Should I Watch This? Joe K*** steals Sam S*******'s conceit wholesale. Check out Sam's actual column HERE, and then text Sam and tell him that this column is worth saving. (Look, I just really wanna write about Community's season 4, and this seemed like the best way to do it.)
Show: Community
Season: Four (released in the spring of 2013, episodically, on NBC)
Episodes: 13, each around 22 minutes or so
How to Watch: Netflix AND Hulu (how often does that happen?)
Genre: Pop-culture-indebted-(and occasionally meta-)comedy
You'd Enjoy This Show if You Like: Endless pop culture references; quirky characters with zippy one-liners; understanding important moments in TV history
You'd Hate This Show if You Dislike: Heavily serialized comedies, or rather comedies that depend on callbacks for humor; meta exercises; mushy heart monologues; comedy legends phoning it in
The Pitch: It's kind of bizarre to think that there was a time in my life when a TV show was this important. Community, the story of seven lovable losers who attended a community college, was able to balance grand pop culture homages with melancholy truths about the human condition, which, to me and to a few hundred others, felt like this made Community a show worth saving. Its heart and wit were not appreciated by enough people in its time to be considered safe from the TV exec jackals who only care about how much profit a show can generate. And so I worked hard (embarrassingly, in retrospect) to make sure my friends appreciated this show too, in real time; if enough people watched it, then maybe it would never go away. My apologies for all the pointless Facebook statuses I made about this show. That was weird.
But anyway, I'm building a case for our skepticism of Community Season 4, and how that was warranted at the time. Infamously, Community's creator and showrunner for the first three seasons, Dan Harmon, was unceremoniously fired, and replaced by two guys whose resume included only some CW show no one remembers. Could Community maintain that precious balance of three-laughs-a-second and somber reflections on the sadness at the core of humanity? There was reason to be skeptical, for sure.
But maybe it was unfair to be so harsh, at that time, to this strange season of television. Yeah, it wasn't the same Community, but that doesn't mean season 4 isn't worth your time. I'm finding now, during a rewatch of the series, years after the finale, and with enough time and maturity, that season 4 is worth the watch. There is enough worthy material to cobble together that I can say that it is good enough, or, at the very least, an extremely interesting failure.
Still... it's a little off. As I see it, there are two main concerns, and they both involve that balance I spoke about two paragraphs ago. First, the laughs really aren't there anymore, at least not in the script. Other Community seasons find plenty of ways to squeeze jokes out of every line, even when the various mechanisms of each episodes are being set up. Community season 4 doesn't have the capacity to do any of that; too many lines of dialogue are spent setting other things up, and then the "joke" is often tacked on at the end, like the scriptwriter said "oh shit, this is a comedy, we gotta put a joke here somewhere." It's flawed. I can't say I didn't laugh at all during this season, because the actors are just too fucking good, and are able to create laughs out of thin air/scripts. But the dialogue did no one any favors.
Second, season 4 starts to lean way too heavily into mushy feel-good happiness, which was never a feature of the previous seasons. Jeff Winger, especially, is a character changed in season 4, and for the worse. The whole point of this character is that he loves his friends, but that he never loses that protective shield of irony around him, because he will never be comfortable with showing that love so boldly. Season 4 instead has him often proclaiming out loud that his friends are like his family, no irony, no undercutting, just upfront love. This was never his character. Maybe I'm like Jeff Winger, and I find this uncomfortable because I too need that ironic shield. But my point is that it kinda ruins Community a little bit to misunderstand its characters this much.
There's enough wrong with season 4 that it is no doubt the worst season of Community, but still, the worst season of Community is still better than the best season of many, many other TV shows. There are still plenty of interesting and humorous ideas to keep the season afloat. I sincerely enjoyed the episodes about Britta's attempt at throwing a dance, about using puppets to share secrets, about how the groups lives have all crossed paths before, and about the Dean's attempts to attract a wealthy teenager to attend Greendale. These are all episodes that happen in the season's back half, which makes me think that the showrunners, David Guarascio and Moses Port, were starting to find their footing. (Harmon disagreed, infamously stating that watching season 4 was like "being held down and watching your family get raped on a beach.")
The very best of season 4 found the gang somberly remembering that this is all they have, that life is small and that they should appreciate each other, and that maybe these facts are not worth saying out loud because that's LAME. Season 4 was best when it remembered to show (not tell) that Greendale is a special place, where everyone is welcome, even the worst of us.
So to us Community fans, maybe that's a lesson worth remembering when we consider Community season 4. Even the worst seasons are worth remembering. That's how Greendale would've wanted it.
Should I watch this? I didn't do a good job with my entry for the Should I Watch This? column; I feel like this series is supposed to speak broadly to anyone reading, whether they are familiar with the show or not. And I've written something specifically to people who are already Community fans, but who may be dismissive of the "gas-leak year." Still, maybe that's the point. Should you watch this? Only if you are already a fan of Community. Should you watch this if you've never heard of this show? Sure, but it's worth watch seasons 1 through 3 to appreciate Community for what it was prior, and then also worth watch seasons 5 and 6 to appreciate when the course was corrected. But, as someone who is constantly defending critically slighted pop culture media, I'm telling you definitively, do not skip season 4. It has its moments. If you are anything like Jeff Winger, then you will appreciate this passing grade.

No comments:
Post a Comment