"If you looked into a magic crystal, you saw your army destroyed and yourself dead. If you saw that in the future, as I'm sure you're seeing it now, would you continue to blog about 200 films you've never seen before?" "Yes."
Spartacus
1960
Stanley Kubrick
The very first lines in this film jump forward in time two millennia. The narrator states that Spartacus is a slave and he dreams of ending slavery, "2000 years before it would actually die." In this way, Spartacus immediately reveals itself to be an allegory for the modern day. This isn't the story of one specific guy who rebelled against injustice and paid the price for it. It is actually a story of class struggle and the value of solidarity, and its lessons ripple into the present day and beyond.
I am in a union and I consider myself a democratic socialist, as I believe in the theoretical ideal of the working class holding the power and not being exploited by any sort of ruling class. The ideals here overlap with the 1960s American Communist Party, and the themes run through the film in a very obvious way, which makes sense, because its two screenwriters, Howard Fast and Dalton Trumbo, were part of that Communist Party (the latter infamously blacklisted in Hollywood over it, this film being a large reason for his return from artistic exile). Yes, it's about Spartacus, a slave in the Roman Empire, but it's really about anyone who is oppressed, and it's about what we can do to fight back.
I guess I'm speaking philosophically and not literally, because you won't often see me throwing bricks in the street or knocking on doors with petitions in hand. My "activism" (quotation marks very much intentional) starts with writing some bullshit on a blog and ends with paying money toward causes that will further these ideals and voting for candidates that might at least get us within spitting distance of one day enacting these ideals in society. So I'm not saying that I'm your guy when it comes to being like Spartacus. But I do think that this is part of the reason we watch movies. We are thrilled to see the best of ourselves reflected back at us. The ideal version of me is going to be crucified for sticking up for my fellow humans and fighting for what's right. Even if in reality I'm a coward, I have Spartacus to imagine: what if?
Spartacus is almost 200 minutes long, which is way too much. I say this every time I come across a three-plus-hours movie, and I stand by it here. Rich, coming from some blogging asshole who feels uncomfortable writing anything under 2000 words, but I stand by it. Still, with Spartacus, I understand the length too, to an extent. It's the type of movie that needs to continuously and vigorously underline its point. It's fucked up, this oppression, and here are three hours of a class of people being oppressed. You really need to disconnect from reality in order to walk away from the end credits and still support the capitalistic decimation of the middle class by forty bloodthirsty billionaires. I assume people do it (remember that Paul Ryan's favorite band is Rage Against the Machine), but the sheer weight of this film helps to dispel that ignorance.
There are plenty of moments that I could name here, and they are all important, and they all affected me deeply. Kirk Douglas's Spartacus yelling from his cage "I am not an animal!!" The gladiators waiting to die while the rich Romans drink wine and talk loudly about some bullshit like this is just another picnic in the park. The catharsis of the slaves finally taking charge of the prison camp, violence spilling over and in a way that makes it impossible to think anything other than this being justified. Tony Curtis's Antoninus reciting an incredibly sad poem about going home, knowing that most or all of those gathered will never get there. Spartacus telling the pirate that they are going to fight even if they cannot win. The endless journey for the freed slaves, and a brief shot of an unnamed couple burying their dead child, no explanation, just sadness symbolizing the sacrifices made on the trail. The immortal line of "He'll come back, and he'll be millions."
Will he come back? I'd like to think so. The slave revolt in this film is ultimately a failure, with Spartacus's wife and child being the only survivors, and really only surviving due to the whims of a benevolent member of the ruling class. Slavery technically ended 2000 years later as promised, but still exists under other names and definitions (e.g. the exploitation of incarcerated workers, etc.). Society is fucked in different ways but still fucked with the same intensity as it was back then. There is still injustice, and it is still handed downward.
I see in this film the gladiators overtaking their rulers and gathering followers and building a free community and I think, fuck, why can't we do that? I'm not going to be crucified (or killed over bananas). I am paid for my labor. But I still feel exploited, and it's easy to see the millions that are exploited much worse than I am. The worst injustice I currently face is having time stolen from me by Mayor Umbridge in her inhumane RTO order. My brothers and sisters out there are struggling to put food on the table. And for what? For some fucking Romans to stroll into town and drink wine and let the poor people fight it out for scraps just for the fun of it. It's fucked.
Spartacus gets me so fucking angry because it shows what we can do to fight back, but we'll never do it. We're too fractured. My uncle was a union guy his entire career, but is too racist to see past the false promises of the conservative ruling class, and votes trump. This is by design. The ruling class has fractured us, on purpose, so that we don't have the power to revolt like Spartacus did all those years ago. I am helpless alone. We are not helpless together, united, but I don't think that is ever going to be our reality, and it pains me to admit it.
I guess optimistically speaking, a film like Spartacus gives me hope. Not hope in that my life is going to get better in this specific way. More so hope that the dream will continue to live on. That it did before Christ, that it did in 1960 when the story was filtered through the same modern-day concerns, that it does today, as we continue to feel the boots on our necks, and dream that one day we can take the system back and work it to our own benefit. We'll be back. We are millions.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
STRAY THOUGHTS:
- The natural comparison—one that has been made well before I was even born, let alone blogging or watching movies—is between Spartacus and Ben-Hur. Two epic films made in the same Hollywood style, both taking place around the same time period. But there are so many differences beyond those broad strokes. Ben-Hur is a religious film. Spartacus barely mentions god at all. The four years since I've watched Ben-Hur for this blog project feel like a century, and I forget a lot of it, but even then, I can see the ways in which these films go head-to-head, and I can still definitively say that I enjoyed Spartacus a lot more.
- I think there's also room to compare Spartacus and On the Waterfront, a comparison I have not seen in the wild (and why would I, since the only reason I am making it is due to the arbitrary list of movies I made). Just in the way that '60s politics were filtered through a fictional film, the opposing ways that their respective screenwriters dealt with the McCarthy hearings, and the way that On the Waterfront takes a sick delight in tearing down a union, whereas Spartacus is implicitly pro-union, etc.
- It was jarring seeing my second Tony Curtis film so soon after my first, and how different his character was here as compared to the gleeful Some Like It Hot. His sparring partner from that previous film, Jack Lemmon, was off starring in 1960's The Apartment, which won Best Picture at the '61 Oscars, whereas Spartacus wasn't even nominated.
- Haven't mentioned Peter Ustinov's Batiatus yet. Ustinov was Spartacus' only acting nomination that year's Oscars, and he ended up winning. I'd argue that it was deserved. Dude pulls in some serious laughs in an otherwise serious and epic movie.
- Also didn't mention "I am Spartacus!" in the above essay, which was really an oversight on my part. It landed pretty hard, but of course, the thing is that I already knew it was coming. I'm so thankful that the film didn't end on that part. It was effective, I'm just saying that maybe "he'll be back, and he'll be millions" is even more effective, and I'm glad that this was the final money line. I understand why "I am Spartacus" is the thing that's parodied, though.
- I thought Jean Simmons did a great job as Varinia. My favorite scene was her reunion with Spartacus, and she and Douglas play the scene with such glee and hilarity. It does a fine job of underlining how much joy can be found in being free.
- And overture and an intermission are never necessary, but I'll admit, they still make a film feel more EPIC that it would in their absence.
- Oh shit, also: this is a Stanley Kubrick film. The second-to-last one on our list (2001 is months from now). I am told that this is not a TRUE Kubrick film, since he was a hired hand, and the car was already rolling down the hill at a great speed when he took the steering wheel. Still, though, what can we say about "Kubrick films" based on Spartacus? I tried to look for interesting camera shots. I recall thinking that the gladiator fight early in the film between Spartacus and Woody Strode's Draba was keenly shot, with low angles, and even one where the camera was in the net that Draba used as a weapon. I don't know if this is Kubrickian or just interesting, but it was noticeable. I solemnly swear that the 2001 blog post is going to be Kubrick-focused.
NEXT TIME: I think Spirited Away is the first anime film on my list? Correct me if I'm wrong. I was hanging with an old friend the other night and she coincidentally recommended the film, so I might try to see if she wants to write a little something for it. That's how it goes with blogging—you make one wrong move, and PoYB ensnares you in its trap.

No comments:
Post a Comment