Saturday, March 28, 2020

Song of the Week: [March Madness Shuffle 2020 Winner]

 VS.

Through the course of our March Madness Shuffle (previous entries HERE, HERE, and HERE), we attempt to answer an integral question: What makes a song "good"? This short-term project argues that we can attempt to uncover the answer by examining two completely different songs, dissecting them, figuring out what makes each of them tick, and then determining which song is better. The choice tells us what makes a song good, because the choice is based on the innate feeling you get when you really take a good hard look at a song.

Let's see if we can figure out what makes a good song. Enter the March Madness Shuffle Championship.


"Why Do I Keep Counting?" by the Killers VS. "Into the Earth" by Bloc Party

These are two very different songs, aesthetically. They both present similar real human concerns; the conclusions reached, however, stand in stark contrast.

Musically, here's where we stack up. "Why Do I Keep Counting?" is varied. It has layers. We start softly, with chimes, and Flowers' voice softly floating over the horizon. And then this shit builds, slowly but firmly. The drums come in—in fact, it's one of those songs when all the instruments come in at different times, building the tension. I think I hear a goddamn tympani in there at one point.

It's all rising action here. At one point, the drums are pounding away, Flowers is shrieking, and then everything drops out except vocals and piano plinks. It's a feint—the song comes crashing in even harder. This thing fucking soars, y'all. I mentioned before that this is the de facto conclusion to Sam's Town, and in that context, it works like gangbusters. It even features a false ending, with blaring chords to end in dramatic fashion.

"Into the Earth" is pretty rock solid, musically speaking. There aren't many changes in volume or intensity. The whole think just slinks along, with a tight syncopated drum rhythm. The only thing that comes in or drops out, really, is that sharp electric guitar strumming during the chorus—it's sparse during the verses, but gets real fluttery and beautiful in the refrain. If "Why Do I Keep Counting?" is being played to the cheap seats, then "Into the Earth" is being played somewhere there's no seats at all, you're just dancing right up there at the front of the stage.

But what is each song trying to say? That's important too. It's funny, because both songs seem to presenting the same conundrum: Why is life so long and hard? I suppose there's an argument to be made that every song in history presents that question, but not many as explicitly as these. "Am I strong enough?" asks the Killers. "I don't know what the future holds," confirms Bloc Party.

And to be honest, the solutions presented are actually in sync with one another as well. Both songs realize that maybe you need the help of another to get through it all. "Help me get down, I can make it" theorize the Killers. "I hope we face it together" responds Bloc Party.

I dunno, though, I find a contrast in the conclusions to each song. "Why Do I Keep Counting?" presents a sort of nihilism. It states that we're all going to die, so why bother? "Into the Earth" also admits that we're all going to die, but instead it implores you to "keep it fluid" and to "try to keep an open mind."

You might assume that I'm going to side with Bloc Party on this one, and when it comes to real life and how I personal try to operate, you'd be right. But think about the contexts for each of these songs, and you might be less inclined to make assumptions.

Sam's Town is not explicitly a "concept album" or anything bullshit like that, but the Killers do a pretty good job of presenting all these songs as stories. Of course the music one writes is going to be influenced by your own experiences, but not every song should be saddled with the "confessional" tag. Why should anyone assume that Flowers himself is being nihilistic? Why should anyone assume that Flowers isn't just telling a story about someone who is nihilistic? Isn't the presentation of such nihilism and my subsequent examination of such achieve the same anti-nihilism purpose anyway?

If we apply the same logic to "Into the Earth," then it's possible that we don't have to talk about how uncomfortable all the quasi-religious imagery makes me feel when I read the lyric sheet. It's eastern religion, sure, what with psychedelics and "higher planes" and all that stuff. I prefer my optimism to be a little more grounded, thank you. But again—this is not necessarily a confessional piece, it's just a song. It's possible to take it too seriously.

So where do we stand now? The Killers present a more dynamic tune, but leave the listener desiring more, whereas Bloc Party sticks to the groove, and insists that you'll find enlightenment in there somewhere. Which is preferable?

The short answer is, I have no fucking clue. Choosing favorites is hard. However, I do love the idea of some song that I have dismissed in the past being crowned "the best" at anything, even if it's in some dinky homemade tournament made with scotch tape. So out of that love, I award the win of the tournament to Bloc Party. Congrats. We did it.



"Into the Earth"
Bloc Party
from Hymns
2016

No comments: