Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.
...And Star Power is a bizarre fucking album. I may be in the minority here, but I believe that that makes it a great album, too. There's no denying that the musical stylings of Foxygen are all over the goddamn place on this album. You want psychedelic freakouts? Here's "Cold Winter/Freedom" or "Brooklyn Police Station." You want tender ballads? Try "Coulda Been My Love" or "Everybody Needs Love." You want probably one of the best singles of the decade? "How Can You Really" is right there, waiting for you on track #2.
Not everything works, but that's how these types of albums go. "Revolution #9" is probably the worst song of all time but you don't see me shitting on the White Album, do you? The sheer heft of this thing, the everything-and-the-kitchen-sink mentality of ...And Star Power, that's what makes it fun! That you can go from the hillbilly stomp of "666" to the sad dirge of "Flowers" at the drop of a dime. It's neat!
The central hook in the narrative of ...And Star Power (and it's a flimsy one, as these things usually go) is that this isn't "Foxygen" playing these songs; they've created a fictional band within the album, called "Star Power." Star Power, you see, plays all kinds of wacky shit on their own radio station (also called "Star Power"). Hence the wide variety of tunes you hear on the album. This is STAR POWER throwing shit against the wall, and if you don't like it, well, that's not Foxygen's fault, now is it?!
The precedent that Foxygen wants you to think about here, clearly, is the Beatles, when they played songs as "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band." Paul thought that creating an alter ego band would free up the Beatles to have the "freedom to experiment musically." And true, Foxygen pushes themselves sonically in a similar fashion to the 1967 Beatles: out of their comfort zone, creating sounds that may not be familiar to the audience.
But listening to ...And Star Power, I often think of another alter ego band—Pink Floyd's "Surrogate Band" on The Wall. The narrative in that song cycle is that of a band leader who isolates himself from the world. So, if Foxygen is creating an alter ego band in the same vein as The Wall, then the question becomes: From whom is Foxygen isolating themselves? Why are they building a figurative "wall"? Why are they using a fictional band to distract from the real band standing right in front of us?
The answer quite possibly could be that the band's inner turmoil was taking its toll. Here's an old article from Pitchfork, describing a since-deleted blog post from a band member, who wrote in the post that the two leads of Foxygen, Jonathan Rado and Sam France, were having large issues with each other (issues that lead to an onstage meltdown and a cancelled tour, among other concerns).
And the first four or five songs on ...And Star Power all touch on the theme of broken relationships. On a surface level, there's someone hurt by romance gone wrong, but when you look at it in the context of the band Foxygen itself, it's pretty clear that the broken relationship is between Rado and France. They are singing about themselves.
But then on track six, "Star Power" starts their own trip, and the songs of love and loss go away till the two-song coda at the end of the album. Could it be that Foxygen said at a certain point, "Fuck it, Foxygen has too many issues, let's just pretend we are band called 'Star Power' and maybe all our issues will go away"?
Possibly. Not really our business to know. But it's an interesting thought (one that no one touched on during various interviews with the band in 2014, as far as I could tell). I mean, Foxygen is still together, and put out the even better Hang in 2017. So maybe Star Power was a success in more ways than one.
This is a crazy ass album, and even if it sounds like you are going to hate it, you gotta try it at least once.
...And Star Power
Foxygen
2014
...And Star Power is a bizarre fucking album. I may be in the minority here, but I believe that that makes it a great album, too. There's no denying that the musical stylings of Foxygen are all over the goddamn place on this album. You want psychedelic freakouts? Here's "Cold Winter/Freedom" or "Brooklyn Police Station." You want tender ballads? Try "Coulda Been My Love" or "Everybody Needs Love." You want probably one of the best singles of the decade? "How Can You Really" is right there, waiting for you on track #2.
Not everything works, but that's how these types of albums go. "Revolution #9" is probably the worst song of all time but you don't see me shitting on the White Album, do you? The sheer heft of this thing, the everything-and-the-kitchen-sink mentality of ...And Star Power, that's what makes it fun! That you can go from the hillbilly stomp of "666" to the sad dirge of "Flowers" at the drop of a dime. It's neat!
The central hook in the narrative of ...And Star Power (and it's a flimsy one, as these things usually go) is that this isn't "Foxygen" playing these songs; they've created a fictional band within the album, called "Star Power." Star Power, you see, plays all kinds of wacky shit on their own radio station (also called "Star Power"). Hence the wide variety of tunes you hear on the album. This is STAR POWER throwing shit against the wall, and if you don't like it, well, that's not Foxygen's fault, now is it?!
The precedent that Foxygen wants you to think about here, clearly, is the Beatles, when they played songs as "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band." Paul thought that creating an alter ego band would free up the Beatles to have the "freedom to experiment musically." And true, Foxygen pushes themselves sonically in a similar fashion to the 1967 Beatles: out of their comfort zone, creating sounds that may not be familiar to the audience.
But listening to ...And Star Power, I often think of another alter ego band—Pink Floyd's "Surrogate Band" on The Wall. The narrative in that song cycle is that of a band leader who isolates himself from the world. So, if Foxygen is creating an alter ego band in the same vein as The Wall, then the question becomes: From whom is Foxygen isolating themselves? Why are they building a figurative "wall"? Why are they using a fictional band to distract from the real band standing right in front of us?
The answer quite possibly could be that the band's inner turmoil was taking its toll. Here's an old article from Pitchfork, describing a since-deleted blog post from a band member, who wrote in the post that the two leads of Foxygen, Jonathan Rado and Sam France, were having large issues with each other (issues that lead to an onstage meltdown and a cancelled tour, among other concerns).
And the first four or five songs on ...And Star Power all touch on the theme of broken relationships. On a surface level, there's someone hurt by romance gone wrong, but when you look at it in the context of the band Foxygen itself, it's pretty clear that the broken relationship is between Rado and France. They are singing about themselves.
But then on track six, "Star Power" starts their own trip, and the songs of love and loss go away till the two-song coda at the end of the album. Could it be that Foxygen said at a certain point, "Fuck it, Foxygen has too many issues, let's just pretend we are band called 'Star Power' and maybe all our issues will go away"?
Possibly. Not really our business to know. But it's an interesting thought (one that no one touched on during various interviews with the band in 2014, as far as I could tell). I mean, Foxygen is still together, and put out the even better Hang in 2017. So maybe Star Power was a success in more ways than one.
This is a crazy ass album, and even if it sounds like you are going to hate it, you gotta try it at least once.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Star Power III: What Are We Good For" (I couldn't find a video of just Part III, so you're stuck with "Star Power" parts I-IV in that link. Part III starts around the four-minute mark, I believe.)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Stray Observations
- I'm obviously not the first person to think that the volatile working relationship between France and Rado had an influence on the album's creation. The new point I'm trying to make here is that the alter ego band created here, Star Power, was itself the distraction they provided to heal wounds.
- Concerns of problems within Foxygen continued after 2014, when they tricked everyone into thinking they were breaking up by announcing a "Farewell Tour." As it turns out, they weren't saying farewell to Foxygen, they were saying farewell to their alter egos, Star Power. Gotchya!
- Does anyone else think about the drinking game Kings when they hear the countdown on "666"? Just me? Okay.
- FRONT COVER: A portrait of who I assume are France and Rado, creating music. This ostensibly to show that, NO, WE ARE NOT FIGHTING, LOOK AT US WORKING TOGETHER LIKE GOOD FRIENDS.
- Despite knowing the bare minimum about Foxygen, I'm just chock full of theories about how they operate as a band. Wait until we cover 2017's Hang, when I'll tell you all about how the scmaltzy, corny (but so, so fun) sounds on that album are a direct response to critic's reactions to ...And Star Power.
NEXT TIME: Andrew Bird & the Mysterious Production of Eggs by Andrew Bird

No comments:
Post a Comment