Monday, February 10, 2020

Music Doc Review: Miss Americana


It's clear that Miss Americana is asking you to be sympathetic toward Taylor Swift. If this is a bridge too far to cross for you, for whatever reason, then Miss Americana is probably not the music documentary for you. But I will say to those people that I think you're being a little callous.

That's not the purpose of this blog post. I don't need to rush to my keyboard to defend a beautiful, popular millionaire. Even if that's exactly what Taylor Swift wants (and she practically says as much throughout the doc), and even if that makes me feel a little icky, like I'm falling into a PR trap or something, I'm still going to defend Miss Americana itself. Again, I'm not saying that everyone will find it worth the watch, but I am saying that its very existence is ultimately validated regardless.

There are four main components of Miss Americana. First, there is the standard-issue "from nothing to being a superstar" story. Second, there are various segments scattered throughout that show Swift in the process of creating the music that we all know and only some of us love. Third, Swift speaks honestly about her history of anorexia. Finally, Swift struggles with wading into politics, and the repercussions and obligations that come with that. Let's take one at a time.

I'm infinitely less interested in the "story" of Taylor Swift, as her particular story isn't anything we haven't heard before. There's grainy footage of National Anthem performances at half-filled rodeos, gratuitously PR-staged dinners with old childhood friends, close-up shots of cancer mommies crying. I'm not saying that the origins story actively disinterested me, but it was definitely the weakest part of the film.

Way more interesting to me was the vignettes of Swift and various male collaborators hunkering down and creating pop songs out of nothing. This kind of bullshit is always going to interest me, no matter the context. It could be an awful movie about teeth prosthetics, it could be a wonderfully sincere autobiography about gender dysphoria, it doesn't really matter to me. I'll always be fascinated with the entire creative process when it comes to music. Even when our glimpse into the process involves Taylor Swift reading lyrics off his phone while some sycophant doofus mumbles "yeah" and "great," I'm still going to love it.

The best aspects of this documentary come in the back half, and they are the segments that help Miss Americana earn its worth. Swift first, in a moment that no viewer could possible claim was duplicitous, speaks about her struggles with body image and her consequential history with anorexia.

You have to be a cold motherfucker to want to believe that this was yet another PR stunt, but let's say that it was. Let's say that this was cooked up by Swift's leggy publicist in a bold attempt to garner sympathy. Let's say that you believe the worst in humans, and you thought this was true. So? I'll argue for net positives any day. Imagine how many teen girls are going through similar issues throughout the country. There has to be at least some of them that are looking to this pop superstar, and realizing that they can relate to Swift's struggles, and then understanding that it helps to get help, to be open and honest about it. There are teenage girls out there whose lives will be improved because they watched Miss Americana. Should we disregard this because of the possibility of Taylor Swift having the audacity to speak about mental health on camera? I say no.

As loathe as I am to say it, the most triumphant moment in Miss Americana was when Taylor Swift clicked "submit" on an Instagram post. Yes, we are talking about the politics of it all, and in these troubled times, not even PR-shielded Taylor Swift can escape it. Good—count me as one of the bitter fucks who took Swift's 2016 silence as selfish on her part. But the genius of Miss Americana isn't that it makes a case that Taylor Swift is right about supporting a liberal candidate (even though she is right), it's that it successfully makes a case for being empathetic toward Swift in this particular context, that it was actually hard for her to dip the big toe into politics, and that it was a self-actualization moment to post it on Instagram.

The doc makes this case by first delving into the short history of Taylor Swift getting sexually assaulted in 2013 by a Denver radio morning show personality, and having to go to court to defend herself in 2017. The dots are connected to the 2018 midterms, when Swift realizes that she can't sit back and allow her state of Tennessee to elect someone she hilariously calls "trump in a wig." But I think even without the sexual assault case, she'd have a point; she says it herself, "How can I go out there and celebrate something like Gay Pride Month and then not rally against a homophobic candidate?" As someone who very often talks the big talk and then fails to walk the big walk, I was proud of Swift for sticking up for what she believed in, in a very tangible way.

Yeah, it was just an Instagram post, but for the Dixie Chicks, it was just one three-second comment about the president, and you can start to see what the stakes truly were for Taylor Swift. You can even put aside the fact that TN ultimately voted for the trump in the wig, but Swift had a measurable impact on the voting numbers, and like her mom says in the doc, it was a good place to start—now she's gotta gear up for 2020.

Like the anorexia, you can choose to believe that this was too calculated. If you believe that, then you are probably too entrenched in your Taylor Swift opinions for this lowly blog to change your mind. But if don't believe that there were thousands of kids in the Midwest who grew up surrounded by their Fox News-fed zombie family members, and that some of them saw Taylor Swift speaking up, and at least were exposed to a different point of view for their first time in their fucking lives, if you don't believe that that happened, or that it matters, or that it wasn't impactful, then I don't know what the fuck to tell you. You might as well be a trump in a wig.

So Miss Americana achieves what it sets out to. It features Taylor Swift in an ostensibly honest and intimate light. It informs the viewer of Swift's process, both musically and morally. It asks for empathy for Taylor Swift, and for the most part receives it. It would be pretty normal to look at something like Miss Americana and just see a 90-minute infomercial for a megastar who is drying her tears with $100 bills—plenty of people are thinking that, and have been for a while now, and I won't even sit here and argue that you don't have reason to think it.

What I will argue for, however, is that thinking such things can make a person's heart shrivel up. It can make you hollow inside. I'm arguing for optimism. I'm arguing for net positives. I'm arguing that you should try to see the best in someone instead of focusing on the worst. Yes, even Taylor Swift.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: