Thursday, August 31, 2023

Summer Song Challenge, Day 95: Joe

Prompt: "A song you used to hate but now you love"

Selected by Joe


"C'est la Vie"
B*Witched
B*Witched, 1998

Music is a choice.

It's a choice to listen to music, and it's a choice regarding which music you listen to. Passivity can also be a choice, but in that case you are choosing to not choose, which is still technically a choice. Active listening, though? Definitely a choice. To tell someone what you're listening to? You're proclaiming your choice.

What I'm proposing now is that that choice, the choice to listen to whatever song you're listening to by that song's artist, that choice says something about you, the listener/chooser.

I know not everyone agrees with me in that regard. I know I'm probably in the minority. There might even be accusations of me "taking this too seriously" or, even worse, me "being judgmental" when it comes to other people's choices. I swear that's not the case. But there is a judgment involved, right? How can there not be? That's the engine that runs what we do here. That's what we've been spending all summer doing! Offering up songs for specifically stated reasons, and allowing our peers to judge—judge the song, judge the choice. It's unavoidable. To be uncomfortable with that probably means that you're avoiding writing on a music blog anyway. To be here, present, making choices, requires a certain measure of courage.

Courage because, occasionally, you're gonna be wrong. I don't exclude myself from this fact. It's unavoidable. The great thing about music is that it gives the listener a lot of room to be wrong. And that wrongness can be a pathway to a conversation. What's right, what's wrong, where does the disagreement lie, and so on.

But it begins with a choice, and that's important too. Maybe the most important thing. The choice is unavoidable. Without judgment, I think that choosing to listen to a song that was created by and continues to exist in this world because of a child molester, a rapist, a sexual abuser, a racist, an anti-Semite, and so on, is wrong. I can prove to you that I am not judging you by saying that it's wrong, simply by showing you the DOZENS of songs created by these types of artists that were chosen for the Summer Song Challenge and still published on this blog despite this editor's full knowledge of the artist's actions.

There is a great argument that art should be separated from the artist, and I know that plenty of people believe that and let it influence the choice of What Should I Listen To Today. I get it. That's the easiest thing to do, and it might even be factually correct to say that listening to, for example, Morgan Wallen in the privacy of one's own home does literally no harm to anyone in any tangible way. That's true! It doesn't!

It gets trickier still when you consider the fact that maybe not everyone knows that this dude is a racist. I acknowledge that I am "more online" than others, and certainly more "plugged into" the world of music (and thus music news) than people who just listen to whatever the algorithm gives 'em. Not that there's judgment in any of this, but there's especially no judgment here, in the space of ignorance. It's okay. You don't have to know everything about every artist.

Go ahead and use the search bar above and see how many effusively positive words you can find that I've written about Arcade Fire. This was an important band to me. A foundational band in my own personal musical upbringing, I'd even say. But its frontman, Win Butler, was outed as abusive toward women, and so I don't listen to Arcade Fire. Do you think that was an easy choice for me? Do you think I get my rocks off pretending I have some moral high ground? No, and no. It sucks. It's a terrible but (in my opinion) necessary choice. How could I possible hear the same things in Funeral now that I know the person who made it and who he is? Why would I want that choice to reflect on me?

Ignorance is an excuse, but only up to the point when you're informed. When you're told that Morgan Wallace is a racist, and you still choose to listen to his music, then what does that say about your choice? What does it say about you? I'm arguing that music is a choice. You, the listener, are asked to make a choice. The choice is important.

And then you have to consider the fact that blogging can be different things to different people. What I proposed at the beginning of the summer was that you are choosing songs that fit the prompt. That's all. I said nothing about people actually having to listen to those songs. If you ask me personally (as opposed to "me, the PoYB editor-in-chief"), I would tell you that I think the endeavor only works if you are choosing songs that you want other people to listen to—that you are making your choice known—but I certainly acknowledge that maybe not everyone saw it this way.

Maybe you might see as more of a questionnaire. "What is a song that begins and ends with the same letter?" If you're just answering the question, then "Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains)" by Arcade Fire fits the prompt. If you're just answering the question, then there's no need to consider the choice. It wouldn't be a choice. You're just answering a question. I get it! That's the great thing about blogging—it can function differently for different writers, even on the same blog. Far be it from me to take blogging TOO SERIOUSLY.

But it's still a fucking choice! And if you really are just answering a question about punctuation or some shit, then you're leaving yourself open to misinterpretation. I only know that anyone who chose an Arcade Fire song, or a Jason Aldean song, or a Michael Jackson song, or a Brand New song, or a Kanye West song, doesn't adhere to the beliefs of the artist because I know you, the person who chose it. But this is a fucking public blog, and it wouldn't be unreasonable for someone who doesn't know any of us from jackshit to see a Brand New song and assume that the person who chose it really doesn't give a two fucks that man who fronted Brand New is a sexual abuser, let alone condone his actions implicitly by your choice.

It's reasonable to know this and say: who cares! Seriously. Maybe this really comes down to different opinions about how we should portray ourselves online. I take my online persona seriously, and I try to align it with my real-life persona as best I can. I take sexual abuse seriously in real life. It's part of my career and my life's (actual paying) work. I make decisions based on my beliefs in this realm that affect how I live my life. And it is my belief that writing a blog post in which a fucking Ryan Adams song is embedded and discussed and possibly misinterpreted as "a song that I want you to hear" would betray who I am as a person and what I hold dear.

And—this is probably the most important point as I attempt to build a parallel case that I'm not being judgmental here—it's totally reasonable and probably expected that everyone is going to draw their own lines in this regard, even if you do agree with me that listening to music is a choice. For example, I could imagine maybe a female with a sexual abuse history listening to Arcade Fire, since it means something to them and that didn't change when the truth about Win Butler came to light, or maybe they hear Arcade Fire in a new light and are able to gain some semblance of power and agency, ironically or not, back from the band. Or, more simply, consider the scenario in which a Jewish individual chooses to listen to Kanye West because they separate art from artist. I've never been a victim of abuse, and I'm not Jewish, and so maybe I would even have less of a say in these matters. I don't know.

What I'm saying is that it's totally okay to draw the line between art and artist, even though I personally will never and could never. I believe with every fiber of my being that music is a choice that we actively make every single fucking day, and I believe furthermore that this choice means something. Maybe not even that. Maybe the choice means EVERYTHING.

And so, I make the choice today. I listen to a song. I choose this song—an innocent and lethally catchy '90s pop song that for some reason turns into an fiddle-led Irish dancing song in the bridge—as the song I want you to hear today. When I was young, I did not like this song, because I thought that liking pop music like this might give people the wrong impression. I like it today, as it remains the same catchy pop song, but my definition of "wrong impression" has completely changed. What I fear about others' perceptions of me looks different than it did way back then. Hence, the switch from hate to love. Hence, the switch from deceit to honesty. This is what this song says about me, that I've worked hard over the past few decades to make that switch.

I swear that I'm not saying anything I said today in order to declare moral superiority. The exact opposite—I'm right there with y'all, in the trenches, making the tough choices. I completely understand that the art/artist separate is real and feasible to some. I'm kinda jealous, to be honest. I wish I could feel that way. But I don't.

I think what I'm really trying to say here is that I take music seriously. That's all. I think music is the most important thing that we have as humans, beyond... love, maybe? But even the concept of love is so inextricably tied to music sometimes that it's easy to conflate the two. I think music is precious, and should be protected at all costs. And I would hate to see the act of music sharing be fucking wasted on some fucking assholes who utterly disrespect the thing that we hold so dear.

I think that's what I'm trying to say. Maybe not. If you want to assume I'm just being obnoxiously pious here, then there's nothing I can do to stop you, just like there was nothing I could do to stop anyone from choosing a morally dubious artist to publicize on Puke on Your Birthday this summer.

Ah well. So it goes. Such is life. Wait, isn't there another phrase similar to this that I could use here?

No comments: