Thursday, March 5, 2020

The Albums That Matter: Beat the Champ

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Beat the Champ
The Mountain Goats
2015

The easiest way to describe Beat the Champ is: "It's the Mountain Goats album about wrestling." And that would be true! All thirteen songs are about either a professional wrestler or about some aspect of the wrestling entertainment industry.

But really, in the tradition of some of our greatest artists, John Darnielle used a disparate subject as a writing prompt, and from that was able to spin tales about the human condition. Beat the Champ has as much to do with wrestling as The Monitor does with the Civil War.

So that's why you're not going to hear me say that I love this album because I too used to be a big wrestling fan. Yes, especially due to the fact that I wrote about that already, almost eleven years ago, and even at that point it was nostalgia, so what could it possibly be now? And yes, due to the fact that the specific wrestlers name-checked on Beat the Champ predated my brief love with the sport. But mostly because the wrestling isn't even the point. Like a wrestler unmasked, Darnielle rips away the facade, and exposes the true human nature embedded in this seemingly childish charade.

My favorite moment of this bald and beautiful exhibition of pure humanity occurs during "Heel Turn 2," which sees the narrator, a wrestling character, make what the biz calls a "heel turn." This is when a character who is known as a hero and well-liked by the fans suddenly makes a statement that now, and forevermore, I WILL BE A BAD GUY. Which is an interesting thing to think about, right? How people, not just wrestling characters, but in all walks of life make decisions every single day as to whether they are going to be "good" or "bad."

So anyways, there's a line in the song that goes: "President of the fan club / up there choking on his tears." The line is dual in nature. Of course, it speaks to a very specific occurrence in professional wrestling, how the characters can make sudden changes to how they act, and how that might affect someone who loved the character because they were the hero. But it also reverberates to our more general assessment of human nature, how choosing to be "bad" might feel like it's liberating in a sense, but also that there are going to be consequences for the people around you.

This is heavy shit for a subject that is ostensibly a live-action cartoon. And this is every fucking song, you guys! "Werewolf Gimmick" is in some ways the opposite of "Heel Turn 2," in that it describes a character that is so deep into his "heel" nature that he doesn't even know what "good" is anymore. "Animal Mask" is on the surface about wrestlers teaming up during a battle royal, but beneath the surface it is a surprisingly moving allegory for welcoming a new child into the world (your new "tag team partner"). "The Ballad of Bull Ramos" is an almost straight telling of the story of an old wrestler who went by the name "Bull," but the more I listen to it, the more I realize it is an amazing ode to living a full and optimistic life, despite its challenges.

I casually dismissed a few paragraphs ago the fact that the wrestlers in these stories are mostly those from the '60s and '70s, during the "territorial era," but I think that's part of this album's appeal too. I only watched wrestling in the '90s, during the "attitude era," when WWF was the only show worth watching, and it was televised nationally, and the athletes were household names. Darnielle is more singing about the wrestlers who would be part of organizations that were only known locally or regionally, before TV.

I say it's part of the album's appeal because I never knew who Bruiser Brody or Bull Ramos or the Sheik were, and so these stories more easily become legends for me, to pore over and to appreciate from a distance. If Darnielle ever decided to make a Beat the Champ 2 featuring Stone Cold Steve Austin and Vince McMahon and the Rock and the Big Show and Mr. Socko, then it would have the potential to just come off as hokey, because I know these guys (and socks) already. There's no need to tell that tale. I was there. But tell me more about how Bruiser Brody was stabbed to death in a dressing room, I will lap that shit up.

Of course, there are few artists who could pull this off other than the Mountain Goats, so who knows, maybe "The Ballad of the Mankind (Hell in a Cell)" would be a great fucking song. In fact, I do. I know it would be. That's how much I love the Mountain Goats. Only John Darnielle could create such a jaunty, baritone sax-lead song about hitting someone with a steel chair. Who the fuck else is going to write a bossa nova jam about blinding someone with a fireball?

We haven't talked about the best song on the album yet, but I've been saving it for last because it does the best job at displaying all these elements that I've just written about so glowingly. "The Legend of Chavo Guerrero" is the best Mountain Goats song (yes, even better than "This Year"), not only because it is such a fun and uplifting song, and not just because it paints such a vivid picture (here, of a wrestler flying off the top turnbuckle, landing on his opponent, elbow outstretched). It's the best because it takes such an outlandish subject (wrestling), and moves the focus just a little to the left. The focus is now on Darnielle as a young child, watching Chavo Guerrero fly through the air:

"Before a black and white TV in the middle of the night
I'm lying on the floor, I'm bathed in blue light
With the telecast in Spanish, I can understand some
And I need justice in my life, here it comes."

Darnielle has been pretty open about the abuse he suffered as a kid at the hands of his stepdad (you should listen to The Sunset Tree, even if The Albums That Matter probably never will), and here, he frames wrestling as an escape from all that. It's the classic argument about pro wrestling—it doesn't matter whether it's real or fake, it matters as long as it's affecting you emotionally, like all good stories should. Watching Chavo Guerrero was salvation for Darnielle, and he perfectly captures it.

So no, I don't think you need to have been a wrestling fan in your youth or currently, nor do I think you have to know a single iota about pro wrestling, to appreciate Beat the Champ. You just have to be human. And we all are.

If this album sounds interesting, then try this song: "Foreign Object"

Stray Observations
  • I'll undercut my central argument in this first bullet point (I feel like I always do?). It's not necessary to know anything about wrestling while listening to this album, but learning a little bit about it certainly can deepen your already existing appreciation. Genius.com is a treasure trove for this album.
  • I feel like if someone were to make a podcast where you would listen to the songs from this album, and then in between talk about each song, like maybe give footnote-type information about the specificities of what is sung about, then this would be the perfect album to make one for. But as I will say forever and always, I am not that guy.
  • I guess I was familiar with Luna back in the day, she of the track "Luna"? There weren't as many female wrestlers during my time watching WWF, so the few that existed stood out, and I definitely recall a Luna. Maybe I'm just thinking of an old WWF video game I used to play at my cousin's house. In any case, I did not know that her house burned down, and I'm glad that Darnielle chose a unique angle to write his Luna story around.
  • But Luna is absolutely the "most modern" wrestler mentioned on this album. That didn't stop some modern wrestlers to request Darnielle to write songs about them. Here's Sasha Banks tweeting the request at him in 2015. Here's the song, finally written as promised, three years later.
  • I'll sing the praises of Genius.com again, because they are a great source of all the over-explaining that Darnielle has done about these songs over the years. But I will acknowledge that some of what is written is a stretch. The description for "Fire Editorial" tries to make the argument that jazz is like wrestling. Okay.
  • We're reaching the point where I can talk about "previous The Albums That Matter albums for this artist." I wrote about 2002's All Hail West Texas a couple years ago, saying that I liked it, but I didn't love it, because there wasn't much to it besides Darnielle's admittedly fun lyrics. I'll stand by that, but I'll use Beat the Champ to say, definitely, that whatever was missing on LP6, the Mountains Goats have certainly found by LP15.
  • My boy Tom Breihan wrote a great feature about Darnielle going to an actual wrestling match and discussing this album, back in 2015. Read it HERE.
  • ALBUM COVER: A delightful cartoon image of a Samson-esque wrestler giving a off-the-top-rope kick to a masked wrestler, right in the chin. An album so full of life required a cover art of action, and this delivers. It was drawn by artist Leela Corman, who...
  • ...also drew the cover for Mountain Goats' next album, Goths, which I'll call a step down from Beat the Champ. Don't worry, they absolutely delivered with the one after that (and currently the most recent), In League with Dragons. I'm almost tempted to say I like Dragons better than Beat the Champ.
  • I don't know enough of the MG discography to be able to rank 'em. Seventeen albums is a lot!
  • ALBUM NAME: Not sure if I have to explain this one. Wrestling, like any sport, has a champion. If you "beat the champ," you get the belt.
  • CHARTS: It peaked at #32 on the Billboard 200, when All Time Low's Future Hearts was at #1. I have nothing to say about All Time Low. I've never even heard of them before this moment.
  • AWARDS: No.
  • A great quote from Darnielle about this album that I couldn't fit into the essay: "You can get really good reads on your dreams if you think of every character in them as actually being you." It's very easy to put yourself in the boots of these wrestlers, thanks to the Mountain Goats.
  • I massively underrated "The Legend of Chavo Guerrero" at the end of last year. FUCK.

NEXT TIME: Beatles for Sale by the Beatles

No comments: