This column is making its return today. Find all previous Song of the ___ entries from the past sixteen years HERE. My concentration, here in its new form, is to keep the word count down, somewhere in between 200 and 400 words per entry. I want to maintain a space for short-form music writing in case there comes a day when life forces me to cut down on the long-form writing elsewhere.
"It's the Same Old Song"
Four Tops
Four Tops Second Album
1965
It's no secret that the classic Motown songs of yore are celebratory to me. I've written about it too many times on this blog, to the point that it's starting to feel like some minor form of exploitation. Four Tops have a few tracks on that mountaintop, most prominently "I Can't Help Myself (Sugar Pie Honey Bunch)," a song I've drank to and occasionally would try to export into a karaoke outing, to mixed (and sloppy) results. But I'm listening to a full Four Tops album this week, and the other one I recognize on there from those blotto gatherings of my youth is "It's the Same Old Song," and that's the one that's hitting me in the place where it hurts.
There's a certain type of song that gets harder to hear as it matures. No, sorry—as you mature. Since the Tops are reluctant to get specific about who the "you" in "you've been gone" is, we are forced to put ourselves into the story. You can be sad while listening to this song and all you have to do is miss someone or something. It's a breakup song on the surface, but say maybe you have a rough time at the office and you start to miss those halcyon days when you could spend an entire Friday night getting drunk and listening to Four Tops. That works too. "It's the Same Old Song" is the same old song, but with a different feeling since you (i.e. the you of your choosing) have been gone.
The idea of the listener interpreting a song however they damn well choose in that moment is not a new idea on this blog either, but it might be the most important one we've ever touched on. You choose your own path. And if that path forks and heads in a new direction, so too does the song's meaning. We grow, we change—me and you and Four Tops.
There's a certain type of song that gets harder to hear as it matures. No, sorry—as you mature. Since the Tops are reluctant to get specific about who the "you" in "you've been gone" is, we are forced to put ourselves into the story. You can be sad while listening to this song and all you have to do is miss someone or something. It's a breakup song on the surface, but say maybe you have a rough time at the office and you start to miss those halcyon days when you could spend an entire Friday night getting drunk and listening to Four Tops. That works too. "It's the Same Old Song" is the same old song, but with a different feeling since you (i.e. the you of your choosing) have been gone.
The idea of the listener interpreting a song however they damn well choose in that moment is not a new idea on this blog either, but it might be the most important one we've ever touched on. You choose your own path. And if that path forks and heads in a new direction, so too does the song's meaning. We grow, we change—me and you and Four Tops.
No comments:
Post a Comment