1981
Frank Perry
A huge thank you to Small Group A, who bit the bullet and put together our first all-online movie discussion for Film Club. Everyone in the group who saw the movie wrote a little something about it. I've compiled them all below. Let us know what you think in the comments. I'll be down there, trying to stir some more conversation. There's a lot to talk about!
~~~~~~~~~~
Vinny
Overall, I'd give this one a solid 4.5. It's an extremely uncomfortable movie to watch; you spend the entire time actively hating the main character, and rooting against her horrible actions.
I will say that I enjoyed how the film was made, particularly the cinematography. There is great foreshadowing about how tumultuous Joan Crawford's mental state is, including from the very first scene, which is essentially the morning routine from American Psycho, but for 1930s Hollywood starlets. Not to mention her overbearing OCD when it comes to cleaning her house.
Faye Dunaway is shot like a horror villain in some scenes, particularly the "no wire hangers" freakout. It's a little ham-fisted, but I think it works overall for what they're trying to convey: how aggressive, strict parents can look like monsters to little kids.
The acting is probably the weakest part of the movie. A lot of the lines are delivered like soap opera melodrama, but, again, I think it fits with the theme of mentally ill, extremely narcissistic people.
It's hard for me to too harshly judge the story since, ya know, it really happened.
I will say that the final quarter of the movie, when Crawford seems to rekindle her relationship with her mother, only to have her steal her part on a soap opera, would've been a stroke of brilliant writing, if it wasn't something Crawford really did to her daughter.
I'll admit this movie made me pretty depressed, as someone about to have a kid. It reminds me how badly equipped some people are to be parents.
If nothing else, I can use this as an example of what not to do.
GRADE: 2.5 out of 5
GRADE: 2.5 out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Catherine
I made the mistake of reading Roger Ebert's Mommie Dearest review before I watched the film and quips like "painful experience" "unremittingly depressing" and "who wants to watch this?" rapidly deflated my excitement as I smeared on my clay face mask and poured a glass of wine to start this journey. Despite catching a meme or two over the years, I was somehow unaware of MD's critical reception and cult classic status. I've always assumed it was just noteworthy for being an unprecedented takedown of a Hollywood icon, nothing more. NOW I GET IT.
Sorry to speak ill of the dead, but Mr. Ebert, you're a fucking idiot. Half-joking, of course, since it's definitely bad from a filmmaking standpoint if you're into coherent plots and character development and that kind of thing, but, with the exception of The Room, I've never known a movie to miss the mark so spectacularly that it launches itself into the cultural stratosphere, nestling into our psyches forevermore—like reaching down to pick up a quarter and tripping headfirst into a gold mine (if that gold mine also tanked your career... sorry, Faye Dunaway).
Gun to my head, I could not define "camp" (and I'm not going to read that Susan Sontag essay, so don't tell me to), but I know this is peak camp. I can feel it in my bones. What a feat to crank out scene after scene after scene of unimaginable cruelty and child abuse and leave the audience absolutely tickled. Of course, if you watch the movie as the director intended—like that nerd Ebert—there's nothing funny about it and you'd have to be a monster to be amused, but I think that's what's so special about it: it awakened a fan base of like-minded weirdos, mischievous and macabre. This could be the postmodern irony talking, but rather than writing a review of how the Minecraft movie stinks, isn't it more fun to scream and whoop and throw popcorn when you hear "Chicken Jockey!" because you're aware everything is stupid and it feels powerful and freeing to laugh in the face of pandering and faux sincerity? Can we have a nice time, please? Anyway, eat shit, Roger.
Sorry to speak ill of the dead, but Mr. Ebert, you're a fucking idiot. Half-joking, of course, since it's definitely bad from a filmmaking standpoint if you're into coherent plots and character development and that kind of thing, but, with the exception of The Room, I've never known a movie to miss the mark so spectacularly that it launches itself into the cultural stratosphere, nestling into our psyches forevermore—like reaching down to pick up a quarter and tripping headfirst into a gold mine (if that gold mine also tanked your career... sorry, Faye Dunaway).
Gun to my head, I could not define "camp" (and I'm not going to read that Susan Sontag essay, so don't tell me to), but I know this is peak camp. I can feel it in my bones. What a feat to crank out scene after scene after scene of unimaginable cruelty and child abuse and leave the audience absolutely tickled. Of course, if you watch the movie as the director intended—like that nerd Ebert—there's nothing funny about it and you'd have to be a monster to be amused, but I think that's what's so special about it: it awakened a fan base of like-minded weirdos, mischievous and macabre. This could be the postmodern irony talking, but rather than writing a review of how the Minecraft movie stinks, isn't it more fun to scream and whoop and throw popcorn when you hear "Chicken Jockey!" because you're aware everything is stupid and it feels powerful and freeing to laugh in the face of pandering and faux sincerity? Can we have a nice time, please? Anyway, eat shit, Roger.
GRADE: 4 out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~
Stephan
I expected Mommie Dearest to be a melodramatic and entertaining trainwreck. While very heavy on the melodrama, this movie is far from entertaining. If not for Film Club, I likely wouldn't have finished this film. Most of the performances are devoid of life. The exceptions here are Faye Dunaway and Diana Scarwid. While certainly full of life, Dunaway's wild portrayal of Joan Crawford delivers an unhinged, over-the-top performance that lacks any sort of depth or nuance. Though I know very little about the real Joan Crawford, I know there was evidence to suggest that perhaps she may have struggled with an undiagnosed personality disorder. Be it the writing or Dunaway herself, the depiction of mental illness here is not reflective of lived experiences of those with similar conditions. What could have been a very interesting and compelling film about mental health and its impact on family dynamics, the film chooses instead to depict Crawford as deranged and narcissistic in a way that lacks humanism.
Turning to Diana Scarwid's performance, I actually think that her acting was pretty solid. The main problem for me was the poor character development. Because of its vignette style, the movie never truly builds characters and relationships. It's usually just here are characters in conflict at a moment in time, now on to the next without much consideration for or reflection on what previously transpired. As it relates to Christina's relationship with Joan, the movie leaves so much to be assumed about their relationship, which, yes, is obviously complicated. But the film could have done much more to show and explore its complexities.
A couple final and random thoughts on the movie:
- What's with the timeline of events here? In particular, early in the film, young Christopher ages five years, while Christina hasn't aged at all.
- Speaking of Christopher, we're going to show him being strapped to bed at night with absolutely no context??
- The scenes of child abuse without any sort of character motivation make me feel disconnected from the characters, which, in turn, elicits no emotional response. Though I am probably more desensitized by this kind of content than most, it's absolutely crazy to feel nothing when watching a mom whale on (wail on?) her child. That's an issue with the movie, not with me!
- Diana Scarwid looks and sounds a lot like Laura Linney to me, who I love. So, score another point for Scarwid.
In conclusion, this film did not do it for me.
GRADE: 1 wire hanger out of 5
GRADE: 1 wire hanger out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~
Pam
I don't think I'm the only one whose frame of reference for Mommie Dearest is very narrowly based on the various references made to it on RuPaul's Drag Race. I was always aware of the "NO WIRE HANGERS" quote, but without any context. But otherwise, my knowledge of Joan Crawford was pretty slim.
I liked Mommie Dearest. For starters, give me a taste of old Hollywood and I'm content. The costumes, the makeup, the sets, the way in which Faye Dunaway speaks when playing Joan Crawford—it's alluring.
On the other hand, as a parent—and I knew this was going to happen—it was a bit of a tough watch at times. Not only due to the child abuse, which was pretty shocking, but also because there were moments that I understood Joan Crawford in the tiniest of ways. Have I brushed my kids' hair a little too hard because they were fighting me the whole time? Probably. Have I perhaps flipped out at Joe because the bed wasn't made perfectly? Check. (I was pregnant, I'm cutting myself some slack on that one.)
I think Christina Crawford is smart. And the movie makers were smart. And there is no truer statement than saying that women have complicated relationships with their mothers. Christina Crawford hated her mother, but she also loved her. I think the acceptance speech she gives at the end is telling of this, and I believe this is how she wanted her mother to be portrayed. Not as a hero or a villain.
I think this is what I like so much about Mommie Dearest. Was Joan Crawford a monster at times? For sure. With her night cream caked on her face, she literally looked like a monster during the NO WIRE HANGERS scene. But she had her shining moments as well. Did she work insanely hard to end up being fucked over by the same people (men) who referred to her as "Hollywood Royalty"? Like, yes, her reactions to that were extreme, but also... were they? I'll be honest, I was pretty happy to root for her during the "DON'T FUCK WITH ME, FELLAS" Pepsi board of directors scene.
I think Mommie Dearest is about way more than a mother and a daughter. It almost reminds me of The Substance. Like, let's see just how much ugliness comes between women in these types of situations. I'm glad to have finally seen this movie. I feel like I'm always way off with these things, so I'm really looking forward to reading everyone else's thoughts on Mommie D!
GRADE: 5 out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Zach
I know movies don't always exist to make us feel good about ourselves. Movies that are too feel-good or too cheesy don't appeal to me. We can be excited, we can get into a good story, one that feels real. In the best of worlds, movies should tell a story that resonates.
There's nothing wrong with the movie Mommie Dearest being made. The movie couldn't be more real. It's based on a true story. But there was a point, about halfway through this movie, that I thought about turning it off. It was making me physically ill. I was trying to eat a grapefruit, but I felt incredibly sick. There was something about the scene where Joan gets mad about the wire hangers made me feel so awful that I really didn't want to continue.
And some might say that's a good thing. It's making me feel something. But I can't say I enjoyed this movie. That doesn't mean it's a bad movie. Faye Dunaway is pretty incredible as an actor. But her character doesn't have a lot of complexity in that she seems to be entirely a villain. Yes, there are scenes that I think are meant to make you feel sympathetic to the relationship between Joan and Christina. When she comes by her apartment, for instance, and gives her "support" for her budding acting career. Anything good Christina does for Joan is just to feed Joan's massive ego or anything else.
I can't tell if Christina has any bone in her body that actually likes her mother, or if it's entirely an act when she smiles at her and acts excited when she calls. When she tells her she loves her, is there something real there? It's that lack of clarity that makes Christina a much more complex character than her mother. Her mother is simply pure evil. It's hard to think of a redeeming quality for her mother.
And that's partially what made the movie hard to watch. She's a horrible person, without much more to her. Can a movie character really be this bad?
I think if this movie sheds light on abuse—as I'm sure it did in its time, when abuse was less discussed—then it might have been worth making. But I would never watch it again. I want to run far away from it. It was disturbing and I felt awful after watching it.
I will say the last line delivered by Christina, after Christopher said their mother got the last word—"does she?"—sent chills down my spine. It's a meta moment, one that is self-referential to the film and the book on which it was based. And I am very happy Christina got her moment. Her mother's reputation is ruined, and deservedly so.
GRADE: 2 out of 5
Allison
GRADE: 2 out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Allison
Everything I knew about this movie, I learned from drag queens, and I wish I had kept it that way. I was looking forward to watching Mommie Dearest until I really thought about it and remembered that the most well-known and quoted scene is a depiction of horrific child abuse. Fun! God, it's hard to enjoy things in 2025. Unsurprisingly, the movie didn't live up to my camp-classic expectations. Melodramatic interpretations of mental health and child abuse aside (not to mention my own complicated feelings about my relationship with my mother, but this isn't YSC, so let's move past it), this movie is just bad. Faye Dunaway truly thought she was going to win an Oscar for this. Barbara, please! Even if this is an accurate portrayal of Crawford (which it isn't, according to the real-life Christina Crawford), it is too over-the-top and too unhinged to be seen as anything other than a grotesque caricature. Dunaway had the look down, but I give most of the credit to the costume, hair, and makeup departments. I did love the get-ready-with-me / morning-shed-vibe opening scene. You heard it here first: TikTok beauty influencers are ripping off Joan Crawford.
Both young and old Christinas give surprisingly compelling performances despite the script actively working against them. Mara Hobel (young Christina) has a quiet and measured sass, making her a worthy opponent against Dunaway's unhinged Crawford. Old Christina, Diana Scarwid (25 at the time), is a convincing mildly rebellious teen despite her face looking the way it does. Once she's able to act her age, her performance breathes life into a weary second act as she tiptoes around her mother's accelerating insanity. However, the choice to only use two actresses paired with the loose storytelling makes it nearly impossible to understand the passing of time, when one actress plays a three-to-ten-year-old and the other plays a twelve-to-40-year-old. I know audiences watching this in the '80s couldn't actively research the accuracy of plot points, but this based-on-a-true-story biopic takes crazy liberties with the timeline. Young Christina remains frozen in time as brother Christopher goes from baby to toddler to adolescent. The movie spans nearly 40 years, but Joan barely ages, yet Renfield-esque Carol Ann has had the life force sucked out of her by the end.
Intentional segue to the true villain of the film, Carol Ann. She's not based on a real person, but rather a composite of housekeepers and assistants from Joan Crawford's life. That said, why was she portrayed as a brainwashed indentured servant? If Joan Crawford were Jim Jones, Carol Ann would be first in line for a glass of Flavor-Aid. If this was a film class, I might write about how Carol Ann represents the countless people in Crawford's life who enabled her mental illness and failed to protect her children, as well as a personification of the toxic celebrity culture of classic Hollywood. But I'd rather just ask, "Hey, what the fuck, Carol Ann?"
Ultimately, am I glad to finally have context for the "no wire hangers" scene? Not really!
GRADE: 2 out of 5 exasperated "Jesus Christ"s while sitting on the bathroom floor covered in soap powder.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Brianna
I had never heard of Mommie Dearest when Pam first offered the movie as an option, and I wanted to go in as blind as possible. With the way trailers are anymore, it was a rare opportunity to know almost nothing about the world I was about to step into, and so I stepped in with both feet.
And holy shit. What a world, huh?
It was jarring, at first, to be thrust into such a whirlwind. Plot points fly by at such a rapid rate. In one scene, Joan (who I had known by name but nothing of her story) is rejected by the adoption agency, and in the next, her beau has wrangled up some kind of deal and the baby is arriving. A scene or two later, baby Christina is now a walking and talking child!
It's straightforward enough to keep up with plot-wise, but I found myself wondering who exactly Joan was in the midst of her theatrics. It could've been my lack of context on the Crawford story, but I didn't really understand her motives. I suppose that could be the point. If this movie is based on Christina's memoirs, then the big fight scene (you know, the attempted murder by strangulation no one talks about again) could be the key to this.
"Why did you adopt me?"
The publicity, perhaps. The desire to be truly loved, sure. Joan didn't seem to know anymore, and Christina certainly didn't. So I'm led to believe the book, and then the movie by association, is an attempt to put a name to it all. Who was this lady and why did she do these, at times, awful things?
Where the movie went wrong for me was the lack of any real effort into this attempt. It became more of a circus than a character study. And, like, an obviously abusive circus where the animals are all sad and/or ready to snap at any moment. Some of the scenes were painful to watch, and without any real contribution to our understanding of Joan other than: she's horrible!! What's the big problem with wire coat hangers anyway?
The saving grace of horrorshow was the acting itself, honestly. I know Faye Dunaway got a lot of shit for her over-the-top performance, but if there's a reason people are still talking about this movie today, it's her. Whether or not that was really who Joan Crawford was, the woman in this film is true villainy, and it was equal parts terrifying and awe inspiring to watch.
And that poor baby Tina!!
In the bathroom scene, when she's looking around at the mess, positively reeling in trauma and emotion now that Mommie Dearest has left the room. I had to pause the movie to see what kinds of awards this child went on to receive in life. It's none, by the way. A role in Broadway's infamous one-day Moose Murders, and a 2019 spot on Blue Bloods. Maybe she was too traumatized to continue down that road? I know I'd be.
So where does that leave it? Too heavy of a story without the character depth to make it feel worth it, and yet enough star power to make it hard to look away.
GRADE: 2.5 of 5 Pukes!
GRADE: 2.5 of 5 Pukes!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Joe
I don't think I've ever been so shocked to learn that a movie won Worst Picture at the Razzies. It honestly makes me hate the Razzies. I liked this movie a lot! Sure, it was over-the-top at points, but I saw that more like "hyperbole" than "camp." I believed what was happening in this movie. Yes, sure, I know now that this is barely non-fiction, that the truth of what actually happened was skewed slightly in Christina Crawford's memoir, and then morphed into a whole different thing in unfaithfully adapting that memoir. I don't care about what's real and what's not. I only care that, in the moment, as I'm experiencing that movie magic, I believe. I believed Mommie Dearest.
I don't give a shit that the real Tina has claimed that she was never actually beaten with a hanger. I was fully invested in that scene. It was like a horror film in moments like that. It's insane that anyone would accuse Faye Dunaway of "overacting" in that moment. That would be like accusing the actor who plays Jason Voorhees of overacting. That's the whole fucking point! You're supposed to be horrified!
And look, I'm not going to lie, I laughed a little bit at the beginning of that scene, when Joan made it clear that she was gonna go bugshit over the idea of her young daughter using a wire hanger to hang up her expensive dress. But the laughter faded quickly. If you're still laughing at this shit, then that just means you're uncomfortable with the idea of child abuse, and the need laughter as a defense mechanism. 36 hours before watching Mommie Dearest, I had to place a kid with a family member because her mom beat her with a belt. I don't think that mom was behaving like Joan Crawford with a wire hanger. I also believe with my whole heart that it probably felt that way anyway to the kid getting beat. So it's really just a matter of perspective, and you gotta remember the POV of this film (through the eyes of Christina, basically).
On the other hand: you're playing a losing game if you look at any adult with children, an adult real or fictional or a weird Joan/Faye combo of the two, and attempt to make a judgment on their parenting. It's pretty clear that Christina Crawford was abused by her mother. Maybe not in the exact way it is portrayed in the film adaptation of her memoir, but still, this is the point of the movie, and ostensibly the memoir. The abuse. A rough childhood. No, it's not right, but it's too easy to say that Joan Crawford (as portrayed in Mommie Dearest) was a shitty parent. Often, it's more complicated than that. She probably had some mental health stuff going on. She was clearly warped by the cold hard Hollywood film system and that warped too her perception of parenthood. And most importantly, who the fuck am I to judge? In what ways am I fucking up my children right now that will look TERRIBLE when one of their memoirs gets adapted into a major motion picture in 40 years?
On the other hand: you're playing a losing game if you look at any adult with children, an adult real or fictional or a weird Joan/Faye combo of the two, and attempt to make a judgment on their parenting. It's pretty clear that Christina Crawford was abused by her mother. Maybe not in the exact way it is portrayed in the film adaptation of her memoir, but still, this is the point of the movie, and ostensibly the memoir. The abuse. A rough childhood. No, it's not right, but it's too easy to say that Joan Crawford (as portrayed in Mommie Dearest) was a shitty parent. Often, it's more complicated than that. She probably had some mental health stuff going on. She was clearly warped by the cold hard Hollywood film system and that warped too her perception of parenthood. And most importantly, who the fuck am I to judge? In what ways am I fucking up my children right now that will look TERRIBLE when one of their memoirs gets adapted into a major motion picture in 40 years?
I will say that it's bizarre to me that my first exposure to the existence of Mommie Dearest was a RuPaul Rusical in which the queens danced around with wire hangers. I assumed at the time that "wire hanger" was a reference to abortion, which would have been dark. But I'll argue that it's almost just as dark that drag queens were having fun dancing around and singing a song inspired by child abuse. I am more forgiving of the drag queen community than most, and I think this is another obvious example of "laughter as defense mechanism." But something about the idea of Mommie Dearest being considered "camp" sits really uneasily with me. Overacted or not, Christina's cries felt too real to me, and they are going to make me recoil the next time I hear a similar crying out in my own home.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 2.875 pukes out of 5
Thanks everybody! See you in the comments!
NEXT TIME: Might get to see some patriotic tapdancing when we watch Yankee Doodle Dandy.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 2.875 pukes out of 5
Thanks everybody! See you in the comments!
NEXT TIME: Might get to see some patriotic tapdancing when we watch Yankee Doodle Dandy.

47 comments:
Thanks to everybody who participating in writing a little something for this movie. I feel like there's a lot to talk about! There's obviously no pressure to have an intense discussion this morning at 8:30 AM. I assume most people are at work anyway. But this post will be up indefinitely, and if you wanna pop in and participate later today or over the weekend or whatever, I can promise I will keep checking and keep responding. Probably the most convenient way to get back to this space is to bookmark the landing page. The link for Mommie Dearest now brings you to this blog post.
I'll probably ask some discussion questions in separate comments below, and we can go from there. If you have a response to one of those Qs, then you can reply to specific comments. If you have a separate thought or question, you can make a new comment.
Or whatever! Who gives a shit. This is supposed to be fun and I'm already writing too much. Thanks for being part of Film Club (and patient as I continue to get my bearings straight).
Something I was thinking about as I was going through all of our reactions is how mostly everyone who watched it felt uncomfortable in some way (as was the film's intentions, probably), but that different viewers reacted to that discomfort in different ways. Some felt uncomfortable and said that's what makes this is a bad viewing experience, and some felt uncomfortable and said that's what made it a worthy viewing experience. Is this just a difference in how movies are approached by the individual?
For "based on true story" films, I'm curious how knowing the subject of the film beforehand affects the viewing experience. I didn't see anyone say "I was a huge Joan Crawford fan and knew a lot about her," but say someone had? How would that experience be different?
This Q goes hand in hand with something that Brianna and Catherine shared opposite experiences with: knowing anything about the movie itself beforehand. I've personally been trying to go into every movie experience with zero knowledge of what it's even about, but maybe knowing a lot about a movie beforehand would soften some of the rougher edges? My other sister (not Brianna) infamously reads the final page of any book she's reading first, which feels absolutely deranged to me, but to each their own.
So wait, can someone explain camp? I get what it is but I wouldn't be able to define it, I don't think. I was thinking about it when I saw this quote from a film critic on the Wikipedia page.
"Drag queens outdo each other for the fiercest impersonation of Faye Dunaway in Crawford mode. And who doesn't want to be part of a 'whiplash' audience, whatever that is? Well, possibly Christina Crawford, who has seen her harrowing history of child abuse transformed into a gay pantomime. Watching audiences howl with laughter as your avatar is beaten and throttled must be a sobering experience."
Two complications here. 1) Laughter as defense mechanism, and 2) the idea that Christina Crawford knows full well that she was never actually beaten with a wire hanger. Thoughts?
I think one thing that pretty much everyone agreed with is that Faye Dunaway did a good job acting in this film. And yet she won the Razzie for Worst Actress. What the fuck, man? My only explanation here is that the definition of "good acting" has changed over the past forty-something years. Maybe in that we are more willing to value "overacting" now? Jim Carrey made a career ten to fifteen years later out of acting wilder than Dunaway ever could, and I didn't hear anyone questioning whether it was "too much." That was the point, ya know? It's the point here too.
I got some laughs from everyone who mentioned the inconsistent timeline, because it's so true! I think there's a certain amount of "buying into" a film that's required for shit like this. I also think that it gets to be a little much when a movie doesn't care at all about it.
I also laughed at the idea of the kid being strapped to the bed and it never being explained why.
Pam mentioned the "don't fuck with me" line as being a good one. When I heard it, felt slightly unearned at first. But I've given it more thought, and I think I have changed my mind. I think it speaks to the idea that some people are really good at some things and lacking in others. Her particular brand of "crazy" ("crazy" in quotes because I'm not referring to any legitimate mental health stuff she may have been suffering through) was actually really well suited for success in Hollywood (she won an Oscar!) and in the business world. And yet it clearly wasn't suited for parenthood. I think the "Don't fuck with me fellas" adds a lot to the complicated portrait of this complicated person.
What was the best line? I'm glad "Why did you adopt me?" and "Does she...?" were mentioned, though both hit pretty good. "Because I am NOT one of your FANS" was good too, especially leading into the brutal fight afterward.
As noted, the average grade given for Mommie Dearest was 3.125 pukes. But I feel like that doesn't really give a good picture of the range of grades we had here. They stretched from 1/5 all the way to 5/5. Does anyone have any second thoughts about their grade after reading everyone else's thoughts?
I think it all depends on how you're grading it, which is not consistent person-to-person (that's a good thing). I'll personally say that, after reading everyone's criticisms, I'll admit there were more there than I originally considered immediately after watching. But I feel like 4/5 is a good indication of how I felt as the credits rolled, something like: "damn, that was so good!" And I don't think that there's much that could retroactively change that feeling.
I had no idea drag queens were so enamored with this movie. That’s….interesting, given how unhinged Joan Crawford is depicted as being here.
I guess everyone has to come over to our house next time because we're clearly watching different movies...
Yo Allison, I liked your thoughts about Carol Ann! It felt like I had missed that while watching. I think you're right, though, that she's more a sycophant than a friend.
I can definitely see the ways that one might consider this a bad movie (e.g. "Carol Ann is a symbol of how Crawford was surrounding my enablers and yet Mommie Dearest itself completely missed the symbolism). Those criticisms didn't get to me, though.
Definitely down for a group viewing of a movie at some point though.
Yeah man! Check out the Rusical. Featuring a disco version of the corporal punishment starting at 3:30.
Having never seen or heard of this movie, these write ups were quite the roller coaster. I'm putting together the plot, from context only.
I am enamored by Zach's image of growing steadily more nauseous trying to enjoy his movie grapefruit snack
This is, unironically, my wife's favorite movie. Going to drag her here to take in this discussion, please hold.
DID NOT WATCH BUT WANT MORE ANSWERS:
1) How do the ever changing societal norms for Moms make you look at this movie? Was there more pressure on a woman in the 40s & 50s?
2) Is there a consideration for how Hollywood treats women in her behaviors?
3) When someone cannot conceive a child is adoption an ethical way to get to motherhood?
4) Is God telling you that you aren't equipped to parent if you cannot carry a child?
5) Drag Queens love this movie and cultural reference, but do we know WHY?
People were specifically told that they did not need to do a plot synopsis in their write-up, so here are some plot points that might help you (in the event you do not want to watch the movie).
— Joan forces Tina to continuous race her in the pool, crushing her every single time, even with huge leads.
— Joan steals Tina's soap opera part, but needs cue cards to remember her lines, and they apparently taping this live?
— Joan steals Tina's dolls because Tina was yelling at the dolls like Joan does to Tina and that made Joan feel bad. We are left to assume that the dolls are drowned in a vat of Pepsi Cola.
Currently gearing up the recording equipment for another edition of Your Favorite Movie.
1) More grace and patience with the idea of being upset with your child. There's a line, of course, and Joan crossed it way too many times, but still. What we have here is a well-intentioned mother who just needed a few parenting classes to get her on track.
2) What I'm wondering now is the possibility that this was one of those "boss yells at man, man yells at wife, wife yells at kid, kid yells at dog" type of situations. Hollywood treated Joan Crawford poorly, and so she treated her own children poorly. It's not as simple as that, but that might be an accurate general framing of it.
3) If you're asking the people reading this, then the answer is yes. If you're asking if the movie thought that adoption is legit, then I would say... no? She had to get the adoption approved through back channels, and then much later her children questioned why she had even bothered.
4) They actually didn't touch on WHY Joan Crawford couldn't have biological children, unless I'm forgetting something.
5) I would take a bullet for drag queens' rights to perform their art, so I say this with love and grace: much like any subset of humans that you could find anywhere, some drag queens are literally the dumbest people on earth (either that or they are playing it up while they are on national television).
I think she said early on in the film that she had been pregnant 7 times (could be wrong, but I think I remember that)
That's a good call! Totally forgot about that. So I'll ammend my statement: it was explained but it was never a focus, I don't think.
I thought everyone had very interesting points on the film. That said, nothing changes my rating of the film. It's hard for me to look past so many of the film's shortcomings to appreciate or enjoy it. It was very hard to buy into the movie as I never felt connected to characters. Because the film is biographical, I wish the performances were more human and authentic, which I feel is mostly the result of bad writing.
I do want to say, in case it's not obvious, that I do have empathy for the real Crawfords, regardless of how true or untrue they are portrayed in the movie.
I'm petitioning you to release the original audio recordings for Your Favorite Movie, maybe as a type of broadcast I could listen to on an iPod.
We can do a fun Joan Crawford double-feature with this and then other Never Seen It Entry "What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?" (1962, 134m, Robert Aldrich)
Stephan, I liked that you mentioned your career in behavioral health, and that you used the word "desensitized." I wonder if, being in your position (I feel like I'm in a similar position, career-wise, which is why I'm speaking to this), that the bar is raised in terms of what the movie has to do to get you to feel something about this. Some hypothetical person who has been shielded from any traumatic experiences either in real life or on the screen might watch the film and be GOBSMACKED at what's going on with that wire hanger, while others, those who know that this kind of shit is happening a lot more than you'd think, might need a little more from Mommie Dearest itself. Like, there should be no room for overacting in that case.
Everyone is always talking about podcasts, but how often has anyone ever WRITTEN ABOUT a podcast on the blog? Barely fucking ever (unless you count my ironic attempts at it, or when Rachel S. mentions where she heard about her Record Club pick). That tells me that podcasts are a lesser art. There's nothing else to discuss after the podcast ends. Whereas I'll probably spend a whole week in the Mommie Dearest comment section.
We are covering two movies a week, so if anyone wants me to push a film forward on the schedule and then join me in a Tuesday morning discussion about it, I'm totally down.
After reading everyone's reviews I think most people agreed the movie was kinda "bad" (very broad term) in some way, but some of us embraced that. Maybe camp is tied to the bad somehow? Depending on interpretation it's bad...in a good way? So-bad-it's good? Still mulling that over but it seems to be the through line. Similar to kitsch.
Joe, please publish the audio of us drunkenly making fun of The Last Boy Scout at El Bar.
I think you're probably on the right track, but something about that definition of camp rubs me the wrong way. I feel the same way about the term "guilty pleasure." If you like something, why should you feel guilty about it? If you like something, why can't you just admit that you think it's good instead of donning an ironic shield of "it's bad but"?
Just wanna say I love that we chose this movie. It's pretty divisive in a great way and even though I really enjoyed it I found myself agreeing with almost all the criticisms. Why DID they treat Christopher being strapped to the bed as a throwaway moment?? Wild. Also, I laughed out loud at "morning routine from American Psycho, but for 1930s Hollywood starlets." Spot on. (This is Catherine btw I'm computer illiterate and can only post under anonymous)
Your Favorite Movie as a blog project was about 80% an excuse to get drunk (the other 20% to hang out with friends). There were some good times. I am absolutely not at the point yet where I can listen to an audio recording of drunk Joe talking for multiple hours.
This may seem strange because I loved the movie, and I definitely enjoyed Dunaway's performance, but... was it good? A few of you pointed out that it feels a little off that we know nothing specific about Crawford's mental state or life history, so at times it kind of feels like Faye Dunaway is just blindly playing "crazy." I don't think I can post the screenshot here but there's a moment as the wire hangers/bathroom soap scene is closing that she goes FULLY CROSS-EYED and sort of wiggles her mouth like a cartoon that just got hit with a frying pan and I couldn't help but laugh -- it was such a bizarre acting choice for an extremely heavily emotional scene. I think moments like this are where the drag/camp embrace comes in. It's so over-the-top and cartoonish that it goes from bad to fun. (CZ)
I think the distinction is I genuinely feel it's both good and bad at once. Paris, Texas is probably my favorite movie and I think it's just good. That's all. Mommie Dearest is sort of an unintentional masterpiece. There are a lot of flaws and I don't think the positive reception has anything to do with Frank Perry's intentions. For me, just saying it's a good movie leaves out a lot of context.
Maybe it was my timing of watching the newest episode directly before this movie, but I found myself thinking a lot about Nathan Fielder's the Rehearsal while watching. Specifically what it may have been like for the actors to live these experiences, and if it changed them as people - especially with the traumatic content.
I tried to include some connection in my submission but it felt like I was forcing it just to talk find an excuse to talk about how fucking genius the episode was lol but idk, maybe we can talk about the connection here! Anyone have any insight or thoughts? - Brianna
I definitely felt uncomfortable watching the movie but I don't think that's why I didn't love it. I think the purpose of movies is to feel. Whether it be joy, connection, grief, fear, or any other range of emotions; if you feel it, the movie accomplished something valid and I think that makes even the negative feelings worth it.
Who's this comment above, Catherine? I had planned on watching Paris, Texas by like early July for a Tuesday morning Film Club post. I'm gonna hit you up for a few words if it's your favorite.
Yeah, you're right. And to be clear, "feeling discomfort" can mean a few different things. But mainly, it's either "the movie purposefully intended discomfort" vs. "the audience feels discomfort because of what they are bringing to the film." Maybe the first one is a mark of a good movie, and the second can still come about with bad movies. It feels like we have a little of each throughout the eight write-ups.
I haven't seen the new season at all yet. I thought when you mentioned "timing" you were gonna say how we watched this film right before Mother's Day hahaha. Shout out to all the great mothers out there who keep their wire hangers in the closet where they belong.
Much appreciated for plowing ahead while using the Anonymous handle. Literally no one else on earth uses Blogspot, so I wouldn't even know where to look to figure out how to fix problems like that.
Agreed that this was a great movie pick, though! It's still possible to discuss movies that everyone loves, but it's more fun to talk about movies that some people love and some people hate and all the reasons for those opinions are complicated.
Yep that's me! Hah sorry still having trouble posting under my name. And that sounds great, thanks!
Catherine here. After the pool racing scene, I really loved Joan’s “Why must everything be a competition?” later in the film when Christina won’t eat her dinner. She’s smart enough to psychoanalyze her daughter but completely obvious to her own role in their dynamic. In her mind she can do no wrong. It’s great.
Had a friend (who will hopefully on the blog at some point) tell me that she was part of a film club that watched camp films specifically, and that they all had a good time watching this movie. It made me wonder if I'm being too serious about Mommie Dearest. Like, on one hand, it's tough to laugh about child abuse, but on the other hand, it's a pretty silly movie, and maybe I can just accept the campiness of it. I dunno.
It's nice having all this space to think about a movie over the course of a week, I'll say that.
Curious if any rare moments jumped out for people where Joan is being a "good" mother? It's been a few days now so I can't remember too many, but I read that the soap opera stunt may have been a little kinder than it seemed. Apparently, when Christina was hospitalized the show was planning on killing her character off/completely replacing her. Joan stepped in and played the part to save it for her so her daughter wouldn't lose the job to another young actress. It must've been a little humiliating to play a 25-year-old at 60 so in that regard it could be seen as a selfless act, but obviously with what we seem to know about Joan's ego and competitive streak it could've just been another way to undercut Christina and overshadow her. Who knows, just thought that was interesting. (CZ)
Link here: https://soaps.sheknows.com/soaps/news/582261/daytime-soap-worst-recast-all-time-joan-crawford/
Back to reality - was away from the computer for a few days - so I'm late to the comment party but wow, I'm really impressed with everyone's take. I love how differently everyone saw the movie. This exercise is a smashing success.
I can't see myself ever really watching this movie again but if I do, I want to watch it "Rocky Horror Picture Show" style and completely take it unseriously.
I do appreciate the takes about how hard it is to be a parent. We need to have some compassion for Joan, I think.
I think it was clear that Joan had good intentions, especially at the beginning. "I want you to have what I never had." And being strict is not necessarily bad parenting! I was thinking about this during the scene at the pool where it escalated and Joan put Christina in the pool house. I'll cop to having to basically pick up and throw my kids in their bedroom to cool down. That's a necessity in parenting. The good parenting comes in when both the parent and kid cool down and you have a discussion, which is something we didn't see much of in this film. Doesn't mean it didn't happen. I guess I'm saying that "being strict" is not necessarily bad parenting, and so, in being strict, I saw some flashes of good parenting throughout this film (with a lot of boundary-crossing too, obviously).
Compassion for Joan on Mother's Day especially!!! You're right in that this exercise was a success, because it really highlights how easy it is for different people to view art in completely different ways. That's what I love about movies especially. Questions like "how does being a mom affect how you watch this film" are questions that only arise when we have discussions like this.
Post a Comment