In the interest of posterity, I'm attempting to move all the notes that were written on the Infinite Jest
message board last year. This will serve to preserve something that I
spent a ton of time on, plus can act as a digital guide for anyone who
decided to attempt to read my favorite book of all time after 2023 (or
as a guide for myself when I eventually reread it).
Please see the new Infinite Jest tag for other posts as they go up. Before you read, double-check that you are on the right blog post; the pages are at the top, and I don't want you to be spoiled.
Please see the new Infinite Jest tag for other posts as they go up. Before you read, double-check that you are on the right blog post; the pages are at the top, and I don't want you to be spoiled.
Pages 342-379: Boston AA on Interdependence Day
What a fucking joy, to be able to read a chapter/section like this. In stark contrast to the Eschaton debacle, this section is almost entirely devoid of action. Nothing happens, except that a bunch of Ennett residents attend a White Flag Group AA meeting, a few speakers tell their tales. However, the writing is stunning. It's SO fucking exciting, just in the way it's written. Those run-on sentences are like a goddamn magic trick. The are both impressive and accurately mirror the mind of an addict: give me more, give me more!!!!
— A footnote points out the fact that a lot of terminology in the AA community is capitalized (e.g. "Group," not "group"). Brings us back to Poor Tony Krause, a decidedly non-sober person, who was going through capital-w Withdrawal.
— "Sobriety in Boston is regarded as less a gift than a sort of cosmic loan." Reminds me of what Schacht had to say about Hal's subterranean activities, how there was a psychic credit card bill in the mail for him.
— To complete our triplicate of callbacks, I'll say that a lot of the talk in this chapter about vernacular and terminology brought me all the way back to the Year of Glad, how in that first chapter there was a lot of training about how to view language and how important it is to call things by their correct terms, etc.
— We're finally all together! Lots of the characters we met earlier (sometimes WAY earlier) in the book are gathered here in the nursing home basement. Ken Erdedy! Kate Gompert! Joelle van Dyne is alive and reintroduced in a fucking footnote!!!
— Confirmed: Gately is 29 years old. I first read this book when I was 23. Kinda tough viewing Gately as five years younger than me now. That's what I hate about these Infinite Jest characters: I get older, they stay the same age.
— The POV-switching was really beautifully done, I thought, how there would be long alternating paragraphs that switched between the narrator explaining AA culture and the speaker at the podium telling their story. Plus those moments when the two would kind of converge (I'm thinking e.g. when the narrator is telling the Raquel Welch story in third-person and says something like "oh and the sister is in a PREVIOUSLY UNMENTIONED wheelchair," like the narrator is telling her story and subtly critiquing her story at the same time). All of it was really easy to follow, all things considered.
— The "Face in the Floor" comes back in the description of the disease, a hundred pages or so after Hal indicates that he used to have dreams about seeing a face in the floor.
— Probably one of the best run-on sentences in the whole book, by the way, the one describing the horrors of addiction, especially the part where it's like: "and you can't believe you ever liked doing it but you STILL can't stop, it's like you're totally fucking bats..." etc. If there is one passage that has influenced me in terms of my own writing—there are many in this book, but if I had to pick one—it would be this.
— Gately and/or the narrator also describes addiction as a "cage" multiple times, and note that JOI had at least one film (maybe more? I forget) with the word "Cage" in the title.
— DFW is the master of the absurd anecdote, e.g. the lady who tried to jump off a building but a gust of wind blew her back through a window, the kicker being that she's rabidly Christian now, and everyone avoids her in AA.
— Good line: "Every meeting is a reunion, once you've been here a while."
— I don't know if they ever actually use this word, but a lot of the AA discussion, when you get down to it, has to do with the idea of faith. Faith being the not know how but doing it anyway. You're not supposed to know how AA works, you just have to have faith that it does, and take the figuratively leap.
— Another good line, because it perfectly describes how AA doesn't make sense, in an oxymoron: "And now they've got you, and you're free."
— The Irish dude waxing lyrical about his solid shit!!!!!!!!!!!!!
— Back to the POV-switching: I like when DFW is obviously in the zone, writing all kinds of crazy vocab words, and then has to stop himself in a footnote and be like "obviously the character isn't using these words..."
— I was at an AA meeting myself last Monday, and there was a dude there talking about "convenient forgetting," how it's easy to remember the good times and easy to forget the bad times. I liked when that came up again in this section, how "the Disease is patient," and that whole hypothetical about thinking it's okay to have a nice cold beer at the Celtics/Sixers game.
— How do we feel about the Crocodiles yelling out the window at previously-sober people out on the streets ("Live it up!")? Always kind of makes me feel uncomfortable. But like Gately says multiple times: who the fuck am I to judge other people's behavior?
— The perfect line: "It's all optional; do it or die." At once gets to the heart of the matter here, and ALSO connects efficiently to the whole argument between Marathe and Steeply.
— I like how it's made implicit and explicit how the people in this room are all so wildly different but also everyone is there for the exact same reason. It's a little funny how Erdedy is described as upscale and well-to-do and then there's this line: "Gately is still not yet a good judge of anything upscale people except where they tend to hide their valuables."
— AA is 12-step, and UHID is described as 11-step. I forget if they talked about this yet: what's the missing step? I also forget if this comes up again.
— Man, they do a really good job underlying how humble Gately is, and how that's kind of his superpower right now. Especially that scene with the girl putting out her cigarette on the table that Gately is going to have to clean up later, and how he just kind of... lets it go.
— Really good discussion about Hear vs. Listen.
— Don Gately says that Joelle's voice is familiar in a strange way. Kind of the opposite of when Mario says the same thing earlier. Mario hears her on the radio and can't connect to when he used to hear her in real life. Gately hears her in real life and can't connect to when he most likely heard her on the radio.
— What do we make of the existential crisis Gately has about Joelle's grammar comment? I need a bit more to parse that one out.
— Okay.... why is this section interrupted a few times? What is the point of talking about the Statue of Liberty, of checking in with Marathe and Steeply, or of talking about JOI's Found Drama? I don't know. I don't know.
— "The thing is it has to be the truth to really go over, here."
— I like the stuff about Gately trying to be honest to everyone all the time, and how "this is harder than it sounds." I have thoughts about radical honesty, but I wonder if those thoughts would/will be changed in the specific context of sobriety and recovery.
— LOL at Joelle shuddering when she knows that all the guys in the room recognize the stripper.
— The Raquel Welch thing is fucking insane. The dead baby in a blanket thing is insane. Hearing them back-to-back is insane. Everything about this is insane. It's okay to be horrified by this shit!
— "Cause: no; responsibility: yes."
— LOL(?) at the shudder that all the mothers have at the mention of child services, for reasons that I don't feel like writing about right now.
Pages 380-410: More Interdependence Day Fun
I'll say that Mario's puppet movie isn't my favorite section of the book. I know, I know, it's been like four weeks in a row where I'm coming her and typing that this section we just read is the BEST FUCKING THING EVER. You get a break from that this week! Mario's kiddie puppet theater is just pretty good! Some funny parts, and a lot of crucial info about the U.S/Canada politics that have been floating around the edges until now. I'm thankful that we finally have the info, but it just seems a little too much, to have to explain it via a puppet show. I know that's IJ's m.o., but some work better than others.
Also, before we get to a handful of notes and details: I feel like there are a lot of REALLY IMPORTANT THINGS in these sections that if I point out here, then it would definitely constitute a spoiler. I'm down to acknowledge anything that you notice, but I'm going to hold back with some of the details dropped here.
— Interesting that the U.S. Clean Party was a weird mix of fringe folks from the far left and far right. Could that exist today?
— Really feeling for the Canadian ETA boys who are in the US and meanwhile their homes in Canada are destroyed by the Convexity (if you haven't noticed by now, people in the US call it the Concavity, and people in Canada call it the Convexity).
— How do we feel about Lyle? Creepy? Wise? Both?
— Seems like there's some juicy philosophical stuff to discuss with LaMont Chu's whole deal, how the pursuit of fame may or may not be detrimental to the pursuit of fame?
— Lots of mentions of "cages" from all the characters like every week. This week Lyle is called LaMont Chu's search for fames as a "cage." And one of JOI's movies, Cage III, is mentioned (the one where the audience turns into stone, I think?)
— Love the sub-subplot with the meth-addicted headline writer. Gotta stick some AA-type stuff even in the fake headlines in the puppet movie!!
— What's going on with Ortho Stice and the bed moving around his room? Surprised that one of the possibilities he mentions isn't "ghost."
— Is the story Lyle tells about the dude lifting a chair while he's standing on that chair a metaphor? If so, what does it mean? I never got that one.
— JOI's film The Joke is fucking hilarious, but why are these films being mentioned right now in the story? How are they connected to Johnny Gentle and Lyle's nighttime clientele?
— Q: is the joke that Johnny Gentle was a puppet president figuratively and then shown as a literal puppet in Mario's film, is that Mario's joke, or DFW's?
— AND, if Gentle is a puppet, and Rodney Tine is the alleged puppet master, AND if Marathe was insinuating to Steeply weeks ago that Rodney Tine is in love with a Canadian operative Luria P., then can we assume that Luria, a Quebec separatist, is pulling the strings ultimately? And does this fit in with what Orin was asking Hal about separatism?
— I love how Gentle's solution for the Concavity is to "give it away," which he means literally (give the Concavity to Canada), but also it's a fucking AA slogan!! I wonder if it's also a slogan in a 12-step for OCD?
— The Clipperton shit is INSANE. More below.
Pages 410-434: The Streaming Era; Marathe and Steeply argue soup; a brutal Clipperton conclusion
1. The rise of InterLace
This section definitely seems like more of an aside than usual (especially because it starts from Hal's perspective and says something like "Hal DEFINITELY doesn't want to think about TV commercials right now" and then DFW launches into just that). Like the whole Zoom-esque side story from like Week 3, this one is especially interesting, now that we too are living in an era where entertainment is at our fingertips. So DFW could see the writing on the wall, and predicated correctly (perhaps overstating the importance of mail-order discs, which had a much shorter lifespan with our real-world Netflix).
Not a TON to talk about in terms of themes and whatnot. I do find it interesting that the stated issue with network v. cable v. InterLace is the so-called FREEDOM TO CHOOSE what you want to watch, and that's kind of what Marathe and Steeply have been arguing about this whole time (and how a footnote here, #164, states that this is basically only an illusion of choice, and that some people, i.e. some ad execs, are better at making you THINK you have a choice).
And, I don't know, maybe this is why I hate Netflix so much. How it advertises itself as (in IJ's words) "pro-active and consumer-driven" but it feels so fucking PASSIVE to me, scrolling through all kinds of bullshit to get to the one slightly-less-than-bullshit thing they have.
I also like how a lot of this is conveniently local to our story, with the Viney & Veals ad agency and the Pain Clinic that is involved in those crazy commercials are in the Enfield area. Plus—and this is something I only noticed on this read-through—our boy Ken Erdedy, currently at Ennett House, was previously an exec at Viney & Veals.
Would love to have more time to think on that whole postscript on Schtitt being an early supporter of Johnny Gentle.
2. Marthe and Steeply
DFW is really good at adding details to an otherwise straightforward conversation, and there are a lot of details around the margins worth noting here (e.g. Steeply's subconscious desire for humiliation, e.g. Marathe's wife was born WITHOUT A SKULL). But the main point as I see it is this:
Steeply is trying to say that Americans are taught through experience that sometimes do something for short-term pleasure will result in long-term pain, and that this often looks like the idea of empathy, of treating your fellow man with respect, of how "bonking" someone on the head and stealing their soup might feel good in the moment but will eventually lead to pain, a punishment of some form.
Marathe is saying that, in fact, Americans do NOT act this way, that they are ultimately selfish, and that the very existence of the Concavity—short-term gains for Americans because they get rid of their waste but long-term punishment because the Canadians are royally pissed off and are gonna strike back eventually—proves it. He's also speculating that the Entertainment (the Samizdat, Infinite Jest) would prove it as well, that, if given the CHOICE, i.e. the FREEDOM, to view the Entertainment, that Americans would ultimately choose to watch it for short-term gain (most pleasure you've ever felt in your life) despite long-term punishment (your life is basically over).
Steeply ends the argument (for now) by basically saying fuck you, because that's NOT what happened with the medical attaché, that he didn't have a choice, that he accidentally watched it and yet is still suffering the consequences. But Marathe say... well, okay, but what if? What if Americans actually had the choice?
And to take this conversation more broadly, I say now: how does this apply to substance abuse? Isn't that what we talk about when we talk about how to help those addicted to heroin, for instance? I.e. did they CHOOSE to be addicted? What does choice or freedom look like in the thralls of addiction? Marathe and Steeply aren't talking about drugs but that's how their conversation applies to IJ's broader themes, I think.
3. Clipperton
— This story gave me the howling fantods!
— Interesting discussion about Clipperton "not being treated as real" because he wasn't officially ranked.
— It was a total aside, but anytime Pemulis factors into the story, even for like two sentences, I laugh out loud. He is my favorite character besides Don.
— Love the aside too of the Ennett House resident saying that he was more scared of Clipperton than anything else in sobriety so far.
— The ending to this story is just fucking brutal. It was hard to read this time around for me. It makes me so goddamn sad to think about Mario gently smiling/crying at Clipperton's funeral. It also makes me sincerely uncomfortable to think that this poor kid's horrific suicide is used as a half-sarcastic lesson inflicted upon lazy tennis kids who don't want to run laps. Lots of emotional turmoil here, for the characters and for the reader.
Pages 434-461: Gately's Job, a bit more of the puppets, Gately "in touch with his feelings," Hal's dream / Mario agitated, Tavis and then tennis practice
Gately's "sunlighting on the side"
— I like the phrase "his Gratitude-battery totally recharged." Speaks to Gately's newfound optimism and outlook on life. And probably is a good way of living your life, seeing the negatives as secret positives for your self-esteem. Explains why Gately is able to describe his boss Stavros as "a troubling guy" instead of, like, "fucking creep" or "crook who should pay me more."
ETA Miscellaneous
— I like the intro to Rusk as a completely useless human being, and how ETAs "in the know" know to go to other people for their psychic and emotional needs.
— Interesting that Avril is noted as one of those people whom students can go to. That plus the short shot of Avril comforting the crying child who bumped his head during the puppet show paints a way different picture of Avril than Orin would have you believe.
— I think the puppet show might be my least favorite part of the book. I dunno. I get the joke that a lot of the intricate puppet movements are way too unbelievable that Mario could pull it off, and I like the punchline at the end that explains why the years are named the way they are in this book. But a lot of it just rubs me the wrong way, like it's trying too hard. (I'm one to speak, I know.)
Tough Shit But You Still Can't Drink Group
— So there's the fish joke. I like the idea of DFW using Gately's inability to understand certain things as a way to not necessarily spell out the meaning of those things for the reader. If Gately had been like "Oh, clearly THIS is why the joke is bothering me so much," then that would be the author being mistrustful of the audience that they won't eventually get there themselves.
— Sidenote: DFW used this same joke in a commencement speech that he did at some point (shout out to Sunny for bringing this to my attention originally). So it's important to him.
— But still, I'm not DFW, so let's ask: why did the fish joke bother Gately so much? My theory is that when you're under the influence of substances, you are what they call "blissfully unaware," and to take a step back and understand that influence and understand the harm it's bringing on you... that's called enlightenment, but that enlightenment is painful. Hence the whole "getting in touch with your feelings" being a really tough thing for the newly sober. The fish who have lived their whole lives underwater don't realize there is anything else besides water. The enlightened fish knows, and what's implied is that that enlightened fish experienced a lot of pain when he understood that he's in water and there is other stuff out there. This explanation is a work in progress.
— GREAT metaphor for doing what you have to do every day to stay sober being like a hitting streak in baseball.
— Pretty great point too that Gately makes on his wondering about why bikers are doing the whole motorcycle thing without the drinking or drugs. "It's like what would be the point." I've been thinking about this a lot.
— The speech Gately gives about not understanding god is such a good way to get to know who Gately is as a person. I.e. He is not knowledgeable but he is smart and wise in his own way.
— The whole "getting in touch" thing... oof. I'm 91 days sober as I write this and I'm not there yet, but I'm shuddering in thinking what I might discover about myself and what exactly was the pain that I was trying to cover up.
— Really descriptive intros for Gately's mom and the MP (stepdad but not quite?). Looking forward to discussing them in the future.
Hal's teeth and Mario's radio
— Nice transition from Gately's dream about being underwater to Hal's dream about losing teeth.
— What does it say about the Incandenzas that none of them recognize the voice of Orin's ex-girlfriend on the radio?
All the tennis shit
— Nice acknowledgment here that Mario may or may not be Charles Tavis' son (and it really says a lot about Charles that he would refer to Mario as "the thing it's not entirely impossible he may have fathered," which makes me despise Charles, honestly).
— "Total Worry" is funny though.
— I had a professor last year that preached mindfulness, and I remember one of the mindfulness activities being similar to what Hal was trying with the tooth: "[he] tries a la Lyle to focus very intently on the pain of his tooth without judging it as bad or good."
— short mention of Otho Stice's issues with his bed being moved. It's been mentioned twice now, hang on to that.
— I took very few notes on the tennis stuff. I think it's wonderfully descriptive, and I think it takes great skill for someone to get me interested in tennis drills, so credit to DFW there. But this section exists more to paint the world of IJ than to tell us anything important, in my opinion. I'd be curious to hear if anyone disagrees though.
— Schtitt's speech about "inside world" is a good one, though.
— And I love the dichotomy of Schtitt and de Lint. Recall how they were described before as non-homosexual soulmates (basically), but they come off differently here (Schtitt with his high-minded philosophy and de Lint chiming in like "so shut the fuck up about the cold!"). Maybe they complement each other. (Sidenote: recall from Year of Glad that Hal says that he appreciates de Lint, but see here now a year prior to that how much Hal hates de Lint.)
Pages 461-489: classic cars, p-terminals, and beloved childhood brooms
— Gately's spiritual feelings about Pat's car, the insanity of driving without a license, and how Pat's "questionable judgment" could also be read as faith in Gately.
— We get two different POVs on the DuPleisse death. 1) Gately is remembering that the dude he accidentally killed was "eulogized at terrifying length and headline-size" (lol), and 2) the Antitoi brothers are basically like "you have to be a fucking MORON to believe that bullshit story about accidental death because of mucus, it was an ASSASSINATION" (lol)
— Interesting: "Going back to ingesting substances had become his biggest fear."
— Love that flashback with Gately telling Pat that he wants to change, and Pat having the empathy for him.
— The philosophy of AA re: god—doesn't matter what you believe or why you believe it or don't, it just matters what you DO. And so that's why it works that Gately is getting on his knees every day. ALSO: the cake analogy (love the small footnote about Gately not knowing how to make spaghetti because he's never read the directions hahaha)
— Also with that, Francis G. saying "someone as minor league as Don Gately maybe isn't supposed to 'understand' something as major league as god"
— IS god a necessary part of living in sobriety? Asking for a friend.
— Not excusing this at all, but the casual racism of Don Gately is necessary character shading, I think.
— I just love the whole structure of these week's reading. You have Gately getting in the car, immediately shooting back to flashbacks, then a requisite Steepley/Marathe interlude, then back to Gately, back to flashbacks, and then all of a sudden we're following a piece of trash that Gately's car knocked into the wind, and that leads us to seamlessly transition to the Antitoi bros. Fucking CINEMATIC how that happens.
— A good addition to the Steepley/Marathe saga, about how human beings focus too much on pleasure. Steepley is putting an emphasis on the fact that Canadians are like this as well, but the point goes beyond US/Canada tensions, I think.
— PROGRESS NOT PERFECTION — here re: the car concerns, but great advice in general
— DFW's interjection of "Has anybody mentioned Gately's head is square?" is hilarious on like three different levels.
— I love how all the residents are scared shitless of Gately but also bust his balls behind his back / in the footnotes.
— ANTITOI BROTHERS: lots of connections to shit we've already read. 1) They sold the DMZ to Pemulis, and the details of how they got that originally (from an old hippie in a Grateful Dead shirt) are described here, 2) they were mentioned by Poor Tony as possible friends during his time of need, 3) obviously Gately killed their benefactor, 4) they mentioned limpdick terrorizing via hanging flags from US statues, and Joelle, on the way to her suicide, saw the public workers taking down that flag.
— And now they "hear the squeak." Pretty heartbreaking death for two dudes whom we just met and who are terrorists. Especially Lucien, who is probably autistic? A really beautiful description of death, though, with the flying over the forests of his childhood and whatnot.
— We've only really seen the wheelchair assassins via Marathe, who is tired of that whole game by this point. But now we see them in action, and it's actually pretty scary! Lucien's death is bloody and brutal!
— Is the "railroad spike in the eye" a Biblical reference?
I dunno, that's it.

No comments:
Post a Comment