Thursday, August 6, 2020

Picking Apart the Songs of Dark Was the Night


For a while now, I've been meaning to check out Dark Was the Night, a 2009 charity compilation album curated by Aaron and Bryce Dessner. Aaron's work with folklore finally convinced me to check it out.

I'm surprised it took me this long, seeing as how I am intimately familiar with about 2/3rds of these artists. The album serves to document what indie rock was like at the turn of the decade, with many of these artists having just or just about to drop their seminal work.

For myself here in 2020, the album is serving a dual purpose. One, it is indeed reminding me to appreciate all these wonderful musicians whom I've appreciated since the late aughts. Two, it is providing me with NEW SONGS for each of these artists. I can't believe that the National, the Decemberists, Sufjan Stevens, and so on, were all hiding these gems from me for eleven years. A lot of these tracks aren't bullshit throwaway tracks. They are the real deal. Much of it is the same music that made me fall for these artists in the first place.

For lack of anything better to do around these parts (or perhaps in honor of the incredible fact that Aaron Dessner co-wrote the current #1 song in America!!!), I figured today I would go through each of these songs, and see which ones are worth our time. For the 21 artists I'm already familiar with, I asked: Is this song a worthy addition to an already stellar discography? Or is it a castoff B-side? For the ten artists whom I do not really know that well, I ranked their ten songs at the bottom.

There's not really a good place online to listen to all these songs in the order they were intended, but all are available individually, so I linked to each one as I name them. Click on the ones that sound interesting, maybe? However you wanna do it.

ARE THESE SONGS WORTHY OF THEIR RESPECTIVE ARTIST'S CANON?

"Knotty Pine" by Dirty Projectors and David Byrne
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes for Dirty Projectors, N/A for David Byrne
I'm familiar with enough of Dirty Projectors to know that this is a way better most of the shit that they do (it's a lot cleaner and straightforward). I'm familiar with enough of David Byrne's work to know that there can't really be a comparison; this is Byrne passing the torch, not trying to build on his own legacy.

"Train Song" by Feist and Ben Gibbard
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes for Feist, No for Ben Gibbard
Feist's best songs are the rare stomper; most of her stuff is along the lines of "Train Song," and most of it is fine. I will never fully get into Deathcab, but I know Ben Gibbard usually reaches much greater heights (ha) than this.

"Brackett, WI" by Bon Iver
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
There is no one better at these slow, ethereal, but low-key crooners than Bon Iver. The bouncy guitar in "Brackett, WI" gives it surprising warmth.

"Deep Blue Sea" by Grizzly Bear
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
This song is boring, and I am already bored enough with the rest of Grizzly Bear's shit. Did people really like this in the late aughts?

"So Far Around the Bend" by the National
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
I guess since members of the band curating this album, the National decided to bring their A-game. I can't believe I've never heard this song before. It's maybe one of the most lighthearted National songs in existence (not saying much, but there it is), possibly because of those lovely flutes in the back half. Worthy addition? How about National Top 20?

"Big Red Machine" by Justin Vernon and Aaron Dessner
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
This song inspired these two artists to continue the name "Big Red Machine" as both a name and a self-titled album in 2018. The album is incredibly underrated. Most of the songs are better on that album than this one.

"Sleepless" by the Decemberists
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
The Decemberists have done longer better, but "Sleepless" is no slouch. This band is so good and starting slow and soft, and gradually building up steam till the lighters are in the air. It's the world's slowest sunrise.

"Stolen Houses (Die)" by Iron & Wine
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
During the 66 seconds that "Stolen Houses" exists, it is good. But it is over before you can blink. Iron & Wine is capable of fleshing out sketches of ideas like this, but chose not to on Dark Was the Night. That's a bummer.

"Service Bell" by Feist and Grizzly Bear
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No, for either artist
This is a bad cover of a tepid Radiohead deep cut. There was no reason for either artist to do this, especially you, Feist. You're better than this (okay, maybe Grizzly Bear isn't though). How about just leave this song off and make the album a round 30 songs? It's not like Feist and Grizzly Bear aren't on here already.

"You Are the Blood" by Sufjan Stevens
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
The Age of Adz was as surprising as it was stunning. Maybe I wouldn't have been as surprised if I had heard this musical preview a year earlier. No one does 10-minute fuzzy electronic freakouts better than Sufjan Stevens! Nobody!

"Well-Alright" by Spoon
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
Scuzzy lo-fi rock a la Violent Femmes is actually a pretty good look on Spoon. Do they ever play like this is any of their full-length LPs? I'm only like 2/3rds through their discography, but would move a lot faster if that answer was "yes."

"Lenin" by Arcade Fire
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
"Lenin" is certainly not a bad song, but compared to the majesty of the rest of Arcade Fire's output, this one is weirdly muted. Probably for the best it was tossed off here instead of bloating The Suburbs even further.

"Mimizan" by Beirut
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
Oh gosh, is there any other '00s band that could carry a song on the back of an accordion and make it sound this good? Nope. Just Beirut.

"El Caporal" by My Morning Jacket
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
This song is growing on me, but I acknowledge the fact that Jim James is constantly winking as he sings this lounge lizard tune. A song like "El Caporal" with its Kenny G-esque saxophones have no place in any part of MMJ's canon.

"With a Girl like You" by Dave Sitek
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
I knew that this guy was a big part of TV on the Radio, and I definitely recognize his voice from some TVotR (a backup baritone to match Tunde Adebimpe's lead bark). I also am coming to appreciate this song the more I listen to it. But I just don't see how it could possibly match most of what TV on the Radio did (does?) during their time.

"Hey, Snow White" by the New Pornographers
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
It doesn't quite match up with the best of the New Pornos, but I think it's fascinating that Dan Bejar wrote this song, but it's Carl Newman taking lead vocal duties. Does that happen in any other NP song? I can't think of one. For that reason alone, I'd like to hear more. (Also, this makes me miss Dan Bejar in the New Pornographers.)

"Another Saturday" by Stuart Murdoch
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
Probably the same deal as Dave Sitek above. Are we comparing this to the act he is most associated with (in this case, Belle and Sebastian)? If so, it's B-level material at best. If not, and this is supposed to be true solo material, then I guess it's okay.

"Amazing Grace" by Cat Power and Dirty Delta Blues
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
Only because Cat Power did a covers album at one point, didn't she? (Yup.) "Amazing Grace" doesn't seem to far outside of her wheelhouse. No idea about Dirty Delta Blues, never heard of 'em.

"The Giant of Illinois" by Andrew Bird
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: Yes
I could recognize that violin anywhere. Of course this is Andrew Bird. Now where's that whistle?

"Lua" by Conor Oberst and Gillian Welch
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION(?) TO THE CANON: Yes
I mean, "Lua" is already an Oberst song, so I guess the question would be, is Gillian Welch a worthy addition to "Lua"? The answer there is also yes.

"Love vs. Porn" by Kevin Drew
IS IT A WORTHY ADDITION TO THE CANON: No
I hate when Broken Social Scene sounds like what "Love vs. Porn" sounds like. Thankfully, they do not sound like this too often. Bummer that this is the last track, though. Dark Was the Night really crawls to a close, huh?

~~~~~~~~~~~~

And now, the ten songs by artists I'm not familiar with, ranked:

10. "Happiness" by Jónsi & Alex
Almost nine minutes of ambient music. This is the worst song on Dark Was the Night by a mile. Does there really need to be nine minutes of this?!

9. "Dark Was the Night" by Kronos Quartet
Four minutes of indiscriminate violin strings being plucked. Pass. Kinda wild that the compilation as a whole shares the name with this total bullshit track. (Okay, okay, it was a Blind Willie Johnson song first. If I was at all familiar with Blind Willie Johnson, I would still not recognize this song in this experimental form.)

8. "When the Road Runs Out" by Blonde Redhead & Devastations
I saw Blonde Redhead at the TLA in 2007, and still I never really got into them. This song makes me think I made the right decision. Kinda brutal...

7. "Blood Pt. 2" by Buck 65 featuring Sufjan Stevens & Serengeti
I said I liked "You Are the Blood," but probably not enough that I needed a remix seven songs later.

6. "Gentle Hour" by Yo La Tengo
Yo La Tengo proves to me every time I listen to it that I will never be fully invested in post-rock.

5. "I Was Young When I Left Home" by ANOHNI with Bryce Dessner
She does a decent job with this Bob Dylan song, but I could never get into ANOHNI. Maybe she should cover Dylan all the time.

4. "Cello Song" by the Books featuring José González
I always felt that this was one of Nick Drake's more boring songs, so I was surprised to find I really enjoyed the Books' take. The off-kilter computer bloops in the background weirdly help a lot.

3. "Inspiration Information" by Sharon Jones & The Dap-Kings
Oh man, what an outlier of a band. Oh man, what a pleasant little breather of a song. Oh man, what would a Dap-Kings album look like if Aaron Dessner produced it?!

2. "Feeling Good" by My Brightest Diamond
Really interesting. It sounds almost like a song that a Disney villain would sing in a cartoon. I haven't heard the name "My Brightest Diamond" since college. I wonder if that one dude that I spoke to in freshman year of college and never spoke to again was right about her?

1. "Tightrope" by Yeasayer
A really beautiful song. I wonder if Yeasayer is worth checking out based on this song alone? The internet tells me no, but my heart tells me yes.

No comments: