karaoke, to be fair, but still, the experience was bizarre enough that my reaction was "I need to find an excuse to write about this on the blog" (hopefully using "Apple" for the banana prompt is a good enough joke that you'll forgive me for it). He really did sing "Apple" though. He was the first singer to sing karaoke that day. He was the MC for the event! A nine-year-old! Yes, he said he was the nephew of the woman running the tech boards and pulling up the songs, but still, c'mon.

A fucking surreal experience, standing in the same big room where I have spent so many sloppy summer nights spilling Miller Lights on the dance floor and listening to some Fake Irish dipshits cover "Wagon Wheel." That same stage where two of my own kids were now standing, shellshocked, mumbling "Let It Go" into twin microphones, right next to the bar that I sat at seven in the morning seven summers ago, to the chagrin of my kids' mother, motherfucking Keenan's. Some of you might have been there before. If so, you can imagine how weird it was to be there on a Thursday afternoon, listening to a little kid sing a Charli XCX song on stage in front of a small crowd of half-hungover, half-getting-drunk-again parents and grandparents.

Especially weird because, like, I wouldn't necessarily consider Charli XCX to be "children's music." During the hour and change we were there, we heard, off the top of my head, a bunch of Disney songs, a bunch of Taylor Swift songs, that dumb fucking Benson Boone track, plus my cousin's four-year-old kid claiming that he was going to sing "Stick Season" by Noah Kahan (that is not a joke, he really signed up to sing it). Children's music, all of it. Yes, even the litany of Taylor Swift songs. She makes pop music for children. Some great tracks to her name—I wouldn't even say that any of the songs that we heard performed live by children with an average age of six were bad in any sense, especially not "Love Story," which is a fucking banger—but generally, it's real basic stuff, emotionally speaking. Shit that kids can understand.

I wouldn't describe Charli's music in the same way. The hooks are bright and sticky enough that anyone age three to 99 can bop along to 'em, that's not what I'm saying. I just think that the meaning behind them are a tad more complicated. If I asked my six-year-old what "Love Story" is about, then there's a reasonable chance that she's gonna nail it and say "two people who like each other" or something along them lines. If I asked her was "Apple" was about, she'd be like, "I dunno, the fruit?" Because "Apple" is fun enough to be palatable to children of all ages, but it's mature enough that you can't say that it's literally made for children. You see the difference.

The difference doesn't matter, by the way. I don't care. I was more interested in the context of a nine-year-old singing "Apple" than the fact of a nine-year-old singing "Apple." It wasn't just that he was singing the song. It was that he was singing it at a bar, this bar, in the afternoon, surrounding by even younger children who were waiting to sing songs too, children who were brought to a bar by their adult family members and caretakers, for, let's be real here, the purposes of having an excuse to drink in broad daylight at a bar on a weekday.

I pray that you don't think the last part of that paragraph is intended to be a judgment of any kind. My empathy for the adults in that situation is bottomless. I love it. I totally get it. I get it so hard that I literally had to give up drinking due to how hard I got it. Needing an excuse to drink is an important part of the ritual of drinking. If I'm being honest, it was probably one of my favorite parts of that ritual. The weirder the excuse, the better. As already linked to above, I had once crashed a bachelorette party at 7 AM to drink in this very same bar. No excuse too ridiculous. I'm just saying that the visual of some pudgy kid singing one of the best songs on my favorite pop album of the year, an album that in no way can be misconstrued as "an album for nine-year-olds," only serves to underline how truly absurd an excuse it was. Kids' karaoke! At Keenan's! What the fuck?!

Almost as weird as President Obama raving to Charli XCX's "365" this summer. Almost as weird as listening to songs about bananas. Almost as weird as some sources indicating that it's stylized as BRAT or Brat but the album cover clearly stylizing it as brat. Almost as weird as not realizing that Charli is singing "airport" and not "apple" until a nine-year-old made the difference clear with his own diction. Almost as weird as Joe K*** unabashedly adoring a pop album.

No comments: