Way out front, you know I ain't frontin', hittin' home runs, I ain't about buntin'.
Monday, February 11, 2019
FUCK THE GRAMMYS (but not for the reason you think)
I guess Puke on Your Birthday is a music blog now (even though I still spend one or two days a week prattling on about times I got drunk in the woods or whatever), but I've never written anything here about the Grammys, the so-called "biggest night in music."
I've never felt the need to write about it, because you, the reader, probably think you already know my take. You read my music reviews and my yearly rankings. You know that my favorite music and the music honored at the award show are vastly dissimilar. What do I have to gain from watching fucking Post Malone perform with the fucking Red Hot Chili Peppers? What could I possibly add to the conversation about Best New Artist Dua Lipa, an artist whom I've never listened to for more than three seconds (before she made eye sex with St. Vincent)?
And that would be a lukewarm take, the whole "I hate this music, so I hate the Grammys" mindset. On one hand, I get it. It's tough to love music so much but then be told by the Powers That Be that, no, the music you like sucks, and it sucks so bad we won't even acknowledge most of it, and instead of even nominating the music you love, we're gonna give fucking Post Malone center stage.
In other words, it would be one thing to give out Grammys to artists who are purely popular. If it doesn't matter what the critics say, and Post Malone is going to be nominated for Album of the Year based solely on his popularity (Beerbongs & Bentleys, completely unlistenable trash, is currently triple-platinum), then that would be absolutely understandable. At least we would understand that the Grammys honor music which the majority of people enjoy. I could disregard the Grammys as a populist thing, and move on.
But that's not how the Grammys operate, because they also occasionally award music that was not, by reasonable metrics, necessarily "popular" with the general public. Instead, it was loved by critics (count PoYB as a "critic," no matter what you feel about my sometimes terrible critical takes), and then wins an award.
Look at Kasey Musgraves last night, winning the highest honor for her pretty great album Golden Hour. This album didn't show up too much on PoYB's 2018 Year in Review, but I like the album a lot all the same, and enjoy it every time Pam puts it on in the car. And according to most aggregates, it was in the Top Three overall as far as critical reception in 2018 goes. But if you ask my sister Jenny, who regularly plays Beerbongs & Bentleys at parties, do you think she's going to know who fucking Kasey Musgraves is? Absolutely not. She spent weeks on the album charts, and she'll definitely get a boost after last night's win, but she is by no means "popular" in the same way we would call Post Malone "popular." And yet she won the biggest Grammy last night.
So my problem is NOT that the Grammys never honor the music I listen to, because that's not even true sometimes. My problem is that the Grammys are not consistent with how they award and honor music. They are stuck trying to please both the populists and the critics, and by doing both, no one wins.
I think this is a problem unique to music, if you consider the three other major award shows.
The Tonys honor art on the stage, both dramas and musicals. However, only a minute portion of the U.S. population regularly attends the theater, and so these awards are purely catered toward these people, the industry and its very small audience. There's no need or desire to bow down to what is "popular" because "popular theater" doesn't even exist. I'm not saying there aren't shows that deserve awards—those handful of times I've witnessed professional theater in person, I'm consistently blown away—but I'm saying that no one, NO ONE, is watching the Tonys and saying "but these nominees aren't my theater." There are people who know theater, and there are the many, many more people who don't know theater, and the award show caters to the former group, and that's it.
With the Emmys, I'd argue they have a much easier job at caterer to both the critical crowd and the populist crowd, because much more with TV than with any other medium, what's critically acclaimed and what's popular very often are the same exact thing. That's not always the case. Fucking Sheldon has won FOUR EMMYS in that role (popular but critically loathed), while Community was completed snubbed for six years (critically acclaimed but not very popular). But very often, the shows nominated for awards are at least generally well-liked by critics and generally watched by a lot of people. Think about all the awards that Breaking Bad won, while being very good and pretty popular. Think about all the awards that Game of Thrones has won, while being pretty good and very popular. If many TV shows already exist as popular and critically acclaimed programs, then the award shows that honor TV can give those TV shows the awards, and no one will feel left out.
Only movies come close to having the same dilemma as music does, in that there is a large gap between what is popular and what is critically acclaimed. In 2018, the nine movies nominated for Best Oscar pulled in an average of $63 million at the box office (pre-nomination). None of those films were in the Top Ten Highest Grossing Films of that year. The highest grossing film (Star Wars Whatever Whatever) pulled in $620 million domestic, almost TEN TIMES the Oscar average. It's fair to say that what is "popular" and what is "acclaimed" is vastly different when it comes to movies.
But the difference with the Oscars is that they make no pretense at ever catering toward what is popular. With the Academy Awards, they cater toward critical opinion, and eschew popular opinion (if how the population spends their money indicates popularity, anyway). If your favorite movie of 2017 was Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle, then the Oscars were probably pretty boring for you. If that were the case, then you would have every right to claim "I think the Oscars are stupid because they don't reflect what I watch." Which is true! They wouldn't!
In fact, the Academy just months ago announced and then immediately retracted the announcement that there would be a new "Best Popular Movie" category. The backlash was immediate, because those who give a fuck about the Oscars don't give a fuck about popular movies. A "Best Popular Movie" category would defeat the whole purpose of the Oscars, because the Oscars do not honor movies simply because they are popular, and they have a record and a history of proving that.
In other words, a "Best Popular Movie" category would have made the ceremony more like the Grammys. And no one wanted that, surely.
The Oscars are consistent, and the Grammys are not. One year, Arcade Fire will win best album, and that album will be pretty good. But what does that award really mean if it was awarded just three years after Herbie fucking Hancock won the same award? If the National were the #1 album on PoYB and the #1 Alternative Music Album at the Grammys, the same award that fucking Coldplay has won TWICE, then what does that say about the National? And about Puke on Your Birthday? And about the Grammys themselves? If Led Zeppelin can win the award for Best Rock Album in fucking 2014, should we care that the War on Drugs won in 2017? If Led Zeppelin was never even nominated for the Best Album award, then should we truly give a fuck if fucking motherfucker Post fucking Malone gets nominated, for some fucking reason?!
No. Ultimately, we should not care about any of this. It's not that I don't care because "my music isn't honored," because sometimes it is. And that's part of the problem. Sometimes my music is "deserving of an award," and sometimes it is completely ignored in service of clearly inferior garbage. When there's inconsistencies like this, when the Grammys try to cater to both crowds, it's THEN that I don't care. The Grammys becomes worthless. Fuck the Grammys.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment