Friday, July 3, 2020

diana, Joe


I keep telling people that you can write a review however you want. There are no rules! For example, I've seen some people in the past write a review that consists of the author going through each individual song and writing their reactions to and opinions for each. It's a structure that I've personally never used before, but it obviously works. So that's how I'm going to structure my review today.

"Upside Down"—I love how off-balance this song feels, almost like it's missing a few beats somewhere. All good, because we have that bass drum to anchor us; every fourth measure (starting on the third) during the choruses, the bass drum has that double time kick for two beats. It's sooo fucking good, but I will stop writing about it, because I doubt anyone cares. Let's talk about how the gang vocals come in at the end, and how fun that is. What a fucking song.

"Tenderness"—This is classic disco cut on diana. Unlike "Upside Down," nothing new or interesting is brought to the table. But it's Diana Ross, and she can coo her way through anything, even a very normal disco track cut about a year after disco ostensibly died. The backing vocals aren't as fun as they are in "Upside Down" either; I'd even call them a detriment, if I'm being saucy, but maybe they just didn't age as well. A final complaint: it's too long. But that's it. Otherwise, a decent track.

"Friend to Friend"—I mean, I guess we needed a ballad on this album, but boy, does "Friend to Friend" bring the party crashing to a halt. At least the backing band (Chic) brings a little bit of off-kilter rhythms to this otherwise boring affair—the guitar rhythm has this lurching quality that keeps Diana Ross on her toes (she, of course, nails the big notes). Still, though... boring, boring, take me to the next song please.

"I'm Coming Out"—Okay, here we go, this is an all-timer. I know this song... but kind of don't? Like, I know the hook, but I guess I only know it from the Biggie song "Mo Money Mo Problems." I had never taken the time to consider that that sample was Diana Ross, or whether the actual song is better than the song with the sample. Spoiler: it is. There is a trombone solo on the actual song! It's fucking great!

Pam informs me that Diana Ross is an LGBTQ icon, and indeed, this song was written by Nile Rogers (of Chic) after he attended a drag show and saw three drag queens dressed like Diana Ross. Ross assumed that "I'm coming out" was referring to her escape from being under the thumb of Berry Gordy (who had forced her to take part in the absurd Mahogany, among other things); apparently, when she found out that this was a term for when homosexual men acknowledge that they are gay, Ross tearfully accused Rogers of "trying to ruin [her] career." That Ross still seems to be an LGBTQ icon today probably means that she has had a change of heart sometime in the past forty years.

But let's talk more about that trombone solo! It's played by Meco, who had his own Billboard #1 hit with a disco version of the Star Wars theme! Interesting stuff!

"Have Fun (Again)"—Maybe it's the tracking, with this song having to come right after the monster hit, but I don't like "Have Fun (Again)." I mean, it's fine, it's just that the chorus is weirdly off-putting. Singing about children is silly and stupid. And the verses are stagnant. The song is almost six minutes without a single memorable hook! It's not bad enough that it ruins a good album, but if we're looking at each song under a microscope, then I have nothing good to report while examining this slide.

"My Old Piano"—Strangely, out of all eight songs on this album, this was the one stuck in my head the most this week. Strange because it's a weird, downcast, almost minor-key-ish song about Diana Ross wanting to have sex with a musical instrument. Plus, it's got that weird random synth plonk on the upbeat of 2 that just seems out of place every time I hear it... but it also works? I dunno. As much as I love "Upside Down" and "I'm Coming Out," "My Old Piano" is gonna be the song that sticks with me, I think.

"Now That You're Gone"—The slowest track behind "Friend to Friend," this track still works because of the slinking, kinda creepy nighttime rhythm that brings a whole different feel to the song. I like it. I like the percussion section here, especially the great use of the güiro. And I really like how Ross sings the line "I'm just wearing a mask" while I'm wearing my mask. Thank you for protecting us from COVID, Diana.

"Give Up"—If there is one thing diana does well (there are many things it does well, but bare with me), it's the track order. There's the start of the party in the front, and the back half just screams "it's the end of the night." "Give Up" is the perfect closing track. It's pure disco, so it calls back to the overall premise of the album, but also there's something purposefully tired about it. It gives off an odor of desperation, like, we know you're exhausted from dancing all night, but just give us this one more, okay? It really works. I like this song.

Conclusion—I don't know enough about Diana Ross, nor am I familiar with enough of her extensive discography, to be able to give a broader context for any of this. I can say that, regarding the songs themselves, there are way more hits than misses, and the big hits are so strong that they have no trouble keeping the mediocre songs afloat.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: