"the last great american dynasty"
Taylor Swift
from folklore
2020
It's a travesty that I didn't even mention this song in last week's review, since it's fantastic, so here ya go. But I mainly wanted an excuse to mention briefly something weird I noticed on Twitter on the weekend after this album was released.
Puke on Your Birthday is on Twitter now, in case you haven't seen that. Yay? I've been on Twitter personally for almost twelve years but have used it almost exclusively as a form of ultra-short blogging for that entire time. Because I'm just using it as a notepad for half-formed jokes, I haven't been privy to the overarching purpose of Twitter all this time, that toxic hivemind aspect of it that everyone else has been exposed to. But with PoYB's account, I dove in, following anyone that looked interesting to follow. It's fucking weird and strangely alien, watching how complete strangers react en masse to certain pop culture events.
I followed Pitchfork, and because they are a music publication, they tweeted like five times about folklore in the 48 hours after it was released. Curious about how Twitter responded to the album, I clicked on a few of the tweets to look at the replies. Every tweet was absolutely flooded with replies that all basically said the same thing: "You should review folklore and give it a 10.0 or I'm going to kill myself."
I mean, this is weird, right? Even copypasta aside. I'm not just going crazy here? Is this how Twitter is all the time? Or are Swifties just a strange and loyal breed?
The main question is, what do these people even hope to achieve? folklore is already the most talked about album of the summer. It's going to sell more than any other album this year, and we're talking actual hard copies of CDs that are paid for with cash. It's going to win awards. Taylor Swift is already one of the top five most popular musical artists working today. What exactly is the point of tweeting at a music publication, asking for a review?
The closest thing I could even compare this to in my own life is my behavior regarding Community when it aired (talked about this briefly a few weeks ago). I used to write on Facebook, asking people to watch Community, since it was at risk of being yanked off the air. As embarrassing as that social media behavior was, at least there was a purpose behind it. Community, a show I liked, would stay on the air if more people watched it. My actions were flawed (it really didn't matter if you tuned in unless you were a Nielsen family), but the intention was sincere. I wanted a thing I liked to continue to exist.
It really doesn't matter what Pitchfork does with folklore. It could get a 1.0 review or a 9.9 review, and the results would be the same: Taylor Swift fans will love it, anti-poptimists will dismiss it, and the sad dads in between will be healthily intrigued.
My main point, I guess, is that I have no idea why people waste their time like this on Twitter. Frankly, I don't want to understand it. Swift is somewhere between a 10.0 and 0.0, and I'll enjoy it no matter what Pitchfork or the stans in its replies say.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~





No comments:
Post a Comment