Thursday, February 14, 2019

Thirsty Thursday: CHEERS TO THE GUV'NAH (redux)


I've written about Cheers to the Guv'nah before, almost nine years ago, and it remains one of my favorite drinking games to this day. Sit in a circle, count to thirteen, then slowly start replacing numbers with increasingly convoluted rules, and keep going around the circle until everyone remembers every rule at the same time. It works equally as a team-building exercise and an excuse to get drunk. And it's really fun when played correctly!

But I've noticed in recent editions of this game that I've become a bit of an... asshole while playing it. I don't know if I've always acted this way, or that my actions have prominent in recent months, but there seems recently to always be one or two people who become really annoyed at the way that I play Cheers to the Guv'nah. It's manifested in two ways.

Primarily, I've become really strict about the act of helping other players out when they forget a rule, or don't complete the rule exactly as it was intended. In my opinion, the integrity of the game is compromised when you help people out or give them hints. The point of the game is that we all learn the rules through drunken trial and error. If someone doesn't learn the rule, but skimps by because someone just told them the answer, then they don't learn, and are more prone to keep misremembering the rule, and the game actually takes longer. 

And you know me (especially drunk me), and so you know that I'm not necessarily gentle when it comes to calling people out on their "cheating." I don't think my friends take kindly to the fact that I'm yelling "you fucked up!!!!" at them, even if the purpose of my yelling is to protect the game itself. I'm probably taking Cheers way too seriously, true, but at the same time, it's like, why are you even playing if you're not going to play it right?!

The second thing I've been doing during Cheers that usually causes massive eye rolls is that I've become obsessed with creating unnecessarily complicated rules when it's my turn to choose. A game of Cheers to the Guv'nah is boring as shit to me if "One" is just replaced with another word, "Two" is simply replaced with a noise, and "Three" is replaced solely by a hand motion. I don't think it's particularly fun or scintillating or worth it if round after round starts with "Butts," "Woo!" and three claps. It's too easy. Even "Name a [category], no repeats"-type rules are starting to bore me.

I want rules to be even more complicated than that. I want them to refer back to other rules, adding layers to what you have to remember. Last weekend, one of the rules I created was "Instead of 11, name a U.S. city that starts with the last letter as the car that was named for number 3 of this round." Another was "Instead of 12, take as guess as to whether the animal in number four is native in the state named in number 7." In the past, I've done shit like "instead of 9, point to someone, who either points to someone else or becomes 9 themselves, etc." and all kinds of nonsense.

I think this adds a fun extra challenge to the game. However, inevitably, when I make these types of rules, I'm met with a host of complaints, and accusations that I'm "too much." Which, like the first issue, I kind of get. I am too much sometimes, just like I'm too brash and too quick to confrontation.

So if I keep running into resistance with how I play a simple silly fucking drinking game, it begs the question... what's the problem here? Is Cheers to the Guv'nah flawed? Or am I in the wrong? Like Principal Skinner in that one meme—No, it's the game who is wrong.

The problem with Cheers to the Guv'nah, in general, is that the stakes are too low. There's no winner or loser, so people don't feel responsible to follow the rules. In competitive games, your opponent will call you out if you cheat, because it effects their own chances of winning. In Cheers, there is no opponent, so people feel affronted when a supposed ally is calling them out on their cheating anyway.

But then if you consider the rules themselves as the opponent, then people are equally mad when you embolden your so-called opponent in the act of making the rules extra-complicated. When I'm create an arduous rule, I'm not just placing a handicap on myself, I'm handicapping everyone, some of whom don't necessarily wish to be handicapped (figuratively) any more than the inebriation already makes them. And this is an affront to friends as well.

The problem, ultimately, is that I am a very competitive person, even if that means competing with myself, even if that means challenging myself at the expense of others. I don't like playing drinking games that I find unchallenging, and things like helping other players and making simple rules turn Cheers to the Guv'nah into a less challenging endeavor.

I acknowledge the fact that being this type of person (and likewise blogging about being this type of person) also makes me a huge asshole. I get that. It's a character flaw that I continuously try to work on in other aspects of my life (and mostly fail, but I'm trying). 

But when it comes to already dumb and pointless drinking games played with friends, I refuse to change. If the point of drinking games is to kill time and to have fun, then being a competitive asshole is the only way I know how to do it, even if I'm playing a drinking a game in which no competition is required.

If you find yourself in the same position as I am, and would rather play "Cheers to the Guv'nah on Steroids" instead of slogging through the same simple rules, hit me up. There's a better way to play. Let's get together and play a supersized version of Cheers. We'll count to fifty. We'll hold the cheaters accountable until no one cheats at all. We'll make the rules insanely byzantine and knotty. We'll drink a lot. We'll challenge each other, and ourselves. We'll actually feel accomplished when we complete the game.

In the meantime, I suppose next time I play Cheers to the Guv'nah, I'll try to do better in striking that balance between having fun and making sure others have fun, even if that means going against every instinct I have. I think it would be nice walking away from a drinking game for once without someone considering me to be a piece of shit.

No comments: