Wednesday, February 20, 2019

The Albums That Matter: Torches

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE. Obviously, Torches does not fall in line alphabetically, but as previously explained, I'm also using this column to talk about the best albums of the 2010s. This is the first album I am discussing. Come back in December to find out where it falls in the rankings.


Torches
Foster the People
2011

I have a working theory that there are exactly three ways to listen to music, and for a while I was planning on writing a whole separate blog post to explain this dumb theory. The theory even has a name, called the "Three K*** Siblings Music Theory," because the "three ways to listen to music" are personified exactly by my and my two sisters' listening habits.

My sister Jenny was mentioned the other day as being a big Post Malone fan. She represents that faction of the music-listening population who doesn't really give the whole idea of being a "fan of music" the time of day. The radio tells her what is good, and so she listens to that. Call it "Mainstream Top 40" if you want. "Music" as an idea is background noise, not an art. Jenny represents the majority of America.

My sister Brianna (who wrote a review last week) takes music a little more seriously (I should say now that I'm not indicating that any of these three ways to listen to music is necessarily better than the others, just that, ya know, people listen to music differently as a fact). "Seriously" in that she chooses who to listen to instead of making the radio gatekeepers her sole musical curators. This is a choice I personally make as well. However, Brianna's goal in curating her own music is to achieve oneness with fellow human beings, i.e. in concert. Let's call it "festival indie," even if Urban Dictionary refuses to do so. The bands and artists Brianna and her crew listen to connect to their audiences through music festivals and concerts. Music is, in a sense, a means to forge bonds with other humans. Firefly and Bonnaroo are times to experience something together, ya feel me? Brianna is literally and figuratively the girl who walks around the festival grounds with a sign that says "If you're lost, come dance with us" in psychedelic font.

And I, the elder brother, represent the musical hermits, those for whom music is a life and death pursuit to be enjoyed between two ears only. I spend my days trolling music websites and trying out new music and thoughtfully considering whether I should add this particular music to my "collection," i.e. my iPod (having an unexciting job helps in this endeavor). The music itself is considered the prize, as opposed to a means to an end. Any communication between fellow music listeners (e.g. PoYB Record Club) is akin to passing notes between jail cells. Sure, I go to concerts very very occasionally, but I tend more to get annoyed with the fact that I have to share this experience with the rest of the crowd than anything else. When I went to see the Hold Steady last summer, for instance, and some random fucking dude, drunk and euphoric, grabbed the scruff of my neck when the band hit those opening notes of "Chips Ahoy," I did not consider him my brother in arms. Instead, I told him to not touch me again or I'd punch him in his goddamn face. I love music more than any other nonhuman thing in this world, but I'm a fucking miser when it comes to sharing that love.

Okay, so I'm four IPAs deep, now let me explain why I buried the lede so fucking badly. Torches by Foster the People is THE album of the 2010s that hits all three K*** siblings' sensibilities when it comes to music. It is an album that we can all share. This is not the sole reason that makes Torches special, but it's the most important reason.

Torches, in a sense, exposes my "Three K***s Music Theory" as just a means of describing the different types of gatekeepers that provide different music to people with different music needs (or lack thereof). Torches was loved by everyone—the radio listeners, the concert goers, the musicophile recluses. There is a very basic reason for this. The reason is that Torches is a simple, catchy album that couldn't be ignored. The term "earworm" was thrown around a lot when the LP was released, and it's the best description I can think of now. Every song on the album—every fucking song—has the capability to burrow itself in your brain and stick with you for the rest of the day.

Yes, that is true for the most popular Foster the People song, "Pumped Up Kicks." I would do a poor job of trying to dissect "Pump Up Kicks" if I tried, but y'all know there was something "earwormy" about this song from the get-go. Every radio station played it (104.5 might as well have been renamed "The Pumped Up Kicks Station, Presented by The Most Annoying Radio Personalities You'll Ever Hear"). Kids at the Laf, kids with whom the only other thing I had in common with was the amount of Milwaukee's Best we drank each weekend, were singing this song under their breath as they busted tables. "Pumped Up Kicks" reached #3 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart, which is fucking insane for a ramshackle indie rock ditty.

But what's kind of more insane is that "Pumped Up Kicks" isn't even close to being the catchiest song on the album. The most insane part of this whole thing is that every single song is catchy. There isn't a bad song in the bunch, and I'm not fucking exaggerating. Go ahead, name the worst song. It's fucking impossible. Also, go ahead and name other albums that don't have a less-than-great song on them. That's a pretty difficult task as well. Every Apologies to the Queen Mary has a "Dinner Bells." Every Cardinal has a "Waveform." Torches doesn't have that song. They are all really good. They could all be a successful single.

Like, if I wanted to, I could go through every song and tell you the moment that makes that song great. Let's start—"Waste" has a falsetto call-and-response chorus structure that tickles me. Let's continue—"I Would Do Anything for You" is a pseudo-disco track that somehow uses an "ooh la la" as the foundation of its chorus without being corny. Let's continue—"Houdini" has a towering, pounding drum beat over skittering synth sounds, and even though those two sounds don't sound like they would work together, they really fucking do. Let's end—because these are only the songs that I was listening to while writing this paragraph. I could seriously do it all day.

As I start moving forward through the best albums of the decade—and make no mistake, Torches is unmistakably one of the best albums of the 2010s—there will probably be a lot of sloppy tipsy assessments of albums I love. This is one of them (both one of the albums, and one of the sloppy tipsy assessments). But I don't know if there will be another album on that eventual list that warrants a spot on the list due to catchiness alone. And I don't know if there will be another album that reaches across the musical divide as effortlessly as Torches does. It's an album that all siblings can appreciate.

~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Call It What You Want"



~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • I don't know if this was common knowledge or what, but Foster the People is basically the musical project of a guy named Mark Foster. Foster bounced around LA for a while, writing commercial jingles. "Pumped Up Kicks" started as one of those jingles. Luckily, it ended up as an actual song, and not like a fucking Honda ad or some bullshit.
  • The gap between "Pumped Up Kicks" being released as a single, and Torches being released as an album, was sizable, apparently due to fears from the record company that audiences would start to dislike the band due to "over-exposure." Based on how many times I heard "Pumped Up Kicks" in 2011, I'd say that this attempt was a failure. Luckily the album's strengths ultimately saved it.
  • I mentioned above that "Pumped Up Kicks" peaked at #3 on the Billboard charts. In case you were wondering, it was blocked from the top spot by "Party Rock Anthem" by LMFAO at #2, and fucking "Moves like Jagger" at #1. The Billboard Hot 100 is very often a fucking travesty, and this is no exception.
  • And since I guess I'm going to talk about Grammys more now that I bullshitted about them a couple weeks ago, let's talk Torches at the 2012 Grammys. It was up for Best Alternative Album, but eventually lost to Bon Iver, Bon Iver. I won't comment on these results here, as I don't want to risk spoiling PoYB's eventual Best of the 2010s list.
  • And at those same Grammys, "Pumped Up Kicks" lost Best Pop Duo/Group Performance to a Tony Bennett / dead Amy Winehouse collaboration. As much as I love Winehouse, that award seems pretty egregious to me.
  • ALBUM COVER: The artwork was created by Young & Sick, an LA art/music collective. If you are looking for an album cover that absolutely fucking screams early-'10s 104.5 festival band bullshit, you found it here.
  • Originally the "Three K***s Music Theory" was the "Five K***s Music Theory," and included my parents. But I couldn't articulate the way that Jenny, Dad, and Mom were different; they all took their cues from the radio, and the only difference was the specific radio station that they took those cues from (Q102, 88.5 XPN, and a mix of XTU, B101, and WMGK, respectively).

NEXT TIME: Band on the Run by Paul McCartney and Wings

No comments: