Stout
(#18)
Exemplified by Dragon Stout
Imperial Stout
(#23)
Exemplified by Old Rasputin
I'm bunching these two together because they are basically the same thing, except the imperial is stronger than the regular, but that's it.
When we talked about porters, we brought up the question I've been asking literally since Day 1: what is the difference between a porter and a stout? In our discussion about porters, there was no answer, because I wasn't sure. For today's discussion about stouts, I will unequivocally answer the question, once and for all. **There is no difference**. That's it! That's the answer!
Originally, stouts were just "strong porters." I mean, if you want some 19th century proof of this, then look no further than an 1803 article in The Times of London newspaper about some dickhead stealing a barrel of beer: "the cask was of a porter, of superior quality, called Brown Stout."
There's been plenty of different stout recipes over the years, and some of them wildly different. As long as they have a dark black or brown color, and a roasty flavor, then you can safely call them a stout (or porter, or whatever, what do I look like, the beer police?). All of them have those two things in common, but other than that, it's whatever.
Randy Mosher claims that stouts today are usually closer to a coffee flavor, and porters are closer to a chocolate flavor. Of course, that's not always the case. The American Stout that I had a couple weeks ago was incredibly coffee-like, but the stout I had yesterday was sweeter, definitely akin to chocolate—but called "stout," not "porter."
And like I said, the imperial stout is basically the same as a stout (or porter too, I guess), except it has more alcohol in it. With the Old Rasputin I had today, at least, you could sincerely taste the alcohol. It was bracing, and was almost unbearable on top of the spicy jerk chicken and spicy rice on my dinner plate. But I am no wimp. I finished my imperial stout. I'm just saying that it's not something I would drink for pleasure.
It's disappointing that there is no answer to "what's the difference between porter and stout?" But that's how it goes with beer—everything is subjective, nothing matters, drink what you want.
NOTES
BEER: Old Rasputin (illusions to the "imperial court of Russia," hence, "imperial stout")
STYLE: Imperial Stout
ABV: 9.0%
BREWED BY: North Coast Brewing Co.
LOCATION: Fort Bragg, California
PURCHASED AT: IGA
PAIRED WITH: Jerk chicken on the grill (trying to use up some of these marinades in the fridge before they expire)
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
BEER COUNT: 313.5 (Pam refuses to drink anything beer heavy and dark, so no splitsies today)

No comments:
Post a Comment