Friday, August 25, 2023

Summer Song Challenge, Day 89: Sam

Prompt: "A live version that just hits better than the official version"

Selected by Sam


"Julia (Live)"
Limbeck
Hey, Everything's Fine., 2003

Nothing in music to me will ever be as good as the live Limbeck album. It's the perfect moment recorded in time that may very well mean more to me than to the band. Essentially, the band released a studio album and recorded an acoustic version of the songs at a house party. There are mistakes where they have to start song a few times, and the band members get pissy with each other. Justin, the lead singer of Motion City Soundtrack, was there, and sings. I had $5 in my pocket, and bought this off the band at a show at the TLA. 

Nate and Robb M****** caught the fever, and felt the feels I felt. I lived in a basement apartment with them one summer in Ventor City, NJ. It was not nearly as fun as it should have been. But we listened to a lot of music in the rats nest (as dubbed by Liz W*****), including this album. 

I've never experienced the perfect opposite reaction of this live album being so good and the recorded album (Hi, Everything's Great.) it’s based on being so bad. Robb saw Limbeck later and referenced the live album to them. The members laughed and enjoyed his reference, but no one had a copy of the album anymore. It didn't exist. It's not streamable or available for purchase.

No comments: