Thursday, February 6, 2020

PoYB's 3rd Annual Guide to the Oscars, 2020


Welcome back to Puke on Your Birthday's annual Oscar round-up, where we discuss each of the Best Picture nominees, and you get to read my unwarranted and ignorant opinion about each of them. (Check out 2018's HERE and 2019's HERE).

As always, we judge the movies on two criteria:

1) Was this a movie that stayed interesting and enjoyable from start to finish?

2) Was this a movie that gave me something to think about after the end credits rolled? Was it interesting in a way that was new or fresh? Did it stay with me for any measurable amount of time?

In other words, we are here to talk about "what should win" at the Oscars, and not "what will win" at the Oscars. I don't fucking know what will win. If you want to know that, go ask any number of bow-tie-clad starfuckers in Hollywood. PoYB is not that. PoYB is just one lowly guy who torrented a whole bunch of films and watched them in between baby wails.

I took the word "novice" out of the title of this annual blog post this year. In years past, watching the Best Picture nominees constituted the bulk of my critical thinking regarding film, and so this round-up came with the caveat of it being from a guy who ostensibly knew nothing about movies in general. This year... well, I still don't know anything, but I will say that I did spend a considerable amount of time critically thinking about and discussing non-Oscar movies. Whether you think I am successful in that project is certainly up for debate, but there can be no doubt that slipping into "film mode" was a lot easier this year, because I've been doing it every week already.

Anyways, here are the nine films nominated for Best Picture at the 92nd Academy Awards. I'll go through each movie in alphabetical order, and then give a final ranking at the end. I'm sure I'll hear from you in the Facebook comments section.

***SPOILERS, OBVIOUSLY! C'MON!!***


Ford v Ferrari


Directed by: James Mangold

Wikipedia description: A "sports drama film" that follows "a determined team of American engineers and designers with the mission of building the Ford GT40, a new racing car with the potential to finally defeat the perennially dominant Ferrari racing team at the 1966 24 Hours of Le Mans race in France."

You will like it if you like: Very fast cars and very tiny penises; Christian Bale committing himself to an early death by yet again losing a ton of weight for a movie; enjoying the thrill of a sports movie even though you know the ending; saying "holy shit!" when you realize that the one dude is the Reverend Smith from fucking Season 1 of Deadwood.

Is it GREAT: I will be the first to admit that I enjoyed watching this movie, even though my expectations were pretty low. I enjoyed it, because sports movies are meant to be enjoyed. A sports hero (yes, sports car racing is a sport) overcomes seemingly impossible odds to achieve glory in his field of choice. It's a formula that countless movies have followed; it's become a formula because it fucking works.

The moderate-to-high levels of excitement I felt watching this movie were the same exact feelings that I've felt watching actual sports. It's an argument that I've had in the past with sports (especially the Olympics), how I don't think that sports have to have a "narrative" outside of the game itself. I don't need to know where athletes come from, what their life story is, etc. The only thing that matters is: did the team/athlete who I was rooting for ultimately win?

Unfortunately, I take the opposite stance when it comes to movies gunning for a prestigious award. A film cannot just be "who won?" There has to be something more. If my immediate reaction to a movie is "Hmm, that was pretty fun," but then I have nothing to chew on in the hours and days after, then I cannot in good faith say that the movie was GREAT.

I don't think Ford v Ferrari did anything noteworthy outside of selling the stakes of the big race. The heel was some slippery exec who went through all the general steps a villain of his ilk typically performs in these types of movies (though, I will express my appreciation for the fact that the movie didn't really try to make Ford Motor Company itself a particularly strong hero, because then I'd be filling these paragraphs with my usual socialist screeds). There were some interesting things happening around the margins—Shelby swallowing a ton of pills, the kid's PTSD about Miles' brakes giving way—but they left all that to the side. The only female of the film, Caitriona Balfe's Mollie, was basically just a m(ech)anic pixie dream girl.

So while this was way better than it had any right to be, no, I don't think it was "GREAT," or worthy of an Oscar. But it was still a good movie, and still worth a watch.


The Irishman


Directed by: Martin Scorsese

Wikipedia description: An "epic crime film" that follows "a truck driver who becomes a hitman involved with a mobster and his crime family, including his time working for the powerful Teamster Jimmy Hoffa."

You will like it if you like: Not being able to finish a film in one sitting; de-aging technology stolen straight from the uncanny valley of The Polar Express; old mobsters doing their thing one last time; gently tickling Scorsese low-hanging scrotum-shaped ego as you jerk him off.

Is it GREAT: I am only moderately certain that Martin Scorsese read my Wolf of Wall Street interview and decided to challenge me on two points. In one bit, I claimed that Scorsese had a "shtick," and that at this point, releasing three-hour movies with the same shtick is just Scorsese flexing, because he can, and no one is going to stop him. "Oh, is three hours of a morally bankrupt character descending into hell too much for ya?! How about four hours of that shit?!" At a certain point, it becomes overkill, and I really don't understand how Scorsese is continually exempt from any widespread criticism on this point.

Aside from its gratuitous length and desperate lack of creativity, I will say that I found the ending to be interesting, in that Scorsese seems to be challenging my perception of characters like Jordan Belfast. I see these characters—the ones we follow for hours—find absolutely zero redemption after, and show zero remorse for, all the bullshit they get up to. I get it's a story, and that you are watching Frank Sheeran and his tale, and it can be a fun and exciting story, like it is here, and Wolf of Wall Street, and so on. But there has to be a point in the story where anyone—the character, the fucking director, fucking anyone—acknowledges that you can't just do this shit and get away with it. There has to be repercussions.

And the interesting part of The Irishman is that, for once, the main character actually flirts with the idea of regret. Sheeran doesn't quite get there (and that's the cliffhanger, I would argue, whether he actually will ever get to that point), but at least it's clear from Scorsese's standpoint that maybe Sheeran should be repentant of his crimes and misdoings. To me, this is Scorsese acknowledging the sins of his previous heroic poems of this vain. Even though, again, it's only a half-measure—how could someone of Scorsese stature ever admit he was wrong, god forbid—but at least it's something.


Jojo Rabbit


Directed by: Taika Waititi

Wikipedia description: A "comedy-drama film" that follows "a Hitler Youth member who finds out his mother is hiding a Jewish girl in their attic. He must then question his beliefs, while dealing with the intervention of his imaginary friend, a fanciful version of Adolf Hitler."

You will like it if you like: Laughing at and with Hitler; big explosions caused by cute kids; German versions of your favorite pop songs; hating our current dictator and the cult surrounding him and subsequently forcing the metaphor.

Is it GREAT: What a delightful goddamn movie—which is not something I ever thought I'd say about a movie so full of Nazis. The kid actors—Jojo, Elsa, scene-stealing Yorki—were a fucking revelation. Sam Rockwell found more depth in his character than he had any right to. Taika Waititi as Hitler was my favorite character of any Oscar nominated movie this year, and he was playing Hitler! I actually laughed at Rebel Wilson for the first time in my life! Multiple times!

Here is the movie's biggest success: They never once humanized the idea of Nazism. Not once. Yes, Jojo was a self-proclaimed Nazi, but he is told straight to his face that "you are not a Nazi." There's no justification in being a Nazi and a good person, because that's impossible, and the movie would've faltered had they attempted that line of thinking. Rather, it's a call to be self-reflective in your beliefs and your actions, and acknowledging when what you believe and how you feel and what is true just can't square.

I watched this movie the same day that The Inquirer published a story about the cult of trump descending on Wildwood, NJ, sharing beers and finding camaraderie in loving the same despot. Those types of stories always ruin my day, that there are people out there who believe such hateful things, and rally around that hate. Jojo Rabbit was the perfect movie to watch, because of course I saw trumpism in Jojo's beliefs. You know Jojo is not a bad kid, and yet he rallies around the most evil person in history (so far). How does that happen? And how can we look to Elsa for advice on how to address it?

I don't know if that was the point of Jojo Rabbit, or if this was just supposed to be a beautifully hilarious romp through a troubled time in history. But I'll take from this movie what I want, and boy, is there a lot to take.


Joker


Directed by: Todd Phillips

Wikipedia description: A "Joker origin story" that follows "Arthur Fleck, a failed stand-up comedian whose descent into insanity and nihilism inspires a violent counter-cultural revolution against the wealthy in a decaying Gotham City."

You will like it if you like: Attempts to walk in Heath Leger's gigantic clown-shoe footprints; being told that "eat the rich" literally means "murder rich people"; the guy who did The Hangover trying on his best pair of Scorsese big boy pants; "superhero movies" I guess???

Is it GREAT: Here's what I won't say, because I and a bunch of other PoYB contributors already disregarded this allegation—"Joker is irresponsible" or "dangerous" or any other bullshit like that. Yes, the protagonist is a psychopath murderer, but if you think that movies like this are the reason real life white males are murdering innocent civilians with guns, then you can just move on along to a different blog.

I bring that nonsense up, though, because I don't want you to misinterpret the following criticism as having anything to do with that. No, the problem I had with Joker is: 1) I actually agree with the overall sentiment that the clown-hooded masses expressed throughout this movie, in that billionaires have too much power and should be made obsolete, 2) but I vehemently disagree that the way to go about expressing this opinion is to murder people on the subway, in alleyways, and on national television, and 3) I don't think that the movie did a competent enough job in making that distinction clear.

What I'm trying to say is that no one could possibly believe that the Joker should be in any way sympathetic or empathetic, and yet, the movie was pretty clear in its portrayal of the Joker as such. And I'm not even saying that Todd Phillips is seriously making the argument that the audience should sympathize with the Joker. But I'm saying that the movie made that case anyway, which means that Todd Phillips did a shitty job.

Sure, the fact that I'm arguing about Joker in person and on this blog right now does lend credence to the belief that this is "art" and that it's worthy of a nomination. But don't forget—besides making you think, it also has to be good. Joker is not that. I didn't hate it as much as I've hated Oscar-nominated movies in the past, but it is the least deserving movie to be here this year.


Little Women


Directed by: Greta Gerwig

Wikipedia description: A "coming-of-age period drama film," adapted from Louisa May Alcott's 1868 novel.

You will like it if you like: Adaptations of books you've never read; happy endings and not happy endings; the dad from Ladybird finally getting his comeuppance; your own children.

Is it GREAT: Short answer is yes. Long answer breaks it down. It is good because Greta Gerwig is a great filmmaker, and look no farther than how masterfully the film cut between two timelines, not holding your hand but somehow also making it clear every time it happened. It is good because the actresses in this movie are all good and deserve all the statuettes. It is good because it somehow finds fun and humor and excitement in droll 19th century Europe, a time period that usually bores the fuck out of me (at least in cinema).

And it certainly impacted me, though more so than "is it good," this probably requires a "YMMV" qualification. It impacted me because I have two daughters (okay!) and this movie was about (we get it!) the complicated family dynamics as women grow up (relax with the parenting shit!) and I just about died at the happy ending. Add on top of that the fact that the happy ending was probably not actually the ending, and you have a movie that gives you a lot to think about as you cradle a little woman in your arms.


Marriage Story


Directed by: Noah Baumbach

Wikipedia description: A "drama film" that "follows a married couple going through a coast-to-coast divorce."

You will like it if you like: Movies that you probably shouldn't watch with your wife but you do it anyway; dressing up like classic rock artists for Halloween; uncomfortably long monologues that kill; uncomfortably long musical singalongs from Company that kill.

Is it GREAT: Like Little Women, it's good because everyone involved is good, and it's a compelling story, etc., etc. But it's great in almost the opposite way that Little Women is great. Little Women made me feel good, despite the fact that its happiness was insinuated as being fictional. Marriage Story made me feel bad, man. Bad in the way only a good hard look in the mirror can make you feel bad.

I'm certainly not implying that Pam and I are anywhere in the vicinity of even saying the word "divorce," but I'm saying that there are issues in relationships that are universal, but divorce movies like this one take them and make them explicit and right out there in the open. And so, when Adam Driver has to contemplate the myriad of ways in which he has fucked up his marriage, I too contemplate right there with him.

That's another thing that's worth mentioning, I suppose—it was refreshing that, even though it seemed like more than 50% of the movie was from Driver's character's point of view, it felt like less than 50% of the sympathy was being directed toward Driver's character. This might be the main reason why Baumbach is successful in creating this movie as it is—it is ostensibly based on Baumbach's own experiences, but at no point does he ever ask for sympathy for himself (via Driver). Great work.


Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood


Directed by: Quentin Tarantino

Wikipedia description: A "comedy-drama film" that follows "an actor and his stunt double, as they navigate the changing film industry, and features multiple storylines in a 'modern fairy tale tribute to the final moments of Hollywood's golden age.'"

You will like it if you like: directors that have quirks that you can actually stomach (sorry, just can't get past the Scorsese shit still); saving lives through the magic of film; Lena Dunham at her frumpiest; Brad Pitt as your Best Supporting Actor no matter what anyone says; hangout movies that jarringly stop with all the hanging out.

Is it GREAT: This is probably gonna be my favorite movie to discuss as we get closer to the Oscars, mainly because I could see both sides of the central argument. The argument, of course, being about whether the ultraviolence of the movie's climax was successful.

I will argue it was successful. You go in thinking that, like every Tarantino movie, it's going to be a violent affair. Those are your expectations. So credit Tarantino that he was able to lure the audience into a false sense of security at all. But he does, through many tangents and sideplots and comedic bits, all of them enjoyable. Then, in a matter of moments, the movie becomes a horror movie. Like, I was physically taken aback when the shitshow finally began. Good art makes you feel something! Even if the feeling is disgust!

But I thought that's what the whole point was. The rug-pulling, and then the aftertaste of the lingering questions: Are we supposed to be rooting for these guys, our ostensible heroes, who just brutally murdered these young women in the most over-the-top ways possible (smashing a face in, using a blowtorch)? Especially knowing that Brad Pitt's character probably already murdered his wife? Is there justification in the murders because we know here on Earth-1 that those who were murdered were going to do some brutal murdering of their own?

From a certain angle, I can see the argument that maybe this isn't the right time to glorify murder (and indeed, I thought it was distasteful in Joker, so maybe I'm a hypocrite, I dunno). Maybe you think the fantasy of saving Sharron Tate is pointless, especially since not much was made of Tate's character in the actual movie besides being followed around with a big blinking arrow that said "this chick is gonna die!!!!"

Believe it or not, I know someone who watched this movie without knowing who Sharron Tate was or that the creepy hippies portrayed in the movie were supposed to be the Manson family, and she thought the movie was good. So if you strip away everything else, I think at least we can agree on that. Right? That Quentin Tarantino is a good filmmaker? Okay, okay, maybe we can't all agree with that either, but I have never seen a Tarantino flick I didn't like, and the streak doesn't stop here.


Parasite


Directed by: Bong Joon-ho

Wikipedia description: A "dark comedy thriller film" that follows "the members of a poor household who scheme to become employed by a much wealthier family by infiltrating the household and posing as unrelated, highly qualified individuals."

You will like it if you like: morse code; giving yourself way more credit than is deserved for "overcoming the one-inch barrier"; scenes where people sneak around a house unbeknownst to its occupants; drinking rich people's whisky.

Is it GREAT: Who is the "parasite" of the film? The best trick the movie pulls is that you think the answer is obvious at the beginning—it's gotta be the family who pulls a madcap caper to take over a household, right?—but then by the end, you are legitimately starting to question whether the rich family are actually the true parasites.

I'm so glad that I saw this movie after I saw Joker, because a climactic incident that I complained about for that one is present here as well—a have-not becomes fed up with a have-everything, and brutally murders him in front of a lot of people. In Parasite, however, the murder itself is not celebrated, and so the movie gives you the opportunity to start to question the motive. Did Kim Ki-taek have a point?! The dude a is a shitheel, and yet you see him swimming through sewage water and then have to kiss the shoes of rich snobs throwing a garden party the same day, so there's some empathy there, maybe?!

Parasite was subtle in every way that Joker was cartoonishly explicit. Which is really saying something, considering that this is the same movie that involves secret basements, peach-poisoning plots, ghosts tapping out morse code, etc., etc. What an interesting and fun movie! I had no idea what to expect going into it. I'm glad I didn't expect this, because the surprise was fucking delightful.


1917


Directed by: Sam Mendes

Wikipedia description: An "epic war film" that chronicles "the story of two young British soldiers during World War I who are tasked with delivering a message calling off an attack doomed to fail soon after the German retreat to the Hindenburg Line during Operation Alberich in 1917."

You will like it if you like: I dunno, any other of the thousands of war films?; rats in more than one sense of the word; Tommen Baratheon all grown up; one-shot takes (obviously).

Is it GREAT: I'm a big fan of any visual medium with an audacious structure, and you can't get much more audacious than a one-shot, especially when the entire movie is constructed that way. Yes, 1917 fulfills the potential in the idea of following two blokes in almost real time through the trenches of WWI. The explosions and gunfire are forceful, the scope is undeniable, the performances are real (the cameos are only a little distracting), the movie was a literal joyride.

But if I'm being honest with myself—as painful as that often is—and we are sticking by the strict rubric for "is it GREAT?", then I don't know if I can bring myself to say this movie is GREAT. It's so, so good, and so fun, but at the end of the day, that's all it is. It's a war movie, and our heroes achieve their ultimate purpose, winning the very small battle in front of the backdrop of a much larger war. There's nothing to be said other than that.

It's possible that, in the long run, being "GREAT," i.e. having a higher purpose than just being enjoyable, isn't as important as I've made it out to be in this blog post. But this is the Oscars. You're looking for the best movie of the year, right? Shouldn't that be more than fun explosions and muddy tears? Watch 1917 with a big bucket of popcorn, and then forget about it when you watch the big war movie next year.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Final Ranking

9. Joker
8. The Irishman
7. Ford v. Ferrari
6. 1917
5. Marriage Story
4. Parasite
3. Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood
2. Little Women
1. Jojo Rabbit

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

A final word: I know that I said that I wouldn't try to guess "what will win," and would only make an argument for "what should win," but it's worth noting that a pattern has emerged in the last two years of me doing this whole thing. In 2018, The Shape of Water won Best Picture. In 2019, Green Book won Best Picture. In both years, PoYB ranked those movies as #6 in the final rankings of Best Picture Nominations. So if I were a betting man, and were to tell you what I think "will" win, then I'm telling you now that it's 1917. Because it's ranked #6.

Honestly, I'm okay with that. I know I am saying there's a difference between "good" movies and "great" movies, and if we were to draw the line in the sand in that regard, it'd be between #5 Marriage Story and #6 1917. Any of the top five should win this award. The movie-watcher in me that doesn't care about being snooty, however, would be okay with the top seven. Even with Irishman and Joker, I'll just roll my eyes and be slightly disappointed if they win. But there's no movie this year that I'd be pissed about winning (okay, okay, maybe Joker, I dunno.) Which is fucking great! I hate watching bad movies! I love watching good movies! Thank you for the suggestions, 2020 Academy Awards!

No comments: