![]() |
| ***SPOILERS for all three seasons of True Detective below*** |
Here's a hot take: Season 1 of True Detective is way overrated. Exactly three things were great about that season of television. The first, obviously, was the acting. The second was how it layered on the gothic, bayou-style horror on top of a rather pedestrian detective mystery. The third was the insane six-minute tracking shot at the end of the fourth episode, probably one of the best moments in television in the '00s. The problem with Season 1 was that it was all downhill from that tracking shot, and what started as a creepy, supernatural mystery story ended with the villain being a mentally challenged dude on a tractor. It totally petered out. It was unsatisfying. It did not deserve the hype it got back in 2014.
Here's a lukewarm take: Season 2 of True Detective is properly rated as pretty bad. It shared with Season 1 some pretty terrific acting (my defense of Vince Vaughn's role in this would have to be a whole separate blog post, sorry) and a pretty decent action set piece (again in Episode 4, this time a crazy shootout, and I don't want to go back and watch it again just in case it was the alcohol that made me love it so much the first time around). But it lacked any type of plot that you could even begin to grasp. It started convoluted, it remained convoluted, and it ended convoluted. There's being obtuse because you want to build mystery, and then there's being obtuse because you have written a terrible script. Showrunner Nic Pizzolatto is guilty of the latter all over Season 2.
Here's my take on Season 3, even though it's only been a day since the finale and I haven't been able to determine what temperature this take is yet: Season 3 of True Detective was pretty good! Yet again, there's terrific acting; Mahershala Ali and Stephen Dorff build deep, integral characters across three different timelines, and Carmen Ejogo manages to not only avoid playing the cliché "antihero's shrill wife" role, but also threatens to steal the show from the boys multiple times.
The opposite of Season 2, this season was written well back to front. The mystery was intriguing but not overwhelming. The dialogue was, for the most part, straightforward and honest, lacking any of the pretense and sheer stupidity of Season 2. And the idea that "our protagonist was the real mystery all along" is definitely a trope, but at least it was a well-handled trope throughout Season 3.
The opposite of Season 1, this season actually ended satisfactorily. I wouldn't say that we necessarily know exactly "who done it," but we know what happened, and we are left intrigued as to whether Wayne (Ali) actually figured it out (he has dementia, you see), and whether his son is going to keep unraveling the mystery. But the best part about the ending was that, as it turns out, the mystery was in service of the character-building the whole time. The final scene acknowledges—we may never be satisfied with the conclusion of the mystery, but at least we have each other. It serves as a commentary on the genre itself. It sounds dumb as I write it out, but trust me, Season 3 handles the cheesiness really, really well.
The only thing Season 3 lacked, in my opinion, was that big set piece that blows everyone away. There is nothing daring or audacious here. There was a semi-large police shootout, sure, but there was no urgency there because, due to the time-hopping nature of the plot, we already knew who would survive. The entire season was all slow burn. Everything was intriguing, but nothing got me all-caps EXCITED, ya know what I mean?
That's probably the most subjective part of my take, though. Ask Pam in December, and she'll probably name True Detective as her favorite show of the year. Pam has never been the type of person to need or desire an action blowout spectacles (when I remember Game of Thrones' "Battle of the Bastards," for instance, I always imagine Pam making jerk-off motions and fart noises). And she's probably right. My desire to watch explosions probably has something to do with some unresolved and embarrassing masculinity issues.
I just feel like True Detective was so close to being perfect in Season 3, so much closer than the preceding two seasons, but it didn't quite check all my boxes, and that bums me out. At the end of the day, Season 3 was unequivocally the best season of this anthology series. Here's to hoping that Season 4 (if it ever eventually exists) can truly reach every height that the first three seasons were able to sporadically hit in different ways.

No comments:
Post a Comment