Friday, May 16, 2025

If You Asked for a Picture, Tom


It's always hard to gather thoughts on a condensed timeline. Two weeks isn't always long enough for a record to show off its nuances. But in the spirit of PoYB's original intention for the blog—that is, everyone gets something new and gives first impressions as best they can—I chose Blondshell's latest instead of her two-year-old debut. As a fan of that record, which combined bursts of distortion and rumbling drums that would make any fans of the Cranberries, the Breeders, and Sleater-Kinney say "man, I miss the '90s" with a Jewish / bisexual woman / junkie's (coke, booze, television) views on toxic love (romantic, platonic, sexual, self), I figured she had plenty of material to mine from. This time out though, Sabrina Teitelbaum's padded out her work, stretching each song like saran wrap over a dish that's too big until it threatens to tear. Too many choruses that don't pay off, too much guitar that's neither interesting noise or hooky melody—it just sits there in the middle of the mix like mush. Too unspecific outside of those "tits & ass" and "sixteen, sucking dick" jolts of reality that don't do much to deepen her work outside of Using Sex to Compensate for Self Worth. Too long at 47 minutes. 

I'll keep listening for a bit, maybe something else will reveal itself to me, and in fairness it's competent and pleasant. Every writer in the major publications mentions her "candor" and "unflinching honesty" but she knows, and so do those of us who've had Liz Phair or Rilo Kiley or Hop Along as formative influences, that the trick to her appeal is its treatment of pathology much more than any mere autobiographical detail. Last time it was how in Veronica Mars and "Logan's a dick / I'm learning that's hot," now it's "Part of me never left her in 2012." But it's too little of her spark to justify the end product, at least it is right now to my ears.

3.5 Pukes out of 5

No comments: