Wednesday, February 19, 2020

SEPTA Bar Crawl (Subway Edition)

I was asked recently to come up with some bars near SEPTA subway stops, because "that seemed like something you would know." I'll be honest, it was not something I had previously committed to figuring out, though the idea obviously intrigued me enough that I've been thinking about it ever since.

Coming up with a list of one bar for every subway stop is extremely challenging, for a few reasons. First, our city's relatively simple subway system cuts in all four directions, through many neighborhoods that I am not intimately familiar with, and have no reason to go to recreationally. As I mentioned when I visited Tavern on the Green, there are bars that I go to normally, and then there are thousands of other bars that I've never even been near, let alone in.

And that isn't some kind of dog whistle, by the way. I believe in the power of alcohol to bring people together, and I wouldn't feel uncomfortable posting up at a bar that doesn't traditionally see a whole lot of people who look like me. If anything, I would be worried in the opposite direction, that I would be making people uncomfortable by my presence in their own bar. Respect is the name of the game, no matter what bar you go to in this city. Rolling into a bar in North Philly with a shrieking bachelorette party wouldn't be advisable, simply because it would come off as obnoxious, possibly even like cultural appropriation.

Back to the point—creating this list is challenging because I'm just straight-up not familiar with many of the bars that are in the vicinity of subway stops. How can you claim that a bar is "the best" in any subcategory if you've never been to that bar? The short answer is that you can't. The longer answer is that you have to commit to eventually checking out the bars on such a list, just to verify that it is a solid list.

So yeah, obviously I want to visit all these bars, just so I can say without a doubt that these are the official bars of each subway stop. Because of how my life is structured right now, I certainly won't be completing the list any time soon (definitely not in 2020). But out of all the bars I want to explore, these move to the top of the list.

There are a bunch of bars I've been to on this list as well—I'm not a fucking homebody. And for those subway stops, it mostly ended up being what was my favorite of all the bars in the vicinity of that subway stop.

In fact, this is a good place to explain how I picked each bar. Obviously, I used Google Maps for a lot of the selections, and I made sure that there were no bars chosen that were more than a ten-minute walk from the station. Some stations had a bar right on the same corner; others, you definitely have to walk the ten minutes (and sometimes, the closest bar is actually itself closer to another subway stop, but I did what I could).

There are other subway stops, like I already mentioned, that have a multitude of bars in the area, so I tried to pick the bar that best represented what I like in bars, typically. The 2nd St. stop on the El is a great example—Nick's is not the best bar within 0.5 miles of that stop, and it's definitely not the bar that best "represents" that neighborhood (Old City). But it's a great little spot, and I think it best represents the spirit of such a list—that these are all accessible bars in more ways than one (both welcoming and literally accessible via subway).

Okay, enough preamble, let's get to the list. It's broken up by subway, and moves from either North to South, or East to West. I'll note when I've never been to the bar with an asterisk, and I'll also give a short explanation of why that bar is the station's official bar when that's warranted.

Finally, let me say that I am not claiming that doing a bar crawl through the entirety of either subway line is actually feasible or even physically possibly, though if anyone truly wants to make an attempt, consider me the guy to call, okay?


Broad Street Line (BSL)

Fern Rock 
My Place Tavern
5911 North Broad Street
Distance from the station: 0.4 miles
WEBSITE

You might be surprised to not see an asterisk next to our first bar. After attending a funeral for my good friend Rose back in 2010, Dave and I went to the closest bar for a drink/toast, and that happened to be My Place Tavern. The only thing I can attest to a decade later is that it is indeed a bar and they do indeed sell drinks. Also, this is a little far from Fern Rock, but it is literally the closest bar to the station, which is a little off the beaten path in the first place.


Olney
Tellups Tavern*
1322 West Olney Avenue
the bar is right fucking there
Distance from the station: 450 feet
WEBSITE

I've driven past this bar thousands of times (when I used to go between Rockledge and La Salle), and the name has always tickled me in a way that I can't really describe. Maybe it's the simple alliteration. I used to joke in college that we should go to this bar instead of Finnegan's, and I'm honestly surprised no one actually took me up on it.


Logan
Charley B's*
4948 North Broad Street
Distance from the station: 210 feet
WEBSITE

It pains me that I can't include the "Ice Cold Beer" forty store that is right around the corner from the station. You can still go if you want! Ask for a case of Hurricanes, they'll open up their garage door and sell to you at wholesale! But we need to pick a bar here, so head to Charley B's, even though it looks like it might be a chain (there's one on Stenton Ave. too, but I can't find any owner information for either).


Wyoming
Circles Lounge*
4800 North Broad Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

I have similar regrets not including Sid Booker's on this list, but it's not a bar! Ah well. Circles Lounge looks legit. Hopefully it's still open—their last Facebook post was in 2015 for Darchell's birthday.


doesn't this look good? no? okay.
Hunting Park
Tashia's Cocktails and Cuisine*
1641 West Hunting Park Avenue
Distance from the station: 0.3 miles
WEBSITE

Not gonna lie, the food here looks pretty great. They are pushing Uber Eats hard on their Facebook page, but c'mon, I want the full Tashia experience.



Erie
Eagle Bar*
3653 Germantown Avenue
Distance from the station: 300 feet
WEBSITE

I'm pretty ashamed that I haven't been here yet. Not only was it featured in Bar Code, but it was also in Creed and This Is Us! A Philly institution! I'm gonna pop down on the BSL from work for lunch one of these days, promise.


Allegheny
Sky Beer & Steak Deli*
3403 Germantown Avenue
Distance from the station: 0.3 miles
WEBSITE (kind of)

I know I said in the Logan Station blurb that my selections had to be bars, but there legitimately is not a single bar within 0.5 miles from Allegheny Station. Uncut Bar is the closest, and it's almost a mile away, a distance which would defeat the purpose of a subway bar crawl. So we're stuck with Sky Beer, which I have to assume is a forty store that you can sit in and drink your alcohol. Good enough.


the scene at Al's
North Philadelphia
Al's Spot*
2540 North 15th Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

I have nothing. It's a bar. According to Facebook, they sometimes have shrimp.


Susquehanna-Dauphin
Red Top 24 Bar*
2400 North 16th Street
Distance from the station: 0.3 miles
WEBSITE

I didn't read anything that supported this, but their Facebook profile pic and cover photo are both pictures of little cupcakes, so let's assume that this is a bar and bakery both. You hear that, folks?! Red Top 24 Bar is the best bakery in North Philly!


Cecil B. Moore
Draught Horse Pub & Grill
1431 Cecil B. Moore Avenue
Distance from the station: 350 feet
WEBSITE

Finally, another bar I've actually been to already! We went a few years ago (pre-babies for sure) during a Monday Beer Runners session. It was during a blizzard, and somehow this was the most well-attended bar run of the year. Being at any bar during a snowstorm is a great fucking time. I wonder if this bar is just as fun during the warmer months?


Girard
RePlay*
822 North Broad Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

This one is going to take an in-person confirmation. It's definitely the closest bar to the BSL Girard stop, but FB hasn't been posted on since 2017, and Google just keeps giving me the goddamn Chicago bar with the same name (which I've been to, believe it or not... it was fine).


Fairmount
Cicala*
699 North Broad Street
Distance from the station: 59 feet
WEBSITE

there is a bar in here, but unfortuantely there is no bar
in BONER 4EVER
This is a fancy restaurant, and so I can imagine the whiplash coming from some of the previous bars on this list and then rolling into Cicala. But it's absolutely the closest bar to the station (like, literally right above the station), and according to some pictures on PhillyMag, they do indeed have a bar.



Spring Garden
Keliann's Bar & Grill
1549 Spring Garden Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

This is the perfect corner bar. Nothing fancy, fair prices, good camaraderie. I've only been there once (for Beer Runners, when else?), but I had a nice hour or two there, and it's absolutely the closest bar to the subway station (for now—North Broad is on the up and up!).


Race-Vine
West Tavern
1440 Callowhill Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

Many people know this bar as "Westy's." Some people—mainly, my La Salle friends—know this as "the bar where the karaoke DJ tried to fight us." A great night, a shitty bar, I love this fucking place.


City Hall
Parkside Beef & Ale*
1433 Arch Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

There are a ton of options around this subway station, obviously. It's the center of our city. But I chose something north of the station, since we have the El stations for all bars south. And yeah, I chose a bar I've never been to; you might think it's weird that I've never been to a bar that's so close to my work, but consider the fact that it may be a little too close to work. My boss could probably see me walk in the front doors from her office window.


Walnut-Locust
Locust Rendezvous
1415 Locust Street
Distance from the station: 400 feet
WEBSITE

This was an easy pick. Not only is it the closest bar to this stop (R.I.P. Perch Pub), but it's one of the most comfortable and down-to-earth bars in Center City. It's cheap and warm—what else do you want?


Bob and Barbara's on Thursday nights
Lombard-South
Bob and Barbara's
1509 South Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

This was a bit harder to choose—or should I say, harder to justify—because it is not the closest bar to this stop (though it's still not that far). So yeah, you could go to South Street Diner (right above the station), or you could hit up the new Wine Dive or the Cambridge (both technically closer to the station by a few feet), but you can't beat a beer-and-a-shot landmark.


Ellsworth-Federal
Scotty's Bar*
1420 Ellsworth Street
Distance from the station: 400 feet
WEBSITE

Chosen for the same two reasons I'm picking a lot of the bars I've never been to—it's literally the closest bar, and it was featured in the great defunct Inquirer column Bar Code. I've definitely been meaning to stop by for breakfast one of these days, though.


Tasker-Morris
Bonnie's Capistrano Bar*
1503 South 13th Street
Distance from the station:
WEBSITE

Yup, it's confirmed. Samantha Melamed was trying to complete this subway bar crawl via Bar Code.


Snyder
Big Charlie's Saloon
1953 South 11th Street
Distance from the station: 0.4 miles
WEBSITE

Well, yeah, obviously Bar Code covered this one too, but I've actually been to Big Charlie's. It is a Kansas City Chiefs bar, a fact they make clear to everyone who steps foot in the door (the bartender brought me and Dwyer and Stephan to the back room, which was covered with Chiefs memorabilia). It was a local, insular crowd, but they were incredibly nice to us Eagles fans during our few beers there. That's why I'm choosing this bar over bars closer (Second District Brewing) or equidistant (South Philly Tap Room).

yes, you are still in Philly

Oregon
Black Cat Tavern*
2654 South 12th Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

This bar gets the nod over the SouthHouse (which is closer, but just barely), because SouthHouse was pretty mediocre overall with really bad service that one time we went for Beer Runners, and also Stephan's been telling me to check Black Cat out for like a year now (and, yeah.... Samantha Melamed was there too...... she fucking HATES North Philly, huh?).


NRG
Xfinity Live!
1100 Pattison Avenue
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

Until literally ANYTHING ELSE opens up near this station, then you're stuck with our corporate overlords' idea of a "fun time." Check out the Broad Street Bullies Pub corner of the complex for cheaper beers (sometimes, although maybe that's mythopoeia at this point).


Market-Frankford Line ("The El")

Frankford Transportation Center
Quinn's II Irish Pub*
5104 Frankford Avenue
Distance from the station: 500 feet
WEBSITE

Look, there bars on here that I have a sneaking suspicion are either closed permanently or open sporadically, and I won't really be able to confirm until I actually try to grab a beer there. This is one of those bars. Yelp only has one review (and that review notes the surprise in finding so many white people in the bar), no hours are listed, and the facade, per Google Maps, looks pretty run down. But it doesn't look there are any other bars within our 0.5-mile limit, so let's say Quinn's II for now, and hope for the best.


Arrot Transportation Center
Quinns Bar*
4401 Frankford Avenue
Distance from the station: 0.4 miles
WEBSITE

not Philly Quinns
I am more confident in Quinns' existence and operations than I am of its Roman-numerated sequel bar. I am also confident that this is the closest bar to Arrot, even though it's actually closer to the next station...


Church
The Point After*
4250 Frankford Avenue
Distance from the station: 210 feet
WEBSITE

No hours listed and no posts on Facebook since 2017 don't bode well for this bar, the only one close to Church Station (besides Quinns, but no repeats). At least the most recent FB post is fucking hilarious. We'll always have that.


Erie-Torresdale
Pat's Pub*
3884 M Street
Distance from the station: 0.3 miles
WEBSITE

I used to drive past this place when we used to shop at Aldi, and I have always been sincerely interested as to whether the claim of the sign on the side of the bar—"Best chili in Philly!"—is legit. I think this and Eagle Bar are up there at the top of the list of bars that I'll be going to next.

