Way out front, you know I ain't frontin', hittin' home runs, I ain't about buntin'.
Friday, February 8, 2019
Heard It in a Past Life, Joe
When I listen to Heard It in a Past Life, I hear potential. This isn't a complaint—I think there's a lot to like on this album, but it definitely sounds like a first album of a new artist. From what I hear on LP1, Maggie Rogers has a lot to offer, but I think in future releases, as she becomes more comfortable with who she is and what she wants to sound like, she'll start flourishing.
For now, you can probably take the title Heard It in a Past Life literally, because you'll hear a lot of influences from some of the modern female indie rock landscape of the recent past. For example, "Give a Little," Rogers' call for empathy, features a chorus ripped right out of Haim's playbook. Another example is "Burning," in which I hear elements of Carly Rae Jepsen's indie twee. Now, I love Haim and Carly Rae Jepsen, so I don't necessarily think that this is a bad thing. And I don't even think that the song comes off as a "watered down version of Haim / Jepsen" or anything like that. They are strong songs. It's just not anything unique.
"Alaska" carries the most baggage on this album, what with its unwitting viral benefactor, but hearing it here with fresh ears (I had never heard of Maggie Rogers, let alone knew how she became known in general, before hearing this song), there's a reason Pharrell's ears perked up when this song reached him—it's probably the best song on the album. It's got a minimal groove that sincerely invokes visions of harsh winter solitude, and that bridge to the chorus just hooks me every time.
If we're talking most uplifting moment, that would probably be "Light On"'s chorus, a soaring, towering chorus that speaks to the power of unity while the synths swirl around and the '80s-style drums boom and crack. If you want to hear that potential I was talking about earlier, imagine a whole album full of these types of choruses. (And if you really want to get walloped by this chorus, take a gander at this stunning live rendition of the song.)
But for every uplifting moment, there's an equal amount of comedowns, and unfortunately they are mostly forgettable. Like: the almost-title track "Past Life" is a snoozefest piano ballad. Like: Rostam continuing his post-Vampire Weekend 0-fer with the trite "Fallingwater."
The songs that don't reach those heights are really disappointing, because you know from other songs that Maggie Rogers CAN reach those heights. When you hear her do some soaring almost-R&B stylings over an LCD Soundsystem-esque piano loop on "On + Off," it's fucking thrilling, but then it's like, why can't she do this all the time?! I want her casual use of the word "fuck" on "Retrograde" to be in every fucking song, ya feel me???
Overall, despite it's notable failings, there's absolutely enough here to keep me interested and involved. I will 100% be following Maggie Rogers to this album's follow up, and I have the sense that she'll have reached that next level by that time.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment