Wednesday, February 26, 2020

The Albums That Matter: Beast Moans

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Beast Moans
Swan Lake
2006

Swan Lake is a "supergroup," if we stretch the term to its very limits. The underlying implication is that already established stars are coming together to create something new together—think the Traveling Wilburys or the Highwaymen.

I suppose you could make the argument for Swan Lake as well, which is composed of Dan Bejar, Spencer Krug, and Carey Mercer. These are not household names, but if you are deep in the indie rock weeds, then you know who they are. Bejar is Destroyer and a former part of New Pornographers. Krug did Sunset Rubdown and is one half of Wolf Parade. Mercer was the frontman for the now-defunct Frog Eyes.

It's an interesting combination, because an outside could totally place all three artists in the "eccentric indie rock" box without being wrong, but then when you actually do place them in a room together, their differences become stark. So it goes with Beast Moans.

The ultimate question posed when it comes to this sort of thing: Is the sum greater than the parts? Well, I guess you'd have to be familiar with the parts. Let's go through each one and discuss what I think of them as separate artists and what I think of them in the context of this album.

Dan Bejar

The best quality that Bejar owns is his voice, which is reedy and mysterious, and he uses it to sings some bizarrely clever/funny lines (think when he says "cue fake drums" on that new Destroyer release). What's interesting about Bejar is that, while he is clearly a wordsmith, his music soars when he lets someone else get their hands on it. Some of his best songs went through the New Pornographers machine, where A.C. Newman no doubt spruced 'em up a bit with his pop sensibilities. Even with this year's Have We Met, Bejar spoke at length about how he basically came up with some demos and sent them to his buddy, who did whatever he wanted as far as the music went. So while I like Destroyer for the most part (more hits, plenty of misses), Swan Lake may or may not be the ideal situation for him?

Spencer Krug

I can't say the same about Krug, even though most of his best work is indeed with Wolf Parade (including one of the best songs of all time). But if you take the absolute best of all three of these artists' solo work and put 'em head-to-head-to-head, Krug's comes out on top (mainly the first and third Sunset Rubdown albums). And like all these guys, Krug is very idiosyncratic, but I think he is the most committed to actually laying down a hook every once in a while. I won't say that Swan Lake is better for Spencer Krug, but I'll say that Swan Lake is better because of Spencer Krug.

Carey Mercer

Frog Eyes was an absolutely batshit bedroom freak rock project, and they released exactly one great album—Tears of the Valedictorian, which is also the only tolerable Frog Eyes album, in my lowly opinion. So it's kind of hard to say that Mercer does better in Swan Lake. Maybe it's that Swan Lake is great despite Carey Mercer? But even that seems a little harsh. Add this to the fact that Mercer stated he was the captain at the helm for this project—not that he contributed more to the writing or the music, but he made all the "boring" production decisions, while Krug and Bejar flitted in and out when they could. Anything that is just too weird and doesn't work because of that, blame Mercer. On the flip side, anything that is so fucking weird and works despite that, you can probably thank Mercer. Weird dude.

Each of the three artists wrote four songs, and brought them to the group to flesh out. It's pretty clear what songs are whose if you are familiar with their respective signature sounds, but also it's pretty easy to pick out what specific influences the other two non-writing members had on each song. I'm thinking something like "The Freedom," which is a total Bejar song (most Bejar line: "You said 'the truth shall set you free,' / Oh, you lied to me, when you said 'the truth shall set you free.'"), but then has this furiously fluttering coda that is such a Mercer move. Or "All Fires," that is absolutely a Krug tune, but the lyrics are just too delicious for Bejar to have had nothing to do with it. And so on.

Probably the biggest difference between the three artists on this album is where the vocals are in the mix. Krug's are way up front, Bejar's are normal, and Mercer's are absolutely fucking buried. So you have songs like "Bluebird," where Krug is way louder than he probably should be (not necessarily complaining, but still), and then you have "City Calls," where it sounds like the band is playing in one room, and the mic just happens to be picking up Mercer's echo-y yawlp from down the hall. I guess this speaks to how important each artist considers vocals, and the weirder the singer, the more buried the vocals are going to be.

We are at paragraph #10 and you're asking me whether I think you'll like this album, right? Because I've been unclear so far. My answer is this: I don't know. Maybe I've been avoiding the question. I like Beast Moans a lot, despite its slapdash avant-garde nature. But I can definitely understand why you wouldn't like it. I guess try to consider whether you like one of the three artists, and then go by this list:

1) If you really like Spencer Krug, then you're really going to like Swan Lake (it sounds like Sunset Rubdown at parts!)
2) If you really like Dan Bejar, then you're going to kind of like Swan Lake (sometimes it flourishes, sometimes it feels like it would've been less weird and more fun with Destroyer!)
3) If you really like Carey Mercer, then you're probably not going to like Swan Lake (Swan Lake isn't letting him fly his truest freak flag!)

Then go from there. And if you've never heard of any of these people, then this is probably not a great place to start. How can you guess whether you'll like a supergroup if you don't know the "stars" that comprise it?

If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "The Partisan but He's Got to Know"

Stray Observations
  • Oh yeah, I mentioned that each artist wrote four songs, but there are thirteen total. "Petersburg, Liberty Theater, 1914" doesn't have writing credits (Wikipedia says "The writer is currently unknown"). So who knows? My guess is that they all wrote it together, but didn't want to ruin the narrative of "everyone wrote their own stuff and then the group made the music together."
  • I learned a lot from reading three separate interviews that a blog called Radio Free Canuckistan—read Bejar's, Mercer's, and Krug's. I wish I lived in a world where Puke on Your Birthday had the pull to interview these legends.
  • "All Fires" has the best lyric: "1000 people did what they could / They found a steeple / And tore up the wood. / 500 pieces means 500 float / 1000 people means 500 don't." There's a haunting vividness in its specificity.
  • I know I said that Mercer was the one who buried his vocals, but what the fuck is going on with Bejar's closing track, "Shooting Rockets"? Bejar himself claims that it's buried because the vocal take was awful, but I dunno, the whole thing just seems unnecessary. It's over five minutes of indecipherable music! What a bummer way to end the album!
  • Treble Zine in 2006 claimed: "I would venture to say that Swan Lake is an even better collaborative effort than the New Pornographers." I love Beast Moans, but c'mon, that's preposterous.
  • ("Bejar Swan Lake Song Most Likely to Make Sense As a New Pornos Song" though? 100% "A Venue Called Rubella." Newman could've done some wild shit with that one.)
  • Another quote, this from the aforementioned Krug interview. Krug wonders out loud if the "frat boy Wolf Parade fans" are going to like Beast Moans. Does such a thing exist?!
  • ALBUM COVER: A naked person (male or female, I'm not sure, though females tend to be the protagonists or muses throughout these songs, so let's assume female) plays a guitar(?) on the side of a cliff during sunset(?). The Swan Lake Wikipedia page says that someone named Daniel Murphy created the cover, but every other source I can find says it was artist Shary Boyle who painted it. Anyone know how to edit Wikipedia?
  • ALBUM TITLE: Apparently Krug said the overall aesthetic of Swan Lake's sound was like "a boar dying in a tar pit," and so Mercer came up with the name from that.
  • CHARTS AND AWARDS: No. Puke on Your Birthday didn't exist in 2006 so I can't even say it won any local awards.
  • As much as I like this band, I'll concede that the name "Swan Lake" is fucking awful. Maybe that's just my frustration at ungoogleable terms speaking. (Apparently they were originally called "Thunder Cloud," which is similarly dumb but probably preferable, if I'm being honest.)
  • See you in 2035 for their second and final album, Enemy Mine. It's good too, but in a completely different way—the members made a concerted effort to write the songs together, which makes the songs sound more cohesive, but which also finds them losing some of that manic magic that made 'em so special in the first place.

NEXT TIME: Beat the Champ by the Mountain Goats

No comments: