I've mentioned Beer Advocate plenty of times in this column, but let's take a moment to sing its praises.
Beer Advocate (apparently there is no space in between the words, but we are going to keep the space there for consistency's sake) is a collaboratively run website all about beer, existing for the explicit purpose of reviewing beer. If you drink a beer, you can write a review on Beer Advocate. This also means that, besides the reviews, it exists as a vast trove of knowledge about almost every beer you've ever had. If you want to know how strong a beer is, where it was brewed, or what flavors it contains, then it's a simple google search away.
I've used Beer Advocate almost every day this year so far, more often than not to fill out the "Notes" section at the bottom of every This Is My Blood post. I've often used it as a source for where to buy beer in the city (though, not too much hitherto unknown info in that regard), as well as clarifying beer styles, and finding known brands within each style.
I also peruse the reviews occasionally, but I've never written one. So let me do that today. Let's write a review for Farmhouse Golden Ale, brewed by Flying Fish (a brand I've accidentally avoided this year, somehow). I will be the first review for this beer on this site, apparently.
One thing that I've noticed about beer reviews is that it's a total fucking paint-by-numbers operation. The boxes are checked—how does it look, how does it smell, how does it taste, how does it feel, overall impressions—and that's about it. There's a total absence of creativity. I understand that the joy for most people is the beer itself, not the describing it in words, but still... this shit gets boring after a while.
If you've read any of my Record Club reviews, you know that boilerplate is not what I strive for (example 1, example 2, example 3). I want to stretch the creative bounds of a typical beer review.
Now, here's the thing: I don't want to burst right out of the gate and right some batshit stupid beer review on Beer Advocate. I have no idea how strict they are. I've seen some really bare and poorly written reviews stick, but maybe that's okay and creative risks are not. I don't know! I need to work my way up to full-on crazy, and start slow.
So I'm going to write a review for Farmhouse Golden Ale, and only add one minor off-the-wall bit, while keeping the rest pretty normal. I'll dip my toe in the waters, check the temperature, and then come back later to see if it's safe to cannonball in.
"Farmhouse Golden Ale poured a solid yellow (more so than gold), with only a short foam head, which dissipated quickly, leaving a circle around the rim. It had a smooth mouthfeel. Bitter hops were noticeable on first sip. Minor notes of flora in the aroma, while the taste flavors included lemon (strong) and citrus (less so). Also had a somewhat metallic aftertaste, but that could've been the fault of a persistent ulcer I've had in the back of my throat for weeks. In any case, for a completely healthy person, this was a refreshing beer from first sip to last, but didn't leave a lasting impression by any means."
Sure enough, this warning was affixed to the review submission page: "Nonconstructive reviews may be removed without notice and action may be taken on your account." So we'll see how that ulcer bit flies. I'm hoping that, as long as I give constructive criticism first and foremost, I will then be able to attach and bullshit creative fancy I desire afterward.
As a sort of sidenote, I also attempted to update the picture for Farmhouse Golden Ale, since no one had done so yet. They seem to be a little stricter with this, at least more so than the reviews. They are strict about copyright (no worries, I take all my own pics, embarrassingly so). They are also super strict about the dimensions of the picture. It needs to be exactly 150(w)x300(h), and also under 20kb. So this picture I took yesterday wouldn't upload:
I found some shitty free website that was able to both change the dimensions and also make it worse quality. I was able to submit it. Um... something tells me this still won't be accepted by the admins...
Awful clownish photo notwithstanding, this was a good(?) first attempt at making my opinion known to the masses on a beer-specific website. I don't know how often I'll be submitting to Beer Advocate, but I want to add the general pooled knowledge of beer drinkers any way I can.
I will probably revisit this site via This Is My Blood next time I drink a beer that isn't known to Beer Advocate at all (most likely any beer from any of the small-batch local breweries).
NOTES
BEER: Farmhouse Golden Ale
STYLE: American Blonde Ale
ABV: 4.6%
BREWED BY: Flying Fish Brewing Company
LOCATION: Somerdale, New Jersey
PURCHASED AT: IGA (Flying Fish appeared to be on sale, based on the surplus of FF products on the clearance rack)
PAIRED WITH: Crack chicken (meh pairing, I needed something less bitter)
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
BEER COUNT: 264.5




No comments:
Post a Comment