Saturday, August 15, 2020

Nucky and Tony

***spoilers for both TV series below!!!!!!!***

There are a lot of comparisons to be made between The Sopranos and Boardwalk Empire, especially because one of the main creative forces behind The Sopranos subsequently created Boardwalk Empire. They have similar sensibilities, both television programs following criminals and then asking the audience to root for those same criminals. They are both fun exercises in deep, fun performances taking precedence over the distress of dire circumstances.

I think it would be a disservice, though, to compare the main characters of each television show, as tempted as you might be to do so. Tony Soprano and Nucky Thompson are both pivotal figures in their own circles of crime, but the comparisons stop there. In terms of the manner in which we the audience perceive each character, they couldn't be farther apart.

Tony Soprano is a joy to watch, despite the fact that he is presented time and again to be a true monster. The man has charisma. His gravitas makes him the center of every room he steps into throughout the six seasons of The Sopranos, and his actions and decisions make for compelling television. He makes no measures to convince anyone in the audience at home that he is anything but the worst, most evil person on earth. He ruthlessly murders anyone in his path; even amidst his endless talk about "family being important," the members of his mob family are at no less a risk to his murderous rage. The Sopranos is rather explicit about all this, at various times framing him in the shot so that he literally resembles the devil himself. And yet, the audience roots for Tony Soprano. We want him to succeed. FBI Agent Harris is a stand-in for all of us, whooping and cheering when he finds out that Tony has won the NY vs. NJ war, even though he was once assigned to track Tony's various criminal undertakings. It doesn't matter what sins he commits—as a TV character, he is our hero.

Nucky Thompson is, in many ways, the opposite of Tony Soprano. His position in the room is always a bit precarious, his status always in question, so while he does his fair share of criminal maneuvering, he also has to play nice much more often than Tony does. Nucky is not a dictator, he is a politician. There is more pressure for him to find that balance between good and evil. Yes, the tally often ends up in favor of evil, but at least the attempt is there. That's more than you can ask of Tony Soprano. In addition, Nucky, by his very nature, lacks the focus and gravity that comes so naturally to Tony. It's part of the job—a politician exists to serve, not to be served. He is at time a vessel for other people's biddings. Yes, I can understand how that might make for a less compelling television character (and many people have many negative things to say about Steve Buscemi's performance, unfortunately). But I'm tired of your standard anti-hero. I want to at least be able to pretend that the character I'm rooting for was anything but the devil incarnate.

I'm not saying that there is more nuance to the character than Tony Soprano, because Tony Soprano has buckets of nuance, carried on the back of James Gandolfini's performance. I am, however, saying that there's more nuance in the audience's reaction to Nucky than the reaction to Tony. With Tony, you know what cards everyone holds. The dude sucks, but for better or worse we're gonna make a commitment to supporting him anyway (at least as a removed onlooker to a fiction story). With Nucky Thompson, it's tough to ever know what to think. Is he ultimately good, having just gotten wrapped up in some heinous, unforgivable lifestyles? Is he ultimately evil, with only a politician's superhuman ability to trick you otherwise?

This was the brilliance of the conclusion to Boardwalk Empire—that question was answered, finally, and in emphatic fashion. After wondering for years who exactly Nucky Thompson was, and what he really stood for, you get absolutely bitch-slapped with the answer.

The Sopranos' finale, of course, had a different kind of brilliance. All the questions had already been answered, at times gruesomely. You knew exactly where everyone stood as the Soprano family sat in that diner. The series, however, ends with one final question, a question that will never be answered.

So yeah, I could see how you might compare Nucky Thomspon and Tony Soprano if you're being lazy—they are both mob bosses who ostensibly care about family above all else. But there's much more to it than that. Damn the comparisons—Nucky Thompson is worthy of your consideration as one of the best characters in TV drama history.

No comments: