"Helpless"
Phillipa Soo and the cast of Hamilton
from the Hamilton soundtrack
2015
I am of the opinion that it's extremely reasonable to want to question every single piece of pop culture these days and examine whether it is appropriate. If a song, an episode of TV, a movie, a book, a sports team logo, if any of it is going to cause any undue pain for an already marginalized community, then tear it down. Why not? What could I possible add to that conversation, as a straight white male? Nothing. Who the fuck am I to say whether something offends someone else with its very existence?
There was a movement a few weeks ago to scrub away all instances of black face in modern television episodes, and I didn't have enough unique thoughts about it to craft an entire blog post about it, so I'll just tack it on here. Yes, having one of my favorite Community episodes deleted from Netflix really sucks for me, the white person who enjoys Community and didn't think twice about how a silly bit might affect others. I could even argue that the point of Chang painting his entire body black was that it wasn't racist, that he was imitating a fictional Dungeons & Dragons character, that it was supposed to show his utter commitment to the role, and that the actual joke was that Pierce and Shirley didn't understand any of this and just assumed that he was being racist. Sure, I could say all that, and I might even be right, but what does that matter at all? If someone is going to watch Community and see Ken Jeong with his face painted black and that's going to trigger some undue awful PTSD-type feelings from previous racism, then fuck it. Get rid of it. It's an episode of television. This isn't a hill to die on. (Better yet: reshoot the scene with a non-painted Chang, but alas, a boy can dream.)
It's easy to get behind the idea of scrubbing away those TV episodes (and songs, and etc.) because they actively did something that might cause hurt. Trickier is addressing those pop culture entertainments that maybe should have addressed an important subject, but didn't. This is the precarious situation Hamilton finds itself in currently, in the court of public opinion anyway. Do people really want to "cancel" Hamilton? Why?
Here's the argument: Hamilton, despite all its window dressings of POC portraying historical figures, still showcases slave-owners as heroes, and barely addresses the fact that these historical figures owned humans as property.
The facts in the argument are true. Washington, Jefferson, Burr, all wealthy slave-owners. Hamilton himself allegedly hated slavery, but often allowed his morals to be compromised for the sake of his political ambition (and buying slaves for his in-laws, and so on). The argument, however, is that Hamilton the musical has the moral obligation to address the issue of slavery, and here's where I am a little reticent to agree with those anti-Hamilton agitators.
It basically comes down to questions that I ask all the time about all the various entertainments that I consume: What responsibilities should this entertainment be beholden to? Is it the responsibility of a piece of art to be completely historically accurate? Or can a play, a movie, a TV show forgo accuracy in order to make a separate point that it was trying to make?
Like, say I'm watching Jersey Boys for a movie club, and they almost completely ignore "December, 1963 (Oh, What a Night)," the best Four Seasons song. Is Jersey Boys any worse because it is inaccurate? No! Because that wasn't the point. The point was to portray four characters in how they were alone, and then to highlight how great of a band they formed when they came together. If "December, 1963 (Oh, What a Night)" didn't add anything to that narrative, then I understand its exclusion. (The movie was bad for other reasons, but that's a whole different blog post.)
I have yet to hear a good argument as to why Hamilton has a responsibility to portray these characters any way besides the way Lin-Manuel Miranda chooses. The point of Hamilton, I'd argue, is to show that these founding fathers had interesting and complex lives, with a secondary point being that Miranda was able to find similarities between himself and Hamilton (coming from humble beginnings, possessing a burning hunger for success, etc.). I don't think the point of Hamilton is to educate anyone on anything. It's entertainment.
Now, we can talk hypotheticals if you want. Say Hamilton featured slave characters, and the protagonists were flippant or dismissing toward their plight. Say the slaves were featured and used as comedic relief. Something like that. Of course the argument would be different. Then that would be Hamilton actively portraying something inappropriately. Then that would be the equivalent of J.D. wearing blackface to Turk's fraternity party. Not cool; fucking cut it; who cares?
But Hamilton doesn't do anything. To some, not doing anything is still a problem. To me, Hamilton is off the hook.
Still, being a straight white male who still needs to learn a thing or two, I'm absolutely willing to hear all arguments to the contrary. I am completely comfortable with being proven wrong on all of this. Please do it.
Until then, I'm gonna keep listening to "Helpless" and not worrying that I'm doing something wrong.
No comments:
Post a Comment