Tuesday, February 11, 2020

Should I Watch This? The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel

Should I Watch This? Sam S******* wades through the glut of television content to offer his view on whether a TV show is worth your time. The only connective tissue for this column is that Sam watched it.

Is that Christopher Darden AND Shy Baldwin?

Show: The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel

Season: Three (released 2019)

Episodes: 8; each between 48 minutes and an hour, 12 minutes

How to Watch: Amazon Prime

Genre: 1960s-era Comedy

You'd Enjoy This Show If You Like: Old Hollywood; Jewish culture and slapstick; Gilmore Girls; female empowerment.

You'd Hate This Show If You Dislike: Gilmore Girls. The Amy Sherman Palladino lightning-fast dialogue is a barrier to entry for some.

People Involved: Sherman Palladino created the show with her husband, David. By Season 3, you're probably familiar with the award-winning cast, but this season particularly spotlights Midge Maisel's manager, Susie, played by Alex Bornstein (Mad TV, Family Guy) and her mother, Rose, played by Marin Hinkle (a reoccurring cast member on Two and a Half Men?!?!?!?!?).  Also, fun guest spots by Jane Lynch (a hack comedian turned Broadway star) and Jason Alexander, who has a two-episode arc as Tony Shaloub's communist, playwright friend.

The big highlights come from this season's plot device. Midge is on tour with crooner Shy Baldwin (Leroy McClain). McClain is vibrant on stage and vulnerable off. But the real payoff is that Sterling K. Brown plays his manager, Reggie. Brown steals every scene he's in with a seething anger and electric coolness. They only got him for four episodes, but you get to hear him sing (he's pretty good!).

The Pitch: Turn your brain off and enjoy a feel-good, well-written, funny show with beautiful period sets. The season is more of the same as before: Rachel Brosnahan as Mrs. Maisel totally embodies the character. My brain can't track she's the same actress as the damaged girl on House of Cards. You root for her on-stage; you're annoyed with her off-stage. The stakes are fairly low, even when things go bad. Plus, the characters are funnier when things go to shit (Midge's parents move in with the Maisels; get ready for a lot of Kevin Pollack shouting off-stage). There's a lot more singing this season, which is sometimes fine, but occasionally feels as if they are filling time (which is stupid in this streaming world—just make the episode shorter).

Do I Need to Watch the Other Seasons First? Definitely. The plot is easy to digest (female housewife turned comedian upsets her life), but you'd miss out on the character growth.

Should I Watch This? Yes! It's fun. Come on, don't be a dick.

1 comment:

Joe K said...

Mrs. Maisel might not be the straight-up best show on television, but it's definitely the most FUN show on television.