Friday, February 21, 2020

IGOR, Joe


You should know that this is the first Tyler, the Creator album that I own and am intimate with. This personal fact is crucial to the narrative. The narrative affects how much I enjoy the album. My enjoyment of the album is also part of the narrative. It's a cycle that Tyler, the Creator sure seems like he wants to escape, but he cannot. He is part of the narrative too. It's his album.

And, for better or worse, the narrative is probably more interesting to think about than the album itself. I'm not saying it's a bad album—I quite like it. But I'm more interested in talking about the WHYs than the WHATs, so we'll start with the WHYs and eventually circle back, promise.

Tyler, the Creator (gosh that comma really annoys me) was the de facto leader of the early 2010s rap collective, Odd Future Wolf Gang Kill Them All, whom you may remember from that early Jimmy Fallon appearance (during which Felicia Day became an unwitting member of Odd Future Wolf Gang Kill Them All). They manufactured a rap sound that Wikipedia calls "horrorcore," and their lyrics were rife with misogyny and homophobia.

That whole sound and content and density just didn't really appeal to me in the 2010s, for the most part. I'm not even making the argument that the homophobia was any part of dissuading me from giving Tyler, the Creator a chance, though I'm sure it didn't help. I just wasn't at a place where I could appreciate rap. Sometimes I still feel that way, though I'm getting better, and I'm working real hard at it.

Then, on 2017's Scum Fuck Flower Boy, Tyler came out as gay. I didn't listen to that album either, but that seemed like a pretty interesting left turn in the narrative—I guess the all the uses of the word f***** really was a projection of some deep-seeded self-hate. It was an album that I enjoyed reading about more than I enjoyed listening to, and so I didn't really give it a chance.

By the time we reach IGOR in 2019, a few things have changed, and both are important. First, Tyler barely does any rapping on the thing. I don't have numbers for you, but it's gotta be at least 80% a neo-soul/funk/R&B hybrid, and maybe 20% rap (depends on what you want to define as "rap," so that number could possibly be lower under other definitions). Again, not saying that blinking neon letters spelling "NOT RAP" are going to attract me to an album, but I'm definitely more likely to pick up a funk album than a rap album, right?

The second thing that has changed is that quite possibly the biggest name in pop music right now is an eighteen-year-old white girl named Billie Eilish, and the music that catapulted her to win all four Grammys this year is practically the same music that Odd Future was making at the turn of the decade. It's packaged differently—Odd Future came this close to righteously beating up a noxiously unfunny Fallon, and Eilish is spending her time serenading dead movie stars—but c'mon, the similarities are striking. It's that industrial horrorcore for a new audience.

So these dueling narratives reached an impasse at the 2020 Grammys, where Tyler, the Creator stole the early part of the show (the part before 99% of America fell asleep) by jumping into a pit of fire, and then won the Best Rap Album Grammy for a non-rap album (beating Record Club alum YBN Cordae!). Then, later on in the night, when America really was asleep, Billie Eilish won everything.

I don't know if I personally would've tweeted in all caps if I was Tyler, the Creator, but I can certainly understand why he was upset. Not only did the music industry by and large ignore him until he stopped with the horrorcore rapping and made a "safe" R&B-soul album, but then they also turn around and give the night's highest honors to a white teenage girl who is taking his old music and selling it to the masses. She was fucking SHOWERED in Grammys for it.

I get it. That's frustrating as fuck. And now to add insult to injury, we're going to analyze IGOR this week in Record Club. Would we have reviewed Goblin? Maybe. Would I have liked it? Probably not. So great, Tyler created in IGOR an album that even this shitty pompous white kid can enjoy. I'm sure that makes him feel AWESOME.

You can just ignore all this, honestly. You can listen to an anthem about guns and homosexuality(?) that goes down as smooth as the softest soul ballad ("A BOY IS A GUN"). You can listen to the stomp-clap Jackson-5-esque off-kilter beauty ("GONE, GONE / THANK YOU"). You can listen to "EARFQUAKE," which was supposed to be a Rihanna song originally, and sounds like it (this is a good thing). A lot of it sounds like some shit Kanye West would come up with, but you can actually listen to it without feeling bad about yourself (which says more about Kanye than it does Tyler).

You don't need the narrative, is basically what I'm saying. But you got it anyway. You're welcome?!?!

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

1 comment:

Sam Fran said...

I learned a lot from reading this post. Including that Billie Eilish is a white woman. I seriously have been picturing Post Malone this whole time.