Thursday, July 9, 2020

Political Memes Don't Work

okay but how do we fix this

The 2020 Presidential is, unfortunately, approaching, and so we rationally minded people have to start figuring out how to convince this country not to elect an orange-skinned conman into office yet again (I left out my usual "rapist" descriptor, and will probably have to for the remainder of the year, since Joe Biden is also a rapist).

The current president cannot be our future president. I know it's probably impossible to imagine that any trump cultist could be convinced otherwise, but there will be plenty opportunities to at least try in the next few months. I've started to think about the various methods I could go about accomplishing this tall task, and which methods would work and which wouldn't. One I came up with last month involves ignoring everything except one issue, and beating everyone over the head with it. Makes sense in theory, but it's a lot harder in practice, especially when trolls are spewing incredibly racist bullshit all over your brother-in-law's Facebook wall and I just can't help but respond (I swear, I'm deleting Facebook soon, promise!).

But in pondering all this, I'm finding that there is definitely at least one method that absolutely, positively will not work, and that's trying to shame these people by making fun of how stupid they are. Let me be clear—if you support trump at this point, you are either incredible ignorant or a straight-up unempathetic monster. Either way, using memes to show that the opposing side is "wrong" is not the answer. It's too easy to brush them away.

I thought for today I could share a bunch of memes that I have seen recently on the Political Humor subreddit, and try to play devil's advocate. This is just a selection from what's been posted in the past 48 hours or so, but I could've gone back through every day in the last four years and done this forever. It's bad.

Because I believe wholeheartedly that you are dumb and/or an asshole when you support trump, I mostly agree with the point these memes are trying to make. But I don't agree with the method. Showing such a meme to a conservative would only serve to entrench them further in their conservative views, which is incredibly counterproductive. I get that.

I get that there needs to be a better way of going about this. Sharing political memes accomplishes nothing. NOTHING. It's a waste of time. It's a circle-jerk session for liberals who, yes, know that the president is a complete shitbird, because it's true, but who also feel the need to make that superiority known to the general internet public. It's not right. It's not helping. We need to stop this. There's gotta be a better way.


A conservative could easily respond: "Not all Republicans are like this. I'm a Republican and I'm not a racist. But what's so wrong about wanting to know all the facts before you make a judgment? Isn't that what this country was founded upon? A fair trial?"


A conservative could easily respond: "These pictures might look similar, but they are completely different contexts. The extremist actively wants to destroy American values, and has already admitted as much. The American is trying to protect her values, and is just taking a picture with both her values (found in the Bible), and the protection of them (the gun) featured in it. Plus, it's a free country, and she's not breaking any laws, so what's the big deal?"


A conservative could easily respond: "She's clearly a liar, and clearly just jealous of her brother. If she wasn't wrong, then why would she resign? How can we trust such a person?"


A conservative could easily respond: "trump is doing everything he can to protect as many lives as he can. Of course Republicans are upset that so many people are dying, even though so many of those lives are just old people in nursing homes. Abortion is different. Those are human lives that trump is trying to protect as well. There's only so much we can do about COVID, and if more lives could've been saved, trump would've saved them. But there are millions of human lives about to be born that are being snuffed out by libtard murders. Republicans are trying to protect them too!"


A conservative could easily respond: "First of all, there are pictures of trump looking more fit than this, but the liberal media refuses to post them. Secondly, what does it matter how fit a president is? trump seems to be doing a good enough job regardless of whether he wears jogging shorts or not."


A conservative could easily respond: "It must've been easier for a country with 1.4% of the population numbers as the United States. Plus, we have our own scientists, and what have idiots like Dr. Fauci done for us so far?"


A conservative could easily respond: "What, I'm supposed to be upset because Mexico was stupid enough to do trump's job for him? Plus, didn't trump say that he was going to make Mexico pay for the border closing? Looks like trump fulfilled another campaign promise. Also, Jeff Tiedrich is a creepy obsessive who responds to every single one of trump's tweets, so he clearly has no life."


A conservative could easily respond: "The people who are in this position are clearly not smart with their money. The government gave out thousands of dollars on average to each family a couple months ago, and they are already having trouble filling up a gas tank? Um, maybe don't drive when you don't have to? You can't blame your money woes on people who happen to have more money than you because of the stock market doing so well. Maybe you should've thought of that before you bought something you didn't need. Also, who's saying that I didn't take a hit because of COVID too? Everyone was hurting. But I made it through unscathed, so I don't understand why other people can't too."


A conservative could easily respond: "This is clearly fake news, because it wasn't Donald trump Jr. who was barred from doing any more charity work, it was his brother Eric. Secondly, that ruling was clearly biased anyway. The judge was probably a liberal extremist. Speaking of which, if Eric really did something wrong, why didn't he go to jail? Don't people who break the law go to jail? If he didn't go to jail, he clearly didn't break the law."


A conservative could easily respond: "It's a well-known fact that foreign countries are paying for fake twitter accounts. Why should I listen to a person who is clearly fake?"


A conservative could easily respond: "America is the greatest country in the world, and by you showing me this meme, you're proving that you are a traitor. If you hate America so much, why don't you just leave?"


That was a little painful to write. Hopefully you can imagine my retorts if anyone actually tried to make these arguments to me. But that's not the point of this blog post.

I'm not trying to prove that there are two sides to any of the issues immaturely broadcasted by these memes. There's only one correct side. As you can see above, any argument to the contrary is flimsy and wrongheaded and ignorant and completely lacking empathy for their fellow man. But it doesn't matter, because conservatives are going to make that argument anyway. I'm not trying to prove them right; I'm trying to prove that it doesn't matter if you prove them wrong, because they are going to find a way to pretend to be right anyway. Memes aren't the answer.

I wish I had the answer, but I don't. All I can do right now is educate myself, keep my mouth shut during family parties, and continue to challenge my own beliefs.

1 comment:

sunny said...

Completely agree. The trend of using memes as political argument is infuriating. That subreddit is called r/PoliticalHumor but how many of these are actually... funny?

There's a big disconnect between people schlepping this stuff and how the average person uses information to form, hold, and change beliefs. But feeling powerless, they pump out these memes to help themselves cope under guise of convincing others. Like you said, a circle jerk.