Ben-Hur
1959
I'm trying to look at this project like every movie is bringing new to the table, regardless of whether I deign to mark it as a "good movie" or a "bad movie" or whatever. Every movie adds a piece of understanding to the grand idea of "MOVIES." What is a movie? It's a question I'm hoping to answer in 200 parts.
I had never seen Ben-Hur, but importantly, I have rarely seen any movie like Ben-Hur. And when I say "like Ben-Hur" I'm mainly referring to the idea of Old Hollywood.
When I first heard this phrase uttered by Allison N. during her Wizard of Oz interview, I put the phrase in quotes, because I just thought it was a general descriptor of any movie that was made before a certain time period. As it turns out, that is not the case. Old Hollywood is the term that a certain era of filmmaking is referred to as. It's not just when it was made, but how. There are rules and guidelines that films during that time period follow. Film theory was established and somewhat rigid. There's a fucking Wikipedia page for Old Hollywood. It's a thing.
So when I say I haven't watched many movies like Ben-Hur in my lifetime, I'm saying that I've maybe seen three other movies from the Old Hollywood era in my lifetime (Oz, It's a Wonderful Life, Citizen Kane), and were it not for this list, I would have no reason or motive to watch any more ever again. Is that because I don't like how movies from Old Hollywood were made? The answer is both yes and no.
But first, let's talk about what makes a movie Old Hollywood, or "Classical Hollywood Cinema," as it is formally referred to. Beyond visual style, which would be the obvious answer to "what makes a movie Old Hollywood?," there is also a narrative style that most Old Hollywood movies operate under. The latter is actually more important, and takes precedence when Old Hollywood's typical visual style and narrative style cannot coexist in a particular scene of a movie.
Visual style is evident if you watch any of these movies, especially the big-budget classics. There were scenes in Ben-Hur that looked like a movie set, as opposed to tricking me into thinking that it was actually the ancient Roman Empire. Think about Wizard of Oz, and how they were marching down the Yellow Brick Road in what was very clearly a studio set, a big warehouse that had placed within it props and set pieces that were there to allegedly give the illusion of a forest, but c'mon, you know this is a movie.
That's more to do with Old Hollywood's limitations than its rules, though, if we're being fair. There are also some visual rules that kinda get into the movie-making weeds a little bit, i.e. it goes over my philistine head. Let's try. There is first what's called the "180-degree rule," which supposes that the movie set is on one side, and the movie audience is on another. This was a natural progression as art started to be made on film as opposed to theater—the audience's distance from the action remained. There is also occasional dips into what's called the "30-degree rule," meaning that the "camera" (if you will) takes close ups of certain characters, but the sense of scenery and context remains even during those shots that cut to a specific part of the "stage." This is all about holding the audience's hand, in a sense; the purpose of the movie isn't to confuse, and you want to make sure that, visually at least, the audience can easily follow what's happening.
As far as "narrative rules" go, there are similar in theory and purpose, in that they exist so that the audience has a clear sense of what the fuck is happening. There is a main character, and he (or, unfortunately more rarely, she) has a definable traits, and that character is striving toward a definable goal (he is, for the most part, goal-oriented). The narrative follows a linear pattern, from point A to point B and so on, only jumping back occasionally when a character has a "flashback," mostly as a "memory sequence." There is object permanence—just because the second scene does not feature the flower pot pivotal to the first scene, does not mean the flower pot ceases to exist. The person or thing of importance in the scene is always centered in the frame, never out of focus, and everything from the lighting to the costumes give additional clues as to what the audience is supposed to be focused on.
Now, I'm reading about and writing about all of this heady shit after I watched Ben-Hur, so it's unfair of me to try to go back and pick out those moments that were clearly defined as "Old Hollywood" according to these rules. Unfair, but easy too. Think about the scene in the galley when Quintus decides to test Judah and gradually up the rowing speed, all the way until "ramming speed," when people are straight-up passing out from exhaustion. The camera cuts back and forth from Judah (in the center of the frame, glistening) to Quintus (in the center of the frame, intrigued look clearly painted on his face). Back and forth, giving both a sense of the entire galley scenery and the specific action points withing that scene. There is no trickery. You know why Judah is rowing with intent. You know why Quintus is giving the orders. You know where you are, and at what point in the story, and who is involved. The galley scene announces to the world what its purpose is, and allows to audience to easily follow along as it achieves that purpose.
This might all seem obvious, but let me give you some examples of how such a scene could be changed if it was created and shot during any moment after Old Hollywood's demise. This is just off the top of my head—Judah's intense rowing could've been out of focus behind another slave who just couldn't keep pace; Quintus could've been introduced in this scene, and the audience could figure out his motivation later; the camera cutting could've sped up, matching the speed of the oars as they too sped up; the camera could've not cut at all, instead swiveling around 360 degrees to show everything, including the space where the audience watching clearly is not; the camera could've moved in any noticeable fashion while shooting, obviously, including maybe going into a Dutch angle, or maybe a camcorder mode where it shakes the faster the ship goes; maybe this is how the movie starts, in media res, and eventually the narrative catches up to it; etc., etc., etc.
It wasn't that hard to come up with those examples, but remember—I was born almost 30 years after this movie was released, and didn't really give a fuck about movies till almost 60 years after the movie was released. I was born and raised in a post-Old Hollywood world, where no one is beholden to these rules any longer. This means that, to me, the Old Hollywood rules seem oppressive. They seem limiting. Visually and narrative-wise, a typical classic cinema film could be so much more.
It's the "Elvis Presley theory" (which I think I coined but most likely already exists under a different name). I will never like Elvis Presley's music, even while acknowledging how much it progressed the idea of rock 'n' roll. Because so many other artists progressed music so much further than he did before I came to appreciate music, Elvis Presley will always seem primitive to me, and I can't get into him. That's not fair to Elvis, because if it weren't for him, then the lineage of the Beatles, the Who, the Clash, Nirvana, and Arcade Fire wouldn't exist at all, but still, I've seen what rock 'n' roll can be, so I have trouble listening to what allowed it to be that in the first place.
Same with Old Hollywood. I've seen what movies can be. None of the thirteen previous movies on the Never Seen It list could exist in classic cinema. Too many rules are broken. But shit, man, some of these movies have been great, possible because they break so many rules. Could there be A Beautiful Mind without Citizen Kane? No, there could not. But because I love and appreciate A Beautiful Mind, Citizen Kane looks positively crude and archaic in comparison.
All this probably seems like I'm leading up to the big thesis reveal of "Ben-Hur sucked," but I'm not going to get there. It has its flaws, for certain, but I will state right now that I liked Ben-Hur a lot. It's Old Hollywood through and through, but its saving grace is the fact that this particular film commits to bigger/better than its predecessors. Its $15 million budget seems quaint today, but in 1959, this was the biggest budget of all time. They went ALL OUT in creating the Ben-Hur experience.
In other words, they did everything they could to make this Old Hollywood experience something new and exciting, while still adhering to the old rules. The camera focuses on each chariot rider, one at a time, their emotions plain and their motivations plainer, but all the while the action is taking place in a larger-than-life ancient Roman stadium, and the background extras number in the thousands. There is one main character, and he owns mostly every scene, and you're going to follow him for almost FOUR HOURS, point A to point B to point C, in a linear fashion, no fuckery needed, and yet still, some of those points along the way are absolutely epic—point J is navy battle between two slave ships, point Q is a visit to the valley of the lepers, and so on. Yes, there is one main character, and he remains the focus, but there are other tertiary characters that factor into the action, and one of those characters is literally Jesus Christ. Like, that should tell you how pumped up the action is, when Jesus Christ himself is so supporting a character that he basically becomes a plot device.
Everything about Ben-Hur seemed bigger and better than the films of its kind, and that's the part that made me appreciate it overall. It does nothing to blow up the idea of classic cinema, it just brings classic cinema to its absolute zenith, through sheer grandiosity. Like, the idea of an overture to start a movie is practically draped in cobwebs it's so antiquated, but who among us doesn't get absolutely PUMPED at that stirring orchestral introduction? The music might not seem necessary, but through its bombast, it becomes essential. Ben-Hur is like that over and over.
It was necessary for Ben-Hur to operate in an over-the-top fashion for it to be considered "great," but this film would've absolutely still been "good" if it were just for the narrative itself. It's basic, for sure, but something about Judah Ben-Hur's story affected me in a profound way. Let's see if we can talk about it without sounding trite.
Okay, pull back curtain—this is a story about Jesus. Kind of. As I already mentioned, Jesus is more of a supporting character, but the film begins by portraying the birth of Christ (in the creepiest way, but that wasn't on purpose, it's just the film aging poorly in some respects). He is born, his followers acknowledge his presence, and then we cut to the story of our true main protagonist, Judah Ben-Hur, a well-respected member of the Jewish community in Israel under Roman rule. His best friend from his youth, Messala, has returned to town after becoming a high-ranking Roman official. The friends vigorously shake hands (more on that later) and enjoy each other's company, despite the fact that one is a Roman, one is a Jew, and both are part of communities who are currently at odds.
The friendship cannot last. Judah refuses to back down and sell out the other Jewish leaders to Messala, and so the relationship crumbles. Soon after, when a Roman governor is parading through town, an accident involving Judah's sister and a poorly constructed roof results in the governor being injured during the parade. Though Messala investigates and discovers that it truly was an accident, he still uses the incident to banish Judah from the country, sent into slavery to row until his death on a galley ship. Judah knows that Messala knows that it was an accident, and is dismayed to realize that Messala doesn't give a fuck. Messala's true colors are revealed—he is a fascist who will gladly lick Caesar's boots by throwing his friend and his friend's family under the proverbial bus.
The next, I dunno, three hours(!) is the story of Judah Ben-Hur and his bloodthirsty quest for revenge against his friend-turned-enemy. On a primitive human level, the need for revenge is justifiable—Ben-Hur's life is completely burned to the ground out of sheer pettiness. Who among us wouldn't be as enraged, and as motivated to get even? I don't know if I would have the strength to row a slave ship for three years straight, but I know what it feels like to have that fire in my belly, the fire to get back at the oppressor.
But I also personally know what that means, to have that need for revenge, and the price you pay with your soul. This is what Ben-Hur actually learns through the course of his travels, and this is where Jesus factors into the equation. After being sent away, Ben-Hur faces every known indignity, and continually is beaten down and told that he is not worthy of life. A low point is when he is marched through the desert, chained to other slaves, denied even a sip of water from his prison guards. As they pass through a small town called Nazareth, he falls to the sand, content to die. That's when a mysterious young man, whose face the audience never sees, bends down and offers Judah a sip of water.
That moment, that small act of kindness, is burned into Judah's mind. It doesn't compute. The world shows again and again that it is unrelentingly cruel, and yet here was a stranger, in a strange town, making room in that cruel world for a modicum of altruism. The hate is so overwhelming within Judah Ben-Hur that he cannot process the event in Nazareth for years.
This definitely isn't life-changing stuff, and yeah, it gets a little too pro-Christianity preachy at times (more on that in a bit too), but overall, I appreciated the message. If you hate the villain too much, then you start to become the villain yourself. I not only appreciate that message, but I need that message right now. I'm open to any film that makes the case for being open to love and tolerance.
This quote from Esther is key: "It was Judah Ben-Hur I loved. What has become of him? You seem to be now the very thing you set out to destroy. Giving evil for evil. Hatred is turning you to stone. It's as though you had become Messala." She is right. Her method of fixing this—dropping everything, following Jesus Christ—might not be the message I ever need to hear, but if the idea of "Jesus" is a stand-in for the overarching idea of "love," then count me in. There is nothing that cannot be fixed with a little bit of love.
I warned you—this is basic stuff, banal and saccharine. But it's a universal truth, and it's a truth that Ben-Hur masterfully made the case for, within the limitations of the 1950s Old Hollywood epic film anyway.
This might seem like two different essays smashed together, one about classic cinema and one about the value of love, and maybe it is. But it may also show you that Ben-Hur is a multi-faceted film, capable of both creating epic scope within the confines of the filmmaking of its time and using that epic scope to land a tried-and-true message about life. I don't even know if I can recommend this movie for anyone—it's long, with plenty of unnecessary scenes and moments, on top of the fact that it is relatively straight-forward, and that can be boring at times.
What I can say, however, is that in the week since I've seen this film, Ben-Hur hasn't really left my mind. I keep returning to that scene in the desert, how hokey the whole thing seemed, with the Roman guard being shocked at seeing Christ's face, even when we are denied the privilege, how silly it all seemed, and yet how crucial, how fucking crucial that moment of humanity seems in the grand scheme of things, movies or no. I watch Ben-Hur struggle with that scene, and I become Ben-Hur, forever to struggle with that scene. It looked fake, because this is classic cinema, and the 180-degrees rule existed, but then, it also felt so fucking real.
I don't know how both can be true, how Ben-Hur can be both a phony, corny, over-produced Old Hollywood film, and a very raw, honest, genuine film experience, both at the same time. That's the truth, though. Ben-Hur is the truth.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Who's Involved
This section is gonna be interesting today for two reasons. First, one thing about Old Hollywood I didn't mention above was how the structure of the movie business was a lot different back then, which affected casting. During the classic cinema period, it was the studios who were the primary creators of the art of cinema, and the studios who controlled all aspects of the creation of the film. Nowadays, the directors are the points of contact when a decision has to be made, but studios held all the power back in the day.
So, like, a studio such as MGM (the studio that created Ben-Hur) would be the primary force in making a movie happen. E.g. MGM realized in 1952 that they have a bunch of assets in Italy, and wanted to figure out a way to put them to use, so they hired a bunch of people (producer, writer, director, cast) to make the movie as a way to turn that profit.
There was a 1948 Supreme Court case that put an end to the true vertical integration of Old Hollywood film studios, but the idea still remained that the studio was in the driver seat. So by 1959, it wasn't like Charlton Heston was under an MGM contract and had to appear in Ben-Hur whether he wanted to or not (this happened all the time prior to 1948, actors were just straight-up owned by studios). But MGM still had a say in whether Charlton Heston should be the main lead. It would take a couple more decades before the power structure shifted.
The other reason today's "Who's Involved" section is interesting is because I don't know any of these people. Usually I discuss what other roles I'm familiar with in each actor's filmography, but I'm not familiar with anyone in Ben-Hur, so I can't do that.
Sure, there are people like Charlton Heston whom I know by name only, but before watching Ben-Hur, I would not have been able to pick him out of any lineup. I just knew that was an Old Hollywood "Big Name Actor," and that's it. I could actually look at the filmography and realize that he also starred in Planet of the Apes, a movie I have seen and am familiar with, but obviously not enough to remember that Heston starred in it. I could look at his Wikipedia page and see all the conservative politics he put his stamp on later in life, but who wants to get bummed out by that?
I am also also reluctant to give my opinion on many of these actors' and actresses' performances in the film, because, again, Old Hollywood and all that. If at any point there was a scene where the actor appeared overstated or rigid, then that's because all performances were like that. There was no room for nuance in films like Ben-Hur because the goal of this type of film was to make each character's intentions plain. These guys were still basically theater performers, holding the skull aloft and speaking to it outlandishly. I can't possibly blame any actor for simply being a performer stuck in his or her time.
All that being said, I appreciated Stephen Boyd's performance as Messala, as the pompous yet repressed emotions he brought to each scene matched perfectly with the idea that Messala is supposed to be a villain. That's his purpose, and that Boyd made that perfectly clear in every goddamn scene should be congratulated. Man, that death scene, after the chariot race? A performance absolutely dripping with vitriol. I loved it. (I don't recognize any of his other movies, and he passed away in 1977, so there's not much anyway.)
Jack Hawkins was billed as second lead, and he played Quintus in a somewhat smaller role than his billing would suggest. He was serviceable in his role, I'd say. Nothing to write home about. But maybe that was the point—here's a Roman nobleman, humbled by a slave who saved his life. I dunno. Maybe the two other Old Hollywood movies he shows up in on my list—The Bridge on the River Kwai and Lawrence of Arabia—will prove me wrong.
Haya Harareet plays Judah's love interest, Esther. Not a great performance, but I said I wasn't going to do this... it's Old Hollywood. Great performances not necessary. Plus, this was Harareet's first American film (only one of two total), and I can't imagine how difficult it is to be ESL and be asked to act in English. (I have more to say about Esther, but I'll save it for later.)
Probably the less said about Hugh Griffith's (Oscar-winning?!?!) performance, the better.
I dunno, I'm struggling to think of a reason to mention anyone else, as neither the performers are recognizable to me nor were the performances particular memorable. I know that's shitty of me to sweep it all under the rug just because this movie is from a different era, but I've already done enough equivocating. Like, I guess it's noteworthy than Martha Scott portrayed Charlton Heston's mother in both Ben-Hur and The Ten Commandments? But otherwise, why should I care about Martha Scott? Is it really worth paging through a filmography that includes such hits as 1943's Hi Diddle Diddle?? No, there's nothing else to see here.
Okay, alright, I suppose I should mention the director and writers, even though it's kind of the same deal as with actors. William Wyler directed Ben-Hur, and I thought it was a job well done, even though there were plenty of directorial choices that were left on the table just due to the fact that this was Old Hollywood. Sorry, I know I'm beating the horse dead right now with the Old Hollywood shit, but it's important! Ben-Hur is a surprisingly simple film, and it's not the movie's fault, and it's certainly not director William Wyler's fault.
At least it seemed like Wyler was trying to push the boundaries a little bit, ya know? I noted one particular shot in my phone memos while watching, around the time Judah and Quintus were saved by the slave ship after their own ship had sunk and they had been stranded at sea. The camera follows Judah's vision as he looks into the dark galley, where the slaves are still pounding away at the oars. That shot conveys the thought that Judah himself may be saved, but the anger and injustice of it all still exists. That shot stood out to me because it came very close to breaking the 180-degrees rule. Not that the camera is panning to the audience, but it is panning down, beneath the metaphorical stage, if you will. It bent a rule, but still served an important purpose. So good job Wyler.
There were a whole bunch of writers attached to this screenplay, with one guy writing something that the director didn't like, and having other writers take a pass at it, and so on, right on down the line, so it gets to the point where you don't even know who wrote what. Does this happen often today? Most of the Pixar films we watch with the kids, for instance, usually have like four writers given credit. It seems like this was a more regular thing in Old Hollywood, however.
Doesn't mean if it was normal that it was necessarily accepted by the writers themselves. Karl Tunberg is given full credit for the screenplay, but Gore Vidal and Christopher Fry, two other writers who had contributed a lot, started a "bitter publicized dispute" between each other and with William Wyler. The argument over who wrote what seems to have contributed to the fact that Best Adapted Screenplay was the only Oscar nomination for Ben-Hur that did not translate into a win.
Gore Vidal seems to have had the most to say about the screenplay, but we're gonna touch on some of his insight in the next section.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Does It Hold Up?
Maybe I misnamed this section. There are definitely a few moments and decisions in this film that I can definitively point to and say "that does not hold up," but I also want to discuss a few other thoughts I had about this film, those iffy decisions that aren't necessarily frowned up by everyone, but could definitely be pointed to as a reason why someone might not like this film as much as someone else.
First, the most obvious, and the most disappointing. A major character in this film wears brownface. There's no sweeping this one under the rug. Hugh Griffiths plays Sheik Ilderim, a character who recruits chariot racers and sets up bets for chariot races (I think? I was a little unclear with his role in this). Griffiths is a Welsh actor, i.e. white, and he is playing the role of a man from Arabia. He wears brown makeup. There's no denying this.
Two things make it worse. First is that he plays the role cartoonishly. Not that a serious role would translate much better, but it's extra unfortunate that Griffiths uses the outlandish Arabian accent and is all wide-eyed parody. Second is that this role was apparently WORTHY OF AN OSCAR. The Academy did not condemn the use of brownface in Ben-Hur, oh no. They rewarded it.
The immediate reaction is to say "1959 was a different time," and I've overexplained the subsequent train of thought before (when the N-word was used in The Bad News Bears, the transphobia in Ace Ventura, etc.). Yes, it was a different time, when portraying a racial stereotype was deemed okay. Yes, it is not the type of performance that is okay today, or accepted, and rightly so. But what I struggle with, the reason why I keep bringing shit like this up every time a movie makes me, is my role in all of this. I don't enjoy Griffiths performance, I like Ben-Hur a little less because of it, I would warn
a POC that this happens in the movie before he or she watches it, I would advocate for and be totally accepting of a warning flashed on screen prior to filming that it features brownface, and so on.
I don't know where I should draw the line personally. I don't think there is a responsibility on my end to completely dismiss Ben-Hur because of the brownface. It seems more important to discuss this, to condemn this specific aspect of the film, and to make it clear that it's NOT OKAY, than to just skip over Ben-Hur completely. I'm trying to keep myself educated, and I'm going to have a better grip on this next time a movie that doesn't hold up in this specific regard pops up. For now, this is where I have to leave it, even if it's starting to sound like virtue signaling.
This isn't the only aspect that doesn't "hold up" with Ben-Hur. Though it's not as explicitly noxious as brownface, I think the power dynamics between Judah and Esther have aged pretty poorly too. There's a pair of scenes (before the inciting incident of the roof collapse) which feature the two characters. In the first, Judah meets his slave's daughter, and approves of her freedom so that she can be married off to a wealthy suitor, even though it's clear that Judah now has eyes for her too. In the second scene, Judah expresses his desires to her, and they make googly eyes at each other, before finally making out. It practically comes out of nowhere, is injected into the movie so as to create romantic tension basically, and comes off as just really, really creepy. Slave owner hooking up with slave is an unbeatably awful breech of power dynamics. Icky, icky, icky.
But the movie plays it off like some grand romance. Once again, we ask the intentions of an Old Hollywood film. It wouldn't make any sense for a grand historical epic to not feature a romance! This is just how movies worked. No one is questioning power dynamics when two hot leads are locking lips!
That leads me to wonder if Esther was properly utilized in this film. Clearly, Ben-Hur operates from a patriarchal viewpoint—Esther mostly exists to be viewed at by the heterosexual men around her. Same with Judah's mother and sister, though not in an incestuous way. Rather, they are terrified that Judah will see them with their leprosy, and would rather he believe they are dead then see them with rotting flesh on their faces.
