Thursday, February 21, 2019

A Novice's 2nd Annual Guide to the Oscars, 2019

As we established in last year's inaugural Puke on Your Birthday Oscar Roundup, I don't watch many movies. I watched all nine Oscar Best Picture noms last year, and those nine movies totaled probably 80% of my movie-watching through the entire year. I don't know movies. I cannot place movies in a historical context. All I can do is watch Academy-acclaimed films and judge them with my personal, occasional ignorant opinion.

And so, this year, I (along with my beautiful wife) have again watched every Oscar-nominated film up for Best Picture. And again, I am here to tell you what I think of them. My opinion and overall ranking of these eight movies are based on two criteria:

1) The movie keeps you interested throughout its entire length (i.e. is it GOOD).

2) The movie gives you something to think about or ponder after it is over; it stays with you for reasons either tangible or ineffable, or both (i.e. is it IMPORTANT)

If a movie meets both of these criteria, then I consider it to be a GREAT movie, and worthy of an Academy Award. A movie can be good, and it can be important, but it has to be both for me to be okay with it ultimately winning the Oscar.

These metrics are subjective, so you'll find no pondering here about which movie WILL win. I don't know anything about how the winners are chosen and what advantages certain movies have over others. Last year's ultimate winner, The Shape of Water, was #6 of 9 in my ranking, so clearly I don't know shit.

But it's still fun to talk about the movies that everyone watched, and so I will do that, here, now, in alphabetical order by film title (with a final ranking of the eight movies at the end). Enjoy.

***SPOILERS, OBVIOUSLY!!!!***


Black Panther


Directed by: Ryan Coogler

Wikipedia description: A "superhero film" in which the titular character "is crowned king of Wakanda following his father's death, but his sovereignty is challenged by an adversary who plans to abandon the country's isolationist policies and begin a global revolution."

You will like it if you like: every other superhero movie made in the past fifteen years; Michael B. Jordan's abs; superheroes who don't turn to dust at the end of the movie; seeing a panther on every first grader's backpack in North Philly

Is it GREAT: I will mostly be saying the same thing that I said about Get Out last year, except for the fact that I'm more optimistic about Black Panther as a movie. This was an important film, no doubt about it. When superhero movies rake in billions and billions of dollars annually, it's nice to have a black-acted and -directed movie out-earn them all. And it's awesome that some little kids finally have a superhero they can cheer for and say "he looks like me!" Based on the importance of the film alone, I'm okay with the fact that it is nominated for Best Picture.

But is it any good?! My answer to the question is: "...sure." Look, I'm in that cynical camp that believes that every MCU movie is the same fucking thing, so the fact that Black Panther was even marginally different than the rest of those films is an achievement. But at the end of the day, it wasn't that different. So I enjoyed it, sure. It was fun watching Black Panther. But I'm not going to say it reinvented the wheel or anything.


BlacKkKlansman


Directed by: Spike Lee

Wikipedia description: A "biographical crime comedy-drama film" following "the first African-American detective in the city's police department as he sets out to infiltrate and expose the local chapter of the Ku Klux Klan."

You will like it if you like: racists getting made fools of; Adam Driver doing his whole Adam Driver thing; the doctor from New Amsterdam dropping N-bombs; being legitimately unsure whether you should laugh or be horrified

Is it GREAT: BlacKkKlansman takes a pretty good premise and stretches it as far as it can, Did it stretch credulity at certain points? Sure. But maybe everything I felt was a little off (e.g. not being able to tell the difference between John David Washington's and Adam Driver's voices? e.g. the evil villains conveniently dying in a car bomb explosion of their own making?), maybe all that really was how it was. Maybe racists really ARE that stupid, ya know? As scary as the movie was at points (scary in a "that's how it really was?!" sort of way), BlacKkKlansman also mined a lot of humor from its premise.

And yeah, the movie seemed like it was going to end a little lamely. It seemed like the story just kind of... ended. It was based on a true story, and that's how true stories go sometimes. But then! Then the movie absolutely gives the biggest gut punch imaginable. After laughing at the exploits of the police and the KKK members, the movie pulls the rug out from under you so fast that it's giving me chills just writing about it now. What was a good, if modest, movie becomes absolutely essential in its final frames. Everything you just laughed at? It's happening RIGHT NOW. And it's not fucking funny.


Bohemian Rhapsody


Directed by: Bryan Singer (FUCK THIS GUY)

Wikipedia description: A music biopic that tells the story of "[Queen] singer Freddie Mercury's life from when he joins the band in 1970 to their 1985 Live Aid performance at the former Wembley Stadium in London."

You will like it if you like: false teeth; not thinking about AIDS too much; music biopics even after you've seen Walk Hard; uh, the music of Queen I guess

Is it GREAT: Let's start with some positives. I will at least moderately enjoy any movie about music, no matter what it is about specifically. I do not like Queen's music, but I sincerely enjoyed learning about the story of Queen (even though the veracity of the story as presented here has been questioned, but I'll save that whole discussion for Green Book). And I thought that Rami Malek put on a fascinating performance, even though it was pretty much all camp and probably does not deserve an Acting Oscar.

But I thought Bohemian Rhapsody was otherwise a shitty, shitty movie. Seriously, fuck this movie. It was generic and clichéd. It was every biopic ever made, with lame music to boot. You know the movie trope where band members are arguing and there is a commotion, but then someone is heard playing something cool in the background, and the commotion stops, and everyone is wide-eyed at how good that sounds, and then the movie smash-cuts to the band playing that same riff in concert, to the applause of thousands? Yeah, that trope was done at least THREE TIMES in this movie.

It was pathetic. It made me hate Queen even more. All this not even mentioning that the director is a rapist. Fuck this shit. It's not only the worst movie of the eight noms, it's the worst movie I've seen in at least the past five years.


The Favourite


Directed by: Yorgos Lanthimos

Wikipedia description: A "historical period drama film" that "examines the relationship between two cousins vying to be court [favorites] of Queen Anne."

You will like it if you like: getting your thighs rubbed; when two separate sides of English Parliament old white men yell at each other across the aisle; rabbits as a metaphor; sneaky Emma Stone

Is it GREAT: I went into The Favourite with the lowest expectations, because I'm so fucking tired of period pieces. So I'm not sure if I enjoyed it so much because it was actually a good movie, or just because it so exceeded my expectations. All the political backstabbing and subterfuge was pretty fascinating, especially in against the backdrop of secret LGBTQ affairs in medieval England. The three female leads did a great job of amping up the drama throughout. And that final scene absolutely gave me enough to chew on. I'd say that I enjoyed the movie enough and have thought about the movie enough since I've seen it that I can definitively call it GREAT.


Green Book


Directed by: Peter Farrelly (with cum in his hair)

Wikipedia description: A "biographical comedy-drama film" inspired by the alleged story of "a tour of the Deep South by African-American classical and jazz pianist Don Shirley and Tony Vallelonga, an Italian-American bouncer who served as Shirley's driver and bodyguard."

You will like it if you like: eating fried chicken without a napkin; Carmine Lupertazzi, in his youth, beating the shit out of everyone; your racism stories fed to you like warm milk; white people clapping to classical music and black people clapping to the blues

Is it GREAT: There's a whole controversy about Green Book, because there always is about at least one Oscar nominee. The controversy is that Don Shirley's family has come out and said that the whole movie is bullshit, that Shirley never even had a friendly relationship with Tony Vallelonga, that the "True Story" aspect of Green Book is an absolute lie. I don't doubt that, but I dunno man, that whole thing doesn't really perturb me. It's not really any of concern whether a movie is truth or fiction. It's not like my opinion of Black Panther was affected by the fact that Wakanda PROBABLY doesn't exist.

No, what concerns me is that weird, uncomfortable feeling I had at the end of the movie. I enjoyed it while I was watching it, for sure, but I also felt a little uneasy too. Setting out to find out why that is, I did some research into some other controversies for this movie. There's the idea of the "Magical Negro," that Shirley's character exists solely to help the white characters. I agree that this might be part of the problem, but I think too that the movie takes a clear effort to make it so that the two men are helping each other (Tony accepts others, Don accepts himself).

I think what bugged me the most specifically was the final scene on Christmas, when Shirley shows up at Vallelonga's family dinner, and after a brief pause, a hitherto racist as fuck family members yells "fix him a plate!" As if Don Shirley's mere presence solves racism. I'm certainly not saying that I don't wish racism could be solved by such a simple gesture. I'm saying that the scene is unsubtle and unearned. And I think that the final scene is only one example of this issue. The Root described it as "palatable racism for white people," and I tend to agree with that.

I don't think there's anything wrong with a feel-good movie, one that shows the good in people, and condemns the bad in people. That is Green Book. It also unfortunately means that Green Book is light and fluffy and irrelevant. I liked watching it, but I don't like thinking about it too much, and I feel dirty watching it, like I'm enjoying it even though I shouldn't.


Roma


Directed by: Alfonso Cuarón

Wikipedia description: A "semi-autobiographical take" following "the life of a live-in housekeeper of a middle-class family."

You will like it if you like: cleaning up dog shit; a camera that pans slowly from right to left; not having to spend an hour trying to bootleg an illegal movie stream like every other goddamn movie on this list

Is it GREAT: Hooooooly shit. Maybe this is recency bias, because we watched this movie last (and only about twelve hours ago as of this writing), but again: holy shit. Roma was a masterpiece. Should I count the ways?

How about that this was a black-and-white movie with subtitles, and I didn't even notice either of these challenges by the time we were thirty minutes in. How about that this was probably the first movie I've ever seen that I thought "wow, the direction is really good," with Cuarón constantly panning the camera to take in the entire scene. How about every scene, how every fucking scene was absolutely overflowing with life and activity; it was a masterclass in world-building; it was a slice-of-life drama, but every slice was very, very hearty.

How about having to watch the extended, excruciating birth scene while my daughter sleeps soundly on the smaller screen below the TV. How about almost crying then. How about almost crying again after the ocean rescue scene. How about almost crying yet again as I'm typing this.

It doesn't happen often, but every once in a while I watch a movie that so wrings me out emotionally that I can't do anything but stare at the credits in shock. Roma was that movie this year. So, yeah, to answer your question, it was great.


A Star Is Born


Directed by: Bradley Cooper

Wikipedia description: A "musical romantic drama" featuring "a hard-drinking musician who discovers and falls in love with a young singer."

You will like it if you like: Gaga doing her thing; picturing Jack White doing Bradley Cooper's thing; remakes of remakes of remakes of movies; impromptu weddings organized by Dave Chappelle

Is it GREAT: Yeah man, it was great. There is probably a reason this is the fourth time someone made the same movie. The plot moves, Gaga and Cooper are phenomenal, and the songs are mostly pretty great. I don't have anything bad to say about the movie, except, ya know, damn this movie for making me choke up a bit at the end and whatnot.

It gave me a lot to think about too. What I took away from it is probably the least important aspect of the film in general, but it most interests me personally, and that is the discussion of "what is 'real' music?" Jackson and Ally argue about Ally's burgeoning music career in the pop industry, and Jackson (drunkenly) argues that Ally is "selling out" to sing SNL-style butt-popping music. Whether Jackson Maine is correct in his assessment could power more than a few think pieces (I think he is wrong and I don't think the movie is making the argument that he's right either).

But you could ask one hundred people, and you'd get one hundred answers about why A Star Is Born is a special movie. There's the mental health aspect (and the foreshadowing throughout the movie of Maine's demise), there are lessons about romance in the face of domestic violence, there's the meta-narrative of Lady Gaga herself doing her own thing throughout her career and winning over everyone with a world-conquering performance, just like her character does in the movie. It's everything, and it is great.


Vice


Directed by: Adam McKay

Wikipedia description: A "biographical comedy-drama" about "[Dick] Cheney on his path to become the most powerful Vice President in American history."

You will like it if you like: stroking your liberal ego with some good ol' confirmation bias; "witty" political commentary from the man who brought you Step Brothers; smash cuts to loud noises of bombs; Christian Bale not caring that he will die young if it means just one more Oscar nod

Is it GREAT: There's a bit at the beginning of this movie in which the narrator says something like: "Americans are working harder than ever for less pay, so the last thing they want to do in their free time is to talk about politics." The movie's point was that villainous politicians like Dick Cheney use Americans' apathetic nature to take advantage of them without their knowing. But I saw it as a self-indictment—you're right, Vice, I don't want to think about you in my spare time.

What's worse is that the movie took something that was actually boring, and tried to spice it up in the clunkiest, most cringe-worthy ways imaginable. So not only to I have to get beat over the head with the fact that our country is fucked, but now I have to learn about HOW fucked we are while withstanding sophomoric Ferrell-esque humor. It's fucking embarrassing.

Yes, it was enlightening at times, but it was enlightening in the same way The Passion of Christ was enlightening—we know how this story goes, and we know that it ends in death.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

FINAL RANKING

1. Roma
2. A Star Is Born
3. The Favourite
4. BlacKkKlansman
5. Black Panther
6. Green Book
7. Vice
8. Bohemian Rhapsody

1 comment:

Sam Fran said...

Just watched Vice last night. So here are my retroactive rankings. I think you and I have a similar tier structure but differ on the placements within the tiers. Glad that the best actor and best picture came from my lease favo(u)rite films. Interesting that the best actress and supporting actress came from my most favo(u)rite

1. The Favourite
2. A Star is Born
3. Roma
4. Black Panther
5. Blackkklansman
6. Vice
7. Green Book
8. Bohemian Rhapsody