Friday, March 20, 2020

This Is My Blood: Wingman

We have arrived at the point in my drinking journey that I have been anticipating the most—how to pair beer with food. As it is with tasting just beer, tasting beer and food together is a nebulous art. There are guideposts in the fog, rules to follow so that you can pretend that you know what you're doing, but at the end of the day, you're going to be drinking good beer and eating good food, sometimes together, and so why quibble about what goes together and what doesn't?

I didn't mean to start this blog post with that much skepticism. That's the old Joe talking. The old Joe's favorite beer/food pairing of all time was ice cold Keystone Light and hot buffalo wings, and while that may prove to be a technically sound pairing, it also ignores the spirit of the hobby. The point isn't being comfortable with any old pairing, the point is to explore your palette in two dimensions, and maybe even surprise yourself with some unexpected combinations.

Mosher makes a good point in Tasting Beer; he says that the point of beer/food pairing is to find a pair that bring out the best in each other, and possibly mutual transform each other into something better than they would be apart. Maybe you don't like imperial IPAs or strong stinky cheeses, but a perfect combination of the two of them will make you appreciate both. You never know!

Tasting Beer eschews the idea of what they call "matchy-matchy" pairs, like say a chocolate stout and a Hershey's bar. Obviously they go together, but that ignores the spirit of the hobby worse than light beer and wings does. Instead, you want to try to find contrasting elements that can balance each other.

There are already combinations like this that you are familiar with. Grilled cheese isn't made of cheese and cheese, it's made with cheese and toasted bread, two different flavors that complement each other so well. We can apply this mindset to beer/food pairing as well. Maybe a spicy Czech hop beer goes well with a soft cheese. Maybe a orange witbier goes well with vanilla pudding. I could keep going.

There are a few simple guidelines to keep in mind when trying to match, and these are the guidelines I will try to live by for the remainder of the year (as best I can, of course, considering financial and logistical restrictions).

1) Intensity of flavors should be equal in the beer and the food. We're switching gears and not saying sweet vs. spicy or something like that. We're speaking more in general, like this food has a lot of flavor, and this beer has a lot of flavor, so maybe they would go together. Or this fish is a little plain, so maybe it would pair better with a light blonde ale. The purpose of this is to prevent one flavor to overpower the other. If you paired an imperial IPA with a soft pretzel, you wouldn't be able to taste the pretzel at all, so what's the point of the pairing?

2) Look for harmonies in aroma. Remember, aroma and taste are intertwined but also separate ideas. When it comes to aroma, there are millions and millions of types, and when it comes to pairing, you want to see if you can find a beer and a food with a similar type of aroma (or tangential at least). And it's not as exact as you'd think. According to a chart in Tasting Beer, such aroma combos as salty/roasty, and fruity/vanilla, and cookie/spice, and meaty/caramel are all close enough aroma-wise that they make sense as a pairing.

3) It's a different story with taste. There are millions of aromas, and only a handful of tastes (you know—sweet, spicy, salty, umami, that kind of stuff). Certain tastes balance other tastes when you pair them, and other aggravate. Some even cancel each other out (for being too similar). Here's a chart of the different interactions.


So here's where we're at. If I thought I was bad at discerning different flavors in beer, then imagine how bad I will be at figuring out flavors in beer and in food and the flavors in a combination of the two.

You gotta start somewhere, though. I started tonight with a Lidl Supreme Pizza (we usually get plain pizza from Lidl, but, ya know, none left—hoarders be hoarders these days). You'd think that pizza would be easy to pair with—and to make this point again, I will probably drink anything with pizza, or any other food, I'm not picky—but this particular pizza was a conundrum, because it featured so many different aromas and tastes—sweet sauce, toasty bread, spicy sausage, meaty pepperoni, sweet green pepper, caramelized onion—that I wasn't sure what kind of beer to match it with.

I decided to concentrate today on the first guideline, intensity of flavor. It wasn't a plain pizza, but it was a $5 pizza, so it wasn't going to exactly be knocking us over with flavor. So I searched through the fridge for a medium lager or ale, thinking that an average beer would be enough to stand up to the toppings of the 'za, but not strong enough to completely ruin the joy of pizza night.

It's possible that I chose Wingman for more thematic reasons ("wingman" for my first pairing, see?), but I think it was a nice choice regardless. The beer already featured a nice balance of malty and bitter. Per the chart, malty bitterness goes well with fat, which the pizza was definitely full of.

Not that I'm going to be talking about beer and food pairing every day for the remainder of the year, but I do want to take some time every once in a while to reflect on whether what I'm drinking and what I'm eating actually make sense together, and maybe once or twice a week, make a conscious pairing decision, based on what I'm reading about.

More to come.

NOTES

BEER: Wingman

GENRE: American Pale Ale

ABV: 4.5%

BREWED BY: Weyerbacher Brewing Co.

LOCATION: Easton, PA

PURCHASED AT: ABV Beverages

PAIRED WITH: Lidl Supreme Pizza

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

BEER COUNT: 118

No comments: