Friday, August 18, 2023

I Feel Alright, Joe


I love the word "alright." Such a wide range of emotions that could be embedded in that one word. You could use it as the portmanteau of "all" and "right" and assume that someone who is "all right" is experiencing nothing wrong. You could also use it as a defense mechanism, as in "there are many things going wrong right now, but I'm concentrating on all the right things anyway." Listening to "Feel Alright" by Steve Earle makes me think that he's gunning for that second definition. The verses are awash in darkness and despair, but the chorus is a defiant stand against the pain: "I feel alright."

I feel more than alright listening to this album. That should probably be the main thesis of this album review, even though we all know it won't be when I'm through with it. This is a good album. It's catchy, it's dusty and gritty, it's triumphant, it's heart-on-sleeve, it's pure entertainment, it's a distillation of everything country music should be. It's good enough that I'm seriously gonna be pissed if we get the usual slate of "well, country isn't really my thing" equivocations this week. There's a whole wide world of music out there! If you're letting the Aldeans of the world shape your understanding of what country music is, then YOU are at fault! Try harder.

It's not hard with Steve Earle, an outlaw in the tradition of the Highwaymen (country music well before it split into multiple factions), but with a modern sense of that rock 'n' roll sound. Plenty of genre names speak to this sound—country rock, alt-country, Southern rock, Americana, pick your poison—but my point is that this is rock music within the country tradition. The themes are pure country, but the sound only has country flair. Electric guitars loom large (rock), the harmonica is a constant presence (more folk), plus some outliers (the orchestration on "Valentine's Day" is very pretty and decidedly not country). What I'm saying is don't take the fucking bait—this isn't just "alright," and you cannot possibly use your feelings about "country music" to dismiss what is ultimately a really great album, regardless of genre.

This is the best "country music" album we've listened to since Adeem the Artist. You can easily draw a line between the two. Steve Earle is an outlaw in the traditional sense. Adeem the Artist is an outlaw in an extremely modern sense. Both were and are working the sidelines of popular music due to their respective identities—Earle literally running away from home to find community in the 1980s Nashville alt-country scene, and Adeem blazing brand new ground within the descendent country scene, out and proud and inclusive and working in a space that transcends geography (but not tradition).

I like that we're here because "Feel Alright" soundtracks the Season 2-ending montage of The Wire (maaaybe it's best season? but maybe I'm just saying that because I've been listening to Steve Earle all week). It makes sense, because that TV show is similarly about people living in the margins. The beaten and forgotten. The use of "alright" in that montage is clearly using the second definition, if not moving past that into straight-up irony. The characters in The Wire are definitively not alright. None of us are, when you think about it. But I appreciate the perverse sense of optimism that this song, and this album, bring to the table in that context. We're alright, because we're all trying our best, despite, ya know, everything.

But I Feel Alright works best when it's clicking in both gears—heartbreakingly true-to-life stories, and uptempo rock music. It falters slightly in the back half whenever it concentrates solely on the former (e.g. "CCKMP," which is bleak in a good way, but also not very fun). It's not "alright" according to the first definition. There are occasional missteps, few but notable. But with every too-slow dirge, we get something like "The Unrepentant" right around the corner, with its heavy-as-fuck rhythm keeping this thing moving like a fucking bulldozer. I'm not really complaining too much about songs like "Hurtin' Me, Hurtin' You," since I know this is just Steve Earle stretching what he's "all right" at. But, like, a song such as "You're Still Standin' There" proves that Earle can do both simultaneously, the hard (those booming drums and that gruff vocal lead) and the pretty (the soaring harmonica and the wonderful turn by guest star Lucinda Williams).

Me? I feel alright. Not all right, but alright for sure. Shit sucks, but life is good to me, and I concentrate on that. It feels especially alright to be blessed with yet another great country music album in the confines of Record Club. There have been plenty of albums recently that prove that country music (in its Americana et al. permutations) is still fucking thriving today. But I Feel Alright feels like it's one that gives us a good understanding of where that started, for the most part. Earle stands at the fork in the road. We've chosen the right path, but it had to split somewhere, and I felt alright getting a glance at that split this week. Very good shit. Keep it up. Feel alright.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: