Tuesday, August 25, 2020

XPN's Greatest Songs of All Time


Ranking "Greatest Songs of All Time" is an impossible task, due to the sheer volume of amazing songs out there. Nevertheless, the WXPN community has once again taken on this impossible task, after having already done so in 2004. The radio station is asking its listeners to rank their own Top Ten, and then they'll compile all the lists to create one master list. The list will rank the alleged Top two-thousand and twenty songs of all time.

You can take a look at 2004's list, and see that there aren't many surprises. The boomers who listen to XPN know what they like. The Beatles, Bob Dylan, and Bruce Springsteen make up nine of the top twelve songs (with the Stones, Van Morrison, and U2 claiming the other three spots). For a station that prides itself in playing all kinds of new and interesting music, their Greatest Songs list sure seems like something a classic rock station would put together.

I guess I'm not complaining. I could see a scenario in which I consider "Thunder Road" one of the greatest songs of all time. It's not the greatest song of all time, mind you, but XPN's #1 song choice is not so egregiously off the mark that I'm upset about it. Same with something like "Like a Rolling Stone." Amazing song... not the third best song of all time, but, ya know, it's good enough that #3 sits just comfortably enough with me. (Really, out of the Top 20, the only preposterous choice in my opinion is #2 "Imagine." It's an awful song, regardless of how you feel about John Lennon.)

Okay, but this is a community-generated list. Anyone can submit their Top Ten. I have a say in what makes the list and what doesn't. My submission might be a drop of water in an ocean of personal lists, but I still have some say in how the list shakes out. If I can use my own personal list to change XPN's Top 2020 in some infinitesimal way, then it will have been worth it.

In that vein, I think simply submitting a list of my own personal Top Ten Songs of All Time would be a waste of time. I don't want to list ten songs if none of them have a chance to crack the list of 2020. I want to strategically compile my personal list, and make it so as to maximize my chances of having an impact as XPN compiles the master list.

(Plus, the list is "greatest" songs, not "favorite" songs. I'm comfortable including on my list mostly songs that wouldn't even crack my Top 40 "favorite" songs, because "favorite" implies personal preference. "Greatest" should also consider cultural impact, staying power, artist legacy, and so on. So that's something to keep in mind.)

Here are some thoughts.

My #1 choice should be my sincere #1 song of all time. I have an answer for this; I have for years. It should be no surprise to anyone who has listened to this song with me before (or has read about it on this blog). I keep this song at #1, even though there is a close to 0% chance that it will make the list, because there are 2020 songs on the list, and so if only like two other people include the song, then who knows, it might roll in at #1993 or something. I can't rule out the possibility, and I have to give it every chance I can.

At least three other songs should be included somewhere in the #6 through #10 spots as a protest vote. These are songs that are also legitimately Top Ten All Time for me personally, but there is so little chance that they could end up on this list that it might as well be impossible. But I include them still because they are songs that deserve to be sung out to the masses, and so I include them in the same way I would throw a penny in a fountain and make a wish. I show support even if the support means nothing.

Four songs should already be on the list from 2004, but deserve to be higher. I include these songs because I know they already have a following—they must if they were included on enough 2004 lists to make XPN's Top 885 already. I want to add my vote to their new totals, and hopefully bump them up as many spots as they deserve to be bumped.

Finally, two songs should be from artists that are heavily featured on the previous list, but the songs themselves were not included because people are idiots. These are the deep cut tracks designed to split votes. Maybe an artist's most famous song needed one more vote to crack the Top Ten, but I deprive that artist of that needed vote by voting instead for their least popular song. I can add to the possibility that my favorite song from that artist will be featured, while at the same time knocking one of their worse (in my opinion) songs down a few pegs.

With all that in mind, I have compiled my own personal Top Ten Greatest Songs of All Time that I will be subsequently submitting to WXPN for tabulation. Again, this is nothing close to what my personal Favorite Songs of All Time list would like.

You'll have to do your best to determine which songs fit into which of the categories I just described, since I'll keeping the details close to my chest and presenting the list as is.

10. "Everybody's Got Something to Hide Except for Me and My Monkey" by the Beatles

9. "Point/Counterpoint" by Streetlight Manifesto

8. "Don't Go Back to Rockville" by R.E.M.

7. "Steal My Sunshine" Len

6. "Stuck Between Stations" by the Hold Steady

5. "Pink Moon" by Nick Drake

4. "I'm Goin' Down" by Bruce Springsteen

3. "Comfortably Numb" by Pink Floyd 

2. "There She Goes" by the La's

1. "The Underdog" by Spoon

No comments: