I only have four months to live, and so I'm spending that time talking with friends about their favorite films of all time. Welcome back to Your Favorite Movie.
The sullen emo teen I'm interviewing this week is Dionna C******. She was a freshman when I was a senior at La Salle, and she was also in the theater program, so we would usually be at the same parties that year (and yeah, of course we talked about the Masque in this interview). Since then, I usually run into her on the streets of Center City... like, weirdly often. Also, she is Stephan's younger sister, but he declined to have anything to do with this interview, since he hates the movie.
The movie he hates and Dionna loves is Life as a House, the bizarre 2001 ostensible tear-jerker starring Kevin Kline and Anakin Skywalker. It's bad, but we make the case that it's actually good, even though, yes, it's also quite bad.
Dionna and I met up on Super Bowl Sunday for lunch at the Foodery, and talked movies over beers. Our discussion is transcribed below with Dionna's permission, and edited slightly because there's only so much an audience can read about Hayden Christensen's masturbation habits. Enjoy.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dionna: [laughter] That's what I like! Movies that no one watches!
Joe: This is my thirtieth interview. I went back and checked, and this is only the fifth movie I've talked about that I hadn't heard of prior to the project. Which was kind of the whole point in the first place!
Dionna: That's what I like about this. That's what I find so interesting.
Joe: I am interested to hear your defense of this movie.
Dionna: I'm not sure it will be good!
Joe: In asking people who have also seen it—mainly your brother and sister-in-law—and also looking on Rotten Tomatoes...
Dionna: I don't trust Rotten Tomatoes.
Joe: It wasn't a good score. It was like mid-40s.
Dionna: It was pretty bad, but I've watched movies that are like 20%, so this is pretty good, considering!
Joe: And, ya know, there's certainly nothing wrong with watching a "bad movie," or a movie that has gotten bad critical reviews. But I'm definitely interested to hear why this movie, which is generally known to be a bad movie, is your favorite movie of all time. So let's start with this, and I haven't done this in a while. I just want you to explain the plot of this movie.
Dionna: Okay, so, you have a middle-aged man who finds out that he's dying of cancer. That's not a surprise, so I'm not ruining the movie.
Joe: We'll give a spoiler warning just in case.
Dionna: So—older man, dying of cancer. He decides that, since he's dying, he wants to makes amends with his family. He's divorced, not in a relationship, not really connected with his son, so he decides: "I'm going to take my son for the summer, and we're going to build this house together." And that's the entire plot! [laughter]
Joe: Had you heard that plot without having seen the movie, would you assume that it was a good movie?
Dionna: Absolutely not.
Joe: [laughter] I wouldn't either. And I didn't.
Dionna: When I first heard about this movie, I thought, "Oh, Hayden Christensen is in it, great! I'm obsessed with him right now, I'll totally watch this movie." It was his first film.
Joe: So you didn't watch this in 2001, you watched this later.
Dionna: Yeah.
Joe: When did you first watch it?
Dionna: I had to have been in high school, so probably '05?
Joe: So post-Star Wars. Is that what you had first seen him in, Star Wars?
Dionna: No, which is weird.
Joe: What did you first see him in then?
Dionna: A Canadian television show called Higher Ground that was absolutely awful... I used to rush home and watch it. [laughter] Shameful.
Joe: Degrassi notwithstanding, Canadian television is usually not great.
Dionna: It was pretty bad. But I liked him, and I thought he was good. And then I saw him in Star Wars. And then my obsession began.
Joe: ...
Dionna: Where do we go from there? [laughter]
Joe: I guess I should say that I went into watching this movie with basement-level expectations, and I actually ended up really enjoying it. I don't know if that was because... it wasn't a "it's so bad it's good" type situation. There were moments that were good, and that I enjoyed because they were good. And there were moments that were fucking bad, and I enjoyed them because they were bad. I laughed a lot!
Dionna: I can agree with that. There are some really terrible moments in this movie. Not "terrible" in the sense that it's "sad" or anything, just that "Oh, this is a bad movie."
Joe: So, I dunno, does your defense of this movie just boil down to "Hayden Christensen"?
Dionna: My defense is a lot of the cast. Kristin Scott Thomas—I love her. I've loved her since The English Patient.
Joe: She was in The English Patient?
Dionna: Yeah, she was the lead.
Joe: I wasn't familiar with her.
Dionna: She's phenomenal. I think she's beautiful. I like the way she speaks, so that helped. I love Kevin Kline. I think he's weird. [laughter] So I really liked seeing him in this role. Those were my big selling points. And the story itself—the idea of divorced parents, and building a house with your father leading to rebuilding a relationship.
Joe: The idea of divorced parents because of your parents?
Dionna: My parents, yeah.
Joe: I wasn't going to be the one to bring that up, but we can definitely delve into that.
Dionna: Oh no, my parents are divorced. That's well-known.
Joe: But you feel like, overall, this is a matter of "cast elevating material"?
Dionna: For sure. Without this cast, I'm not sure I would've seen this movie.
Joe: You wouldn't have been convinced to watch it knowing that Hayden Christensen autoerotic asphyxiates himself? [laughter]
Dionna: Within the first five minutes!
Joe: What a great introduction.
Dionna: I don't know if I need that.
Joe: "Here's the actor you're obsessed with... now watch him jerk off in a closet."
Dionna: Yeah... [laughter] I had been warned about that.
Joe: But why do people think this is a bad movie? If you had to be devil's advocate.
Dionna: There are definitely some corny moments. There's some cheesiness. I think that they try to make it lighthearted, but also heavy, and some people don't like that. Some people just want it to be a really heavy film, or a really lighthearted film. To me, the film is a good balance between the two. I think it's a good balance, and that's why I like it. Some people thought it was just cheesy. One of my best friends hates this movie.
Joe: There was a bunch of just out-of-nowhere, batshit crazy parts.
Dionna: And that's why she hates it.
Joe: It was one of the easier movies to make a list of "funniest parts" for me. I legitimately laughed at a lot of it.
Dionna: There are definitely some hilarious moments.
Joe: We already touched on the autoerotic asphyxiation.
Dionna: Hysterical.
Joe: That might've gotten the biggest laugh out of me.
Dionna: I think it's the most awkward thing on earth.
Joe: Because of the act itself, or because Hayden Christensen is the one doing it?
Dionna: I think for me, it's the fact that I love this movie, and so I then keep introducing it to people, and that is the introduction to my favorite character and my favorite actor! And then it's like... oh. This is what he's doing. [laughter]
Joe: He also prostitutes himself? Very briefly.
Dionna: Yeah...
Joe: That...
Dionna: A little out of the blue there.
Joe: I know they technically lead up to it with the whole "$300! For two hours! Every week!" But they were pretty cagey about what he was doing, when he went into a dark-tinted car in the middle of the woods.
Dionna: With a bunch of other cars, yeah!
Joe: He was... blowing this guy?
Dionna: I think the guy was blowing him.
Joe: Okay. [laughter] I mean, $300 is $300.
Dionna: ...True.
Joe: Tahoe is expensive!
Dionna: I wasn't going to mention that part.
Joe: Speaking of Hayden Christensen's pimp, I loved how all of a sudden he was banging Mary Steenburgen. To me, that seemed like the most out-of-context thing that happened in the movie. Maybe the most unnecessary?
Dionna: It was unnecessary, but I still liked it. I dunno why. I like her as an actress, and I like her playing the weird mom who is completely inappropriate.
Joe: Like how she had such a big problem with Kevin Kline's penis at the beginning of the movie?
Dionna: But then, you're banging this high school student? Also, is he in high school? He is dating your daughter, and he is a pimp, these are the only things we know.
Joe: He was hanging around the high school during that first scene.
Dionna: But does he attend high school? I have no idea. It's very weird... it was unnecessary.
Joe: Did you see Ian Somerhalder in Lost?
Dionna: Yeah.
Joe: So him dying in an airplane crash was payback for fucking his girlfriend's mother?
Dionna: He dies in a lot of things he's in! I liked him in Smallville. He got shot in that!
Joe: I forgot he was in Smallville.
Dionna: For a little bit.
Joe: Speaking as someone who would definitely have sex with Mary Steenburgen—
Dionna: I do like her.
Joe: —I didn't really have a problem with it from an emotional standpoint. Maybe just from a plot standpoint?
Dionna: I like her. I mean, she's weird, but I like her. And she's hot. She's a hot mom. [laughter]
Joe: She also didn't seem to have a problem with her daughter and the sullen boy next door taking a shower together?
Dionna: Well... she had a problem when she found out that he was not gay, and that he was sleeping with her daughter. She didn't have an issue when she was like, "He might be gay." But I don't see why that would matter?
Joe: I didn't pick up on that. When did she say that?
Dionna: Well, the daughter implied that she thought he was gay. Because she kept doing things, and he was like, "Why are you doing these things, like getting in the shower with me?" and she was like, "Because you're not interested in women...?" and he's like, "No! Hello! I am!"
Joe: He proved that literally three seconds later. [laughter]
Dionna: A little sad. [laughter] Oh man. But no, I think it was when the mom realized that he's not gay when she was like, "This can't happen." Also, you're judging your daughter while you're sleeping with her boyfriend?
Joe: I thought the daughter was just going after the "bad boy" type. Would "bad boy type" be the way to describe Sam?
Dionna: More like "emo."
Joe: "Troubled"?
Dionna: "Sad." [laughter]
Joe: "Sad little emo boy"?
Dionna: Maybe that's why I like this character. [laughter] At that time, emo was in. He was definitely a sad emo kid.
Joe: Is that a type that you are interested in?
Dionna: Oh, absolutely. Well, it was back then, since "emo" isn't really a thing anymore. But back then, yeah, emo was super hot.
Joe: Is your boyfriend going to read this?
Dionna: Yeah. My boyfriend knows.
Joe: Is your boyfriend a Sam-type?
Dionna: ...No. [laughter] My boyfriend's a nerd. I've only dated nerds. But this is just the dream.
Joe: No facial piercings?
Dionna: No.
Joe: Eyeliner?
Dionna: No! My boyfriend is so plain, and regular. [laughter]
Joe: In a good way!
Dionna: He is the definition of "the IT guy." When you think clean cut, keeps a nice shave going, short hair.
Joe: In the sex advice column Savage Love, one of its big things is that people shouldn't get defensive when their significant others get aroused by types, or things that you are not... so Dionna's boyfriend, if you're reading this, don't think there's anything wrong with her being attracted to Sam in Life as a House.
Dionna: I think he understands... no, I don't think he understands any of my attractions to any of the guys I'm attracted to, but he's like, "Okay, that's your thing, cool." He's like, "...that's a weird one for me. I don't see it, but... that's good..." [laughter]
Joe: I'm glad you can talk about... Life as a House with your boyfriend.
Dionna: I force this movie on everyone.
Joe: He has watched it?
Dionna: Yes, he had.
Joe: What was his opinion on it?
Dionna: He said it was okay. He said it wasn't awful. He wouldn't put it in his top five... or ten... or 20...
Joe: It's not his best movie of all time,
Dionna: Definitely not. But his is Ben-Hur, so come on.
Joe: Interesting.
Dionna: But he would watch it again.
Joe: Moving on, you definitely... any person with a brain cell can know, at the beginning of the movie, that Sam is going to change by the end of the movie. This the type of movie where that happens.
Dionna: I think that's the whole point.
Joe: Do you feel like his change is earned?
Dionna: That's a good question. I don't actually think it is. But I don't think we see enough of Sam to know if the change is real. I would say no, it's not earned, but I think he's trying. And I think we would see, if the movie had continued, you'd see that the change itself does not continue. That it would kind of fall off.
Joe: After George dies.
Dionna: Right, he would fall off into his old habits. I think he was trying to make an effort, though.
Joe: I guess the question would be, what was it that caused him to make the change in the particular way that he did? Was the activating event for him?
Dionna: That his father gave a crap. George was finally just like, "I'm not going to put up with your nonsense." For some people, that works. Some people need that hard kick, like, "Hey, I think what you're doing is terrible, and really dangerous, so I'm not going to let you do it." I think he needed to know that, like, okay, someone actually cares that I'm doing all these terrible things.
Joe: I know that's an actual thing in real life, but do you feel like a typical seventeen-year-old with behavioral health issues, all he would need is "tough love"?
Dionna: No. I think it depends. For someone like myself, it might have worked, but I didn't have a lot of behavioral issues. For me, sure, if I'm acting out a little bit, that might work for me! But other people my age, no. I know it doesn't work. People have tried it, it doesn't work.
Joe: As a social worker, I see a lot of kids who have behavioral problems, and most of the time I'm going to see them because they were inappropriately disciplined. The dad was fed up with the kid's behavior, and choked him. So like... that shit's clearly not working.
Dionna: Yeah, true.
Joe: I kind of saw the activating event maybe, if I had to find one in this movie, it would be when George was telling his story about his own abusive upbringing? And how his dad always made him feel "small." If I had to say that. But at the same time, Sam's reaction was "...that's weird," and then putting his headphones on.
Dionna: I think that was Sam being like, "I don't want to react to this. I don't want to show you that I'm reacting to this, so I'd rather pretend it's not."
Joe: That's fair. So he was being disingenuous when he said "That's weird."
Dionna: Yeah, and I think by putting on the headphones, it gives him the excuse not to have to deal with it. Instead of actually having a conversation with his father.
Joe: Okay, I like thinking about it that way. Because that was probably the only part of the movie where Sam's actions legitimately pissed me off. I think due to the context of trying to have these conversations about movies, and I would hate if someone was just like, "You're weird," and shut me down, ya know?
Dionna: I feel like some people just don't know how to react when people tell them hard stories? Me, I feel like I would know how to respond. But there are definitely people in my life where, if I told them about something terrible in my life, they'd be like, "Oh..." and that's the end of the conversation. Not that they don't care, it's just that they don't know how to react.
Joe: Not emotionally mature enough, maybe. Sam was definitely not emotionally mature.
Dionna: Oh, for sure.
Joe: And of course, we saw that through his listening to Marilyn Manson at top volume. [laughter]
Dionna: Um, couldn't they have picked anyone else? [laughter] Really?
Joe: This is my segue into talking about the soundtrack. Which, I thought was... out of all the movies I've watched, the soundtrack was definitely the most "of its time" for that movie. Like, the multiple Guster songs was so 2001. So good.
Dionna: I did like that, yeah.
Joe: Are you a fan of Guster?
Dionna: No, but I was going to say, I did listen to the soundtrack after watching the movie.
Joe: I wouldn't say I'm a "fan" of Guster, but I like their shit sometimes.
Dionna: I'm a fan of music.
Joe: The only interesting thing on the IMDB trivia page for this movie was that the scriptwriter was a huge fan of Guster. That's why there's two Guster songs. That's why the dog's name is "Guster."
Dionna: Guster the dog! I completely forgot about that!
Joe: And that's why Sam's two half-brothers are named Ryan and Adam, because those are names of two members of Guster.
Dionna: Two characters that weren't needed.
Joe: Right? Although, no, I'll say this—
Dionna: I mean, they didn't have to be in the movie. They could've just been mentioned.
Joe: It's definitely one of the many extraneous parts of this movie.
Dionna: The movie needed a stepfather, but I don't think it needed step-children.
