Prompt: "A demo, B-side, or alternate take that just hits better than the official version"
Selected by Joe
"Major Label Debut (Fast)"
Broken Social Scene
EP to Be You and Me EP, 2005
Broken Social Scene isn't a perfect album, because there are no perfect albums. But it gets a lot closer than most. It's one of the best of all time. It was the perfect blend of quality and timing. The right album at the right time in my life. You know the deal. I don't need to explain to you what the term "my favorite music" means. You get it.
As a whole, this album comprised of fourteen songs is amazing, but taken as fourteen separate pieces of art, there are understandably a few weak links. "Major Label Debut" is one of them. Relative to the history of music, it's a great song; relative to some of the other all-timers on this tracklist, it falls sorta flat. It lacks a strong backbeat, is my main problem (ain't it always). There's a rhythm but it's slight and messy at the same time. Broken Social Scene leaves a lot of room on all their albums for these sort of hang-out-and-chill jammy-type songs, and I totally ride with 'em. Not only because even the unrestrained messes are usually on my frequency anyway, but because they make the solid hits stand out even further.
The weird thing is that "Major Label Debut" could have been one of those hits, if they had just tweaked a couple of things. The weirder thing is that the band already fixed the issues and had a better version of the song sitting right there, and for some reason chose to go with the murky, cluttered version for the proper album instead. What's apparently known as "Major Label Debut (Fast)" is found on a bonus EP that came with original copies of the proper album. It's a lot better. Again, it's better mainly due to the fact that it's uptempo and has a driving drum beat.
It's not my place to speculate as to why the subjectively worse version was chosen for Broken Social Scene. They had their reasons. There were enough people involved in the rotating collective of musicians that maybe there was a vote at one point, or maybe someone made a snap decision without consulting anyone. It could also be that the faster version would disrupt the overall flow of the album. I think I can see an argument there. "7/4 (Shoreline)" has a similar rhythm two songs prior, and maybe "Major Label Debut (Fast)" would've sounded like a lesser version of it too soon after. Who knows, man!
As a whole, this album comprised of fourteen songs is amazing, but taken as fourteen separate pieces of art, there are understandably a few weak links. "Major Label Debut" is one of them. Relative to the history of music, it's a great song; relative to some of the other all-timers on this tracklist, it falls sorta flat. It lacks a strong backbeat, is my main problem (ain't it always). There's a rhythm but it's slight and messy at the same time. Broken Social Scene leaves a lot of room on all their albums for these sort of hang-out-and-chill jammy-type songs, and I totally ride with 'em. Not only because even the unrestrained messes are usually on my frequency anyway, but because they make the solid hits stand out even further.
The weird thing is that "Major Label Debut" could have been one of those hits, if they had just tweaked a couple of things. The weirder thing is that the band already fixed the issues and had a better version of the song sitting right there, and for some reason chose to go with the murky, cluttered version for the proper album instead. What's apparently known as "Major Label Debut (Fast)" is found on a bonus EP that came with original copies of the proper album. It's a lot better. Again, it's better mainly due to the fact that it's uptempo and has a driving drum beat.
It's not my place to speculate as to why the subjectively worse version was chosen for Broken Social Scene. They had their reasons. There were enough people involved in the rotating collective of musicians that maybe there was a vote at one point, or maybe someone made a snap decision without consulting anyone. It could also be that the faster version would disrupt the overall flow of the album. I think I can see an argument there. "7/4 (Shoreline)" has a similar rhythm two songs prior, and maybe "Major Label Debut (Fast)" would've sounded like a lesser version of it too soon after. Who knows, man!
All I know is that "Major Label Debut (Fast)" is better, but Broken Social Scene is so good that it doesn't even matter. There are so many paths left not taken for this band, for me, for us, for this world, so many alternate decisions that might've had no consequence or that might have changed the entire face of human history. We don't know, because time moves linearly, and we can't go back or retroactively change it.
We can use it as a thought exercise though: What if?
We can use it as a thought exercise though: What if?
What I'm proposing at this juncture is that we ask that question but apply it to the choices I've made in the past 87 days during our Summer Song Challenge. What if: I hadn't made the personal rule that I wasn't going to pick more than one song from any given album (since I already chose "It's All Gonna Break" for a prompt in mid-June)? And, more importantly—What if: I had made an effort to choose every single song from Broken Social Scene's 2005 self-titled album at least once during my SSC experience?
Let's take the path not taken out of the hypothetical and place them firmly in this physical reality. Here's a brief snippet of what my summer might have looked like. (For the sake of my sanity in this endeavor, let's tack on one more form of that question. What if: I didn't feel the need to write so goddamn much about everything?)
Let's take the path not taken out of the hypothetical and place them firmly in this physical reality. Here's a brief snippet of what my summer might have looked like. (For the sake of my sanity in this endeavor, let's tack on one more form of that question. What if: I didn't feel the need to write so goddamn much about everything?)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 1: Joe
Prompt: "A song about beginnings"
Selected by Joe
"Our Faces Split the Coast in Half"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
To me, this song says "beginnings" in so many ways. But that could just be me. It's not quite an instrumental, but anything that anyone is saying is mostly unintelligible (that might be Feist, but you can never be quite sure with this band). And so, we impose our own meanings, and the meaning that I impose is: beginnings. The beginning of the album. The beginning of what I considered at the time to be one of my first big boy steps into the real adult world of indie rock music ("indie" as a genre, not as a label signifier or lack thereof). The beginning of this summer-long music project! Hi everyone! Welcome to Summer Song Challenge 2023! I can't wait to spend the next 98 days with all SIXTEEN of you on this blog. WOW. Thanks for the huge turnout. I have no doubt whatsoever that these numbers will remain high throughout every day of the summer. Let's get started.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 17: Joe
Prompt: "A song that makes you think of your favorite book"
Selected by Joe
"Ibi Dreams of Pavement (A Better Day)"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
Fuck Infinite Jest, that book is for LOSERS. Here's my actual favorite book of all time—The Angel Riots by Ibi Kaslik. It's at a tight 286 pages (and NO FOOTNOTES, imagine that), and it's about a rising indie rock band from Montreal. Sound familiar? Kaslik says not to go looking for Kevin Drew, Brendan Canning, et al., in the pages of his novel, but you can't help it sometimes, especially when you realize that Kaslik went to school with some of the band members at Etobicoke School of the Arts... and that the second song on their best album is named in honor of their pal.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 29: Joe
Prompt: "A song in a weird time signature (i.e. not 4/4 or 3/4)"
Selected by Joe
"7/4 (Shoreline)"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
There will come a day when I will be forced to explain why "7/4 (Shoreline)" is one of my favorite songs of all time, point blank, period, no weird-time-signature qualifier required. Today is not that day, fortunately, because I ain't no good on writing bout the musics. All I know is that it's a shoreline, and it's a high speed, and it's a cruel world, and that it's been that way for almost two decades now.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 61: Joe
Prompt: "A song whose lyrics describe someone eating something"
Selected by Joe
"Finish Your Collapse and Stay for Breakfast"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
Alright, so this is a bit of a cheat, since the song is an instrumental, LOL, but bear with me. The title indicates that you should finish your collapse and then stay for breakfast. After your collapse, in other words, you should stay and eat some food. Some breakfast food. For breakfast. It's all there in the title, and if you can't see it, then I don't know if I can explain it to you any further than I already have in this state-mandated 50 words that I have typed out in between work emails.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 25: Joe
Prompt: "A song that, if the cute person sitting next to you on the bus let you borrow their earbuds and hear this song, you'd be like, 'Damn, this person is cool'"
Selected by Joe
"Major Label Debut"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
What I'm told I SHOULD have said was: "This prompt is WRONG this prompt is BAD I am MARRIED and I will NOT speak to ANYONE who attempts to engage me in conversation on THE BUS." Let's spell out exactly how this conversation would go, for all those still doubting my marital fidelity.
JOE: [minding his own business]
HUMAN OF A NON-SPECIFIED GENDER IN JOE'S GENERAL VICINITY DURING AN AFTERNOON COMMUTE WHO BY ALL REASONABLE MEASURES WOULD PROBABLY BE SUBJECTIVELY RATED AS "CUTE" BY THE MAJORITY OF HUMANS WHO ARE ATTRACTED TO THEIR GENDER, WHICH IS, AGAIN, NON-SPECIFIED FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS HYPOTHETICAL SCENARIO: Hi.
JOE: [removing headphones] What's that?
HUMAN: I said "Hi."
JOE: Oh. Hi.
HUMAN: What are you listening to?
JOE: [removing headphones yet again] I'm sorry?
HUMAN: I asked you what you're listening to.
JOE: Um... Broken Social Scene.
HUMAN: Oh, is it the 2005 self-titled album by that band? Nice. I've been meaning to check that out. Would you say you'd recommend it to me? Do you like the fifth song, titled "Major Label Debut"? I heard that's a good one.
JOE: [minding his own business]
HUMAN OF A NON-SPECIFIED GENDER IN JOE'S GENERAL VICINITY DURING AN AFTERNOON COMMUTE WHO BY ALL REASONABLE MEASURES WOULD PROBABLY BE SUBJECTIVELY RATED AS "CUTE" BY THE MAJORITY OF HUMANS WHO ARE ATTRACTED TO THEIR GENDER, WHICH IS, AGAIN, NON-SPECIFIED FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS HYPOTHETICAL SCENARIO: Hi.
JOE: [removing headphones] What's that?
HUMAN: I said "Hi."
JOE: Oh. Hi.
HUMAN: What are you listening to?
JOE: [removing headphones yet again] I'm sorry?
HUMAN: I asked you what you're listening to.
JOE: Um... Broken Social Scene.
HUMAN: Oh, is it the 2005 self-titled album by that band? Nice. I've been meaning to check that out. Would you say you'd recommend it to me? Do you like the fifth song, titled "Major Label Debut"? I heard that's a good one.
JOE: No, the fast version is better.
HUMAN: Oh, cool, I'm not even familiar with that B-side version. Can you tell me more about it? Since we clearly have the same taste in music based on what you told me you are listening to and what I know for a fact that I personally enjoy listening to. I have no ulterior motives here, by the way, I just figured that this might be a nice way to spend 20 minutes of my day, conversing with a stranger in a totally platonic way. What do you say?
JOE: This is my stop.
HUMAN: Oh, cool, I'm not even familiar with that B-side version. Can you tell me more about it? Since we clearly have the same taste in music based on what you told me you are listening to and what I know for a fact that I personally enjoy listening to. I have no ulterior motives here, by the way, I just figured that this might be a nice way to spend 20 minutes of my day, conversing with a stranger in a totally platonic way. What do you say?
JOE: This is my stop.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 4: Joe
Prompt: "A song that makes you think about something somebody said about that song, a while ago"
Selected by Joe
"Fire Eye'd Boy"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
this song makes me think of the time that my priest said that this song was about the DEVIL and that i should repent if i wanted to make it into heaven and i said but father it's just about a young man like myself who is excited about the world and all that it is in it b/c he feels the hope and the possibility and the flames in his eyes are a metaphor don't you see father and father just looked at me and said turn around and bend over and then i don't even want to tell you what happened next but let me tell you that the fire has been extinguished from my own eyes ever since
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 46: Joe
Prompt: "If you were a professional athlete, a song that you'd like the guy in charge of the stadium soundtrack to play as you emerge from the locker room, in order to hype the audience up"
Selected by Joe
"Windsurfing Nation"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
Not only is windsurfing technically a professional sport and thus technically you might have the, um, windsurfing hype man / DJ play this song on the PA loudspeakers during the, uh, windsurfing match(?) at the beach(??)... but also, consider the lyrics in the chorus:
This sounds to me like a back and forth between the sports entertainer and their audience. All "they" (i.e. the audience) want is to feel "it" (i.e. the sweet thrill of victory), and yet the sports entertainer is upfront with them—we won't always be the winners that you wish us to be (oh no), but we are going to try our very hardest, every night, here, in front of you, the paying audience, our loyal fans. The, er, the windsurfing fans.
"All they want is to feel it
(We won't be what you want to be, oh no!)"
This sounds to me like a back and forth between the sports entertainer and their audience. All "they" (i.e. the audience) want is to feel "it" (i.e. the sweet thrill of victory), and yet the sports entertainer is upfront with them—we won't always be the winners that you wish us to be (oh no), but we are going to try our very hardest, every night, here, in front of you, the paying audience, our loyal fans. The, er, the windsurfing fans.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 54: Joe
Prompt: "A song that starts and ends with the same letter in its title"
Selected by Joe
"Swimmers"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
I was like eighteen or nineteen years old. I was in Wildwood, NJ for the annual family trip. That year, a couple of my cousins-not-related were down there too. Harry and Andrew. I feel like I've already documented a few of our trio's various shore-town exploits on this blog already, but here's one in miniature.
One day, we decided that we are going to spend the day sneaking into every single motel pool in the entire town, and swimming in each one. There are well over a 100 in just North Wildwood, but this somehow still seemed like a reasonable goal to three teenagers. During the very first attempt, at the very first motel pool, the owner chased us away with a baseball bat.
One day, we decided that we are going to spend the day sneaking into every single motel pool in the entire town, and swimming in each one. There are well over a 100 in just North Wildwood, but this somehow still seemed like a reasonable goal to three teenagers. During the very first attempt, at the very first motel pool, the owner chased us away with a baseball bat.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 78: Joe
Prompt: "A song that has a prominent sample"
Selected by Joe
"Hotel"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
Not sure if this is a technically sample OH WELL we're just going with the flow at this point in the summer. Here's what BSS quasi-frontman Kevin Drew has to say about the song:
Feist is in the band (sometimes) and so I'm not sure if this is technically a sample, since she's involved and, like, didn't have to clear a sample for herself. Actually, I'm realizing now that I really don't know how samples works. How does anyone get paid? How does music as a business make any sense whatsoever? Can't we all just forget about all that and enjoy the weirdness of "Hotel"?
"We've been playing 'Hotel,' which started as 'One Evening,' a Feist song, a remix that the band [Jason Collett, Andrew Whiteman, Brendan Caning and Justin Peroff] had together, and [David Newfeld] took that song and he just chopped it up, mutated it, played a lot of parts on it, and turned it into this great song which we titled 'Hotel.'"
Feist is in the band (sometimes) and so I'm not sure if this is technically a sample, since she's involved and, like, didn't have to clear a sample for herself. Actually, I'm realizing now that I really don't know how samples works. How does anyone get paid? How does music as a business make any sense whatsoever? Can't we all just forget about all that and enjoy the weirdness of "Hotel"?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 90: Joe
Prompt: "A non-holiday song for your favorite holiday"
Selected by Joe
"Handjobs for the Holidays"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
Ah SHIT, we're not up to this prompt yet. Whoops. I will now fill out the remainder of my 50 words by repeating the word "fuck." FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 14: Joe
Prompt: "A song that makes you think of your hometown"
Selected by Joe
"Superconnected"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
"But I really don't want to think about those things anymore
No, I really don't want to think about those things."
I grew up in Northeast Philadelphia. I escaped. But something about it drew me back in. And now here I am.
I really don't want to think about those things anymore.
LOL, jk, this is Puke on Your Birthday, that's all I write about.
Great song, P.S.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 10: Joe
Prompt: "A song you'd describe as 'not enough'"
Selected by Joe
"Bandwitch"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
On a totally different song on this album (the end of "Windsurfing Nation" leading into "Swimmers"), Emily Haines mutters "Gimme more of that beat." That's a good directive. That's what you should always be asking of your favorite music. Gimme more of that motherfucking beat! Bummer that BSS didn't listen to their own advice on "Bandwitch," maybe the only song that dips below the good/bad line on the entire album. It's all good! Some nice sounds here. Maybe we can consider it a breather. I just wish it didn't do the annoying thing where the drum beat goes in and out and sometimes completely disappears for some reason, occasionally right in the middle of a measure. OH WELL!!!!! I'll live.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 13: Joe
Prompt: "A song that probably should have been playing the first time you had sex"
Selected by Joe
"Tremoloa Debut"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
Just like this song, I ended in LESS THAN A MINUTE.
I will now spend the remainder of my 50 words apologizing to the reader for yet again being forced to relive with me the experience of a young drunk hairy elf Joe K*** having sex for the first time.
I'm sorry.
I will now spend the remainder of my 50 words apologizing to the reader for yet again being forced to relive with me the experience of a young drunk hairy elf Joe K*** having sex for the first time.
I'm sorry.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Summer Song Challenge, Day 43: Joe
Prompt: "A song that's so much better than 'Bohemian Rhapsody' that it honestly makes 'Bohemian Rhapsody' sound like the Mister Softee jingle"
Selected by Joe
"It's All Gonna Break"
Broken Social Scene
Broken Social Scene, 2005
3 comments:
I envy your ability to commit to the bit.
This is Joe's Avengers: Endgame.
Tomorrow's write-up is my Captain America: Civil War (I think... I've never actually seen any of these movies)
Post a Comment