The Bible 2
AJJ
2016
I hate to generalize when it comes to whole genres of music, so let me be as specific as I can—there's a certain brand of DIY folk punk that I've traditionally tried to keep at arm's length. AJJ is a part of this subgenre. I tend to avoid it because I've found that that scene's particular brand of snarkiness rubs me the wrong way. Any stab at humor from these types of bands seems like an attempt to be "edgy" but just ends up being lame and off-putting. To me, anyway.
Or maybe "juvenile" is a better word for it (which is fucking rich, coming from me). I dunno. I just think about how much I dislike the Moldy Peaches (the forebearers of this particular strand of folk punk). "Who's Got the Crack?" is funny when you're a preteen, but it's grating when you reach your thirties.
I'm not that intimate with AJJ, but I know enough of their canon that I'm familiar with their dalliances in that type of "edgy" humor. Knife Man, as far as I know the best folk punk album of all time, wears this (ironic bowler) hat on occasion, not afraid to reach for guffaws by describing gruesome scenarios, the punk equivalent to a dead baby joke. But there's enough emotional, unironic honesty on Knife Man that it works despite the lame bullshit. (AJJ's most recent album, Good Luck Everybody, by contrast, is pretty much unlistenable.)
So if The Bible 2 is worth your time, then it's because it spends the bulk of its runtime looking inward, and that's a great look for a band like AJJ. There's some extraneous, cringe-worthy bullshit around the edges for sure, but mostly the album exists as a exercise in looking at one's past, examining the low points, and figuring out how to use that to do better in the future. There's no room for fart jokes, and The Bible 2 is all the better for it.
(I'm just realizing now that the very title of the album betrays the point I'm trying to make. "The Bible 2" is a dumb title, but don't worry, the edgy atheist-style joke stops there.)
Here's what is clear: frontman Sean Bonnette seems to have had a pretty rough go of it, growing up in the Midwest. If we take this work as autobiographical, then Bonnette had some bad behavioral health issues in grade school (the "visions" cause him to act violently in "Cody's Theme," and he eventually ends up in a mental institution in "Junkie Church," and so on).
But in The Bible 2, Bonnette makes the case that there is always room for growth. It doesn't matter that "nothing ever made you complete," because there's always today, and you can always attempt to do better. Twice on the album, Bonnette yells the album's mantra—"No more fear, no more shame, no more dread." If your life has been filled with those things, then maybe today is a great day to let it go. Try to find the positive things in life.
A fun punk album might help. With barely anything to cringe over (okay, the Girls reference is a bit much for me), the hooks shine on The Bible 2. I love that a song like "White Worms" can take one of those aforementioned "visions" from Bonnette's youth, describe it in disgusting detail, but then also craft a catchy, pounding chorus out of it (complete with an anti-Journey "stop believing!" chant-along).
Despite the seemingly raucous nature of some of these tunes, the important aspect of The Bible 2 remains its ability to stay intimate despite its decibel level. AJJ finds beauty in looking inward, even if what they find it's necessarily beautiful in and of itself. Consider it an outlier in the DIY folk punk scene. Consider it worthy of your time.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
If this album sounds interesting, then try this song: "Goodbye, Oh Goodbye"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Stray Observations
- Maybe going with the premise of "DIY folk punk is by and large unfunny" was the wrong choice, seeing as how I'm just watching the video for "Goodbye, Oh Goodbye" for the first time right now (embedded just above), and that was the most I've laughed during a music video in a long, long time. This is my type of humor—a smart, sarcastic, self-deprecating takedown of something that is polished and popular.
- The production value on this album reminds me strongly of Some Loud Thunder by Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, i.e. it is TERRIBLE. There are three possibilities here. The first is that sounding like it was recorded through AOL dial-up is some punk retro move, like, "we don't need fancy shit we're too cool for that." The second is that the intense static is supposed to reflect the clarity (or lack thereof) in which the memories are being transmitted back from the past. Third is that they were lazy. I do not have a guess as to which of these possibilities is true.
- Also bad (as referenced above): the line "If I was one of the Girls, I would be Shoshanna." It's only been three years since that show went off the year, but my god, it sounds so dated already.
- ALBUM TITLE: As noted above, some of that dumb edgy humor sneaks by in the title, "The Bible 2," meant to troll religious types that would be offended by AJJ anyway. As far as I can tell, there are no explicit references to religion on The Bible 2; you could probably consider it implicit, however, that the entirety of the narrative takes place in a space completely devoid of religion.
- ALBUM COVER: The cartoonish style of the cartoon cutout being shot through with bullets kind of reminds me of the style employed in the great unheralded Adult Swim series Superjail!
- I enjoyed reading this interview with Sean Bonnette on Bandcamp (conducted by a fan). I thought Bonnette came off as genial and humble. I enjoyed learning that his wife is a psychologist, which makes sense, given his ability to make some pretty good insights about himself on this record. And I enjoyed the fact that, clearly, Bonnette is living a healthier lifestyle than he did when he was younger, both physically and emotionally.
- The only thing that didn't connect with me in this interview was all the questions about the band's previous album, Christmas Island, which I've never heard. Sounds like I would like it, though, since apparently this was the first album in which AJJ settles down and gets serious, and that's what I liked about The Bible 2.
- So yeah, I really only otherwise know AJJ albums Knife Man and People Who Can Eat People Are the Luckiest People in the World (the latter being kind of annoying, as you might surmise from the title). I gave 2020's Good Luck Everybody one listen, and realized that some bands are really struggling with how to deal with the trump era in their music, and AJJ is absolutely one of them.
- I should also mention that AJJ used to be known as "Andrew Jackson Jihad," but changed their name in 2016 with the following statement: "1) We are not Muslims, and as such, it is disrespectful and irresponsible for us to use the word 'jihad' in our band’s name; 2) We no longer wish to be a living reminder of the president Andrew Jackson. Interesting historical figure as he was, he was an odious person and our fascination with him has grown stale." In other words: "We're not asshole teenagers anymore."
- It looks like The Bible 2 was released one song at a time online. As Bonnette describes it, this was done so that the album wouldn't leak beforehand. If they could control the release schedule, they could monetize it. I'm not the type of person who is going to listen to individual AJJ songs on a daily basis, but I admit that the plan makes sense the general.
- I have two friends who met each other at an AJJ concert (I think, don't quote me on that), and we used to chat AJJ occasionally, especially after The Bible 2 came out. I haven't seen them since Monday Beer Runners petered out. Steph and Kristin, if y'all are reading this, I miss you guys.
NEXT TIME: Big Bad Luv by John Moreland

No comments:
Post a Comment