This struck me as rather absurd, that the movie would be that heavily invested in how Judah's family members look. I mean, I get that leprosy was an extreme form of social exclusion at the time (lepers even had their own "valley" in which they all had to live together!), but the film takes their looks seriously, to an uncomfortable degree. See how the prison warden looks on at disgust at the lepers. See how Messala uses their leprosy as one last evil dig at Judah before Messala dies. See how distraught and suicidal Judah becomes when he sees his disfigured family members.
It's just weird to me because if, say, I was disfigured in a car accident, I wouldn't expect Pam to find me quote unquote "attractive" anymore, but I also wouldn't want to fake my own death over it, and I certainly wouldn't want Pam to question her own will to live because of it. It's the idea that the mother's and sister's existence and worth depends entirely on their looks that gives me pause, and absolutely makes me consider Ben-Hur to be an exercise in the "male gaze" in Old Hollywood.
There's a lot that doesn't hold up, clearly (we probably won't even get to that random scene in the Roman Palace featuring Les Ballets Africains!), but there is one aspect of the film that might have ironically aged quite nicely here in 2020. Let's get back to one of the screenwriters, Gore Vidal (man, if there was ever an Old Hollywood Screenwriter Name, it's "Gore Vidal").
Starting in the '90s, Vidal started making the claim that he had written the reunion scene between Judah and Messala at the beginning of the film to feature "homoerotic undertones." His thinking was that Messala should feel the way a spurned lover would feel, and apparently word got to Stephen Boyd that he should play the scene that way.
Everyone's role in this half-urban-legend, half-substantiated-allegation is a bit muddled, because everyone says something different. Vidal made the initial claim that that's how he wrote it. Wyler claims that he didn't remember having that conversation with Vidal, and that Vidal didn't contribute much to the final version of that scene anyway. A film critic F.X. Feeney was able to compare drafts and note that Vidal did have many significant contributions to the final product. The publicity director for the film, Morgan Hudgens, inferred the homoeroticism, and later noted in correspondence with Vidal: "[Heston] really threw himself into your 'first meeting' scene yesterday. You should have seen those boys embrace!" Heston denied knowing anything about it, saying later that the implication "irritates the hell out of me" (showing shades of Diana Ross in her initial reaction to "I'm Coming Out," though while Ross would eventually relish her role in the LGBTQ community, Heston would only become more homophobic as he aged). Vidal claimed that he only told Boyd about this implied part of the script, but was told by Wyler: "don't tell Chuck because he'll fall apart."
Whatever the case may be, the alleged romantic tension between the two characters and two actors was palpable enough that Pam brought it up during our viewing, without knowing anything about Ben-Hur or the writing production. She said that she was told at one point that a lot of these Old Hollywood movies featured implied homosexuality, since they couldn't actually show it, due to the times and "how it was."
I don't doubt that other Old Hollywood films feature similar type scenes, though I wouldn't be able to tell you offhand. (Okay, wait, wasn't "Friend of Dorothy" a thing stemming from Wizard of Oz?) I can definitely tell you that Old Hollywood films were definitely not allowed to feature such ideas even if they wanted to. This was an actual thing—the Motion Picture Production Code. It's a set of guidelines that spell out the rules of self-censorship from what was deemed immoral and unacceptable at the time.
That Hollywood now fully embraces the existence of homosexuality, and no longer deems it "immoral," means that a movie like Ben-Hur wouldn't have to hide it any longer (and might even mean that its lead would be accepting of the stage note, instead of "irritated as hell" by it). Such a relationship between Ben-Hur and Messala would deepen their relationship on screen, and cause their rift to be felt on additional levels. So let's take Gore Vidal's word for it—if we pretend/acknowledge that Judah and Messala are gay together, then we not only improve Ben-Hur slightly, but we can also make shitheel Charlton Heston spin in his grave a few times while we're at it.
There's one other aspect of Ben-Hur I want to touch on here, even though I don't know if it's a question of "how well does this hold up?" It's important to discuss, though, because it's an aspect of the film that I could see being a turn-off for a portion of the audience. I'm talking about the film's overt push for Christianity.
I've already impressed upon you the importance of Jesus in the context of this film, but there are definitely a few moments that go beyond "Jesus was nice and you should be nice too." Esther's turn to Christianity is presented as a reasonable solution to Judah's issue with being too hateful—if we all follow Jesus, then everything will be solved. This is made literal when Judah's sister and mother, afflicted with leprosy, are miraculously cured by Jesus as a last-second miracle while he dies on the cross. It is made known to Judah: if you believe in Christ, you will be healed.
And that's... that's a little too heavy handed for me and my atheistic ass, even if I appreciate the broader message of "be kind to your neighbor." Just a little bit, though. I appreciate the lengths that Ben-Hur went to create as secular an experience as possible, but sometimes it just wasn't possible. No one wants to watch a "Christian film," but there's really no way around this one. Jesus is a character. The other characters learn to be more like Jesus. It mostly stops there, but if it had taken even a half-step further in that direction, I think it would've been too much.
There's an argument to be made that the whole thing with Jesus is a metaphor, applicable to any modern scenario you might encounter. If there's evil, you need to meet it with goodness, and be willing to explore the duality of good/evil and how the line between the two isn't always clear, etc., etc. The director, for example, (and a Jew, by the way) took on this film because he saw parallels between Judah's struggles with the fascist Roman Empire and the situation in Israel today (or "today" in 1959, anyway). He also saw the same struggle in Hollywood itself at the time, and how Hollywood was fighting back against America's blacklisting any suspected Communists, and so on.
It doesn't have to be that Christian. It just so happens that it is kind of Christian. Enough that China banned Ben-Hur for having "propaganda of superstitious beliefs, namely Christianity." I wouldn't go so far as to say it was propaganda, and I don't appreciate censorship from anyone, but, ya know, it is kind of superstitious, ya know?
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Chariot Race Scene
Pretty much everything I've read says that the so-called "chariot race scene" in Ben-Hur is the most memorable and famous scene in the movie, and possibly up there in terms of cinema in general. I enjoyed it, for the most part, but I think this is the work of the "Elvis Presley Theory" again. I get how monumental the scene was to 1959 moviegoers, but in 2020, it seems just a little bit primitive to me. Some cool shots, and it definitely moved the story forward in an interesting way, but I've been more thrilled with other action sequences.
Anyways, how about you see for yourself? If you've made it down this far without ever having seen Ben-Hur (not sure why you'd be reading all this, but to each his own), then you deserve a break. Let's see some chariot racers trampled, shall we?
I'm not that much of an asshole—I do appreciate the fact that it was a monumental task to pull these stunts off in 1959, without the aid of digital effect or CGI.
I appreciate that the scene was so monumental that critics are still talking about it 60 years later, as if that eight-minute bit is the most important part of the four-hour movie. Maybe it is, who the fuck am I to say? The Guardian, in its 60th anniversary retrospective, made the argument that the chariot race is the only enduring legacy of this movie, and no one gives a fuck about anything else. The NY Times, in its review of the 2016 remake (more in a second), said that maybe it wasn't the spectacle that was important, but the context of that spectacle, since the remake had an incredible CGI-filled action-packed chariot scene for a new era and it ultimately fell flat.
Whatever the case is, I had a fun time watching, and I couldn't care less about what its legacy is.
(Wait, I almost forgot to mention, apparently the pod race from The Phantom Menace was heavily influenced by the chariot race? I'm not going to put in the legwork on this one, but all you Menaceheads can feel free to speak up in the comments!)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
IMDB Trivia
We explore the best and worst of IMDB's Ben-Hur trivia page.
BEST: "The sum wagered by Messala against the sheik of 4-to-1 odds on 1,000 talents would be the modern-day equivalent of approximately 660 million dollars." This is constantly a question Pam and I pose to each other when an older historical fiction mentions any type of money. Pam asked this in what I thought was jest during Ben-Hur during this scene, but only because I thought that "talents" was a made-up currency. It's not, apparently. Here's the answer, Pammy.
WORST: "There was no wrap party after the shooting of Ben-Hur." I mean, it's almost hilarious how inconsequential the trivia gets toward the bottom of these pages.
ALMOST CASTED (WHO THE FUCK CARES): "Cesare Danova screen-tested to play Ben-Hur." Who the fuck cares? And who the fuck is Cesare Danova?
I also have a piece of trivia to add to this section myself. I recently rewatched the pilot to Cheers (probably because I miss bars), and one of the bar arguments that Norm, Cliff, and the guys get into is "What's the sweatiest movie ever made?" I.e. what movie features characters that sweat the most? All the three examples given are on my Never Seen It list. Rocky II and Alien were contenders, but Ben-Hur had the best reception: "Hey, it got sweaty in those galleys!"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Awards
I was tempted to cut this section, because the Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards did not exist back then, and that's really the only award ceremony I give a shit about. So we won't be talk about the chariot race between Keenan Thompson and Kel Mitchell, or the award for "Best Buttkicking God" going to Jesus Christ, or Hugh Griffith having the opportunity to wear greenface instead of brownface (because, you see, he got slimed).
But I'll include the section anyway, only because Ben-Hur is the most Oscar-winning film of all time. It won eleven of the twelve awards it was nominated for, including Best Picture, Director, Actor, Supporting Actor, Score (it's most deserved, in my opinion), and so on. Its eleven wins were only matched by two other movies—Titanic and LotR: Return of the King—and never beaten. When you consider the fact that many awards won by those latter two movies didn't exist in 1960, one might still consider Ben-Hur the all-time Oscar champ. (Also of note: William Wyler is the only person in history to have directed three Best Picture winners.)
For real, though, its zero Kids Choice Blimps ties it for the least amount of Blimps in film history.
~~~~~~~~~
Source, Sequels, and so on
This is the least interesting part of any movie discussion I've ever had: the fact that this movie is based on a book that neither I nor anyone I know will ever read. That goes double for Ben-Hur, since its source material was a turgid Christian book from 1880. [Chandler voice] Could I be any less interested?
I am equally uninterested in the 1925 version of Ben-Hur, which was a black-and-white silent film. I'm sure it was kinda like 1959's version but even more primitive and infinitely boring. I read through a comparison between all the versions (written on an Austin-based local news station's blog, I guess?), and it makes the case that dunking on the 1925 version would be really unfair, since filmmaking at its outset was just so fucking limited with what it could do. I get it.
But the 2016 remake sounds real fucking bad, doesn't it? And what's that film's excuse? All the info I have for this comes from that NY Times review. It stars Jack Huston (holy shit, it's Richard from Boardwalk Empire!!) as Judah. It probably fixes all the uncomfortable bullshit from the 1959 film (Morgan Freeman plays the sheik so no racial makeup required, probably doesn't give off rapey vibes between Judah and Esther, etc.), but also is apparently more explicitly Christian? And not only shows Jesus' face this time, but also has him drop cliché platitudes for the audience? (And is played by Paulo from Lost?)
As we exhaustively covered in our Your Favorite Movie series, there is rarely a need for a remake. The fact that the 2016 version of Ben-Hur was the FIFTH adaptation of the same fucking book is insane to me. Let's get some new ideas in here.
Like... what would a Ben-Hur sequel look like? I think it would probably be some sort of interquel, a story that takes place at the same time as both Judah's story and Jesus' story. Or it could be like The Lion King 1½, where you just follow Judah during the three years of his slave galley adventures. What kinda wacky stuff was he getting into during those years? Let's find out!!!! Studio execs, are you listening?!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Final Thoughts
Okay, cards on the table. When considering Judah and Messala's relationship, the ways in which it crumbles, and the central tension between the two, I could think of nothing but trumpers. I'm sorry, I know this gets to be too much sometimes on this blog, but the comparison is just too easy. Two friends, one who just wants his community to have a better life, and one who is a bootlicking toady willing to crush his friend in service of his almighty leader. I don't know how you can watch Ben-Hur and see Messala as anything but a proto-version of a MAGA hat wearer.
You see what you want to see. I get it. Here's what I didn't want to see: the protagonist, our hero, be told he is wrong too. I mean, he's right: it was fucked up that the Romans came in and destroyed the Jewish community just because they could. But the main thesis of this whole thing is that Ben-Hur's reaction, the way he allowed the hate to curdle within him and to turn him into the villain... that's how I saw myself.
I wake up every day and hate trump, and obsess over how various friends and family members have disappointed me by acting like Messala during trump's rule. I can feel the hate curdling inside of me. It doesn't feel very good. If I think that I am right, just like Judah thought he was right, then I also feel like SHIT about it, just like Judah felt like SHIT about it.
So yeah, Ben-Hur is one of those movies that seems old and primitive, because it is, and it has its flaws because of the time period it was made. But despite all that, I really appreciated the way it was able to reach across the generations and put a mirror to my face. I don't want to become the person I hate. There's room for more love in my life.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~
NEXT TIME: I can't imagine a more welcome respite from a '50s epic historical four-hour drama then the potentially breezy romantic comedy of Bend It like Beckham.

2 comments:
Nice write up - I haven't watched this movie and this helped fill in the gaps of why it won all the Oscars (which is why I read so far). I think your points around "Old Hollywood" and the Elvis theory are spot on.
The Phantom Menace fun fact really tripped me up, but the internet is afire with it. Here's an old Gizmodo article and a YouTube video about it.
Now THIS is chariot racing !!
Yes! I knew in my heart of hearts that Sunny was a Menacehead!!
Post a Comment