Monday, July 6, 2020

Never Seen It, #11 of 200: A Beautiful Mind

I created a list of 200 movies I had never seen before, and now I'm working my way through that list, in alphabetical order, while writing my thoughts on this fucking blog.


A Beautiful Mind
2001

A Beautiful Mind was the perfect movie to watch without knowing anything. How rare is that these days? That we can watch a critically acclaimed movie without even knowing the general premise? I can't think of many in my lifetime.

The story of John Nash, our protagonist in A Beautiful Mind, is one of mental illness. If you knew anything about the real-life John Nash or about this Oscar-winning film, then you knew that fact. You knew that eventually the hammer was going to drop, and this brilliant man was going to suffer from schizophrenia. You'd know that the first half of the movie was through Nash's eyes, and the second half was through the eyes of everyone else. And you might find great pleasure in experiencing such a moving film. I probably would have.

But that's not how I experienced A Beautiful Mind. Literally the only things I knew about this movie were that Russell Crowe was in it, and that it won Best Picture at the Oscars. That's it. I had no idea what the story was about. I sincerely thought that this movie was going to be about a codebreaker who found secret Russian messages in Time magazine. When the film violently shifts to an homage of 1940s-style gangster shoot-'em-up movies, and Ed Harris is blasting away at Russian spies in a high-speed chase, my thought was: "Holy shit, this movie is awful. What are they even doing?" I literally wrote in my notes: "Is this fucking serious?"

Then it was revealed to the audience that, yeah, none of it was real. Nash was suffering from delusions. He had schizophrenia, and imagined the whole thing, everything from a stern CIA agent to a supportive college roommate. The twist was absolutely seismic for me, because I just had no fucking idea. I felt like Nash's two colleagues, taking a look at the insanity of Nash's office, with magazine cutouts and the string connecting them—the evidence was there, staring us in the face, but we just kind of assumed that's how he was.

I assumed this movie was about Ed Harris and Russell Crowe tackling the Soviets with brain power. I was wrong. And that's what made my viewing experience really fucking incredible.

Ya know, I referred to the schizophrenia diagnosis as a "twist," but I don't even know if you can call it that. A Beautiful Mind got me thinking about the relationship between a movie, its audiences, and the critics in determining how much someone should know about a movie going into it. Example questions popping up in my mind right now:

1) Do critics have a responsibility keep certain things close to the chest in order to provide a clean viewing experience for their and the films' audiences (ostensibly the same people)? Roger Ebert spoiled the very last line of the film in the first sentence of his review, for christ's sake. Had I read his review in 2001, my experience with A Beautiful Mind would have been wildly different—perhaps still fulfilling, but definitely not mind-blowing in any sense.

2) Do filmmakers assume that certain things are going to be "spoiled" (if you want to call it that) to the audience beforehand, and set your expectations accordingly? Like, did A Beautiful Mind not worry too much about tricking the audience with the schizo reveal because maybe that reveal wasn't the point of the movie, but what happens after the reveal is the point, and that impact is still measurable even if you know about it going into your viewing experience?

3) Does an audience have a responsibility to prepare for a movie or purposefully go into a movie unprepared? How do you avoid "spoilers" when the definition of "spoiler" is different to everyone? Wikipedia doesn't consider it a spoiler—the reveal is in the first paragraph of the article. Truth be told, I don't know if I would have considered it a spoiler. Had Pam said "I think this is a movie about a guy with schizophrenia," I would have responded, "Oh, is that what this is about? Good shit, let's watch." I would've enjoyed the shootout scene more because I would've known its true intentions, but I also would not have had that jaw-dropping realization that the wool had been over my eyes. I like that feeling, that special type of reveal, and I'm glad that I didn't know. But I only didn't know due to pure chance; I didn't give a fuck in 2001, and the world didn't give enough of a fuck to clue me in during the past nineteen years.

So should I not read anything about any of the rest of these movies? What's my role in this? What are my responsibilities? Should I be worried about a movie like Se7en because I was spoiled to the ending? Or am I free from obligation to keep my shields up, free to learn anything I please about the movie? At which point the responsibility would then become finding a greater understanding of the movie beyond "what happens"... which I guess is an extremely roundabout way of coming to the conclusion that YES, duh, a movie should be more than "what happens," and if the pleasure derived from a movie lives and dies on plot details, then there is something wrong with me and with the movie.

Had I not been as impressed with A Beautiful Mind's ability to toy with my unbeautiful one, then I most likely would've talked about how this was a corny movie, but still great in a way that Ron Howard seems to be really good at, turning corniness into greatness. I appreciate that skill in a filmmaker, because corniness is satisfying when done well, and I want to feel good about corniness. When John Nash was presented with the pens by fellow faculty toward the end of the film, it was the most obvious thing the movie could've done—like, c'mon, when the ritual was explained toward the beginning of the movie, even the dumbest among us knew that Nash would be getting those motherfucking pens by the end of the film—and yet, it still touched me in a very emotional way.

You're supposed to sympathize with John Nash, even when he is schizophrenic enough that he almost drowns his infant son in the bathtub. So the fact that I did indeed sympathize with him means that Russell Crowe did a pretty fantastic job at playing the vulnerable human side of a man fraying around the edges. This is a performance that could've easily swerved into the cartoonish, but Crowe heroically kept both feet on the ground, all surface-level tics and deep, deep heart.

I keep returning to that reveal, though, and how the movie was able to change course on a fucking dime. If this has more to do with my ignorance, then I apologize, but for once my ignorance paid off. I was enthralled, because it felt like one of those rare moments of true movie magic for me. I don't often get to see a lady sawed in half and actually find myself in the mindset to actually believe the trick. A Beautiful Mind made me believe.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Who's Involved

As noted above, I was really appreciative of director Ron Howard's work here. He's two for two right now on the Never Seen It list, which surprises me. I think there's this kneejerk reaction to dismiss Howard because he was fucking Richie Cunningham, like maybe I don't take him as seriously as I should. Looking back on my Apollo 13 write-up from only a month and a half ago, I'm already surprised about how dismissive I sound. Maybe it needed to sink in a little more, but right now I'm looking back on Apollo 13 as a great movie-watching experience. I don't need the same six weeks for A Beautiful Mind; this was some good shit, and I know that immediately.

I think maybe Ron Howard has a lane, and when he's in it, there's no stopping him. A mostly faithful recreation of a real-life story, a story that seems fantastical and might well be too fantastical if it didn't actual happen, a true story that has plenty of pathos to wring out of, a film tailor made for a stern, barking Ed Harris... I dunno, all these things are true about the two Ron Howard movies that I've watched, so maybe he's just fucking good at making this type of movie. We won't be seeing Howard again in this column for a long time (next up is Willow, but I'm not expecting much from that when I watch it in 2023), but I find myself eager to try out a few of his other movies in my own spare time. Cinderella Man? EdTV? The Da Vinci Code?!? jkjk

I went back to the Gladiator interview with Lamson, and was surprised to get zero Ctrl+F matches for "Russell Crowe" in the actual interview. I guess I was too busy busting Lamson's ball for not paying for a keg cup ten years ago to ask him about the LEAD FUCKING ACTOR of the movie we were talking about?! Ah well. Let's say here instead that I think Russell Crowe is a swell actor. What started as an ironic fanaticism over Russell Crowe's "excellent" performance in Les Misérables has morphed into a genuine appreciation of his craft. He was good in Gladiator, and he was good in A Beautiful Mind, but in a completely different way than Gladiator.

Jennifer Connelly was pretty fucking great too, and this feels like kind of a revelation for me, because I was not familiar with any of Connelly's other work prior to this... well, okay, I guess she was the protagonist in Labyrinth, a movie I've only seen because it's somehow one of Pam's favorite movies ever. It's a bad movie, and Connelly is bad in it. But still, she was a child (not everyone is winning Oscars at the age Tatum O'Neill did), and fifteen years passed between Labyrinth and A Beautiful Mind. Fifteen years is plenty of time to learn how to act. She did it. She took what could've easily been a one-note manic depressive pixie dream girl role and gave it motherfucking depth.

We didn't talk about Ed Harris for Apollo 13, so let's give him a full paragraph here. I'm not going to heap the same praises on him that I did Crowe and Connelly, but I don't know if that's Harris' fault. This is a thankless role—he literally plays a hallucination, and Harris is asked to play is cartoonishly because of that fact. There's no room for depth because his character doesn't exist. So yeah, fun role, but he definitely can't be surprised he was left out during the Oscars hoopla (more on that later). Come to think of it, has Harris ever gotten a meaty role? Not in anything I've seen him in (which, to be fair, isn't a whole lot). Westworld is a fucking drag, so maybe I'm just making shit up unfairly because of that. I dunno. He was a decent villain in The Truman Show I guess? Look, he's in a other movies on this list, so there's plenty of time to prove me wrong. (He's also apparently in the new Top Gun with Jennifer Connelly... I will not be watching the new Top Gun.)

Okay, here's something I'm really excited to mention—the Dazed and Confused reunion! Adam Goldberg and Anthony Rapp palling around again! I hate that the timelines don't quite match up, or else I would've totally considered this a secret Dazed and Confused sequel. I wonder if these types of things are coincidence for the most part, or if a casting director was a big fan of that movie or whatever. Maybe it was coincidence, or else they should've found a role for Marissa Ribisi. (Sidenote: I did not know Anthony Rapp was the first one to accuse Spacey of all his criminal behavior until I read his Wikipedia page right now. Big fan of Rapp, glad he was able to speak up!)

Paul Bettany plays Nash's college roommate, who turns out to be a hallucination as well—creepy stuff! I knew Paul Bettany's name sounded familiar, and as it turns out, this is the second movie from Never Seen It that we've seen him in. Well, heard him in, anyway. He plays the voice of J.A.R.V.I.S., which is basically the computer system inside Iron Man's suit. Apparently in later movies he is uploaded into a simulated human called "Vision"? Hey, maybe Paul Bettany will play a real person in a movie that I actually watch one day.

On a final note, I am bummed that Ron Howard couldn't find a spot for his brother Clint in this movie. Clint would've made a great psych assistant to Christopher Plummer! Just saying!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Awards

I haven't used this section in a while (the Bears aren't really known for winning too many awards, and neither are heroin-addicted basketball players), but it's back, because A Beautiful Life won the Academy Award for Best Picture. This is a big deal! It beat two movies I've never heard of, plus Moulin Rouge!, which I've never seen but I can picture clear enough in my mind because I've seen Baz Luhrmann's ridiculous Romeo + Juliet and I'm sure it has a similar style, and finally The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Rings, a fucking AWFUL movie, fucking fight me if you feel differently. This was a deserved win (unless you are a Life as a House fan, like me, in which case you might feel like Life as a House got shafted at that year's Oscars).

Three other wins: Best Adapted Screenplay (beating Fellowship again (FUCK YOU), and also, hilariously, Shrek), but we'll talk more about the screenplay and source material in a minute;

Best Supporting Actress, which we already indicated that Jennifer Connelly absolutely deserved (gladly giving the middle finger to the STACKED cast of losers, including Mirren, Tomei, Winslet, and Dame Maggie Smith);

Best Director, which, we already praised Ron Howard's work too he beat Peter Jackson—FUCK YOU A THOUSAND TIMES!!!!—Ridley Scott—fuck war movies, but you're cool—David Lynch—we'll be watching Mulholland Drive eventually, also didn't realize that the Twin Peaks guy directed this, also also I should get around to watching Twin Peaks some day.

Four losses to speak of as well (50% ain't bad). Russell Crowe lost his category, but he had just won it for Gladiator the year before (and had lost the year before that for The Insider—hey, 33.3% ain't bad either). He lost to Denzel Washington in Training Day—sorry I do not know enough about this win to comment on it.

Film Editing lost to Black Hawk Down. Ho hum. Best Score lost to Fellowship—FUCK YOU, but also, sure, I'll admit Fellowship is iconic and A Beautiful Mind is perhaps not, specifically regarding music. I have a bigger problem with Best Makeup going to Fellowship too. I get it, fucking dwarves and gollums or whatever needed their goddamn six-inch-thick paint plastered on their faces, okay fine, but c'mon, Russell Crowe didn't look anything like Russell Crowe when he played an old man! That was too impressive to lose to a bunch of fucking goblins! FUCK!!!

Whenever a film does well at the Oscars, I'm infinitely less interested in other awards that it won. Like, I don't really care that it won Best Picture at the Golden Globes. That's B-list shit. I did, however, check out how it fared at the 2002 Kids' Choice Awards... it... didn't even get nominated?! Rush Hour 2 won Best Picture?! Chris Tucker and Jackie Chan won Best Actor and Best Male Buttkicker, respectively?! What are you doing, '90s kids?!?! At least they had a funny bit where Russell Crowe kept trying to slime Paul Bettany over and over, while all the kids in the audience yelled out that Paul Bettany isn't there, he doesn't exist, please stop, this is getting uncomfortable, someone get this man some help, and then Russell Crowe went ahead and sliced some poor concierge's face open with a telephone.

~~~~~~~~

IMDB Trivia

In which we discuss the good and the bad of the trivia for A Beautiful Mind.

BEST: "Jennifer Connelly, who plays Alicia Nash, and Paul Bettany, who plays Charles, married shortly after the movie was released." Okay, this is one of those rare times when IMDB downplays the trivia—it's a lot more interesting than just knowing that two costars got married. First, they barely interacted in the film, maybe sharing a couple scenes, but not speaking with each other because, ya know, Bettany's character didn't exist. Second, they got together two years after filming ended, and Bettany admitted that she had been his childhood crush after seeing her in Labyrinth (man, I wish Pam read these things, she would get a kick out of that part). Third, Wikipedia claims that the September 11th attacks spurned Bettany to finally ask her out, which sounds like a bad SNL bit, not real life. Fourth, they have a son named Stellan, who was named after a similarly-not-an-Avenger.

WORST: "The infant used to portray their 'son' in the dangerous bathtub scene was a female." Pam and I were horrified by the idea of a baby drowning in a bathtub (being a parent fucks with how you perceive the world), so I don't give a shit whether that baby had a goddamn penis or not. I just wanted the baby to live, goddamn it!!!!!!!

ALMOST CASTED (WHO THE FUCK CARES): Ugh, soooo many of these for this movie. "Patrick Dempsey and Josh Lucas tested for the role of Martin Hensen." Who the fuck cares? "Famke Janssen and Ashley Judd campaigned for the role of Alicia Nash." Who the fuck cares? "Jennifer Connelly beat out Brittany Murphy for the role of Alicia Nash." Who the fuck cares? Etc., etc., etc.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Based on a True Story

I appreciate the fact that it's difficult to fault this movie for its various inaccuracies, because I understand that real life is messy and often doesn't square with the typical structure of a film. There's what actually happened in reality, and there's the point the movie is trying to make, and if they aren't exactly simpatico, then so be it.

The biggest example is that John and Alicia Nash were divorced for decades, a fact that the movie does not mention. Apparently Nash even had another kid with a different woman. Life is messy. I didn't read up too much about that whole aspect of Nash's life because, to be honest, I didn't really care. I'm not very interested in John Nash as he truly was. I'm only interested in John Nash as he was portrayed. I understand that they left the separation and the stepsibling out of the movie, because A Beautiful Life was a love story, and it would've muddied that point.

An important person who agrees with me on this point—Sylvia Nasar, the author who wrote A Beautiful Mind the book. She is asked about this in a Washington Post interview after Nash's death, and her argument was a simple one: why complain about the movie's inaccuracies, because if you want details, the biography will always be there. We aren't looking to the movie to provide details; we're looking to the movie to provide that movie magic, which the details can sometimes impede. Both can exist, as both exist for different purposes.

That interview is a good one. There are a couple interesting nuggets of thought that have bounced around in my head since I read it. First is another fact that was gleamed over in the movie—the Nashes' son, briefly seen in the film as a child, also had schizophrenia, and it ended up being way worse than John's dealing with it. If there's a sequel to A Beautiful Mind in some alternate dimension, it's about John Jr., and the struggle it must've been to exist as the son of a brilliant mathematician, and to inherit both his skills at math (but not as much) and his mental health concerns (but more so), and how unfair that must've seemed to everyone involved.

Another point mentioned was something that Pam mentioned too—the fact that John Nash was able to control his schizophrenia without medication. I don't think they underline that fact enough in the film, because someone dumb like me assumed that he started taking his meds again after almost drowning the baby. Nope! He literally ignored his hallucinations until they started to fade away a little bit. Scientific American has a good article about how realistic this is. Studies have shown that around 20 percent of patients can find remission on their own, simply by growing old (60 percent with active treatment). No one knows why this is the case, but it is, and Nash was apparently one of the lucky ones ("lucky" being a relative term).

A Beautiful Mind the movie also did not bullshit when it claimed that Nash was still walking to class and teaching at the university, because that was indeed true when the movie came out. To find out the final fate of John and Alicia Nash, we need to take to the internet. I don't know why this has bothered me so much, but it does—the Nashes lived a long and fruitful and interesting and fulfilling life, and then died in a random car crash on the New Jersey Turnpike in 2015. Perhaps it bothers me because I want film and real life to square, and it makes me uncomfortable that life is so messy and complicated. This was an ignoble death for a larger-than-life character. It's like when Omar gets shot in a convenience store—it just doesn't make sense, and maybe that's the life lesson here. Life isn't a movie. A Nobel Prize winner is gonna get ejected from his vehicle. Nothing makes sense. Life is random.

~~~~~~~~~~

Screenshot at 1:25:04

This wasn't supposed to be funny, but it's the most I laughed at a movie in a really long time. I don't have schizophrenia, but HOLY SHIT I was John Nash in this four-second scene.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Final Thoughts

We talked about the responsibility of the filmmakers, the critics, and the audience, but what about the bloggers? Am I actively making someone's film-watching experience worse by writing about A Beautiful Mind in such detail? I want you, dear reader, to enjoy this movie as much as I did, and I hope that I didn't ruin anything for you. That's my hope, until I remember that no one in their right mind would read such a long and pointless blog post without having seen the movie first. (Also, there probably aren't too many people as dumb as me, going into A Beautiful Mind without knowing anything about it, so...)

GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

NEXT TIME: Movie or meme? We decide when we watch Bee Movie.

4 comments:

Matt said...

I think Crowe was the heavy favorite to take home the award, but an incident involving him throwing a phone at a hotel clerk changed days before the ceremony changed that lol

sunny said...

Great write up. Most movies probably are buoyed by at least one watch without knowing anything about them (Maybe doesn't apply to Romeo and Juliet, but maybe does to Romeo+Juliet). ABM is a great movie with stellar acting (just look at that Crowe screenshot) and directing.

Nash is such a wild character. I have a friend who has/had schizophrenia and it's a disease hard for patient and those around to have any real grasp of what's happening for a while. Sad stuff. But his ideas in game theory and 'rational actors' have been applied in so much depth to our political economy that he's probably (indirectly) one of the biggest influences of our lives today are shaped. The real Nash said later in life that economists took his theories too literally and applied them too far. Who's really the crazy one?

Speaking of Baz (he always does come up), I recently learned he's got his hands on the option for The Master and Margarita. Will it be the greatest Baz yet or another whiff? Time will tell.

Joe K said...

Matt—which Matt is this? I alluded to the telephone incident at the end of the Awards section, but it can't've affected his Oscar chances. The timelines don't match. He lost the Best Actor award in 2002, and he assaulted the concierge in 2005 (at least according to Wikipedia). I'm gonna go with Occam's razor and say that Denzel Washington was just better (though since Training Day didn't make the list, I most likely won't be watching it for a while). Either that or we get into the "politics of winning an Oscar," which I can't fucking stand.

Sunny—I appreciate when your comments fill in the spaces that I overlook in these pieces. I should've looked into and read more about game theory. Even though it wasn't necessarily "the point" of the film, it was still an important piece of it, and I dropped the ball. Maybe I imagined that reading about it would've felt too much like I was looking at the mathematical near-nonsense that Nash wrote on the library windows, and the thought of having to parse through that gave me a headache.

Though, I dunno, I guess I could've gone through Wikipedia if I really wanted to. I think I'm just lazy.

sunny said...

All good man, any movie (esp good movies) could be looked at 200 different ways, and you're looking at 200 different movies, so it would be impossible to do it all. There're always angles in your write-ups I wouldn't have thought of which keeps me coming back.

Also game theory is kind of boring...