Joe: I loved how the shortcut to finding out the step-father's worth was asking the question, "Would you hug your children?" And he couldn't say yes! [laughter] C'mon Kristin Scott Thomas, you didn't notice this before?! Yeah, how do we feel about George and Robin, and the fact that neither of them really questioned all that much the fact that she was cheating on her now-husband with her ex-husband?
Dionna: I think it's very interesting. I look at it like it's weird, because my own parents have a very strange relationship, as divorced people. And my father is remarried.
Joe: I'm interested to hear about it.
Dionna: My parents have known each other since they were nineteen. It's very similar, actually, these two characters and my parents. Because they've known each other a very long time, were married a very long time. They didn't have the greatest marriage—which is why they're divorced—but there's still a connection there, to an extent. And I'm not sure if that really ever leaves. I think for the two characters in the movie, you kind of see that, where it's like "Yeah, we're divorced, but I still care deeply for you." So... yes, cheating on your husband with this guy... but I don't know if I see it in that way. I think I look at it like this is her finally closing this chapter of her life. She needed to have this interaction with him so she can finally say, "This done, this is over, I can say goodbye." And move on.
Joe: For closure, she had to act out a Cialis commercial, basically.
Dionna: ...Yes. [laughter]
Joe: Isn't that kind of what it felt like, when they were dancing as the sun set over the sea? All they needed was the separate his and hers bathtubs.
Dionna: So true. I dunno... again, my parents have a weird relationship.
Joe: But they're civil.
Dionna: Oh yeah. I don't know if they always should be, but they are. So I look at it like, divorced parents are typically very different than mine. To say "they hang out" is interesting, but they hang out. So you see the relationship in this where she's bringing him pizza, and she's doing all these things for him. She's rubbing his back, whatever... that's not necessarily weird to me. I'm like, "Okay, that's normal," because this my normal. Is it actually abnormal? Probably.
Joe: When your parents got divorced, how old were you?
Dionna: My parents officially got divorced when I was in college. My parents had been separated since I was high school, or before that.
Joe: Do you feel like people would try to excuse Sam's behavior because he is a "child of divorce"? I word it that was because you are clearly not like Sam, despite the fact that you were a similar age during a time when your parents were separated. Do you feel like people would try to explain Sam's behavior with that?
Dionna: I think they do, which I don't think is... I understand that most people would act out when their parents are going through something rough, it's affecting your family and the dynamic. But here... his mother has been remarried for how long?
Joe: Right. Eight years?
Dionna: If not longer. So I don't know. I think people would try to excuse his behavior because of that, but I don't know if they should.
Joe: He is so over-the-top with sullenness.
Dionna: Another problem is he's into everything. "I'm into listening to dark music, I wear dark clothing, I have piercings, I dye my hair, I do drugs, I prostitute myself." It's like, okay, what doesn't this guy do?
Joe: Didn't he say he was doing drugs since he was twelve?
Dionna: Yeah!
Joe: Man... Do you think maybe the characters didn't take his behavior as seriously as they should have? That might be me asking as a social worker again.
Dionna: I don't know. It was also a time when everyone was into this kind of "I'm emotional and dark and moody and mysterious."
Joe: So emo is your excuse?! [laughter]
Dionna: Hey, it was a period, people went through it! People were legit dealing with things, and other people thought it was a cool fad to be a part of. So I don't know if it was like, maybe it's just a fad? Or maybe he's legit dealing with things?
Joe: Were you part of that fad?
Dionna: I was, a little.
Joe: You were an emo girl?
Dionna: A little bit. It was more like... goth. In between those.
Joe: Emo-adjacent.
Dionna: Because I went to a Catholic school, and wore a uniform, so I couldn't quite do that.
Joe: No ripped stockings?
Dionna: I would've gotten detention every day. [laughter] But the mood. The mood was definitely there.
Joe: I thought it was interesting... so Sam was pretty outrageous with his hatred of his dad, or supposed hatred. But I thought one of the criticisms he lobbed toward George was pretty interesting. When George finally admits that he's dying, Sam accused him of being "selfish." What are your thoughts on that? Do you think George is being selfish?
Dionna: Yeah, actually, I do. I think throwing that on a child, one that you barely know because you didn't previously take the time to get to know him, throwing the fact that you're dying on him is kind of selfish. It's very heavy. And then forcing them to spend a summer with you, spend all his time getting to know each other. "Oh, by the way, I'm dying," like, super-casual. There was no good lead-up to it, like, "Oh I'm dying, no big deal." No, it's a big deal! I kind of wish he had done this a little differently.
Joe: How could he have done it differently?
Dionna: There is no "differently" at this point, because at this point he's dying.
Joe: But I mean, would things have gone better, worse, or the same if George had straight-up said at the beginning, "You're coming with me for the summer, because this is my last summer"?
Dionna: Maybe! I don't think it would've gone differently. Well, I dunno...
Joe: I wonder what Sam's reaction would've been.
Dionna: I feel like it would've been like, "I don't care!" But it would've definitely been different than developing the relationships, and then dropping a bombshell. "Hey. I'm dying." Because then you have to process that, and deal with that. So I dunno, it's tough. To me, it feels a little selfish. I don't know if that's fair.
Joe: Do you feel like people have more of a right to be selfish the closer they are to death?
Dionna: Maybe.
Joe: Alright, so, okay, when my grandpop was heading toward death, he lived in an assisted living home for a while. And he had trouble swallowing. Even so, my dad and his four siblings would very often sneak him ice cream. Because he liked ice cream, and he's dying, and he's out of it. I could see someone accusing that behavior as being selfish, either of my grandpop or of my dad and his siblings, because he had trouble swallowing it. But, at the same time, he's... pretty close to death, no matter how many ice cream sandwiches he's eating. I dunno.
Dionna: Maybe I think it's selfish because it involves a child. You're already springing something tough on your child, and then you're forcing him into a different environment, and you're forcing him to adjust to that while he's adjusting to this news. So maybe delivering the news in a "safe" environment may have been better. I may have looked at it different.
Joe: That's a good point. I'm even thinking now that Sam may have felt "bamboozled." Maybe Sam felt extra shitty because, had he known his dad was dying of cancer, he wouldn't have acted the way he did, at least not as severely.
Dionna: He was such a jerk!
Joe: He wouldn't have... called the health inspector about the toilet regulations. [laughter]
Dionna: I thought that was great.
Joe: So good. Such a ridiculous scene. And I really appreciate the fact that it goes unstated that Sam was the one that called the inspector. George is just like, "Whatever asshole called should be ashamed of themselves!" And Sam's just has no reaction whatsoever, but you know it's him.
Dionna: "I hope this makes whatever asshole called you happy!" [laughter]
Joe: We've been talking about the movie for a half hour and I still haven't gotten through my list of funniest parts.
Dionna: Sorry.
Joe: No, it's great! That's a mark of a good movie, because there are so many good parts. And you know what I appreciated the most? Out of the 30 movies that I've watched, this is my second Kevin Kline movie. And it was also the second Kevin Kline movie that felt like all the characters were just fucking each other.
Dionna: Yup.
Joe: The Big Chill was exactly like that. Have you ever seen The Big Chill?
Dionna: No. But now I'll have to.
Joe: If you like Kevin Kline, he's... Glenn Close, his wife, tells him to go fuck one of their friends to get her pregnant.
Dionna: That's... always an interesting plot.
Joe: It wasn't technically pimping though!
Dionna: Darn.
Joe: Okay, so let's take a breather, and ask the question. I dunno if you've been reading any of the recent interviews, but I've been doing a thing where the previous interviewee and has to ask the current interviewee a question. So, I have not read this question yet. Hannah was the last interview, with Clueless. I haven't read this yet, but I'm assuming it's going to be a very Hannah D***-esque question. So bear that in mind.
Dionna: Okay.
Joe: "If you could give anyone with a penis in this movie a vagina, who would it be, and how would that change the story?" As we suspected, a very Hannah question. [laughter]
Dionna: Yeah! I don't know... Oh my gosh.
Joe: I'm surprised you're taking a while, because I thought there would be an obvious answer to this question.
Dionna: There is an obvious answer!
Joe: I was thinking Sam.
Dionna: It would really be Sam. Because I'm wondering how it would be for a teenage girl to go through this, instead of a teenage boy. I just wonder. How would it change the story though?
Joe: I don't particularly see a teenage girl acting more or less sullen than Sam does in this movie.
Dionna: I think people might care more about the prostitution story though!
Joe: Right, maybe that would... improve the story?
Dionna: I don't know how else it would change the story.
Joe: So we say that if you gave Sam a vagina, it would change the story the least. What male character being given a vagina would change the story the most?
Dionna: The father? It would be a very different story.
Joe: Interesting.
Dionna: People don't do well with the idea of mothers being neglectful. It's different when your father's absent. I don't know why, but it's like, "Absent Father? Okay." But "Absent Mother"? Not as cool. "How can you not be there for your child?!"
Joe: That's a really interesting point. I was thinking more how it would be weirder that Mary Steenbergen had a problem with Female George popping a squat at the beginning of the movie. [laughter]
Dionna: Maybe she thought it was just rude to be peeing outside of your house?
Joe: I liked your answer better though. I was actually thinking about how it would affect the story if the stepdad was female.
Dionna: I was thinking him too. But then I was like, I dunno. Because he felt so detached at certain points, so would it have an effect on the story?
Joe: I feel like maybe... say Robin remarried a woman. Maybe her now-wife would have more of a reason to be upset with her when she went back to the guy. Like, "You told me that you were a lesbian, so is that a lie?"
Dionna: That would be good. Let's rewrite it.
Joe: Life as a House: Part 2. The stepdad gets cancer.
Dionna: "And... does anyone care?" [laughter]
Joe: I know we talked about how the acting was good—and I agree—but I guess I was kind of surprised that some of the actors were nominated for some awards.
Dionna: Really?
Joe: Not Oscars.
Dionna: I figured not Oscars. Please.
Joe: Life as a House got shut out of the Oscars—whether rightly so or not, we'll leave that for the audience to decide! I... wouldn't have minded seeing get nominated for something though.
Dionna: But what?
Joe: Yeah, that's the thing. Best Set Design, right?
Dionna: They built a house! I also love that whole thing. I love the idea of building a house. That's a dream of mine.
Joe: I definitely want to touch on that in a second. But the awards—the SAG Awards nominated both Kevin Kline and Hayden Christensen.
Dionna: That did happen.
Joe: Russell Crowe beat Kline for his work in A Beautiful Mind.
Dionna: C'mon, that was just unfair!
Joe: And fucking Ian McKellan beat Christensen for his work in Fellowship of the Rings! I... I fucking hate Lord of the Rings.
Dionna: I like Lord of the Rings, and I don't think that was... no. I'll say it. I don't agree with that. He's done better, let's say that.
Joe: Maybe it was because Ian McKellan was so much taller than the hobbits, and you tend to respect taller people?
Dionna: [laughter] You would know.
Joe: As a tall person, I can say that Hayden got fucked! The golden Globes nominated Christensen as well.
Dionna: Did they? I knew about SAG, but I forgot about this.
Joe: He lost to Jim Broadbent, who played Slughorn in Harry Potter.
Dionna: What?!
Joe: No, I'm sorry, it was for his work in another movie. Slughorn was not nominated. [laughter]
Dionna: It's not even a good role.
Joe: If we're talking about characters in Harry Potter, Slughorn was one of the best, but we won't get into that.
Dionna: I may have a different opinion, but okay.
Joe: Well, neither of us are Slytherins... I assume.
Dionna: No, I'm Hufflepuff.
Joe: Ravenclaw.
Dionna: Makes sense.
Joe: Speaking of petty school bullshit, I'm interested in you talking about your history with tech in the Masque, and how it relates to the movie.
Dionna: Well...
Joe: Right? That's not a stretch to ask.
Dionna: Not at all. My first year at La Salle, we built a two-story, rotating house. It was so freaking cool.
Joe: You literally built a house.
Dionna: I built a house. It was all me. [laughter]
Joe: This was after you watched this movie?
Dionna: Yeah.
Joe: While building the sets, did you ever think about this movie?
Dionna: I did, all the time! That's why I showed a bunch of people at La Salle this movie. I was like, "Hey, do you know what movie they build a house in? Life as a House! We should watch that!" And they were like, "Alright... okay..."
Joe: What show was the house built for?
Dionna: Noises Off. But yeah, I like building, I like using my hands. I have no real skill relating to plumbing, or electricity, or any of that. But I can put in screws. I can take measurements. And buy wood! So I can totally build a house!
Joe: There ya go.
Dionna: But I like the idea of being able to build something that's mine, that I built.
Joe: Is that something you thought about before you joined the Masque?
Dionna: Oh yeah. I also knew that I couldn't act... well, let's say that I have no interest in acting.
Joe: You can do whatever you want to do.
Dionna: I can sing—I'm not a great singer, but I can sing. And I hate being on stage, so... the perfect place was where I could build things and be behind the scenes. Great. Perfect.
Joe: I thought about the Masque in that way. I also thought about the Masque in the way that Sam was just so dramatic with everything. [laughter]
Dionna: I do like dramatic people.
Joe: If he went to La Salle, he would've definitely been part of the Masque.
Dionna: And we would've been best friends!
Joe: What is it about theater kids that makes them such fucking drama divas? I include myself in this. Because, if people have been reading my blog, there has to be at least a half dozen times that I've mentioned the Masque and their dramatic bullshit.
Dionna: I don't know what it is. I feel like it's an acceptable place to be dramatic. Anywhere else, people would be like, "I'm not dealing with this." But you just expect people in theater to deal with that nonsense, so it just continues, and it draws people in. "I can be ridiculous? Okay!"
Joe: What would be Sam's Masque name? [Editor's note: a nickname given to Masque members when they "officially" are "inducted" into the organization... actually, the less I say about this, the better. Skip a few sentences if you have no interest in this college malarkey.]
Dionna: I follow a one-name tradition, so it would be tough for me to say.
Joe: It's gotta have something to do with his premature ejaculation in the shower. [laughter]
Dionna: So true! "Quick" something.
Joe: "Sweaty Clusterfuck Quick-Cum"? Sorry to everyone reading this who wasn't part of the Masque. Inside jokes will be the death of this blog. Here's a question I meant to ask earlier, speaking of Sam's behavior again. How does a kid become like that? I know you said it wasn't because of divorce, but then so what was it? Is there a way to allow a kid to become that way? I'm asking this as a father who is scared to death that his daughters will... autoerotic asphyxiate. [laughter]
Dionna: I hope you don't ever have to run into your kid's room when you hear a crash because of it! [laughter] No, I think not being afraid to ask tough questions of your kid. Not being afraid to ask about... I dunno, let's say they are doing drugs. Not talking about it isn't going to stop them from doing it. Not talking about it is only going to make the situation worse. Being able to talk to kids and be upfront with them, keeping those lines of communication open. It feels like that didn't happen with Sam and his mom, and of course with the dad, who was not in his life. But for the mom, who was there all the time—she states "He's here all the time!"—you can tell there's a real lack of communication, and I think that does create... it allows this child to continue the negative behaviors and patterns.
Joe: That sounds legit. I've read things that say that what happens in the household is only going to impact like 20% of how the kid ends up. What happens outside the home is the other 80%
Dionna: Having a good base at home, though, will help when you get out into the real world.
Joe: Treat them right, and hope that no budding pimps go to Our Lady of Port Richmond. [laughter]
Dionna: Again, I don't know, I didn't try drugs as a teenager. But if you are doing them, maybe it's like, "Alright, it's cool, I did it, but this isn't something I want you to do." Or at least your parents are telling you that it's bad, and here's why. That can be helpful. But you're going to be influenced by the people around you. Especially as a teenager! They're terrible influencers.
Joe: I do feel like I have to note here that a weirdly large amount of these interviews make it seem like I'm worried that Willow and Martha are doing drugs. Or maybe just because I just touched on that with Clueless. But I'm not actually worried. As long as they are smart about it.
Dionna: My hope is that, if and when I do have children, that they are good, and safe, and happy.
Joe: Right. The drugs are a very small part of Sam's overall terrible disposition.
Dionna: There are much larger issues. Which is why he might be using! However... going to drugs definitely isn't going to help your issues.
Joe: Really, it might just be a matter of, when they are twelve—around the time Sam started popping pills—making them watch this movie.
Dionna: Yes. [laughter]
Joe: Here is a question. What would you do if you had four months to live? I know you said you enjoy building houses, but...
Dionna: Let's get real, though. I know me. I am not building a house in four months. [laughter] It ain't happening!
Joe: Sure it could. Knock down your dad's house, and rebuild it.
Dionna: Yeah, my dad's house in Atlanta! That'd be really fun. He'd be like, "...no?" No, if I had four months to live, I would travel. I've never been out of the country. I've only been to four states in my entire life. I would travel, because I've never seen anything.
Joe: I feel like there's a large amount of movies in which someone finds out that they are going to die, and then does that type of thing, like travel or whatever. I feel like this is a very unique movie, in that he just stays home, and does his own thing. Instead of traveling.
Dionna: I think that's what I like though. I also like that he's an architect. That's what he does. And this is what he chooses to do. It just shows his passion for it!
Joe: Especially because of the fact that he got fired from that job, just because he wouldn't learn to use the computer. That whole scene where he got fired almost felt like a "mass shooter" scene, when he was smashing up all the designs.
Dionna: My favorite scene!
Joe: Everyone's running away like he's going to murder them!
Dionna: I just love it. I understood where he's coming from. "Why am I dying? Here I am!"
Joe: Do you feel like him building a house had anything to do with him proving to his old coworkers that he did take his job seriously? He didn't need computers. He's going to build a fucking house.
Dionna: He's trying to prove it to a bunch of people! His father. His kids. Himself! That he could finish something, and be good at something.
Joe: Do you feel like... [laughter] Alright, this is the last thing on my list of "funniest moments." It's probably the worst.
Dionna: Oh god.
Joe: The fact that he could see his house from the hospital bed! Give me your response to that.
Dionna: ...
[laughter]
Dionna: I don't know! It's supposed to be a moment that's like, "Aw, that's nice." But it's actually kind of crappy! Because then he knows that he didn't finish it! [laughter]
Joe: Not even that! There were points where logic was stretched, and I laughed. That... that was a point where logic was stretched so far...
Dionna: Everything was in a perfect location that he can just look out a window and see the house.
Joe: And clearly see the Christmas lights! No. C'mon. Jesus Christ. It made me laugh. Oh my god.
Dionna: Maybe he imagined it! Maybe he never actually saw it.
Joe: Oh, that's interesting. This was a fever dream? But this is when Sam comes back from taking a dive.
Dionna: Yup. Sam was delusional.
Joe: That was his moment of clarity for Sam. So you feel like there's a good chance that George dreamed all of this? That Sam jumped, that he had a moment of clarity, that he came to the hospital soaking wet, and the fact that he could see the fucking house from his fucking hospital bed?!
Dionna: I think it's a possibility!
Joe: I don't buy it.
Dionna: No? Okay, fine. It could've! Alright. Alright.
Joe: It would make more sense logistically, but then it would make the movie that much worse.
Dionna: Fine, it all happened! [laughter]
Joe: There were so many moments like that in this movie, and I feel like Scott Bakula—who we haven't talked about yet!—
Dionna: We haven't, I know!
Joe: I feel like he, in reaction to another insane moment, when Sam blackmailed his would-be john, I guess? Into not pressing charges against his dying father, by pointing out that his car was there? Scott Bakula was there, and he laughs, and says, "What the fuck?" The best line reading of all time! It's probably the linchpin of this movie. That Scott Bakula is able to express, in those three words, how ridiculous everything is, and how funny everything is, and how things don't make sense, but you're gonna get those tears jerked anyway.
Dionna: I never thought about that line that way.
Joe: Oh my god, I died when he said it. That made the movie for me. Had anyone else played that role, and had anyone else said that line in a different way, then I don't think I would've liked this movie. But Scott Bakula made Life as a House make sense to me.
Dionna: [laughter] Oh my god. I'm going to have to ask my friend Nicole, who watched this movie, and her reaction was "Oh my god it's Scott Bakula! How have I not watched this movie before?" I'm going to have to ask her if she feels the same way. [Editor's note: I can't find a clip of the quote online, but maybe you can use this as your motivation to watch this ridiculous movie in full.]
Joe: So yeah, maybe I thought it was a bad movie, but I still enjoyed it.
Dionna: That's what I keep trying to explain to people. It's a little out there, like, okay, would any of this really happen? Probably not! However, does that make it a "bad" film? No.
Joe: It's not even "bad" in the same way as The Room. I'll say it again—it's not a "so bad it's good" type of thing. There's so many moments where this movie is bad, and I ended up liking it despite that.
Dionna: I can agree with that.
Joe: It's interesting. I was thinking about this. I've had a lot people ask me, when we're talking about Your Favorite Movie, the blog series, people ask me "Of the movies that you've watched so far, what movie have you liked the least?" Why do you think people always ask me that? What are people's—I don't want to say "obsession"—but why are people so interested in what people don't like?
Dionna: I feel like it tells us more about the person.
Joe: You feel like their dislikes tell you more about someone than their likes?
Dionna: I would definitely say that, except for people who hate everything, because that just says you hate everything. But yeah, I think you can tell a lot about someone through knowing that. If someone said, "I don't like comedies," that would be interesting. It would make me wonder why.
Joe: And I feel like people can dislike something for legitimate reasons. But what would you generalize about a person who said that Life as a House is a "bad movie"?
Dionna: That's a loaded question, because I know someone who hates this movie.
Joe: Who, your friend you mentioned earlier?
Dionna: No, Lily.
Joe: Another Masque techie!
Dionna: She hates this movie. She walked out when we were watching it.
Joe: Okay, so if dislikes say more about someone than likes, what does that say about Lily?
Dionna: I think she likes black-and-white. It can't be funny and serious. This movie is really serious at some points, and really funny during others. If it's lighthearted, cool, if it's serious, cool. But if it's too much of the two, then it's not good.
Joe: She's the type of person who doesn't like peanut butter and jelly?
Dionna: I don't know, because she is definitely the type of person who does! [laughter] Which is weird. I don't know! But looking at a list of movies that she likes, it's usually really funny, or sad. No in between.
Joe: Can you generalize for more people—like, say, the 57% of the population who dislikes this movie, according to Rotten Tomatoes—is that the case for them as well?
Dionna: No. I think it's just a matter of people not willing to give things a chance. Especially the fact that the movie starts with a scene of someone jerking off, that's hard to take for some people! [laughter] That's how it starts!
Joe: 106 out of 200 critics saw autoerotic asphyxiation and immediately thought that this movie was bad?!
Dionna: "I can't. I'm not dealing with this. I can't see why it would get better."
Joe: I don't know if I buy it.
Dionna: I think some people aren't willing to see things through. I'm willing to see almost any movie through. To me, yeah, it might be a shaky start, but the end might be amazing!
Joe: You're saying as long as you don't kink-shame, then you will appreciate Life as a House. Everyone who hates this movie is a kink-shamer! [laughter]
Dionna: Yes, exactly! No, I don't know what it is. There were also a lot of people who said "I will not like this movie," but then I showed it to them, and they were like, "Oh my gosh, Dionna, this is a good movie!" I'd be like, "Yeah, I've been telling you that for how many years?" I don't know. People aren't willing to give things a chance.
Joe: Sure.
Dionna: Also, in today's world, everyone reads what critics write about it. "It got a bad score on Rotten Tomatoes, I'm not watching that!" Don't worry about that. Just watch the movie! I watched Catwoman... that was a bad movie. But I watched it!
Joe: Interesting, because I feel like I gave Pam shit for that recently. We watched a really bad Hulu movie called Lemon. With, um... I forget the guy. Because, ya know, we were just scrolling through Hulu looking for a movie to watch. It was real bad. I was like, "Pam, you gotta start going on Rotten Tomatoes before we watch something."
Dionna: No! There are so many movies that I like that did not do well critically. That critics are just like, "Awful movie! Why would you see this?" Or other people watch it and call it garbage. And then I still like it!
Joe: So do you feel like you are the type of person who is more willing to defend bad movies just because that's who you are?
Dionna: I think I can find the good in almost any movie. That's not to say that I like every movie, but I can make an argument for almost any movie.
Joe: Why would you though?
Dionna: I don't know. Because I like arguing. [laughter]
Joe: That's fair.
Dionna: I will say this—there are movies that have no redeeming qualities. I watched Catwoman because I love Halle Berry. That's an awful movie! There are no redeeming qualities! Even Halle Berry couldn't save it. Bad movie. Other films that people have said "This is absolute garbage," I say no. The Room, terrible movie. There's no getting around it. Should everyone see it? Of course. Bad movie.
Joe: So you're making the argument that movies are straight-up subjective, and that there's no one who can tell you what to expect from a movie, that you should just watch it?
Dionna: That's how I feel. Look, there are people who think that The Godfather is terrible. Why should I listen to other people?
Joe: So I guess you're saying that there's no way anyone could know whether they are going to like Life as a House... unless you like Emo Hayden Christensen.
Dionna: If you like Emo Hayden Christensen. If you like a good laugh, and also a good cry, this is the movie for you! I like a good cry. I like emotional movies. I like watching relationships develop—I like the idea that in building this house, he's also building a relationship. Love that! Some people don't like that. For me... that's my life. I love this. And I do like laughing. Again... this is my favorite movie, so I'm going to say that everyone should see this. But I could see why people don't want to. They're wrong, but I can see it. [laughter]

No comments:
Post a Comment