(UPDATE: I attempted to visit Pat's Pub this past Sunday, but the doors were locked, despite the fact that Google insisted they should be open at the time that I went. Bummer.)


Tioga
Shawn's Bar and Deli*
1947 East Tioga Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

Some chick posted like ten selfies on the FB page during the Super Bowl this year, so I know it's still operational. Whether it's actually worth hitting up (e.g. is it really a bar and a deli?!), I guess there's only one way to find out.


drinking is the legalest thing happening here
Allegheny
Jack's Famous Bar
853 East Allegheny Avenue
Distance from the station: 300 feet
WEBSITE

Samantha Melamed hit this bar up for Bar Code, but that was before ownership changed, so I cannot attest to the portrait that she paints with that article. I hit Jack's up recently myself, and wrote about it... kind of. I didn't really blog too much about the bar itself. Let's say it was fine, and that I cannot imagine walking even the 300 feet it takes to get there when the sun is down.


Somerset
Bentley's Place*
2800 D Street
Distance from the station: pretty much underneath the station
WEBSITE

Apparently, scene(s) from Rocky Balboa (the sixth movie) were filmed in Bentley's Place. That alone makes me believe that this bar is still operational, though I've never gotten off at Somerset during business hours, so I cannot say for sure. (I'm not sure if it counts as irony that a guy named Michael Rambo blew up their FB page with a bunch of tagged posts.)

maybe Bentley's place? I've never seen the movie

Huntingdon
The Penalty Box*
2532 Coral Street
Distance from the station: 0.3
WEBSITE

Sometimes, a bar is called a "sports bars" just because it has TVs that play sports. And sometimes a bar is called a "sports bar" and the name is a sports term and the FB page is littered with Eagles memes.


York-Dauphin
El Cantinflas Bar*
110 West Dauphin Street
Distance from the station: 118 feet
WEBSITE

Ahhhh fuck, that food looks good. Don't blog when you're hungry.


Berks
Common Sense Bar* (???)
1960 North 2nd Street
Distance from the station: 0.3 miles
NO WEBSITE

If you were to rank all 50 of these bars from DEFINITELY OPEN to PROBABLY NEVER EXISTED, then Common Sense Bar would be at the bottom. I cannot find any information besides a name. I will attempt to drive past this bar in the next few weeks to confirm one way or the other. If it's a bust, then I guess you guys are stuck with Evil Genius—which would suck!


kill yrself if u don't
like $2 high lifes
Girard
Fishtown Tavern
1301 Frankford Avenue
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

All of sudden, we get to a subway station that is absolutely surrounded by countless bars that I know and love (and occasionally hate). So this was a tough choice. But I think Fishtown Tavern is a great middle-of-the-road bar—not too shitty, not too fancy, not too expensive—and I've never had a bad time there. If you really don't want to walk 0.2 miles and would prefer to travel like 100 feet, then check out Saint Lazarus, fuck it.


Spring Garden
The 700
700 North 2nd Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

There are actually quite a few bars in walking distance, but The 700 is the closest, and it's good enough. Though, actually, it recently got new owners, so I can't guarantee that the first floor is still as chill as it once was, and the second floor is still as crowded on a Saturday night as it once was.


2nd St.
Nick's Old City Bar & Grille
16 South 2nd Street
Distance from the station: 200 feet
WEBSITE

their roast beef is still
probably pretty good
It used to be called "Nick's Roast Beef" but the roast beef isn't really the focal point anymore (the burgers are better anyway). This bar is so chill, so cheap, and like I said in the intro, it's not like it's the best bar in the area, or even on 2nd Street, but it's close to the subway station and it'll fit real nicely in the slot of any bar crawl.


5th St.
Stratus Rooftop Lounge
433 Chestnut Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

Wow, this was actually a tough one to pick. There is surprisingly few places to drink within a block of 5th and Market. You can walk a couple extra blocks easily to get to better bars, but then you're encroaching on other subway stops (see below). So we're stuck with douchey Stratus. Of course, in the spring and summer this answer changes to Independence Beer Garden, which, yes, is pretty douchey too, but at least there is ample room to hide from the douches. Still, I didn't feel comfortable choosing IBG because it's not open all year 'round.


8th St.
Las Vegas Lounge
704 Chestnut Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

This is a nice little compromise between divey aspirations and a Center City location.


11th St.
MilkBoy
1100 Chestnut Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

Some people like it for the concerts (not me), some people like it for the breakfast beers (me), but for most of the day it's just a regular bar. There are closer options, believe it or not, but I didn't want to pick a chain (Iron Hill Brewery, sorry Mom and Dad!), or a bar that isn't open at night (Molly Malloy's), or just the worst goddamn bar of all time (Field House).


home
13th St.
McGillin's Olde Ale House
1310 Drury Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

One day, I will blog my case for McGillin's as the best bar in the city, despite its flaws. For now, let's just say that no bar crawl is complete without it.


15th St.
Mace's Crossing
1714 Cherry Street
Distance from the station: 0.3 miles
WEBSITE

You're gonna walk past two bars on the way to Mace's that are fine (Tir Na nÓg and Con Murphy's), but something about Mace's just seems more authentic. Whether you think Mace's Crossing is actually another shitty bar masquerading as a quaint Up!-style tavern can probably be up for debate, but I like it enough.


30th St.
The Post
129 South 30th Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

There's a bar inside 30th Street Station—Bridgewater's Pub—but it's extremely average, and you can't even walk there underground from the subway portion of the station, so is it really that much more convenient than The Post? (Wait, did they end up opening that tunnel back up? A surface-level google search didn't provide answers, and I'm not going to waste my time digging deeper, since I don't want to go to Bridgewater's anyway.)


34th St.
Baby Blue's BBQ
3402 Sansom Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

Lots of places to eat around this subway station, but nowhere to drink in the immediate vicinity, except for a small row of bars tucked into Sansom Street. Baby Blue's is the best of the three (I guess New Deck and White Dog are fine too?)


penn jabroni going to Smokes
40th St.
Smokey Joe's
210 South 40th Street
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

Smokey Joe's is a very good college bar. Blarney Stone is also a good one, but I've only been there during off hours, and it strikes me as a bar that could turn terrible when packed with the type of college students I usually try to avoid.


46th St.
Fiume
2249 South 45th Street
Distance from the station: 0.4 miles
WEBSITE

You could probably go to Watusi Pub, which is about half the distance, but I can't attest to how it is in there, and I can say that I've been to Fiume and it's worth the trip.


52nd St.
Galaxy West*
5209 Market Street
Distance from the station: 70 feet
WEBSITE

We are past the gentrified and even semi-gentrified areas of the city for the rest of the list. Galaxy West seems to be a place you can get alcoholic drinks, and it is right next to the subway station, so here we are.


56th St.
Top Shelf Lounge*
5564 Market Street
Distance from the station: 45 feet
WEBSITE

Same blurb as Galaxy West, except that this bar is also apparently open at 7AM. I do not know if this is true, and I will probably never confirm.


when La Salle Friends go to karaoke
60th St.
West Side Tavern*
6052 Market Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

Not to be confused with West Tavern on Callowhill! Though I'm sure you can try to fight the karaoke DJ at either bar!


63rd St.
Kif's Sports Bar*
6142 Market Street
Distance from the station: 0.1 miles
WEBSITE

Kif's is actually closer to West Side Tavern than it is 63rd Street Station, which begs the question—if you're doing this bar crawl, do you absolutely need to take the subway in between each stop? I guess that'd be up to whoever's planning. I think my suggestion would be to at least get on or off at each stop, but not necessarily both. So you could get off at 60th, go to West Side, then walk to Kif's, then get on at 63rd. But you do you.


Millbourne
Waterford Inn*
6825 Ludlow Street, Upper Darby
Distance from the station: 0.5 miles
WEBSITE

Unless you wanna drink a forty along the banks of Cobbs Creek, there is nowhere to drink near Millbourne Station. Sorry. You'll have to walk half a mile to Waterford Inn, literally the closest bar, even though you'll end up really close to the next subway station by that point...


69th St. Transportation Center
Brownies Sports Bar*
26 Garrett Road, Upper Darby
Distance from the station: 0.2 miles
WEBSITE

Waterford Inn is closer to 69th Street than Brownies is. I don't know what to tell you. Who the fuck told you to take your bar crawl to Upper Darby anyway?


If it's easier to see all these bars on a map, then click HERE. 

Otherwise, I'll see you at Fern Rock.

No comments: