Tuesday, August 18, 2020

Top Five Tuesday: Short Songs / Long Songs

The Olivia Tremor Control—not featured on either list, but they love shitty short songs and shitty long songs

I've always been interested in the idea of categorizing music by totally arbitrary means, pairing and grouping music for reasons that have nothing to do with the substance of the music itself. A good example of this was the WPPR episode I did a couple months ago, featuring songs that all had the word "baby" in them. Alphabetizing is another good one. I could go on forever (how about songs with a number in them? albums whose title comes from a lyric on that album only?).

Today, I'd like to briefly explore one such category—length of song. The standard song in the early days was between two and three minutes, but we've long since thrown that rule out. A song can be whatever length you want it to be. So what are some of the extremes?

Top Five Worst "Songs" Under 20 Seconds

There's nothing wrong with a short song—just look at like any punk album ever—but when you start to get really short, you start to lose the essence of what makes a song a song in the first place. Can you fit a complete idea into a fifteen-second song? Theoretically, I guess. But for the most part, uber-short songs are used for dumb padding—intros, outros, rests in between songs, stupid brief skits, you name it. Here is a selection of my least favorite "songs" of this length.

5. "Horn Intro" by Modest Mouse (0:09)

I get that introduction songs are allegedly important to Big Idea albums, but what purpose does "Horn Intro" really serve? The same horns are in Track 9, "This Devil's Workday." Do we really need a preview for that song? Is "This Devil's Workday" really that integral a song?

4. "Miracle Cure" by the Who (0:10)

If you can't get through the plot of your rock opera in the proper songs, then why even do a rock opera? I can't believe the Who unleashed the idea of "the album skit" on the world like this.

3. "Outro" by Rilo Kiley (0:04)

I question the existence of this track—Wikipedia says it doesn't even exist. But every other source confirms that Rilo Kiley did include a four-second silent track at the end of The Execution of All Things. Its existence bothers me in general, but never when I'm listening—it's so short that most time I don't even notice it played.

2. "[seven seconds]" by Titus Andronicus (0:07)

Like Rilo Kiley's "Outro," Titus Andronicus included an under-ten-second silent track on their album (The Most Lamentable Tragedy). Unlike "Outro," "[seven seconds]" is a purposeful break in the action. Because apparently the audience needs seven seconds of rest before the gripping conclusion? I dunno, I question the necessity of this one, especially since there was a 1:17 silent track earlier in the album already.

1. "!!!!!!!" by Billie Eilish (0:14)

"I have taken out my Invisalign, and this is the album," followed by a laugh that says "I think I am way funnier than I actually am." I know that laugh. I fucking invented that laugh.




Top Five Songs Over Ten Minutes

At the other end of the spectrum we have the long songs. And opposite to short lengths being equated to frivolous futility, longer songs tend to have some added weight to them. It's almost as if long songs announce their importance through their length alone. There's a sense of immortality to a lot of them. When done right, long songs are the best songs. After acknowledging that there's a limit to my love (e.g. I have no interest in exploring anything that Guinness might call "the longest ever"), here are my favorite over-ten-minute songs of all time.

5. "Dogs" by Pink Floyd (17:04)

I always thought it was cool how Animals pretty much consists of three really long songs (plus two really short ones), and all three of them hold your attention through their entire lengths. "Dogs" is the longest, and the best, and I'm not sure that's causation or just coincidental correlation.

4. "The Tain" by the Decemberists (18:30)

Are the Decemberists a secret prog-rock band? Judging by their longest and possibly best song, maybe! I saw these guys perform "The Tain" live back in the day, which is fucking ballsy if you ask me.

3. "Impossible Soul" by Sufjan Stevens (25:35)

I've already written about this song a lot, but I just had to include it here. One of the greatest achievements in modern indie rock, and not just because Part III makes me tear up.

2. "The Battle of Hampton Roads" Titus Andronicus (14:02)

I thought long and hard about whether I should contribute to Patrick Stickles' Patreon, if only because a few of the donation levels include Q&A sessions, and I would love to bend this dude's ear about the making of "The Battle of Hampton Roads." (But I've written about this album enough already too.)

1. "Sister Ray" by the Velvet Underground (17:28)

One might call this song "repetitive," and maybe that's true. But I see it as the fact that it is repetitive and yet still enthralling and engaging throughout the entire seventeen minutes is what makes it memorable. I don't mean to be hyperbolic, but this truly is the sound of music collapsing in on itself.



Honorable mentions: "Achilles Last Stand" by Led Zeppelin (also, I didn't include any of the various near-20-minute live Led Zeppelin songs littering my iPod, but all are pretty phenomenal); "Desolation Row" by Bob Dylan (my "first" long song); "Dragon's Lair" by Sunset Rubdown (this, on top of the fact that the title of the song and the title of the album are homophones); "The Past Is a Grotesque Animal" by Of Montreal; "When the Music's Over" by the Doors (John Densmore's drumming was never better); "1983... (a Merman I Should Turn to Be)" by the Jimi Hendrix Experience (I'll never forget being 75% asleep and listening to this song for the very first time—it was the closest I've ever come to having a true hallucinatory experience)

No comments: