Wednesday, August 16, 2023

Summer Song Challenge, Day 80: Joe

Prompt: "A song about a man"

Selected by Joe


"The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down"
The Band
The Band, 1969

Back when you could choose a song to start whenever anyone visited your Xanga page, I had "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" playing while you read all about the mundane exploits of a young man from Northeast Philly. I remember at least one person misheard my own name in the opening lyrics of the song, and I had to explain that, no, they were actually saying "Virgil Caine is the name." But it's kinda close! Virgil definitely spells his last name incorrectly, but they are homonyms!

The fact that I dropped a sincere Xanga reference in the preceding paragraph was meant to inform the reader that I've liked this song for a long time. That was like '06 or '07. In 2012, the song's singer Levon Helm passed away, and to honor him, I sang this song at karaoke that night. (Sidenote: I got it mixed up when we were writing about our karaoke songs earlier in the summer. It wasn't "The Weight." My bad.) And now the songwriter, Robbie Robertson, has passed away, and I mourn his loss the same, though I unfortunately won't have the opportunity to sing this song in public this time around.

About once a year or so, I go through the mental audit for this song, and internally discuss anew whether it's "okay" to unabashedly love it. The big concern is that this story is told from the perspective of a Confederate soldier, and as we all know, the Confederacy existed to protect the heinous idea of slavery. Anyone who still supports this traitorous faction from American history is a racist, point blank. And yet here we are, listening to a song that seems to have some sympathy for its characters, who are from the South during the Civil War, and who are Confederate soldiers.

It's an idea worth discussing, I would argue. And I think that it's possible to do so while staying true to my ideals when it comes to art, while also stay clear of the rabid mouth-foaming culture war acolytes.

We can draw the first line between fiction and non-fiction. I think there would be a big difference if Virgil Caine was a real person. It would be much easier to view this song as, like, "honoring the Confederate hero Virgil Caine," which would be bad, since that would be honoring someone who was pro-slavery. It's fiction, and so there's one point in its favor.

But fiction could easily be sympathetic toward the racists too. If telling the fictional tale of Virgil Caine made it clear that the Band or Robbie Robertson were pro-slavery, then that could also be a problem. Parse through the lyrics, and I don't think you could make that argument either. I would say that Robertson deftly builds a case for empathy on a human level, and not an ideological level. Virgil Caine is a former soldier, back at home after the war is over, and his family is struggling mightily. There's a sense of regret, too, in the lyrics. He doesn't regret anything specific, i.e. any given reason why the war was fought in the first place. He more regrets that the war took place at all, since it was a doomed effort and now he and his family and his neighbors are suffering severe consequences.

There is a narrow focus to "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down." This isn't a song designed to address any broader topics regarding the Civil War. It's instead a fictional but based-on-a-true-story-probably tale of struggle and pain, post-war. Here is a man that was wrapped up in machinations much larger than himself, and that same machine appears content to spit him out and forget about him, and that makes him sad, and bitter, and cold. Robertson is asking you to empathize with those feelings, and nothing more.

In this way, "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" kind of reminds me of "Kim." This is the same argument I was making to Bob when he claimed that Eminem was ripe for "cancellation" because of this song. There's a huge fucking difference between a story about characters acting in a reprehensible way, and the author of that story acting in a reprehensible way. Yes, of course the idea of murdering your partner in a homicidal rage is objectionable, but the man in "Kim" is a fiction. The song then asks you to consider whether Eminem himself feels this way, and if you yourself have ever felt that way, i.e. so fucking angry that you'd commit violence. As far as I know, Eminem has not committed the felony of murder.

The two can be connected, though. Not in either of these cases, but they could, is my point. Like, it would also be bad if, through "Kim," Eminem was advocating for the listener to kill their significant others, either directly or indirectly. I listened to "Kim" a few times after Bob chose it, and I just don't hear anything like that. What it sounds like to me is a self-hating author who is attempting to channel his very worst impulses into a song as a sort of self-cleansing. The lyrics are ugly by design. They are ugly so that the listener will be repulsed by them. That's the point.

So what I think an audit of "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" would entail is examining the intentions of the its author. If his intentions were to valorize a racist, then that would be enough for me to be uncomfortable listening to this song. But I hear the song and I read the lyrics and I can't help but think that Virgil Caine is closer to Kim's killer than, like, "The Ballad of the Green Berets." Robertson and Helm are finding empathy in a dark place. They are presenting this character as a failure, a man who backed the wrong cause and is paying the price, and the song is then daring you to feel bad for him anyway. The resistance and the emotional confusion is the point, I think. Like, if you sympathize with this sad, fictional character, then what does that say about you? The audit of the song becomes an audit of the self.

When I sang this song during karaoke, and when I sing it alone in my car, and when I sing along to it yet again today when I hit play on the embedded YouTube video, I'm not honoring the traitors who loved slavery so much that they tried to leave their own country. Fuck out of here with that shit. I'm honoring the Band, and I'm honoring the men in that band called the Band, and I'm honoring the idea of songwriting in general, that we can find real, true human emotion in what amounts to a fictional tale, and we can sing along to it, loudly, sing along to this idea that the human condition and the struggle is universal. That's what I think about when I hear this song about this man.

And this doesn't even mention that 4/5ths of the Band's members were Canadian.

No comments: