Friday, July 3, 2020

diana, Sam


In the past, the Grammy distinction among “album,” “record,” and “song” was a lot more evident. Many Beatles songs were released as “records” and then later cobbled onto “albums” which were nothing more than compilations of singles and rejected tracks (The Beatles Again and pretty much their first five American-released albums are examples of this). Over time, the album itself gained prominence in rock and roll circles as a thematic art form in its own right. An artist sitting down to create a piece of art at one moment in time with one vision became important.

Which brings us to diana. Motown was a hit machine but focused more on the “record” and “song” genres rather than the “album.” There were outliers (Some of Marvin Gaye‘s best stuff comes on Motown albums) but the record label always focused on the immediacy and success of records.

While it’s Diana Ross’s tenth studio album, diana is her last one on Motown. According to Wikipedia, Ross wanted to break free from the limitations imposed on her by the record label and enlisted Nile Rogers and Bernard Edwards to write an album that captured that sentiment. Unlike Ross' other works, diana possesses a unified vision and sound. And this is when disco is supposedly dying.

From one conversation with Ross, the songwriters learned she wanted to "have fun" turn her career "upside down," and announce to the world she was "coming out." Rogers and Edwards took her very literally and penned songs accordingly.

Because these songs were crafted with Ross in mind, they take on a more personal tone. You can feel Ross' passion. The collaboration is perfect too—the syncopation between the guitar and drums with Ross' voice in "I'm Coming Out" is one of the triumphs of pop music. And because there's unity among the songs, even the dumber numbers work (if you can turn your brain off, "Have Fun (Again)" is fine but you really shouldn't dwell on it.)

I'd also be remiss not to mention that Ross had a turbulent relationship with "I'm Coming Out." Initially, she was oblivious to obvious LGBTQ themes of the song and was worried that people may perceive her as homosexual. For a female, black artist, Ross was supposedly very risk-averse, which makes sense: she had witnessed many artists get put out to pasture. Over time, her relationship with the song became an ode for her devoted queer followers. As with anything, it's a little more nuanced than a blurb on Wikipedia. This article has an interesting summary.

Overall, diana benefits from the unity of vision from Rogers and Edwards, and Ross at the height of her talents. It's not all great, but it's mostly pretty good.

No comments: