Perfume Genius
Week 68: May 17-23, 2020
It's tough to reevaluate your own write, but I attempt to do it consistently. It's also way easier to say that something you wrote fucking sucks than to pat yourself on the back and say good job. So I don't know if I could necessarily name the best review I've written during the first 329 weeks of Record Club. Put a gun to my head and I'll do it, but I don't see no gun, so let's ignore that question, and instead ask: what's my favorite review that I've written?
Also tough, but push comes to shove, I'd choose my review for this Perfume Genius album. I have no idea if this is the type of review that anyone else would live. There's a comment from Sam in the positive, and I know for a fact that RC captain Rachel S. had comments about it (the opinion, not the structure) in the negative, but this review is mainly for me. It cracks me up to read it. And it was one of those reviews that just came to me all at once. I remember sitting in my Port Richmond living room with an infant Martha and toddler Willow and it just smacking me in the face.
After relistening, I stand by pretty much everything that the review says or implies. This is mostly a dour and sad and slow and unfun album. Exceptions, of course, including the aforementioned "Without You," "On the Floor," and "Nothing at All." After a couple listens today, I'd add "Describe" to that list, and maybe "Your Body Changes Everything." But that's it. Everything else stretches way too long. If this really was intended to be a happy album—and why would 2020 Joe lie about that?—then Perfume Genius failed.
Also not a bad album either! I think everyone was pretty on-point when we gave a collective "meh." I don't think there should be any pressure on a Record Club captain's part to choose albums that people are going to love. I also don't think you should choose albums that you already love, because then you won't be upset when no one else loves it.
But I understand the temptation, and I have a lot of empathy for that position. In fact, we could even look at an album selection last year as a sort of cosmic payback for RC shrugging their shoulders at Rachel's first two picks (the other was MUNA). Rachel's team for RC Team Battle Royale chose Waxahatchee's Tigers Blood, an album that I had already fallen in love with by an artist who is incredibly special to me... and most people kinda went "meh." And that fucking hurt! It was honestly shocking how taken aback I was when it happened.
But I understand the temptation, and I have a lot of empathy for that position. In fact, we could even look at an album selection last year as a sort of cosmic payback for RC shrugging their shoulders at Rachel's first two picks (the other was MUNA). Rachel's team for RC Team Battle Royale chose Waxahatchee's Tigers Blood, an album that I had already fallen in love with by an artist who is incredibly special to me... and most people kinda went "meh." And that fucking hurt! It was honestly shocking how taken aback I was when it happened.
So I get it! But I'm also not going to pull any punches when a sadboi does his sadboi shtick. "On the Floor" was worth the price of admission, though. And I appreciated the opportunity to make a joke.

No comments:
Post a Comment