1. Were you happy with the reviews that were published? How do you feel about your week as Record Club captain?
The fact that more than one person took the time to write a review made me feel pretty good about captaining this week. As for the reviews themselves, I was satisfied overall, and found most to be honest and thoughtful.
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
Reviewers identified and responded to different elements of the album, but I got the impression that most felt very similar about the album. While a good length and generally enjoyable, the album's overly familiar sound and themes don't resonate as deeply to listeners in their 30s.
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
There was a single review that flat out did not like the album. While that review didn't get into the why, it did make wonder if perhaps I went into this review too heavily influenced by generally positive takes on the album. As mentioned in my "Why I chose this album?", I was pulled this selection from an article, "50 Essential Albums You've Probably Never Heard," which speaks briefly on the album's influence. Perhaps, if I had just selected this album blindly, and gave it a listen, I would have had a different experience?
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
Yes. Except for me, no one addressed the album's crudeness. I'm probably just overly sensitive, but there were times when some of the language used really felt hateful. I spoke briefly about this in a separate email offline (off-blog?), touching upon the use of homophobic language. There were also instances in which I felt they spoke meanly to women. Like I said in my review, they were young and dumb as I once was so it's forgivable and understandable.
That said, I hope I don't come across as judgmental or that this is a huge deal that needs be talked about, I was just surprised it wasn't mentioned by others is all.
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
I feel positive about my selection. I suppose it's a success in that the album wasn't polarizing and didn't receive any scathing reactions. I was pleased with the turnout, but I am greedy, and I wonder what kind of album would draw even more contributors. I guess I'll have to captain more often to find out.
6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?
Although it was challenging to choose and respond to a genre that I’m not well versed in, it was actually the most fun(?) experience I have had captaining. I think the added challenge allowed me to think a bit differently, which helped my writing.
7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?
As a captain, I think there is a general fear of choosing a "bad" of "lame" album. I fall into this trapping and tend to choose albums that I have heard are, at least, half decent. Also, sticking to what you know tends to be common for captaining. I ended up feeling pretty good about this pick that was foreign to me. To both things, I'd say just go for it.
As a listener/writer, I personally struggle with commitment since I'm not specifically obligated to contribute when I'm not captaining. Not sure how I can remedy that for myself.

No comments:
Post a Comment