Saturday, July 11, 2020

Song of the Week: "A Silent Reaction"

Check out the full playlist of all the songs of the week HERE. (Though I guess this song isn't on there yet, FUCK.)



"A Silent Reaction"
Cloud Nothings
from The Black Hole Understands
2020

It's a fact of life that sometimes you lose track of friends. You fondly remember the good times you had with them, you'll cherish them always, but these days, the texts are exchanged only every once in a while, and everything you know about them was from some fucking Instagram story you saw a few weeks ago. But then, one night, you meet up at a bar, you reminisce about the good times, and you have so much fun that you make a commitment, and honest promise, to keep in touch a little better, to stay more involved in their lives, to be better friends.

So it goes with bands sometimes too. I am a huge fan of Cloud Nothings, always have been and always will be. I remember discussing their quasi-twee self-titled debut at an old with one of those aforementioned friends whom I haven't seen in like six years. I appreciate how their turn toward somewhat-screamy on the great Attack on Memory taught me that sometimes, in indie, harder is better. I love one of their songs so much that I have written about it in the context of "all-time greats," and would again if given the opportunity.

And, I've kept up with Cloud Nothings in the years since. I've downloaded the albums (now four since Attack on Memory). I've given them a little bit of time. But, I dunno, it's all felt surface level, akin to thinking you are still connected with a friend just because you see his tweets. I couldn't tell you the difference between Life Without Sound and Last Building Burning, and I think there was a couple highlight on Here and Nowhere Else? But I forget?

This isn't seeming like I'm a fan of Cloud Nothings. But I am! I want to be! Thankfully, I had one of those reconnection moments this week, and I'm back on board. Cloud Nothings (project of frontman Dylan Baldi and his band) dropped a quarantine album (I guess that's a term that's officially part of the music critic lexicon now) this week called The Black Hole Understands, and it's their best work in years.

Perhaps because the band had to create this by emailing files back and forth from their respective isolations, the sound on this album is scaled back a little bit. There's fewer of those edgy throat-shredding moments that made Attack on Memory, et al, such a visceral joy. Instead, while the band still rawks, it also leaves room for the hooks to move to the front of the stage. Some of these tunes could be a power pop song in a different band's hands.

It works really, really well. I've always tried to reconcile how a band could make both Cloud Nothings, a bouncy, practically falsetto punk album, and also Attack on Memory and everything that came after, i.e. near-hard-emo rippers. The Black Hole Understands finally connects those two realms, finding Cloud Nothings creating something both accessible and hardened.

I threw "A Silent Reaction" in the slot for today because it features the most out of place Cloud Nothings hook on the record, a Fountains of Wayne-esque, cooing sort of hook that immediately ingrains itself. This sounds like something a mid-tier Elephant 6 Collective band were churning out in the mid-to-late-'90s, that sort of lo-fi pop rock that ages incredibly well. It doesn't sound like Attack on Memory at all.

And for the first time in my life, I'm thinking that that's a good thing. This is the sound of a band finding a new voice by taking the best parts of their old voices and combining them to create something totally unique. This is the sound of Cloud Nothings evolving under trying circumstances, and succeeding more than that have in half a decade. This is the sound of a band that I lost touch with, doing everything possible to reconnect with me, and making me feel guilty that I wasn't truly present already.

No comments: