Tuesday, July 28, 2020

Album Review: folklore


If "indie rock" is a marketing term, then here's your motherfucking market. I can't imagine there's many other reasonable decisions Taylor Swift could've made to pique my interest than reach out to the National's Aaron Dessner and get him to co-write/produce eleven of the sixteen songs. I've never hotly anticipated a Taylor Swift album, but there I was, intrigued about whether this was going to sound like a Swift-fronted Big Red Machine, and there I was, downloading and listening to this album before the kids even woke up.

I can't say I'm "disappointed"—to actually think that this was going to be Taylor Swift singing her version of "Mr. November" would be too much to hope for in any reality—but this is definitely a Taylor Swift album, not an Aaron Dessner album. Dessner leaves his mark indelibly, for sure, but Swift is the captain of this ship. I think it would've been helpful if Dessner didn't mention Bryan Devendorf's involvement before the release. The best drummer in the business today! On a Taylor Swift album?! Wild! But it ended up being just a slight programmed drum track on one song. "Mistaken for Strangers" this is not.

First, a clarification: I like Taylor Swift, and I like a lot of her music, and I think she is a wonderful songwriter, and if I say something like "nevermind, this is a Taylor Swift album," I mean that as a compliment, as backhanded as it may seem at first. Next, a folklore-specific take: the best song isn't even a Dessner contribution, so that should prove even further that Swift is in command. She is credited on every song. She is NOT a vehicle for male pop song producers to use for their own visions; she is a conqueror, and whom she uses to flesh out her own vision ultimately doesn't matter.

That's not to say that folklore finds Swift in some kind of No-Miss Zone. There are a few clunkers scattered around the album, mainly the ones that get too slow on an already really slow album (e.g. "epiphany," or maybe "exile"—don't let the Justin Vernon credit fool you). But the overwhelming majority of the songs do just enough to attach their claws into me. It might be a clever turn of phrase, an extra orchestral flourish, an F-bomb (yes, really!), a heart-wrenching Swiftian vocal performance that only she could pull off in this context with such ease.

The best song on folklore rockets to the top of my short list of best Taylor Swift songs of all time: "betty." This is probably just because I'm writing this fucking review only five days after folklore came out, but at this point I really can't imagine liking any other song in 2020 more than I like "betty." For real. It manages to capture the widescreen emotional payoffs of the best romantic comedies, while also sounding like high-grade Americana that the Decemberists traffic in at their best. That shift from "What if I showed up" to "I showed up"! That harmonica! The reveal that it's a companion piece to "cardigan"! That "I know I miss you" chorus that's just begging for a singalong! Ugh, ugh, ugh, I can't listen to this song too much; I want it to last forever.

As noted above, "betty" didn't pass through Aaron Dessner's hands, which possibly means that all the breathless "Who Is Taylor's New Producer: Explained" People Magazine pieces may have been a bit overstated. Let Jack Antonoff has his deserved praise: "betty" is an all-timer. "august" is almost as good, if we're talking Antonoff now. I really like "mirrorball" too.

Of course, there are some fucking excellent Swift/Dessner tracks on this thing too. As one of the internet's few defenders of Sleep Well Beast as the National's best album, I can tell you that Dessner uses the weird, choppy, piano-forward style he cemented on that album to great effect on folklore. The very first song, "the 1," immediately announces itself as a Dessner production with that low-key piano chord / computerized handclap combo. Following that is "cardigan," which layers on the whispery, ghostly synths that were all over the last two National albums (and might as well actually be from those albums, as far as I know).

By the time you get all the way down to "peace," though, maybe Dessner overstayed his welcome. I dunno. It's got a tiny little sliding guitar part that is so Big Red Machine it hurts, and by then it's like, alright, we get it, you've made your mark. I will think of "peace" when Swift is on the stage at next year's empty-arena Grammys, flanked on either side by Dessner and Antonoff as she holds aloft her third Album of the Year trophy, about how something that doesn't sound like Taylor Swift at all ended up sounding like Taylor Swift anyway, how she could take what is to me a commonplace musical motif from an artist whom 99% of Swifties had no previous knowledge of, and bizarrely brought it to the masses.

Here's the bottom line: there is some great shit on this album, and if it doesn't quite live up to the hype, then that's only because I was hyped up from the wrong direction. This isn't "Bloodbuzz Central Pennsylvania." This is Taylor Swift. She is reinvented, but it is still her. In that way, folklore is incredibly successful.

But if the point was to market to "sad dad indie rock fans" like myself, then folklore remains more intriguing than incredible.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: