Haim Without the Heart
My wife Hannah and I were visiting Chicago one summer and realized the music festival Lollapalooza was happening while we were in town. We had previously attended the festival, so we bought one-day passes on a whim and went with our friend Lamson.
Unlike the previous times I had gone to Lolla, I didn't do any research and kind of wandered around all day. The three of us had fun, but the experience was more meandering than focused. (Are Silversun Pickups still good? No. Can Vince Staples captivate an audience? Sorta.) As a result, my enjoyment of the acts was tepid.
That is, until, we saw Haim—the only band that both Hannah and I wanted to see (I couldn't trick her into nerdy dancing to LCD Soundsystem over some pop star I had never heard of). Anyway, we were pumped, and the Haim sisters had a great set.
Lamson had never heard of Haim, but unlike our previous run-ins with new bands, he really dug their set. Yes, he partly liked them due to Este Haim's bass face. But, overall, he immediately got into their sound and could follow the flow of the concert despite having no background whatsoever with the band.
I mention all that by way of explaining what I don't like about Maggie Rogers. Could Lamson (or since this is my opinion, me?) have walked past Rogers at Lolla and be into it?
Rogers appears to have all the same elements of Haim: some catchy choruses, solid group vocals, and nods to Prince. But she lacks the fun or heart I get from Haim. Rogers sounds like a hit seeker; it's all a little to sleek for me. The production strips out mistakes and in turn removes a bit of soul.
Only in the basic piano dirge "Past Life" do I really feel like I am hearing Rogers. Is it coincidence that this is the only song she produced alone without other producers?
All in all, if I stumbled on Maggie Rogers at a festival stage, I probably would listen to a few songs and keep on walking.
Unlike the previous times I had gone to Lolla, I didn't do any research and kind of wandered around all day. The three of us had fun, but the experience was more meandering than focused. (Are Silversun Pickups still good? No. Can Vince Staples captivate an audience? Sorta.) As a result, my enjoyment of the acts was tepid.
That is, until, we saw Haim—the only band that both Hannah and I wanted to see (I couldn't trick her into nerdy dancing to LCD Soundsystem over some pop star I had never heard of). Anyway, we were pumped, and the Haim sisters had a great set.
Lamson had never heard of Haim, but unlike our previous run-ins with new bands, he really dug their set. Yes, he partly liked them due to Este Haim's bass face. But, overall, he immediately got into their sound and could follow the flow of the concert despite having no background whatsoever with the band.
I mention all that by way of explaining what I don't like about Maggie Rogers. Could Lamson (or since this is my opinion, me?) have walked past Rogers at Lolla and be into it?
Rogers appears to have all the same elements of Haim: some catchy choruses, solid group vocals, and nods to Prince. But she lacks the fun or heart I get from Haim. Rogers sounds like a hit seeker; it's all a little to sleek for me. The production strips out mistakes and in turn removes a bit of soul.
Only in the basic piano dirge "Past Life" do I really feel like I am hearing Rogers. Is it coincidence that this is the only song she produced alone without other producers?
All in all, if I stumbled on Maggie Rogers at a festival stage, I probably would listen to a few songs and keep on walking.

No comments:
Post a Comment